small board fail ?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
mort69
mort69
WA
178 posts
WA, 178 posts
27 Dec 2013 8:57pm
Tried an 85l board today ,I'm a touch over 80 and I've been learning on a130l board,I can beach and deep start on the 130 but had an epic fail on the 85,I know its probably a bit early and the boards a bit small but what's the easiest way to get going,as you probably guest the board is bogging down,is it a case of perseverance or is the curve to steepcheers
PhilSWR
PhilSWR
NSW
1104 posts
NSW, 1104 posts
28 Dec 2013 12:18am
That's a pretty big step from 130 to 85. Im only 78 kilos and find anything under 90 litres feels small- mind you i'm not the best sailor... I reckon 100 litres would be a great steep- for either flatwater speed sailing or waves. My wave board is 99 litre, and my flatwater board 110. They feel comfortable to me in anything up to 25 knots. Over that I get hammered.
John340
John340
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
27 Dec 2013 11:53pm
What was the wind speed?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12884 posts
WA, 12884 posts
27 Dec 2013 11:15pm
Small board, a bit under powered, you need to keep your weight forward until it's up and planning,especially if there's not much area/thickness in the tail.

I watched a Tushingham demo video a while ago and the 2 riders were both putting their front foot in front of the mast when water starting. I've only used this technique on my small speed board a couple of times, seemed to help.

Maybe you could have used a bigger sail? You need a bit more grunt to get a sinky board planning, there's also more strain on your arms as there is more drag from the board while it's bogged down.

I'm 70kg and used an 80l board today, about 1400 this was the right size board, a smaller one would have been a struggle for me. But around 1600 when the wind had lifted a fair bit I could have been on a 65/70l without a problem. So if you were trying early in the day, the wind would have been too light, but late arvo it should have been possible.

I don't think the learning curve is too steep, but you need to be in optimum conditions, wind too light you'll bog, too strong, you'll also struggle.
Probably 18kts to 25kts, with a 6.0 to 5.5 sail, and not too small a fin.
mort69
mort69
WA
178 posts
WA, 178 posts
28 Dec 2013 12:10am
About 25 kn,5m sail definitely enough power,is a submerged start possible,my starts tend to be on the upwind side,and then I have to work it down to get going obviously this is a bot harder starting under water,I've also got my foot forward of the mast so the board is pretty well balanced with the nose slightly up, I'm loosing balance waiting for forward movement
Carlos
Carlos
WA
25 posts
WA, 25 posts
28 Dec 2013 12:25am
Please buy a dictionary, get the spelling sorted and the windsurfing will take care of it's self.
mort69
mort69
WA
178 posts
WA, 178 posts
28 Dec 2013 3:06am
Really Carlos,why don't you point out the mistakes so we can all be enlightend ? Don't waste my time
jh2703
jh2703
NSW
1225 posts
NSW, 1225 posts
28 Dec 2013 7:45am
Keep pushing yourself, I found it accelerated the learning curve for me. Yes it's hard but you learn quickly where you must put your weight to keep everything trimmed and the board floating. If it's windy enough it won't matter how small the board is you'll be able to ride it, Just everything happens a whole lot quicker on small boards....It feels like they are alive and wild. If you have forward momentum the board will stay afloat but you really need the board tracking straight by forcing it with your feet as they are easily pushed sideways. Everything on your small board is the same as your big board it just must happen much quicker then before. Water starting is the same, plaining is the same...if you are in a lull just make sure you are over the centre of the board with one foot in front of the mast base and one behind. As you power up move back, Then hook in and step into the straps and away you go.

My 2 cents.
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:11am
mort69 said..

Tried an 85l board today ,I'm a touch over 80 and I've been learning on a130l board


You are doing well for your age.

Smaller boards are more sensitive to weight distribution. You need to keep your weight centred on the board and the board pointing downwind when getting up on the plan. 25 knots with a 5m sail should be enough to get you going.
John340
John340
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
28 Dec 2013 7:32am
I recently borrowed a 80 lit board in 20+ conditions with a 6m sail. I usually sail a 110lit board. JH is right, every thing happens faster, but if you get it right, the rewards are there.
Sputnik11
Sputnik11
VIC
972 posts
VIC, 972 posts
28 Dec 2013 9:48am
I remember moving from a windsurfer One Design to a smaller Bombora (probably 30 years ago) and there was a big difference, but I was 65kgs. I think when your body weight is about the same of the board ltrs you've set yourself up for a pretty big challenge. When you've progressed a bit the 80ltrs in 25 knots will be fine, but no surprises you're getting a bit bogged for now.

As a example, I am now 76kgs (30 years and 11kgs isn't too bad is it?) and I do a lot of my sailing on a 106ltr freeride and 5.5. I was out in 25kts on a 91ltr and 4.7 a couple of days ago and it was great, but much windier and I would want a smaller board.

In my opinion, I reckon you need to go up to about a 90-100 litre board given you're 85kgs and still learning. The extra bouyancy will get you planing and its still a big jump down from 130 ltrs. Going from 130 to 80 is a bit too much. If you can afford it, get something in the middle for the conditions in between.

You're doing great though. Stick at it. If you're going to persist with the 80ltr, much sure you pump a bit when you get out of the water and onto the board. Try to get the boom to take some of your weight as you pump.
stone
stone
WA
243 posts
WA, 243 posts
28 Dec 2013 7:39am
Mast foot pressure. Get low, hang below the boom Bear away off the wind or downwind until you get planning.

Keep persisting.
Chris 249
Chris 249
NSW
3585 posts
NSW, 3585 posts
28 Dec 2013 11:33am
Carlos said..

Please buy a dictionary, get the spelling sorted and the windsurfing will take care of it's self.


Carlos, please buy a book on punctuation and take note that there is no apostrophe when "its" is used as a possessive pronoun. The apostrophe is only used when "it's" is used as a contraction for "it is".

Normally I don't give lessons on grammar, but since your post was so snarky I couldn't help myself. :-)
joe windsurf
joe windsurf
1482 posts
1482 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:37am
brave lad
equipment versus technique ....
at 1.6 times the weight of sailor in kg - excellent beginning - here 80* 1.6 ~ 130 liters
next step down is usually 1.3 times the kg --> 80 * 1.3 = 105 liters
and technique starts there already
and so - 80 kg on 85 liter - hope the sail is lite , the wind stays and you develop technique
you encourage us all :-)
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
28 Dec 2013 1:16pm
I think 10 - 20 litres over your weight is a better step. Once you crack it though, you will always be waiting for bigger wind so you can ride the small board.
Sputnik11
Sputnik11
VIC
972 posts
VIC, 972 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:04pm
Chris 249 said..

Carlos said..

Please buy a dictionary, get the spelling sorted and the windsurfing will take care of it's self.


Carlos, please buy a book on punctuation and take note that there is no apostrophe when "its" is used as a possessive pronoun. The apostrophe is only used when "it's" is used as a contraction for "it is".

Normally I don't give lessons on grammar, but since your post was so snarky I couldn't help myself. :-)


Maybe Carlos meant to say "itself"? Good grammar is the difference between knowing your **** and knowing you're ****.
Sputnik11
Sputnik11
VIC
972 posts
VIC, 972 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:08pm
Sputnik11 said..

Chris 249 said..

Carlos said..

Please buy a dictionary, get the spelling sorted and the windsurfing will take care of it's self.


Carlos, please buy a book on punctuation and take note that there is no apostrophe when "its" is used as a possessive pronoun. The apostrophe is only used when "it's" is used as a contraction for "it is".

Normally I don't give lessons on grammar, but since your post was so snarky I couldn't help myself. :-)


Maybe Carlos meant to say "itself"? Good grammar is the difference between knowing your **** and knowing you're ****.


those **** were meant to say shyyt
pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
28 Dec 2013 5:43pm
When you first go from a big board to a small one, it makes it much easier to only use it on quite windy days, say 22 to 25 knots plus, and about a five to 5.5 metre sail.
The technique is a bit different to a floaty board and the higher wind speed will let you get planing with minimal technique, so you can then sort things out without pulling your arms out of your sockets.
The technique wont come in a day or two so be prepared to put in the time and effort.
Once you get a small board sorted you will be impressed at how nimble they are and how smooth they slice through the chop.
Also, you will eventually be surprised at how small a board you can kick up onto the plane with relatively light wind, (18 knots), but without technique, it's nigh on impossible unless there is sufficient wind to use just brute force..
I didn't always have such long arms.
My arms got this long practising on short boards.
Keep at it.
Orange Whip
Orange Whip
QLD
1081 posts
QLD, 1081 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:36pm
How much of an issue is rig tuning when moving to smaller boards?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12884 posts
WA, 12884 posts
28 Dec 2013 7:57pm
mort69 said..

About 25 kn,5m sail definitely enough power,is a submerged start possible,my starts tend to be on the upwind side,and then I have to work it down to get going obviously this is a bot harder starting under water,I've also got my foot forward of the mast so the board is pretty well balanced with the nose slightly up, I'm loosing balance waiting for forward movement



Agreed an experienced rider would get that going, but you may have been better off with a slightly bigger sail. I'm 70kgs and was using a 5.3 yesterday, a 5.5 may have got you going as long as you weren't too overpowered with it.

Sounds like you are putting too much weight on the board too early.
No matter how small the board you should never sink it, that's just putting too much strain on everything.
When the big guys water start a tiny speed board, they body drag until there is enough speed to put weight on the board. But you have a lot more floatation than that.

Also helps to point downwind slightly, don't go too far down wind, that will see you flying around the front!

I normally water start with my back foot in the strap, and kick with my front foot. That allows me great board control and part of my weight is supported by my front foot kicking, this allows you to get the sail up higher into the wind,
then when I've picked up enough speed then my weight goes on the rig, then the board.
But don't be surprised if you don't get on with this technique, not many people do.
mort69
mort69
WA
178 posts
WA, 178 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:09pm
Haha grammar police policed,that's just bad manners .any way I got the 85 l going a couple of times today,a bit slow and wobbly to start but definitely planning.nice and light feel,now I'm guessing all the turning needs to be pretty efficient to stay up right.is it common to have the board sink if your turns arnt perfect or the wind is a bit gusty.cheers for the positive feedback,helps with motivation.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12884 posts
WA, 12884 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:24pm
mort69 said..

Haha grammar police policed,that's just bad manners .any way I got the 85 l going a couple of times today,a bit slow and wobbly to start but definitely planning.nice and light feel,now I'm guessing all the turning needs to be pretty efficient to stay up right.is it common to have the board sink if your turns arnt perfect or the wind is a bit gusty.cheers for the positive feedback,helps with motivation.


Congratulations, you're well on the way. Good low wind and high wind gear should see you in the water in most conditions, but mid range may not be ideal.
Yep, gybing is much more critical, board will sink if you loose too much speed, same goes for lulls. And tacking is only for the experts.


decrepit
decrepit
WA
12884 posts
WA, 12884 posts
28 Dec 2013 8:26pm
Orange Whip said..

How much of an issue is rig tuning when moving to smaller boards?


Probably slightly more critical than big boards because there is less margin for error, but rig tuning is always important.

paddymac
paddymac
WA
943 posts
WA, 943 posts
28 Dec 2013 11:05pm
mort69, I reckon one of the most useful tips given to me (ever) is mast foot pressure. This means keeping the weight transferred through the rig to the mast foot. When you are transitioning the natural tendency is to let the weight go through your feet. It's easier once you are in the harness but those first few seconds on a low volume board really require you to think about making the forces go through the rig onto the mast foot, this will help a great deal in getting the board to plan. Once you are planning, being able to apply MFP (mast foot pressure) helps in all manner of ways. I try and think of it as hanging off the boom and trying to unweight my feet.
petermac33
petermac33
WA
6415 posts
WA, 6415 posts
29 Dec 2013 1:12am
Never understood the concept of mast foot pressure and still don't. If anything I move my weight from the middle/front of the board when non planning to the back of the board ( trim board using back foot pressure) when planning. Then if fully powered up or over powered I shift upper body weight to the front of the board to stop it lifting too much. Today in 12 to 20 knots I was on a 92 litre slalom board with 5.6m and 34cm fin. Had a few moments but had a pretty crap day. Below 18 knots they don't work, not very well anyway! To mort69, I recommend trying lots and lots of negative outhaul to get going quicker but only if you're using a race sail. Try a bigger fin or stiffer more upright fin of the same size. Using the high clew eyelet on the sail will add a bit of power too. A high boom around shoulder height minimum also seems to add some power. Failing all this just wait for 18 plus knots.
Carantoc
Carantoc
WA
7283 posts
WA, 7283 posts
29 Dec 2013 9:19am
mort69 said..

Tried an 85l board today ,I'm a touch over 80 and I've been learning on a130l board,I can beach and deep start on the 130 but had an epic fail on the 85,I know its probably a bit early and the boards a bit small but what's the easiest way to get going,as you probably guest the board is bogging down,is it a case of perseverance or is the curve to steepcheers



I take it that the issue was that when you beach started the front of the board turned into wind, the board sank and you couldn't get moving ?

In which case I doubt more wind, a bigger sail or a stiffer fin would do anything to assist in get going. It will just make everything fail faster.


This is hard to explain but when you step onto the board you have to be light with your feet and try to apply your weight down the mast into the board,. Heavy feet sink the back of the board and it turns into wind.

Weight down the mast doesn't mean swinging off the boom, but force through the boom and down the length of the mast. The sail doesn't pull you up, you must step up.

Start knee deep, put backfoot just behind front footstraps in the middle of the board, 'push' down the mast via the boom and step up as vertically as you can with your back leg. Put front foot on board touching mast base.

You will then accelerate much slower than on a 130 ltr board. The first 5 knots goes into floating you, not moving you.


Practice a few times knee deep, back foot on board, front foot on bottom and push down the mast. The front of the board moves away. Put more weight on back foot and it comes back.


NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
29 Dec 2013 2:40pm
mort69 said..

Really Carlos,why don't you point out the mistakes so we can all be enlightend ? Don't waste my time



Sputnik11 said..


Sputnik11 said..


Chris 249 said..


Carlos said..

Please buy a dictionary, get the spelling sorted and the windsurfing will take care of it's self.



Carlos, please buy a book on punctuation and take note that there is no apostrophe when "its" is used as a possessive pronoun. The apostrophe is only used when "it's" is used as a contraction for "it is".

Normally I don't give lessons on grammar, but since your post was so snarky I couldn't help myself. :-)



Maybe Carlos meant to say "itself"? Good grammar is the difference between knowing your **** and knowing you're ****.



those **** were meant to say shyyt



Is this the invasion of Poland?
I don't know why all you guys jump to support someone who can't be bothered to make the slightest effort to make his posts readable.

N1GEL
N1GEL
NSW
861 posts
NSW, 861 posts
29 Dec 2013 3:47pm
decrepit said...
mort69 said..

About 25 kn,5m sail definitely enough power,is a submerged start possible,my starts tend to be on the upwind side,and then I have to work it down to get going obviously this is a bot harder starting under water,I've also got my foot forward of the mast so the board is pretty well balanced with the nose slightly up, I'm loosing balance waiting for forward movement



Agreed an experienced rider would get that going, but you may have been better off with a slightly bigger sail. I'm 70kgs and was using a 5.3 yesterday, a 5.5 may have got you going as long as you weren't too overpowered with it.

Sounds like you are putting too much weight on the board too early.
No matter how small the board you should never sink it, that's just putting too much strain on everything.
When the big guys water start a tiny speed board, they body drag until there is enough speed to put weight on the board. But you have a lot more floatation than that.

Also helps to point downwind slightly, don't go too far down wind, that will see you flying around the front!

I normally water start with my back foot in the strap, and kick with my front foot. That allows me great board control and part of my weight is supported by my front foot kicking, this allows you to get the sail up higher into the wind,
then when I've picked up enough speed then my weight goes on the rig, then the board.
But don't be surprised if you don't get on with this technique, not many people do.


Given I had my first sail in 15 years yesterday, but found waterstarting at 85kgs on a 93ltr board was much like riding a bike, I'd have to disagree with getting the back foot up first. Spose it depends how powered up you are... certainly in lighter wind putting your whole front leg (up to the back of your knee) provides more balance around the mast and keeps a smaller board square to the wind. Back foot first will weigh down the @rse end, bogging you down and pointing you windward where there's no power.

Persist with the smaller board is my opinion, though 85ltrs is a bit small for your weight. I've been surfing all my life and I learned on a 6ft board. It made me progress quickly and I struggle to understand why noobs in surfing always start on a mini-mal. IMO you can jump on a small board and still learn and progress. The whole 'big board for learners' is not always true. If you persist and have reasonable balance/coordination you can learn on anything. Persistence is the key. Keep going with what you've got. You'll figure it out and when you do you'll never look back. Sailing is a rich man's spirt, so adding more boards to your quiver is wasting fubds. Let your family buy their own gear if the want to learn. Selfish perhaps, but do you're own thing and enjoy.
mort69
mort69
WA
178 posts
WA, 178 posts
29 Dec 2013 7:09pm
Not wal ,are you going to correct every body for every mistake,this is not an english forum,and my mums not here to check my spelling no apologies offered.Question,why is there a maximum recommend sail size for small boards and what happens whe you go to bigcheers.how's my spellig.
Darkplague
Darkplague
SA
197 posts
SA, 197 posts
29 Dec 2013 10:42pm
The max size is just a general guide to go by.
For example if ya board is a 95ltr and says this: Recomended sail size 4.5m-7m.
This means the board can be "made" to work within this sail range and still feel acceptible. You can in theory use any sail, 3m to 9m perhaps, but they will feel like garbage and be almost impossible to control

If ya split 4.5 and 7 down the middle, u get 5.7m. That is the size that will feel the best for this particular board, its all subjective though. You can + or - 0.5m roughly for individual tastes, weight, conditions, fin size, tides, currents,wind strength,skills, and the list goes on
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
29 Dec 2013 11:16pm
mort69 said..

Not wal ,are you going to correct every body for every mistake,this is not an english forum,and my mums not here to check my spelling no apologies offered.Question,why is there a maximum recommend sail size for small boards and what happens whe you go to bigcheers.how's my spellig.


What?
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply