Gestalt said...
to satisfy minerals comments it would be possible to nominate discards only at the end of the year.
still keeps the monthly winner but allows the overal winner to use the discard system.
holding of discard nomination till the end of year means that teams will still compete each month as they won't be able to pre-empt things.
just an idea.
Not sure I quite agree there Gestalt, I think every team would always nominate their worst month to discard, so why not let the computer do the maths of working this out? That way you get a running total, the way it is at the moment.
As you say, the monthly winner is always independant of discards -- discards only affect the yearly rankings.
Mineral, I agree with you, however the flip side to this is that some people get discouraged if they have a month with no wind "Arrr we'll never win it now!" and give up. Perhaps this will stop that line of reasoning?

I'm happy to code it in for 2010, to see how it goes.