GTC: The Winter Cup Dilemna Whaddyareckon?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
1 Aug 2009 7:44pm
These are the ideas so far:

1 1 cup for each team declared Joint Winter Cup Winners

2 Have Cup sawn Lasered into 2 Halves, and becomes a Unique Novelty and talking point

3 Bring a third team members speeds and scores for each division to separate the two teams and have one winner

4 Have a sail off in August, Combine points for July and August and lowest points becomes the Winter Cup Winner

5 Further ideas welcome?
izaak
izaak
TAS
2013 posts
TAS, 2013 posts
1 Aug 2009 10:10pm
just have the cup month this month !!!!!!!! please
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
1 Aug 2009 8:11pm
izaak said...

just have the cup month this month !!!!!!!! please



Cheeky!!!!!
Goo Screw
Goo Screw
VIC
269 posts
VIC, 269 posts
1 Aug 2009 10:34pm
It will make history if ya cut it in half - don't get too fancy a hacksaw should be the tool of choice.
I think the third team member rule best fits the spirit of the competition.
izaak
izaak
TAS
2013 posts
TAS, 2013 posts
1 Aug 2009 10:45pm
i agree with the sail off, all team included
lao shi
lao shi
WA
1349 posts
WA, 1349 posts
1 Aug 2009 8:50pm
I like the third team members countback idea.
sailquik
sailquik
VIC
6173 posts
VIC, 6173 posts
1 Aug 2009 10:53pm
Slice it in half. Unique and appropriate. Tells the story.
evets
evets
WA
685 posts
WA, 685 posts
1 Aug 2009 8:58pm
I think this time cut it.
If there is to be a countback of third and maybe 4the team members that is a change to the rules people were competing using ( and sounds pretty complicated to me if all team scores are to be compared in this way to get points not just the slect 2)
fullmoon
fullmoon
WA
314 posts
WA, 314 posts
1 Aug 2009 9:08pm
Its all about the fun, Cut It!!!
fullmoon
fullmoon
WA
314 posts
WA, 314 posts
1 Aug 2009 9:09pm
Lengthwise.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12888 posts
WA, 12888 posts
1 Aug 2009 9:23pm
evets said...

I think this time cut it.
If there is to be a countback of third and maybe 4the team members that is a change to the rules people were competing using ( and sounds pretty complicated to me if all team scores are to be compared in this way to get points not just the slect 2)


My idea was only when there was a tie to resolve. Don't think it would be very hard to get the average score of best 3 in each division, for 2 teams.

By the way I've got a trusty hacksaw, that's feeling hungry for trophy! But it might be a fight for the biggest bit.
tim90
tim90
WA
66 posts
WA, 66 posts
1 Aug 2009 10:06pm
Cut it!
snides8
snides8
WA
1731 posts
WA, 1731 posts
1 Aug 2009 10:14pm
doesnt winter consist of 3 months?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12888 posts
WA, 12888 posts
2 Aug 2009 6:45pm
I've had another thought, what about eliminating the butterflies?
If just the 2 teams numbers are used without the rest of the GTC, that probably will give a different result, and should be easier to do than 3 contributors. If it's still a tie, go to 3 contributors..
elmo
elmo
WA
8896 posts
WA, 8896 posts
2 Aug 2009 6:58pm
posted this one on the wrong thread originally

Let the winner be decided with a team battle of Ro Sham Bo

video taped for us to watch whilst there is no wind
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
2 Aug 2009 7:44pm
lao shi said...

I like the third team members countback idea.


No brainer
S018
S018
SA
338 posts
SA, 338 posts
2 Aug 2009 11:25pm
Love the idea of cutting it but can see that being to costly (to do a good cut)
third team members speed scores, is OK with me
not keen on a sail off or joint winners

Trivia:
8 sailing days in July for SA Speed Demons
23 Sessions recorded by 11 sailors, (only one by me)
Well done Team !
tim90
tim90
WA
66 posts
WA, 66 posts
2 Aug 2009 10:26pm
mmm... laser cut cup.....
cmon you know u wana :P
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply