carbon extension as "mast saver" in shore break

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
puffin
puffin
235 posts
235 posts
17 Feb 2009 12:14am
After a recent experience in shore break during which my carbon extension snapped (instead of my mast, when the tip stuck in the sand underwater) it occurred to me that a breakaway extension is desirable...better that snap than the much more expensive mast (which may go on to tear up the sail). I'm contemplating replacing my aluminum extensions with all carbon as I'm spending more time in the waves.
Has anyone found their carbon extensions to break too easily?

blogging about carbon extensions in waves:
www.peconicpuffin.com/the_peconic_puffin/2009/02/carbon-extensions-as-breakaway-mast-savers.html
frpialoux
frpialoux
NSW
107 posts
NSW, 107 posts
17 Feb 2009 10:39am
But then, if you break your extension far from the shore; you loose your mast, your sail, your boom, and more importantly; your harness lines.
A good old powerex mast seems to be the solution!!
nasty
nasty
WA
153 posts
WA, 153 posts
17 Feb 2009 9:51am
Have snapped a couple of carbon extensions recently and wouldn't recommend it. Getting kit out of the break after is a pain in the ass and I was lucky not to break something else as a result. I'm back on the aluminium.
WINDY MILLER
WINDY MILLER
WA
3183 posts
WA, 3183 posts
25 Feb 2009 9:58am
ali bends
carbon clean snaps

gazza
gazza
WA
647 posts
WA, 647 posts
25 Feb 2009 10:42pm
can't beat my trusty piece of scaffolding tube never breaks.
Unless used for scaffolding in vico
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14989 posts
QLD, 14989 posts
26 Feb 2009 12:32am
i once built an extension out of stainless steel. seemd like i was onto a winner until i realised it weighed more than the rest of the rig put together.
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
7 Mar 2009 10:37pm
Gestalt said...

i once built an extension out of stainless steel. seemd like i was onto a winner until i realised it weighed more than the rest of the rig put together.


Yessss!

Carbon fibre composite has THE best strength to weight ratio of ALL mainstream materials. If fibre composite extensions are breaking it is due to either a fault in the particular extension or a design fault in the model.
busterwa
busterwa
3782 posts
3782 posts
8 Mar 2009 2:57pm
stainless is a verry unforgiving metal unfortunatly resulting in the high nikel content and no existand iorn.ore content
if u use stainless u have will have t change your cutting tool angles else your wasing ur time and ll end up chattering insted of cutting - tool diflection
the tolleence on your ,ask havr brrn dictated by engineers and if your mast is stuck ul find that that particles have enterd your join thus reducing the clearence of yout size/size fit
Haircut
Haircut
QLD
6491 posts
QLD, 6491 posts
10 Mar 2009 8:37pm
frpialoux said...


A good old powerex mast seems to be the solution!!


+1 vote for that

if powerex was pron, i'd buy the company
garyk
garyk
QLD
277 posts
QLD, 277 posts
10 Mar 2009 8:58pm
Haircut said...

frpialoux said...


A good old powerex mast seems to be the solution!!


+1 vote for that

if powerex was pron, i'd buy the company


+2 powerex masts are freakishly strong !

But i think the np cambats for me
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply