HaydenDekker said...
Sorry to hear that!
Altona is a beginners beach. If you walk out far enough you are in waist deep water which is perfect to make mistakes in. If it gets too shallow, stop and walk out again. Ankle deep shallow water is for advanced riders only. If you see an amateur attempting to ride in the shallows you should tell them to walk out further.
Once you can body drag upwind, aim to learn in deep water.
also, If you can't control the kite on the sand to get it into the water then you need to move back to a training kite.
I'd be interested to hear what other people thoughts are of the perfect beginners conditions?
Interesting first post, but I won't go into that. People have already posted the problems higher up, but here goes again.
Great in theory except:
1. Launch and landing at Altona has no margin for error. The beach is less than 30m long. Majority of incident we've seen at Altona happen when launching or landing. (kites in trees, power lines, riders hitting the concrete wall) Majority of launch and land incidents are beginners. I.e. kite falls back in the window, beginner can't recover, things go pear shaped.
2. Hidden sand banks. The issue is not whether it gets shallower, its what happens when things go wrong. Majority of problems occur for beginners when something goes wrong, not when everything is perfect. Surprisingly enough it's not not normally due to gusts, it's losing control of a kite due to something unexpected happening. I.e. picking up too much speed, hit a sandbank, riders gets knocked into a rotation and doesn't know how to recover. Even advanced riders take a little while to recover from these situations. beginners often don't pull the correct side of their bar and may do something worse like pull it into a kite loop.
3. Wind is direct onshore majority of the time at Altona. If something goes wrong, there is only one place for the rider to go and that's the shore. Most beginners don't have the understanding of the kite to recover quickly or adopt what is commonly referred to as the grip of death. I.e. they panic and hold on instead of just letting the bar go or pulling their QR when they are in trouble.
4. How far will the rider walk out into waist deep water? 10m? Have you tried walking upwind in waist deep water with waves hitting you (the waist deep water is where the wave start) and with a powered kite when you are barely able to control your kite without looking at it? How about when you are tired and its the 5th time? I suggest you try and come back and tell me again whether you think its a good idea. Reality check! The reality is most beginners will walk until they get to waist deep water and walk back up wind when they get too close to the beach or when they hit a sandbank which is too late. What beginners should do and what they actually do are two separate things.
5. Is it really a smart idea for anyone to ride downwind (what you are suggesting) of a beginner? I.e. beginners upwind in deep water and advanced downwind in shallow water? How long before a beginner loses control and takes out an advanced rider?
The big problem with Altona is that beginners think its great because it's easy to walk back to their board without bodydragging and it's nice and flat so they don't understand the consequences of the conditions. They think about what makes it easy to ride their rather than what makes it dangerous to ride there.
Your comment on learning to bodydrag upwind is also off. Bodydragging upwind is one of the first skills you should know before even getting on a board.
Perfect conditions for a beginner:
1. Wide beach for launching and landing (not at Altona)
2. Cross shore wind (not at Altona)
3. At least waist deep water (only if you walk out far enough and stay there which is unlikely)
P.s if you don't have enough experience to understand what constitutes a beginner beach, it's not a good idea to state a particular beach is a beginners beach.