Yeah I totally agree. Shorter is not always better. Sure enough an 8' or 9' board is great on the wave but its how much effort it takes to get the wave that counts. Usually the conditions have to be glassy to make the most of the smaller shorter boards. And falling in all the time just makes you look like a kook hehehe



Yes big boards are confronting to other surfers and a lot to carry and store away but like everyone has said its keeping the stoke alive. Bigger boards are definitely capable of riding waves. And bigger boards now are being shaped to be able to surf a wave with thinner rails and drawn in tails.
Here is a vid of me surfing a bigger board. I also use this board for flat water paddling and for a family board for when the kids want to paddle it themselves or sit on the nose of the board with me paddling. My dog also has to fight the kids for pole position hehehe