Elite Quick Blade Racer with Dimple Back????

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2098 posts
QLD, 2098 posts
4 Jul 2010 6:36pm
Can somebody please explain to me about the new (you beaut) Elite Quick Blade Racer with the dimple back that looks like a golf ball. the Hawaiian are raving about this new dimple elite back blade?
Question
How does it work?
What does it do?
I’m so curious & am looking for a answer what’s so good about it



rahams
rahams
NSW
544 posts
NSW, 544 posts
4 Jul 2010 6:39pm
golf balls go quicker and longer and straighter with dimples.if a golf ball was smooth tiger woods would be lucky to hit a green with it.so the blade should pull through the water quicker and straighter than a smooth blade
CMC
CMC
QLD
3954 posts
CMC CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:01pm
Legendary Aussie paddler Mike Mills Thom manufactures a paddle called the slingshot. This paddle features a smaller blade but with a deep concave almost like a spoon. Idea being to hold water in concave. People rave about this paddle and the Coffs teams do pretty well using it.

I would imagine the theory in the dimples is to allow the dimples to catch and hold additional Water in the dimples. Kind of like a far less extreme version and with multiple concave sections. By gripping water in these dimples would also reduce flutter.

I haven't seen these paddles but in my own paddles I have made I have experimented with the same blade with a scoop and without. Having a dihedral and scoop fro
what I learnt allows cleaner entry, better hold and reduced flutter also.

Would love to try or see this new paddle, when are they due in Oz?
boofy
boofy
NSW
2110 posts
NSW, 2110 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:03pm
I am thinking it wouldnt make much difference at all with the millions of dollars that have gone into hull design of watercraft over the years I think we would have seen it on hulls by now if it gave any advantage
Boof
CMC
CMC
QLD
3954 posts
CMC CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:09pm
boofy said...

I am thinking it wouldnt make much difference at all with the millions of dollars that have gone into hull design of watercraft over the years I think we would have seen it on hulls by now if it gave any advantage
Boof


Kind of respectfully disagree here. Boat hulls slip parallel to the water or laminar flow. A paddle is designed to trap or hold water on it's face so that you can effectively pull yourself past the point where you have planted the blade. Know what I mean?
boofy
boofy
NSW
2110 posts
NSW, 2110 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:10pm
Thanx CMC I have a better understanding of the physics behind the design now we must have posted at the same time
cheers Boof
bspot68
bspot68
QLD
166 posts
QLD, 166 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:25pm
hey guys, i was over in southern CAL in feb and i dropped into see jimmy, his mates with a good mate of mine over there and we spoke about this paddle. its about getting better grip on the water and release from the water his been working on them for awhile. he was saying he was going to send some over for jamie, mick and shack so maybe have a chat to them and see if they have them.
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:36pm
I would have thought it's more about the release going in and out from the water.. I reckon if you had a smooth blade and pulled it fast sideways out of the water.. and then pulled a dimpled blade fast out of the water you may notice a very slight difference.. but how much? .. I'm guessing there'd be more of a placebo effect.. I'd still love to try one..

DJ
Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2098 posts
QLD, 2098 posts
4 Jul 2010 8:18pm
Thanks everyone for getting back to me. Yes I do have one of these Elite Races with the dimple head I just got it on Friday for when I go to Maui on Thursday. This is my opinion I'm not very impressed with the times I'm recording on it I know I have done heaps better as my GPS Garmin 305 Forerunner dosn't lie.

Yes the blade did feel like this (To the paddler, the blade should feel like it’s planted in concrete when it goes in the water). But I felt really fatigued at 10k's



Scotty Mac
Scotty Mac
SA
2060 posts
SA, 2060 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:58pm
Yer probally work even better with a power band on!



DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
4 Jul 2010 8:28pm
Good luck in Hawaii Phil.. Don't forget your camera..

DJ
Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2098 posts
QLD, 2098 posts
4 Jul 2010 8:53pm
DavidJohn said...

Good luck in Hawaii Phil.. Don't forget your camera..

DJ

Thanks DJ
I've done the hard yards (training)
My best paddle to date was Brunswick Heads to Currumbin Alley 50k's in 4 hours 51 minutes 3 weeks ago so I was very happy to smash the 5 hour mark at my age at 48.
Haven't had a beer since New Years Eve so looking forward to the finish line at Molokai it'll be beer o'clock.
I feel as fit as f###
Just not happy with my new Elite dimple blade racer. My old Elite blade I broke 6 months ago was a much faster blade. It's taken 6 months just to get my hands on this blade (like ### me) I've asked Jim Terrell to send me another Elite racer the older style one to Mark Raaphorst factory in Maui so I do hope they come through???? finger crossed.
My mate Hux is going to film the Molokai race for me.
+ I got Bill to film a Maliko Run
I'll tell you all about it when I get back home in about 10 weeks
DW



Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
4 Jul 2010 9:01pm

Downwinder said....
I'll tell you all about it when I get back home in about 10 weeks
DW


Haha, rub it in !! Have fun too !

CMC - it says dimple back, not dimple front.... I thought you were talking about front.... can't see the dimples doing too much though (on either face!).

I remember Morey Boogie Boards (Body Boards) playing around with dimple bottoms on the slick skins, but the general consensus was it didn't do too much, and it fell by the way side. Rider experience, timing, wave quality, etc, was probably a much bigger influence.

Dimples on either face: My $5 note is firmly planted on "fad" not "faster" !!

If Danny Ching or similar quality athlete wins using one, I'd put it down to the athlete, not the paddle.

(edit: I have not tried the new paddle yet)



knigit
knigit
WA
319 posts
WA, 319 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:05pm
Have to laugh. The dimples on a golf ball break up it's slipstream by making the airflow past it turbulent rather than laminar, which reduces drag. I don't think that the speed your paddle is doing is quite comparable, but it's possible that with water being denser than air that it's supposed to do the same sort of thing (but like CMC says, it would be on boat hulls by now if it worked). i think that it's more likely just marketing hybe and a fancy new look.
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
4 Jul 2010 9:27pm
well, i was lucky enough to have a go of one. this paddle didn't have the u beaut shaft of a normal er paddle. i thought entry into the water was smooth and fast, which from my understanding is what they where aiming for. the exit was nice to, but jacko felt it held to much water coming out. he might post on this !!!!. also this paddle had a plastic handle that had a pattern for grip in-layed which was terrible and i'm sure would rip your hands to bits, hope that's not going to be on the more expensive qb's. i like it, but it's not going to replace my qb er unless i snap mine or something. i would look at it in the future
cheers
Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2098 posts
QLD, 2098 posts
5 Jul 2010 8:44am
Simondo said...


Downwinder said....
I'll tell you all about it when I get back home in about 10 weeks
DW


Haha, rub it in !! Have fun too !

CMC - it says dimple back, not dimple front.... I thought you were talking about front.... can't see the dimples doing too much though (on either face!).

I remember Morey Boogie Boards (Body Boards) playing around with dimple bottoms on the slick skins, but the general consensus was it didn't do too much, and it fell by the way side. Rider experience, timing, wave quality, etc, was probably a much bigger influence.

Dimples on either face: My $5 note is firmly planted on "fad" not "faster" !!

If Danny Ching or similar quality athlete wins using one, I'd put it down to the athlete, not the paddle.

(edit: I have not tried the new paddle yet)





Thanks Simondo
I agree with your comment


Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2098 posts
QLD, 2098 posts
5 Jul 2010 8:46am
Simondo said...


Downwinder said....
I'll tell you all about it when I get back home in about 10 weeks
DW


Haha, rub it in !! Have fun too !

CMC - it says dimple back, not dimple front.... I thought you were talking about front.... can't see the dimples doing too much though (on either face!).

I remember Morey Boogie Boards (Body Boards) playing around with dimple bottoms on the slick skins, but the general consensus was it didn't do too much, and it fell by the way side. Rider experience, timing, wave quality, etc, was probably a much bigger influence.

Dimples on either face: My $5 note is firmly planted on "fad" not "faster" !!

If Danny Ching or similar quality athlete wins using one, I'd put it down to the athlete, not the paddle.

(edit: I have not tried the new paddle yet)





Thanks Simondo
I agree with your comment

LSD
LSD
VIC
763 posts
LSD LSD
VIC, 763 posts
5 Jul 2010 9:18am
Comparing a paddle to a golf ball.....?

A golf ball is desigened to fly....as far as possible & travels up to 300kph

.....a paddle is designed to stick in the water ....& stay there while you pull your self past it. I would think, water being far denser than air, a paddle is not traveling in & out fast enough to have small dimples make any decernable difference.....on the other hand a large "wing" shaped blade/concave like on a kayak wing paddle does.

CMC
CMC
QLD
3954 posts
CMC CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
5 Jul 2010 9:35am
Like LSD and the guy that actually made the paddle said a paddle is meant to hold in te water, DW said he felt fatigued after 10ks with it when he normally paddles 50. My comment was that the dimples would increase surface area and trap extra water. From what DW says I'd say it worked at doing that. Did DW get the same 12" blade that he normally uses as well as dimples? If so it probably held as much water as a 12 1/2 or whatever hence the added fatigue.I don't know that he usually uses a 12 but I know it's big.

Like surfboard fins if you can increase the efficiency and hold of the fin with better design you can reduce area with the same hold.

PS Simondo my assumption is that by back DW means the power face of the paddle.
worrier
worrier
WA
726 posts
WA, 726 posts
5 Jul 2010 8:40am
I can remember having a sailboard with the dimples on the bottom way back in my glory days, 1980's I think.
Local shaper (Geoff Hillwood, scalpel windsurfers) was making some of the best boards around at that time and was puttin em on some of the asymetrical boards we were riding in this area. From memory they were about 5-10mm deep, octagonal shape and about 90mm diameter.Think there was about 10 of em altogether on the bottom.
Sort of just died out and then the asymetrical boards died out as well.
W



DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
5 Jul 2010 11:01am
worrier said...

I can remember having a sailboard with the dimples on the bottom way back in my glory days, 1980's I think.
Local shaper (Geoff Hillwood, scalpel windsurfers) was making some of the best boards around at that time and was puttin em on some of the asymetrical boards we were riding in this area. From memory they were about 5-10mm deep, octagonal shape and about 90mm diameter.Think there was about 10 of em altogether on the bottom.
Sort of just died out and then the asymetrical boards died out as well.
W



Ed Angulo was also doing them on the bottom of their windsurfer boards.. They seemed to work ok.

Mark Angulo used them and he told me what a pain it was for the glassers and sanders.

btw.. I'd love to see asym boards come back in SUP boards..

DJ






Gorgo
Gorgo
VIC
5125 posts
VIC, 5125 posts
5 Jul 2010 12:11pm
DavidJohn said...
...
btw.. I'd love to see asym boards come back in SUP boards..

...


Why? Would you put a slotted fence fin and a cutaway sail on it as well?

I guess you could have two assymetric boards for downwinders depending on whether the wind had an easterly or westerly bias.

CMC said...

Just found some info. http://www.ordinary-water.com/ordinary-water/2010/06/sell-it-quickblades-2010-kanaha-dimple-dipper-race-paddle-.html



Back to the topic ... reading the link it looks like the dimples are on the face and more about increasing surface area or grip when paddling.
rodriguez
rodriguez
VIC
883 posts
VIC, 883 posts
5 Jul 2010 12:14pm
America 2 applied dimples to the hull,america 3 didn't,iguess that sort of answers the performance question.
CMC said...

boofy said...

I am thinking it wouldnt make much difference at all with the millions of dollars that have gone into hull design of watercraft over the years I think we would have seen it on hulls by now if it gave any advantage
Boof


Kind of respectfully disagree here. Boat hulls slip parallel to the water or laminar flow. A paddle is designed to trap or hold water on it's face so that you can effectively pull yourself past the point where you have planted the blade. Know what I mean?


Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2098 posts
QLD, 2098 posts
5 Jul 2010 1:04pm
CMC said...

Like LSD and the guy that actually made the paddle said a paddle is meant to hold in te water, DW said he felt fatigued after 10ks with it when he normally paddles 50. My comment was that the dimples would increase surface area and trap extra water. From what DW says I'd say it worked at doing that. Did DW get the same 12" blade that he normally uses as well as dimples? If so it probably held as much water as a 12 1/2 or whatever hence the added fatigue.I don't know that he usually uses a 12 but I know it's big.

Like surfboard fins if you can increase the efficiency and hold of the fin with better design you can reduce area with the same hold.

PS Simondo my assumption is that by back DW means the power face of the paddle.

G'day CMC
I always use a 10''inch head my other 90''inch Elite Blade with the normal 10'' head was a weapon of a paddle loved it big time was a great blade in smashing times, but the EVA pad handle f### broke I asked for it to be replaced I waited 6 months? got it last week but I was talked into this new dimple head & now I am spewing I have to go back & use my normal flex 88''inch shaft with the 10''inch normal head as it 7 sceonds slower per kilometre to my beloved original Elite Blade just hope my good friend Scott Trudon from Maui has a spare original Elite Races I can borrow or buy?

Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2098 posts
QLD, 2098 posts
5 Jul 2010 1:14pm
I’d like to thank everybody who replied to this topic very interesting quotes
My opinion this Dimple Blade sound great in theory but goes like s##t when used that’s just my experience
DW
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply