Sunday Payout

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
ChrisMcC
ChrisMcC
NSW
667 posts
NSW, 667 posts
25 Apr 2010 7:33pm
agree, think it might be best to delete.
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
25 Apr 2010 8:53pm
Just Wrong said...

agree, think it might be best to delete.


No way - don't delete it. It happened and it was a terrific story - the best ever read on the forum, by far. Journalism as we know it is dying and the story published today is testament to this fact.

Forget it, it's already being used to wrap tonight's fish and chips.
laurie
laurie
QLD
3902 posts
QLD, 3902 posts
26 Apr 2010 1:38pm
No way is the topic going to be deleted just because of a Maris Beck's style of journalism.

Fact is it happened, and there is a healthy & constructive debate in that topic showing that everybody is learning from the experience, and that the SUP community is "self healing"

For example, I'd already published this article last week to share more info:

www.seabreeze.com.au/News/Stand%20Up%20Paddle/SUP-Downwinders-Lessons-Learned_3639064.aspx

Mrs/Ms Beck's perspective is her perspective, not the perspective of us, each individual reader, or any relevant authourities.

Would a single "out of the ordinary" experience be a strong enough reason to regulate the entire sport? I'd hope not.
FlickySpinny
FlickySpinny
WA
657 posts
WA, 657 posts
26 Apr 2010 7:40pm
Let's stay out of the press for a bit hey?

If we quietly carry on doing our silly stuff without any press attention there's a much better chance we'll be left well alone.
aussiefreebs
aussiefreebs
VIC
228 posts
VIC, 228 posts
26 Apr 2010 10:02pm
FlickySpinny, you're response is clearly a cry for attention. If your wife is unsatisfied, your boss bullying you or your children answering you back, please keep your childish attempts to feel like a man to yourself. We're all sure you think you much more of a man than you will ever be.

Regards.
Cosy
Cosy
VIC
63 posts
VIC, 63 posts
26 Apr 2010 11:24pm
When is Max Wells going to do something about regulating the jerkski tossers who endanger others. [}:)]
Bnaccas
Bnaccas
VIC
1722 posts
VIC, 1722 posts
27 Apr 2010 12:36am
Cosy said...

When is Max Wells going to do something about regulating the jerkski tossers who endanger others. [}:)]


Jetski's don't really fall under the Surfing Vic banner.
Either do SUP's on the bay but he has been doing what he can.

If there are more meetings to discuss the future of recreational SUP (on the PP Bay) then
I hope more of us will be able to support Max and give the sport a better presence/voice.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
27 Apr 2010 12:46am
Bnaccas said...

Cosy said...

When is Max Wells going to do something about regulating the jerkski tossers who endanger others. [}:)]


Jetski's don't really fall under the Surfing Vic banner.
Either do SUP's on the bay but he has been doing what he can.

If there are more meetings to discuss the future of recreational SUP (on the PP Bay) then
I hope more of us will be able to support Max and give the sport a better presence/voice.



If SUP doesn't fall under Surfing Victoria's banner, then why are we expecting Max Wells to represent us? I don't know this bloke from Adam, but judging by his comments in this article (which admittedly are quite feasibly misrepresentative, taken out of context or not even his words!!!) however at face value, he doesn't appear overly sympathetic to SUP. Does anyone know whether he's for us or agin us?
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
27 Apr 2010 1:04am
Max is a good bloke and 'for' us.. IMO

DJ
OG SUP
OG SUP
VIC
3516 posts
VIC, 3516 posts
27 Apr 2010 10:08am
Hey Woody,

I think Max's comments got the same treatment as the miss quote attributed to you.

He has also invited the VICSUP titles to fall under Surf Vic again this year without his support it simply would not happen.

He takes input from local crew like lummers etc and always gives a fair hearing from what I have experienced.

I know for fact that he has been working with Marine Safety since approx Mar 2009 to keep self regulation in place as this came up in our OG 13 meetings.

That was also why the OG 13 Event had to have formal hazard managment, water support on hand, fully drafted emergency plan, local consultation with community groups, land managers and retailers etc.

Until we dotted all the i's and crossed all the t's he would not allow it to go ahead and rightly so. As we had 9 retailers involved + volunteer groups no one company could cover insurance for the event.

Max worked with us and the underwriters to get it through Surf Vic. He even gave up his time for the day to come to supervise the event so we did not have to employ staff as he covered off 3 major roles required by the undewriters.

He really didnt have to help us out at all!


PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
27 Apr 2010 12:18pm
Cool, thanks Phil. Sounds like Max is our man.

And shocked and stunned that the alleged journalist responsible appears to have made yet another Media Watch worthy entry in this one article.
brady
brady
TAS
454 posts
TAS, 454 posts
27 Apr 2010 2:44pm
PTWoody said...

FFS. I'm clearly not brady.



You're upset!?! What about me! I missed my chance to shine in a quality, well-balanced, tabloid beat up!
skeeta
skeeta
VIC
8 posts
VIC, 8 posts
27 Apr 2010 3:46pm
Tux said...



And the rest of the board sports on the bay.... It's not just going to be you guys that get regulated.

Not amused.


Hmmmm...cause a windsurfer or kite surfer has never been rescued in the bay....


Not trying to cross it without any support....being rescued is not the problem - it's the steps taken as to why you ended up there in the first place.

Don't worry there are *plenty* of egit kite/wind surfers giving respective sports a bad wrap. Sadly, it happens in every sport
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
27 Apr 2010 2:05pm
PTWoody said...

If SUP doesn't fall under Surfing Victoria's banner, then why are we expecting Max Wells to represent us? I don't know this bloke from Adam, but judging by his comments in this article (which admittedly are quite feasibly misrepresentative, taken out of context or not even his words!!!) however at face value, he doesn't appear overly sympathetic to SUP. Does anyone know whether he's for us or agin us?



Pretty sure I met Max supping in Inverloch. (is it the same one I'm thinking about?)
OG SUP
OG SUP
VIC
3516 posts
VIC, 3516 posts
27 Apr 2010 5:41pm
This is a Marine Safety / Water Police issue take a pic showing what is happening and the rego plates send it to both bodies and you will get action!


Cosy said...

When is Max Wells going to do something about regulating the jerkski tossers who endanger others. [}:)]


OG SUP
OG SUP
VIC
3516 posts
VIC, 3516 posts
27 Apr 2010 6:03pm
Hey Woody,

When it comes to DW on PPB maybe he isnt, his interests would be purely surf as thats what he deals with. My point is Max isnt against SUP by a long stretch.

I was told last year that canoe associations were looking at annexing DW type activites in Vicco.

Maybe they will.


PTWoody said...

Cool, thanks Phil. Sounds like Max is our man.

And shocked and stunned that the alleged journalist responsible appears to have made yet another Media Watch worthy entry in this one article.


mikeman
mikeman
QLD
692 posts
QLD, 692 posts
27 Apr 2010 8:14pm
What still worries me here is that some of these guys are still not prepared to admit that what they tried was stupid and badly prepared. Thanks to this group we might all have to cop it with regulation from the authorities.

I would suggest that you read the post "Safety Recommendations for Downwind Paddles" and actually start adopting some of these recommendations.

DJ has already given positive feedback so this is really good news. This means that we are getting somewhere.

You all got lucky this time. Don't disrespect the sea as next time you might not get away with it.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
27 Apr 2010 8:39pm
mikeman said...

What still worries me here is that some of these guys are still not prepared to admit that what they tried was stupid and badly prepared. Thanks to this group we might all have to cop it with regulation from the authorities.

I would suggest that you read the post "Safety Recommendations for Downwind Paddles" and actually start adopting some of these recommendations.

DJ has already given positive feedback so this is really good news. This means that we are getting somewhere.

You all got lucky this time. Don't disrespect the sea as next time you might not get away with it.



Mikeman, I'm sure everyone appreciates your well considered and constructive thread regarding safety measures. I know for certain that I do. However I don't understand what your point is in the above post. You admit that DJ has acknowledged your thread with positive feedback. So what more do you need? If you're expecting or even demanding the other participants in the ill-fated bay crossing to acknowledge your thread with the requisite humility implied, then I suggest you may have slipped a little from your initial purpose.
Bnaccas
Bnaccas
VIC
1722 posts
VIC, 1722 posts
27 Apr 2010 8:50pm
Oliver, yes that is the Max.

I have been looking into how we can become more involved with appropriate authorities
but it looks like their is nothing on the table to become involved in. So I guess thats a
good thing since what happened.

But it's in our best interest to at least make our presence known so we do have some
say in any regulating that might happen in years to come.
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
27 Apr 2010 7:00pm
5 - 10 years ago while working with music festivals, we started to get approached by building unions etc about OHS on the site. Our response was to formulate our own OHS guidelines, that were specific to what we did - ie set up and break down a site. It took a number of years, but I think it's a whole lot better in the long run as we are not being dictated to by unions that really don't understand what it is we do.

The point I'm trying to make is that maybe the SUP clubs should start to formulate their own policies/rules/codes for these type of activities - that way, when other associations attempt to blanket us with some form of regulations, that may not be relevant to what we do, we are in a better position to deflect them by arguing that we already have our own code of practice in place.

I'm far from being an expert on these things, but mikeman has made some excellent suggestions and I personally think that formulating some guidelines on the SUPvic website, for example, on downwinders as being proactive step. Similar has been posted on this page: www.supvic.com/buysell/
camo hosk
camo hosk
VIC
613 posts
VIC, 613 posts
27 Apr 2010 11:18pm
mikeman said...

What still worries me here is that some of these guys are still not prepared to admit that what they tried was stupid and badly prepared. Thanks to this group we might all have to cop it with regulation from the authorities.

I would suggest that you read the post "Safety Recommendations for Downwind Paddles" and actually start adopting some of these recommendations.

DJ has already given positive feedback so this is really good news. This means that we are getting somewhere.

You all got lucky this time. Don't disrespect the sea as next time you might not get away with it.


All depends on what information your prepared to base your opinions on,totally up to you of course.If your ever down this way come along on a downwinder and see what you think first hand.
Its great you've taken the time and effort posting the safety thread and will be taking all this on board in the future,but I'm more focused on going forward and that's just my opinion,

Cheers.
Kite Mag
Kite Mag
VIC
154 posts
VIC, 154 posts
28 Apr 2010 12:36am
Hi guys,
What a pickle.
I've got an outdoors column in a new Melbourne magazine. I would like to do a story on SUP.
Angle will be SUP to burn calories and strengthen core. Rest of the story will list how to get into the sport
Give me a call.
Most of you know me and know that a story i write usually comes out how it is intended.
send me an email [email protected]
Ideal person would be someone who sups with a personal training or health background.
Ideal time for me is Friday morning.

cheers
George
mikeman
mikeman
QLD
692 posts
QLD, 692 posts
28 Apr 2010 11:43am
PTWoody said...

mikeman said...

What still worries me here is that some of these guys are still not prepared to admit that what they tried was stupid and badly prepared. Thanks to this group we might all have to cop it with regulation from the authorities.

I would suggest that you read the post "Safety Recommendations for Downwind Paddles" and actually start adopting some of these recommendations.

DJ has already given positive feedback so this is really good news. This means that we are getting somewhere.

You all got lucky this time. Don't disrespect the sea as next time you might not get away with it.


Mikeman, I'm sure everyone appreciates your well considered and constructive thread regarding safety measures. I know for certain that I do. However I don't understand what your point is in the above post. You admit that DJ has acknowledged your thread with positive feedback. So what more do you need? If you're expecting or even demanding the other participants in the ill-fated bay crossing to acknowledge your thread with the requisite humility implied, then I suggest you may have slipped a little from your initial purpose.


I am sorry if I slipped into a more negative mode with this post. I hadn't seen this post about the press getting hold of this so I suppose I was a little dissapointed. I am just really keen to see some self imposed changes happen and don't want to read about another one of these "adventures" down the track again.

As Camo Horsk aptly said: "....but I'm more focused on going forward..."
ChrisMcC
ChrisMcC
NSW
667 posts
NSW, 667 posts
28 Apr 2010 12:43pm
oliver said...

5 - 10 years ago while working with music festivals, we started to get approached by building unions etc about OHS on the site. Our response was to formulate our own OHS guidelines, that were specific to what we did - ie set up and break down a site. It took a number of years, but I think it's a whole lot better in the long run as we are not being dictated to by unions that really don't understand what it is we do.

The point I'm trying to make is that maybe the SUP clubs should start to formulate their own policies/rules/codes for these type of activities - that way, when other associations attempt to blanket us with some form of regulations, that may not be relevant to what we do, we are in a better position to deflect them by arguing that we already have our own code of practice in place.

I'm far from being an expert on these things, but mikeman has made some excellent suggestions and I personally think that formulating some guidelines on the SUPvic website, for example, on downwinders as being proactive step. Similar has been posted on this page: www.supvic.com/buysell/


Totally agree.

mikeman
mikeman
QLD
692 posts
QLD, 692 posts
28 Apr 2010 1:33pm
To be proactive on this matter SUPSA (Gold Coast SUP club) will be conducting a "Downwinders for beginners" session soon. This course will also have an important component of safety guidelines in it. I would strongly advise all members and non-members to come along to this. Just Wrong will let you know more about this.

I am also going to hook up with the guys in WA soon and do a similar thing with them.

If the other states/clubs would like I could also make plans to try and see if I can help out with them to. I travel a lot with my job and if I am in one of the big cities I don't mind helping. Send me a message if you would like to make use of this offer.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply