Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

The grumpy old men of seabreeze thread

Reply
Created by Sparx > 9 months ago, 9 Jun 2012
Adapt
QLD, 723 posts
9 Jun 2012 10:09PM
Thumbs Up

chrispychru said...

^^^^^free beer for the biggies and red cordial for the groms


+1

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
9 Jun 2012 10:25PM
Thumbs Up

PTWoody said...

laceys lane said...

PTWoody said...

ockanui said...

Posts like this and opinions expressed, I believe should be passed onto the Sports governing bodies to listen and learn and incorporate, when making decisions of not only age group categories but board length classes, as the Sport is in its infancy in Australia and its the prime time to get the workings right.




Age group categories are a luxury that we can play around with at our own discretion but board length classes do need to follow international competition rules, especially those set down by the ISA. No point being out of step with the rest of the world and the major board manufacturers.


ummm,you tell that to the hawaiians.

only a small percentage of paddlers are going to involved with isa ie international. aus surfing have been able to comply and still have other classes catered for. what about the paddlers that consider the hawaiian experience their macca


should manufacturers be setting the standards to suit themselfs tricky question

i used to be a 14 ft is it, be all, end all. but after getting a big board again, there is a magic there that i would hate to see lost in the rush to appease isa and manufacturing companies


Surfing Australia and the state affiliates don't need to concern themselves with Hawaiian events as they are for individuals rather than a team representing Australia and selected by Surfing Australia. Anyone wishing to go to Hawaii to compete just needs to buy a plane ticket. They don't need to qualify at nationals.

The point being, the state and national titles are a pathway to ISA word titles. If the top competitors at state titles turn up with 17 and 18' boards, how can they be selected for nationals or world titles where the maximum board length is 14'? You might argue that the cream rises to the top regardless of board length but we have found that one or two of our dominant unlimited performers have struggled when stepping down to 14' or 12'6". So that suggests you can't just send people to an international event on the shorter boards and expect that they will go well if they haven't proven themselves.

Likewise, if we allow unlimited boards into BOP races when the rest of the world doesn't, we will not be able to remain competitive at an international level.

Where I mentioned the big international manufacturers, I don't suggest we allow them to set the rules to suit their own agenda. What I mean is that they are following the global trends and building BOP race boards at 12'6" length. If we are out of step with the global trends, then we are out of step with board development and trying to use downwind or flat water boards in BOP races.

I guess what I'm trying to say is we can compromise on age divisions in order to encourage participation, and there is room for flexibility on board length at club comp level. But as soon as we get to state and national titles, there has to be consistency of formats or else the team selection process becomes a farce.


my point is not everybody wants to go to peru. my point is some people's focus could be hawaii. some people might just like riding different boards. some people might just be too dam old to go to peru on a 12'6 board

i'm suggesting 2 pathways or more, not just 1 pathway. i'm sure those paddlers can make their own minds up which pathway they go. let give them a choice i say and not be too dictator -ish about it all

Scotty88
4214 posts
9 Jun 2012 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

You men are very grumpy.

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
9 Jun 2012 10:32PM
Thumbs Up

Scotty88 said...

You men are very grumpy.


who asked you fella

matt18
VIC, 534 posts
9 Jun 2012 10:33PM
Thumbs Up

Adapt said...

ockanui to say "obviously the ravages of time, has not had an impact in your life as such?" Is one of the lamest sentences I have read from an opinion based on what you read on a computer screen. I've been challenged in my short amount of time on this planet in ways that you would not want to see any of your family or friends go through. That's why I have the 'viewpoint' of why should anyone of economic status or age be more recognised in the sport then a minority group, when the focus should be more on how can we increase numbers across all demographics and decreasing the barriers currently associated with the sport. The true meaning of life is to plant trees, under whose shade you do not expect to sit. ~Nelson Henderson
We make a living by what we get, but we make a life by what we give.~Winston Churchill



What is the minority group you talk about, it could be me . I am under 50, don't own race (borrow one when I do have a race) but do own surf style one. I will never be competitive in any division but I do have fun

PTWoody
VIC, 3982 posts
9 Jun 2012 10:40PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...

my point is not everybody wants to go to peru. my point is some people's focus could be hawaii. some people might just like riding different boards. some people might just be too dam old to go to peru on a 12'6 board

i'm suggesting 2 pathways or more, not just 1 pathway. i'm sure those paddlers can make their own minds up which pathway they go. let give them a choice i say and not be too dictator -ish about it all



But again, the Hawaiian pathway is not undermined by current regulations at state and national titles. Those wishing to go to Hawaii just need to buy a plane ticket, they don't need to qualify. On the other hand, the Peru option requires qualification and selection. Surfing Australia has a responsibility to select a team for Peru. That's why they have the current formats in place. This applies to race distances as well as board lengths. If Surfing Australia took on the responsibility of offering competitors some sort of warm up for Hawaii, the race distance would have to double at least, with strong downwind conditions. I'm just unconvinced that it's the purpose of national titles to give competitors a pathway to Hawaii.

Scotty88
4214 posts
9 Jun 2012 9:17PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...

Scotty88 said...

You men are very grumpy.


who asked you fella


Rest my case grumpy
Btw is Mac in tight with the Goldy sup crew now or what ?

BulldogPup
6657 posts
9 Jun 2012 9:27PM
Thumbs Up

have you still got that bottle of Red handy Scotty we need you to stand up and show us yer Label

ccarter
QLD, 76 posts
9 Jun 2012 11:29PM
Thumbs Up

I'm only new to the sup world but I have a couple of ideas if the governing body ran a state base competition monthly and used the best let's say for example 3 results or (however many )for the year at state competition level to select for a state team to then compete at a national level and then on for aussie team selection it's basic but may work and each month the venue could move around the state especially the larger states so everybody could get to the majority of contests.
And on age related surf lifesaving masters works well 35 + 45+ 55+ 10 year age increments for state and 5 at national level you can compete in a lower age group or opens but not a older age group it's an example but generally is very fair. Just thought I'd throw it out there.

Scotty88
4214 posts
9 Jun 2012 9:37PM
Thumbs Up

BulldogPup said...

have you still got that bottle of Red handy Scotty we need you to stand up and show us yer Label


You wish

BulldogPup
6657 posts
9 Jun 2012 9:42PM
Thumbs Up

No No Scotty stand up you've got a bit of fluff that has to be sorted brushed off

rahams
NSW, 544 posts
10 Jun 2012 12:10AM
Thumbs Up

Instead of age groups what about board groups.
Opens up to 9' Short board judging.9' over more points for style?
At the nsw titles I had a couple of heats with guys on 9 plus boards
I'm on a 8' foot board .all I had to do was a couple of dishpan turns
And the guy on the bigger board had no chance .The guy on the bigger board
Surfed unreal but never had a chance with the current system???

HumanCartoon
VIC, 2098 posts
10 Jun 2012 12:30AM
Thumbs Up

chrispychru said...

^^^^^free beer Mylanta for the biggies oldies and red cordial for the groms


FTFY

Piros
QLD, 6892 posts
10 Jun 2012 12:43AM
Thumbs Up

rahams said...

Instead of age groups what about board groups.
Opens up to 9' Short board judging.9' over more points for style?
At the nsw titles I had a couple of heats with guys on 9 plus boards
I'm on a 8' foot board .all I had to do was a couple of dishpan turns
And the guy on the bigger board had no chance .The guy on the bigger board
Surfed unreal but never had a chance with the current system???


Sh!t Noel that's can of worms no different to the Mals with traditional and progressive. I'm staying away from this one.

sharpie
NSW, 347 posts
10 Jun 2012 8:03AM
Thumbs Up

ok you have sucked me in again, 10' and over division and over 50's is my call for us fat, balance challenged, grumpy old men. and by the way its called SURFING AUSTRALIA not sup racing australia. sure, if its got a motor race it, if not just paddle away.[}:)][}:)][}:)] grumpy.

PTWoody
VIC, 3982 posts
10 Jun 2012 11:18AM
Thumbs Up

sharpie said...

and by the way its called SURFING AUSTRALIA not sup racing australia. sure, if its got a motor race it, if not just paddle away.[}:)][}:)][}:)] grumpy.


I guess this applies to Usain Bolt and James Magnussen too?

E T
QLD, 2286 posts
10 Jun 2012 11:28AM
Thumbs Up

Well I too was trying to stay out of this one but can't keep my mouth shut as usual. Whilst I don't dispute the fact that people are competitive and want to beat other people at things I can't understand why anyone over 50 would want to compete. I have heard all the reasons but honestly cannot grasp it. In a contest you do what they say, surf where they say, when they say. A bunch of guys on this thread are not happy with divisions etc. I say don't go. You can paddle, surf when and here you want if you are not tied to a contest. How many times do people complain about conditions, heat times, sign in times the list is endless.
I know there are other reasons such as friendship, etc but if other areas are like the Sunshine Coast there is no end of companions to SUP with and all are very friendly. I am talking ages from 20's to 70's.
I guess it comes back to people not being happy. Maybe they should SUP more.
I still don't get the competeting thing though.

malibujet
QLD, 59 posts
10 Jun 2012 12:21PM
Thumbs Up

Here's my take on it. I have entered the SUP surfing in the Qld 40+ div. I am 60 and still like to compete even though i know I don't have much chance against a 40 yr old but it's still fun. I surf Noosa almost every day and a lot of the SUP surfers there are over 50 and I know a lot of them would enter contests if there were more age divisions. It's not going to spread out the guys who enter into smaller divisions, there would be a lot more entries. Look at Longboard contests, the largest entries are in the 55+ and the 60+ and a lot of them SUP as well. I don't enter SUP races as I would probably get flogged in an open event paddling against a 20 something paddler but if there were age divisions I'd have a go. So if the competition of SUP is to grow there needs to be more age divisions in both surf and race events.

DavidJohn
VIC, 17417 posts
10 Jun 2012 1:33PM
Thumbs Up

malibujet said...

Here's my take on it. I have entered the SUP surfing in the Qld 40+ div. I am 60 and still like to compete even though i know I don't have much chance against a 40 yr old but it's still fun. I surf Noosa almost every day and a lot of the SUP surfers there are over 50 and I know a lot of them would enter contests if there were more age divisions. It's not going to spread out the guys who enter into smaller divisions, there would be a lot more entries. Look at Longboard contests, the largest entries are in the 55+ and the 60+ and a lot of them SUP as well. I don't enter SUP races as I would probably get flogged in an open event paddling against a 20 something paddler but if there were age divisions I'd have a go. So if the competition of SUP is to grow there needs to be more age divisions in both surf and race events.


I agree.

Make the prize money less.. Make the trophys smaller.. Even if it's just an elephant stamp on the back of the hand..

It's more about competing against those your own age than it is about winning or loosing.. or what you win.

It's true that its all about the 'partisapating' but it would be nice if you're not there just so the younger ones have someone to beat...

I'm pretty sure at the BOP Races in the US they have winners for +30, +40, +50 and +60... There's lots of winners..

And another thing.. When are we going to see the sun again here in Melbourne?..

DJ

appsy
NSW, 198 posts
10 Jun 2012 2:19PM
Thumbs Up

Hahahah massive can of worms.

For the surf sup we should only be allowed to ride 9ft plus, no more 8'0s or less. I had way more fun on my 9ft 6 then my 8'0s. But i ride my 8'0s because its easier to get a score.

Spoke to some industry big wigs the other week, they can't sell 8'0s to the public as alot of the crew cant ride em. If they cant sell em then they aren't earning any coin, not earning any coin, means nothing back to the sport. It may also get rid of dishpan's (hahahhaha)

Surfing Aus and SUPA are doing an awesome job. It must be hard to cater for everyone. The racing seems to be hammering ahead.


rahams said...

Instead of age groups what about board groups.
Opens up to 9' Short board judging.9' over more points for style?
At the nsw titles I had a couple of heats with guys on 9 plus boards
I'm on a 8' foot board .all I had to do was a couple of dishpan turns
And the guy on the bigger board had no chance .The guy on the bigger board
Surfed unreal but never had a chance with the current system???


DavidJohn
VIC, 17417 posts
10 Jun 2012 2:39PM
Thumbs Up

They've started making our race boards for the under 9' class..

DJ

Sparx
VIC, 734 posts
10 Jun 2012 2:49PM
Thumbs Up

DavidJohn said...

malibujet said...

Here's my take on it. I have entered the SUP surfing in the Qld 40+ div. I am 60 and still like to compete even though i know I don't have much chance against a 40 yr old but it's still fun. I surf Noosa almost every day and a lot of the SUP surfers there are over 50 and I know a lot of them would enter contests if there were more age divisions. It's not going to spread out the guys who enter into smaller divisions, there would be a lot more entries. Look at Longboard contests, the largest entries are in the 55+ and the 60+ and a lot of them SUP as well. I don't enter SUP races as I would probably get flogged in an open event paddling against a 20 something paddler but if there were age divisions I'd have a go. So if the competition of SUP is to grow there needs to be more age divisions in both surf and race events.




I agree.

Make the prize money less.. Make the trophys smaller.. Even if it's just an elephant stamp on the back of the hand..

It's more about competing against those your own age than it is about winning or loosing.. or what you win.

It's true that its all about the 'partisapating' but not if you're only there for the younger ones to have someone to beat.

I'm pretty sure at the BOP Races in the US they have winners for +30, +40, +50 and +60... There's lots of winners..

And another thing.. When are we going to see the sun again here in Melbourne?..

DJ



Could not have said it better than you guys
Shazam!!! what a can of worms. Lots of great ideas from all and sundry, no right or wrong, all valid in their own context.
I agree that we need to develope a comprehensive junior program and that's a challenge. If we dont want the sport to fade into the sunset as participants get older and older we have to find a way to make it cool for the kids. However when you look at the way trad longboarding has taken hold with the young hip and tragic, who's to say at some point SUP won't be flavor of the month with the twenty five and unders. We dont in Australia have the Kai Lenny's, Zane Shweitzer's, Connor Baxter's and Noah Yaps in any appreciable numbers. Im sure their out there but as of yet, they arent being nurtured.
As for me, as I've said, I love to compete. Not necessarily to beat crew, more to see where I sit in relation to the benchmark. I like to push my personal boundaries every time I hit the water even if that only means trying to get myself out through a shifty beachie hair dry. Fairly obviously the benchmark for a fifty two year old is going to be different to that of a twenty something. My original sook was that even though at this years Nationals there is an Over Forties, its half assed....two heats is more of a demo than a division. We arent getting ahead of ourselves, the numbers are there right now, why not do it properly?
But hey I'm a big boy. If I don't get into the Forties I'll just have to get one of Leons concrete milkshakes into me and HTFU for the Open. As for trying to hang on to my glory days, jeez I've won the local board club aggregate in both Open and Over Forties a few times but.... for the third year in a row I have earned the right to represent my State at the National Titles....for me it doesn't get much more glorious than that.
At the end of the day wether its surfing or racing, we're not invading Poland, we're just a bunch of big kids playing in the ocean.......Enjoy!!
Cheers
Sparx


62mac
WA, 24860 posts
10 Jun 2012 12:53PM
Thumbs Up

Adapt,I don't know your age mate,I'm 50 and played a hell of a lot of sport in my day.
Yep we were all young chargers way back in time and hitting a certain age was something I would look forward too,35,40,45 and now 50 why so I could compete with people in my age bracket.Now this was not to rub my ego as you have mentioned however to see how I sit within my age group.Adapt I can tell you right now I was way better at 40 than now at 50,I think this is what some of the guy's are saying.
I agree with Piros on his comments.

I had a good look around yesterday before the race started and at a guess 50% were 40+,sure support the event but a small trophy for each age group would be priceless to attract more numbers.How many people sup in Queensland,thousands I reckon but 60 odd entered the race yesterday.I would put money down that this would double if people could race within the race in thier own age group.I'm not trying to be negative here but this is how I see it,btw Adapt I no longer sup but was down there yesterday to support the Queensland Sup Titles. Enough from the grumpy old longboarder

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
10 Jun 2012 3:07PM
Thumbs Up

PTWoody said...

laceys lane said...

my point is not everybody wants to go to peru. my point is some people's focus could be hawaii. some people might just like riding different boards. some people might just be too dam old to go to peru on a 12'6 board

i'm suggesting 2 pathways or more, not just 1 pathway. i'm sure those paddlers can make their own minds up which pathway they go. let give them a choice i say and not be too dictator -ish about it all



But again, the Hawaiian pathway is not undermined by current regulations at state and national titles. Those wishing to go to Hawaii just need to buy a plane ticket, they don't need to qualify. On the other hand, the Peru option requires qualification and selection. Surfing Australia has a responsibility to select a team for Peru. That's why they have the current formats in place. This applies to race distances as well as board lengths. If Surfing Australia took on the responsibility of offering competitors some sort of warm up for Hawaii, the race distance would have to double at least, with strong downwind conditions. I'm just unconvinced that it's the purpose of national titles to give competitors a pathway to Hawaii.


but again not everyone wants to peru. the heathen majority

aus surfing can run their races as they see fit for those that wish to go that path.(the new in buzz word- path/way) no problems

but why should that be the be all, end all for 80% of the rest of the paddling population may i ask.

you are asking everybody to conform to a minority, yes a elite minority granted.

i sure hope we don't go down the shortboarding path where only the pro's and their best interests matter - i would be very disappointed

anyway this could go on and on.

i'm happy that qld surfing, troy peasy, the supsa committee and supsa provide a pathway for my dreams

Adapt
QLD, 723 posts
10 Jun 2012 4:04PM
Thumbs Up

I was going to stop writting on this but I think you guys need me to explain myself a bit better in a less angry mood.

All I could see yesterday was a group of guys whinging about not participating in events because there wasn't an age catergory for them or griping because they made a state team but have to compete against younger crew, this started in the Qld titles forum then moved to here.

These comments pissed me off because others and myself get their ass kicked all the time by some of these 50+ year old (Lacey, Dc, Alain, etc), but do I use the excuss that if I had my own age catergory I'd compete more often, HELL NO, I suck it up like a man and enjoy the fact that I'm helping promoting the sport. What I'm getting at here is will a 50+ age catergory really get more people to compete?

Then there was the opinion of having board size and age catergories for events, I'm not totally against this but from an organising percpective this can be a nightmare and not fiancially possible when a sport is still growing. I'm all for when the sport grows more age catergories etc, but ask yourselves why the younger crew don't get involved as much, is it the stigma that SUP is an old mans/womans sport?

In a nutshell I was voicing a viewpoint in a predominant 50+ forum, where I was trying to point out the broader issues for SUP competition rather then a small lets add a 50+ catergory.

62mac I was at the QLD titles as well yesterday and I'll be at the surfing tomorrow supporting the sport and when its not a major event I'm trying to help the local club move forward in a positive direction for all in the sport of SUP.

Obviously I offened people yesterday and sorry if anyone took it personally but I'm a passionate guy when it comes to SUP

Adapt
QLD, 723 posts
10 Jun 2012 4:06PM
Thumbs Up

laceys lane said...


i'm happy that qld surfing, troy peasy, the supsa committee and supsa provide a pathway for my dreams


+1 100%

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
10 Jun 2012 4:10PM
Thumbs Up

Adapt said...

I was going to stop writting on this but I think you guys need me to explain myself a bit better in a less angry mood.

All I could see yesterday was a group of guys whinging about not participating in events because there wasn't an age catergory for them or griping because they made a state team but have to compete against younger crew, this started in the Qld titles forum then moved to here.

These comments pissed me off because others and myself get their ass kicked all the time by some of these 50+ year old (Lacey, Dc, Alain, etc), but do I use the excuss that if I had my own age catergory I'd compete more often, HELL NO, I suck it up like a man and enjoy the fact that I'm helping promoting the sport. What I'm getting at here is will a 50+ age catergory really get more people to compete?

Then there was the opinion of having board size and age catergories for events, I'm not totally against this but from an organising percpective this can be a nightmare and not fiancially possible when a sport is still growing. I'm all for when the sport grows more age catergories etc, but ask yourselves why the younger crew don't get involved as much, is it the stigma that SUP is an old mans/womans sport?

In a nutshell I was voicing a viewpoint in a predominant 50+ forum, where I was trying to point out the broader issues for SUP competition rather then a small lets add a 50+ catergory.

62mac I was at the QLD titles as well yesterday and I'll be at the surfing tomorrow supporting the sport and when its not a major event I'm trying to help the local club move forward in a positive direction for all in the sport of SUP.

Obviously I offened people yesterday and sorry if anyone took it personally but I'm a passionate guy when it comes to SUP


its not a war, we all want the best.
we don't just turn up and race, we train hard

adapt you should be kicking my ass

cheers mate

Sparx
VIC, 734 posts
10 Jun 2012 4:19PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Adapt
Didn't for a minute take anything personaly.
You and Woody were one hundred percent correct in moving us on from the Queensland Titles thread, a time and a place and all that stuff. And there has been some bloody interesting ideas thrown up as a result.
It's great that you're passionate about SUP, with very few exceptions, most who post on this forum are passionate about the sport. All the racing stuff is eye opening for me. It's sometimes easy to get cocooned in your own little interest area, in my case surf, but quite obviously there's committed individuals out there pushing the boundaries of the sport in all its forms for the benefit of everyone.
All good.... hope your getting amongst it
Cheers
Sparx

laceys lane
QLD, 19803 posts
10 Jun 2012 7:51PM
Thumbs Up

Piros said...

rahams said...

Instead of age groups what about board groups.
Opens up to 9' Short board judging.9' over more points for style?
At the nsw titles I had a couple of heats with guys on 9 plus boards
I'm on a 8' foot board .all I had to do was a couple of dishpan turns
And the guy on the bigger board had no chance .The guy on the bigger board
Surfed unreal but never had a chance with the current system???


Sh!t Noel that's can of worms no different to the Mals with traditional and progressive. I'm staying away from this one.




noel the more i think about this, well, i always seem to like the guys like dogman etc on the bigger boards styling, but still surfing/carving.

no comp board under 9'!!!!!!!!????????

a lot more pro models more people can ride, more boards to sell etc etc

ockanui
VIC, 1299 posts
10 Jun 2012 8:59PM
Thumbs Up

After a couple of days hearty discussion there seems to be an overwhelming support for an older age category, where does it go from here? will the surfing associations listen?

I don't want to sound apologetic for the facts, but there seems to be more older people embracing Sup than at the other end, we all would like to see some more youth in the sport competing at the highest level and we would all encourage that and continue to do so, its only a matter of time, but in the mean time, the sport should be inclusive to all ages, including the older category.

I wonder how does the push for the new " over 50's pathway" continue past this thread or the next or the previous?, its up to the keen oldies to hassle those who make the decisions, I guess the one redeeming beauty of older age is that we less inclined to give a farrk of what people think, so therefore that should make it easier to be persistent, won't it ....



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"The grumpy old men of seabreeze thread" started by Sparx