Another reason not to buy Pryde

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
27 Oct 2006 5:48am
Apparently the piping at the bottom of the new Pryde sails is so abrasive, it can cut skin.

So they recommend you take a stanley knife to your brand spanking new sail!

www.neilpryde.com/?Itemid=61&id=189&option=com_content&task=view
winddude
winddude
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
27 Oct 2006 5:55am
Harden up!!!!!!!
Kremlin
Kremlin
418 posts
418 posts
27 Oct 2006 5:56am
Comrade Nebbian
I learn new Australian saying that applying to you for this maybe sure yar ?
'You be drying your eyes princess'
These sails very strong... like week old salted fish left in sun.
I prefer strong sail then one that fall apart
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
27 Oct 2006 6:31am
Comrade Kremlin,

Over here in Australia we have something called the "Ozone Hole", which means lots of UV light. Pryde sails seem to be very sensitive to this light, they get sunburnt and then fall to bits... many many people have had this problem. Not to mention insane downhaul tensions so the chances of a sail going bang when you rig it are high. Perhaps in Poland or motherland Russia you have less of a problem with UV?

Pryde R&D seems to have gone down the toilet lately

They do set nicely though
backloop
backloop
QLD
141 posts
QLD, 141 posts
27 Oct 2006 8:51am
I have some 10 or 15 year old pryde sails and they are still in reasonable condition. the older models must be better quality.

for the uv protection: put a layer of spf30+ on the monofilm.
filf_man
filf_man
WA
45 posts
WA, 45 posts
27 Oct 2006 6:53am
yeah i heard the same sort of thing from lots of people and have had a pryde sail fall apart in the past.
is it with all sails? hey kremlin, ya talking about wave sails or slalom? how much of a beating do u give em?
md74
md74
QLD
1064 posts
QLD, 1064 posts
27 Oct 2006 9:09am
um yes the neil pryde alpha has bitten me!

I have lost big chunks of skin down one shin from this area on my sail, as simple as when the bottom of the sail dragged across my shin in a wave, cut me like a sliced open salmon, leaving behind a nice burley trail!

Looks like I had best go get the stanley knife out

thanks Nebbian for digging this up, Ill make the mod right now.
mr bagus
mr bagus
WA
85 posts
WA, 85 posts
27 Oct 2006 7:09am
Yep,

All sails will fall apart after enough exposure to UV radiation, creasing, being squashed in the back of the car, gragged on the carpark, blown into fences.......

It is just ignorance to say this brand or that brand falls apart - which model, which year, which size, which country, which person using it, which climate.

Where are the scientific facts, statistics etc?

A comment from some guy on the beach is not fact....

A sail which is made of thin monofilm with no UV protection or re-inforcing will not last as long as one with these, in the same conditions and with the same use. Fact.

I'm sick of these self proclaimed "experts" Show us the facts and we will all be enlightened!

Meanwhile, enjoy the wind!
md74
md74
QLD
1064 posts
QLD, 1064 posts
27 Oct 2006 9:43am
allrighty then, now after inspection of both my alpha and saber sails, I can see why my leg was getting cut!

I did the mod and took to the plastic with a knife, took about 2 minutes per sail. No more scraped, bleeding shins!

I can see why they used this profile plastic, to protect the thread running along the bottom of the sail, it just has a very sharp edge.

fixed now. Im a huge fan of these sails, they have both been awesome so far, its a pretty good move by NP to bring this to the attention of sailors.
Kremlin
Kremlin
418 posts
418 posts
27 Oct 2006 9:13am
Comrade Filth
I refer to wave sails only
I give them much big work out... especially when falling/stalling/kooking at critical part of wave and getting smacked.
I do many wash cycles on full heavy duty load. This becauce I am kook not hard core
Other sails would blow panels and stitching... no problem with current sails. I have big wipeout and get flicked up and out but still maointain big grip on boom.
Then I land on sail... no tear no break... just wounded pride NOT wounded Pryde.
Other sails would have shattered for certain.
Next time i try keep together and with board conected i maybe make big crazy reverse twisting shakka aerial... or maybe not (I am kook for certain)

Comrade MD - I have many scars on legs from dragging foot of sail across shin when going for big cut backs... this OK many Russian chicks dig scars.. actually many Russian chicks have scars

Comrade Nebbian - No UV problem here in motherland though I do majority of sailing in Australia and have no problem with panel blow outs. Maybe you fall on sail too much yar ?

Last season I saw many sails from other manufacturer shredded on days where i have no problems. I also know they have many recalls on other brand last year.
I also learn new saying 'Glass for you is always half empty" this is ok ? yar ?
racycoot
racycoot
WA
315 posts
WA, 315 posts
27 Oct 2006 9:41am
The last few seasons of NP sails certainly look stronger.

But I still have a bad taste in my mouth from the late 90's
Leech
Leech
WA
1933 posts
WA, 1933 posts
27 Oct 2006 9:46am
I was talking to Robbie Raddis at scarbs yesterday and he had a new Alpha. He reckoned it was one of the easiest sails. But what astounded me was that he was planing on a 5.4 when guys 10kg less were struggling on 5.8's!
garynoel
garynoel
WA
260 posts
WA, 260 posts
27 Oct 2006 10:23am
That video is UNBELIEVABLE!

I just wonder how long its going to take for someone to sue Neil Pryde when they chop one of their fingers off trying this.


HAL9000
HAL9000
QLD
39 posts
QLD, 39 posts
27 Oct 2006 12:44pm
hopefully there are not to many ****ers like that in our sport.
Revhead
Revhead
ACT
372 posts
ACT, 372 posts
27 Oct 2006 12:47pm
Most sails are pretty good these days, but like most things material quality is suffering in the wake of profitability.

I find if I just sail with them, and not kick them or jump on them, they last longer.
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
27 Oct 2006 11:29am
quote:
Originally posted by Kremlin
Comrade Nebbian - No UV problem here in motherland though I do majority of sailing in Australia and have no problem with panel blow outs. Maybe you fall on sail too much yar ?

Last season I saw many sails from other manufacturer shredded on days where i have no problems. I also know they have many recalls on other brand last year.
I also learn new saying 'Glass for you is always half empty" this is ok ? yar ?



Hey Kremlin,
Yep I fall on sails many times, harness hook downmost, get bashed around in beach break and generally kook out. Never been through a big heavy rinse cycle because I'm too much of a big girls blouse to go out in those conditions.
It's not really "glass half empty", more like trying to justify a new North sail to myself when I know that my existing one doesn't set all that well... also had problems with old Pryde sails in the past, probably more to do with their age than anything else!

But if we're going to throw sayings at each other then I've got one for you:
"Hook line and sinker"
Crash Landing
Crash Landing
NSW
1173 posts
NSW, 1173 posts
27 Oct 2006 5:13pm
Lads (and the occasional lady),

End of the day, in my opinion, rig failiure is as much to do with luck as quality of build, aggressive sailing or being a kook! I have had massive wipeouts in mast and a half and had nothing more than a slight crease in the sail or a snapped outhaul rope. I have had small wipeouts in 2 foot swell where the clew end of the boom has caught on a sandbank and I've bent an extension, snapped a boom and popped a panel!

Based on the vast majority of people on this forum it seems like prydes are shiiite. However, also based on people on this forum I shouldn't have bought gun sails, loft masts and booms. I bought said kit and think it's awesome - so you have to take everything with a pinch of salt!

Look after your kit (i have sunscreened my sails), rinse it, rig it properly, use the right masts and don't do stupid things like leave a sail un-attended without it being attached to a board or you will suffer....
westozwind
westozwind
WA
1419 posts
WA, 1419 posts
7 Nov 2006 8:20am
If you need to "modify" the foot piping of your Alpha/Combat/Zone then Robbie Radis reckons that a potato peeler does a great job. Heaps safer than using a stanley knife!
garynoel
garynoel
WA
260 posts
WA, 260 posts
7 Nov 2006 9:24am

A $750 sail and you end up having to hack it with a potato peeler.

Maybe Pryde should provide one free, you know, velcro'd to the foot like Ezzy have with their batton tensioner tool.

Or they could supply the sail in kit form and you assemble it yourself?



mikekite
mikekite
QLD
55 posts
QLD, 55 posts
7 Nov 2006 12:14pm
Only the first few hundred sails had this problem, the moulding was changed as soon as the problem reared its head
whippingboy
whippingboy
WA
1104 posts
WA, 1104 posts
7 Nov 2006 11:03am
Oh yeah,
Well guess what sails and windsurfing kit are consumable products and get consumed some quicker than others.

I love Pryde and JP cause I can delude myself into thinking I am just like Jason , well I have been called a spoilt brat so now all I need is the skill and the 'nads and I'll be there.

Also they are environmentally unfriendly and made using all sorts of toxic chemicals and compounds

So shut up and buy, buy, buy.
Luv yas all
qldsalty
qldsalty
QLD
299 posts
QLD, 299 posts
7 Nov 2006 2:03pm
I'm with whippingboy. I buy only pryde ( to the disgust of southside shop retailers) If you trash the sail simply get another one and tell yourself that was a great session. If you bust a boom it's only a boom get a new one. I've tried brands other than NP twice and ended up with junk for a similar price. No way I'll change again.

Another spoilt brat.
Java
Java
VIC
14 posts
VIC, 14 posts
7 Nov 2006 5:47pm
I also have had problems with early 90s pryde sails but after ripping KA ,Gaastra ,Naish i am back on pryde and have found there lastest sails to be as strong as any other top brand and they look sick
Magnus8
Magnus8
QLD
366 posts
QLD, 366 posts
8 Nov 2006 8:15am
I'm with Salty & Java, even though my last Pryde race sail (2002)is now nailed to my rumous roof ( battens & cams removed ) with the 20+ repairs and stickers still holding ot together, I still wouldn't change!

Why?

Cause NP is a Kiwi, now I know how you Aussie's lurve a Kiwi!

Seriously they are the best, have not always been the most durable, but since 2004, things have changed.

Go Pryde!
exoman
exoman
WA
48 posts
WA, 48 posts
8 Nov 2006 1:29pm
Reckon I can make a fortune selling all you Pryde boys potato peelers
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
8 Nov 2006 6:36pm
Pryde make good sails- but so do North, gaastra, naish, et al. Pryde have been plagued with problems in the past- monofilm which has since been fixed, extreme mast curves and some silly concepts- the monofilm i blame on cost cutting but the others is by trying to stay at the head of the sport. Currently I only believe they could maybe beef up the seams in the panel above the boom on their wave sails.

Each brand tends to feel a bit different and whilst you may dislike a sail from a few tries sailing the sail a few times and you soon become adapted to that sail. Pryde tend to have a certain feel to all their sails which many people like, does it make them the best sails... no but it does make them good that most people can jump on and sail good right away with them.

You cant look at robbie raddis and say that makes them better- give the top guys sails and almost always they will make them fly and plane earlier than any other sail- its part of what makes them good sailors. If I choose a sail based on performance I tend to look at what is happening locally/state level where often good gear boosts a sailors performance.

I dont currently sail pryde but I would sail them avoiding certain years. I probably wont sail them again as I feel they are a little expensive for what you get. The brand loyalty in this sport is pretty amazing, but I think some people should objectively look at where, how often and what type of sailing they do before they argue. You cant argue against someone that sails 200+ days a year and says these pryde's arent as good as others when you sail maybe once a week so have never had a problem.

Yes pryde screwed up again but hey if it was say gun would have you heard about it, sometimes things like this are unavoidable.
Leech
Leech
WA
1933 posts
WA, 1933 posts
8 Nov 2006 5:41pm
not to mention the sweat shops


death to NP
md74
md74
QLD
1064 posts
QLD, 1064 posts
8 Nov 2006 9:12pm
hey fellas, it was mentioned in this thread the problem wass only on a few hundred sails worldwide, and the problem is fixed from here on in.

Really simple answer, if you dont like NP, dont buy it. But save us the whinge please.

Those that dig NP will continue to buy. Im stoked with my NP sails, but I wont bag the bejesus out of every other sail maker.

hit the water and have fun!
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
8 Nov 2006 10:18pm
Geez the NP folk are very protective in their investment- especially mr wiggle .

You chose to buy the benchmark of the industry, of course it's going to come under scrutiny. In the end who really gives a ****, it's only a piece of plastic.
md74
md74
QLD
1064 posts
QLD, 1064 posts
9 Nov 2006 7:55am
wake up Jeff

hot potato hot potato

whippingboy
whippingboy
WA
1104 posts
WA, 1104 posts
9 Nov 2006 9:54am
Good one !
You can peel my potatoes anytime.
I have pride in my Prydes
but I did have earlier affairs with Ms Gaastra,
Mrs North, Miss Naish and the sadly lost Mrs Sail Logic.
I loved 'em all but as you know you have to stick up for your current girlfriend and try not to mention earlier loves

Maybe I should take to my Alpha with a hot potatoe !

Watch for the photos
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply