Moreton Bay

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
nitai
nitai
QLD
62 posts
QLD, 62 posts
9 Jan 2006 3:20pm
Hi all,
I'm new to these forums and recently just started windsurfing. 4 months so far and loving it. I live at Manly in Moreton Bay and it's an excellent spot. Seen quite a few windsurfers out.

how many of you here surf at Manly or Wello?

I love the sport but am a bit freaked at the moment. I read about the recent shark attack at Straddy and then found this info about Moreton Bay: www.escapewithet.com/

I'm going to have to muster up the courage to get back out there! Anyway, it would be good to know who around here surfs at Moreton and hasn't been eaten yet!
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
9 Jan 2006 4:39pm
Hey nitai, I sailed at manly for years (I now sail at wello since I now live there). I have fished moreton bay all of my life.

There are many big sharks in the bay, tangalooma used to be a whaling station and it was here I believe that the world record white pointer was caught that the story refers to. When we went to St Helena as kids they told us they used to try to attract the sharks to deter prisoners from swimming to the mainland. I have caught heaps of sharks, mostly small ones like pictured but many I have had no chance of landing on some pretty heavy tackle. Dont be put off by the number of small sharks though think of these just like any other fish and are doing us a favour by keeping the bay reasonably clean.

There are situations and places to avoid though, where that woman swimming at amity pt was is one of them. I would never swim in/near the rainbow channel ever (I have actually been fishing at amity when less than 3m away big sharks have come near the surface and scared the crap outta me cause that is damn close when you are sitting by or standing in the water). Think about it this way, big sharks cover a huge area but they will stay where most of the food is. Everything that comes into moreton bay (big sharks, whales, schools of fish etc)comes through 1 of 2 places north of moreton which is quite a large area or between moreton and straddie which is quite narrow condensed area.

Avoid the shipping channel, big sharks traditionally follow the ships and eat all the garbage. Avoid shallow areas next to big drop offs and areas where there is deep-shallow-deep ie the bank that goes out from the point at Manly, dont avoid it like the plague just be wary not to stand out there for half and hour taking a break-it never stopped some of us though(there is a gutter that runs out on the northern side of that bank which is called shark alley/gutter). Most attacks happen in shallow water due to the displacement of water by the shark and natural tendancies to chase things which dont swim to well on the land. I dont know if you've ever seen the dolphins working the schools of fish into the beach down there at Manly, it is pretty cool.

Avoid crab pots and to some extent be aware of the time you spend in the water during crabbing season. Avoid sailing at sunrise/sunset, fishing though we would tend to catch sharks just after the sun has gone down... too dark to sail then. Avoid sailing just after heavy rain, there are more implications than just sharks here hitting a tree floating just under the water tends to put a damper on your day as does stepping on a catfish or bullrout that get flushed into the bay. A word of warning, there used to be a huge tiger shark that used to come into the bay for a week or so every year I dont know if it still does but it used to be around d'arcy light and come down into the bay at manly. We always used to hear if it was around or see it, most people still sailed.

After all that just go out and sail, most people I know suffer some sort of shark phobia. As said a million times before you have greater chance of getting killed by being hit by a car, a boat, another sailboarder or 100x greater chance of a kite landing on your head . Its all a game of odds, when your time is up your time is up. Dont believe all the crap in the media, a so called shark expert said bull sharks are more prevalent in the bay after rain since they get sick from fresh water... this is strange since they can and do live in fresh water (fish get ill/sluggish from fresh water, easy food for sharks)- I hate the media.

If you are ever sailing at manly or wello and see me out come up and say hi, I have either MK7 or AUS357 sail numbers so pretty noticeable. I dont sail manly too much unless I can drag my mate out that lives down there. I sailed there saturday for the first time in ages, was good fun a little gusty but good for a change of scenery.
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
9 Jan 2006 11:19pm
Gday Nitai Ive been sailing in the bay for 17 years and never seen a shark, I know there out there ad have heard of someone getting nipped by a reef shark but that's about it.Anyway I also sail at wello with mkseven when he's there, it seem he spends more time on this forum then windsurfing a Mark.
I sail Aerotech sails and Wind Action boards so feel free to say gday.
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
10 Jan 2006 3:19pm
Why windsurf when you can speak cr@p all day

Some of us dont get the luxury of sailing everyday, and I spend my time relaxing before work here.

Nitai you better catch vando on the land, cause on the water you wont see him- "fastest" sailer in qld be he *cough cough*

Mike- strapped the gps to tom's arm on saturday 28.3 first run (first sail in a year in fact). When I finally got the gps back off him I only managed 29.5 with the chop and gusts it was all a bit of a handful on the hyper. Didnt try a run down the wall though. There is alot of potential in tom if I can get him to sail, he is one of the fastest sailors I know in the right conditions and I gave him some damn fast sails last year.
nitai
nitai
QLD
62 posts
QLD, 62 posts
10 Jan 2006 3:44pm
Hey guys,
thanks for the replies. If you see me say hi. I've got some 5.6 m red and yellow sail and a Tyronsea, a big log of a board.

It's comforting to know you've been sailing there for a long time but all that info you gave me, and the Tiger shark?! Freakin me out.

I really don't want to give up windsurfing. It's the new love of my life but geez ...

Is Wello any different? Less sharks around? I'd consider going there for a surf.

Maybe I should get one of those Sharkshields.


It's amazing I haven't got chomped yet! I started learning in the lota bay just in that small area to the North of the lota canal. Geez now that I think about it, it's not a good spot with the deep, shallow thing going on and very often i've done it in very dirty murky water after rain. Not just last week I was out there and saw a dugong.

What are Crab pots, and when is crabbing season?
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
10 Jan 2006 9:56pm
mmm 28.3 and 29.5 knots a Mark add another 5 and you would be close to me LOL.
Nitai don't worry to much about the shark thing, I would be more worried about those darn kites loping my head off.
nitai
nitai
QLD
62 posts
QLD, 62 posts
10 Jan 2006 10:53pm
yeah ... trying to build up my courage to get back out there ... or splurge $650 on a shark zapper!
drjukka
drjukka
QLD
258 posts
QLD, 258 posts
11 Jan 2006 12:05am
Nitai,

I have sailed Moreton Bay - mostly out of Manly for ~ 10 years.

I have seen sharks (2 x 3ftoot fellow) and 1 x 8-12 foot (out near Green Is in my travels. We think this was the legendary Tiger Shark who used to visit around Christmas every year.

One unfotunate story was of the young lass who was bitten on the heel by the wobbegong she walked on at Manly - just off the rock wall and ther have been reports of a fisherperson landing a 7ft - again off he rock wall at Manly.

The risk really is minimal and it is much more likley that you will be injured from a windsurfing manoeuvre. accident.

Think about it - you fall in the water 8 -10 times over a 2-3 hour period and you need to do so in the vicinity of a shark (rare) to be in any danger.

Keep sailing - When at Manly you can find me using mostly Naish gear.

- J

drjukka
drjukka
QLD
258 posts
QLD, 258 posts
11 Jan 2006 12:05am
Nitai,

I have sailed Moreton Bay - mostly out of Manly for ~ 10 years.

I have seen sharks (2 x 3ftoot fellow) and 1 x 8-12 foot (out near Green Is in my travels. We think this was the legendary Tiger Shark who used to visit around Christmas every year.

One unfotunate story was of the young lass who was bitten on the heel by the wobbegong she walked on at Manly - just off the rock wall and ther have been reports of a fisherperson landing a 7ft - again off he rock wall at Manly.

The risk really is minimal and it is much more likley that you will be injured from a windsurfing manoeuvre. accident.

Think about it - you fall in the water 8 -10 times over a 2-3 hour period and you need to do so in the vicinity of a shark (rare) to be in any danger.

Keep sailing - When at Manly you can find me using mostly Naish gear.

- J

mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
11 Jan 2006 8:12am
nitai i really wouldnt worry about it, really when your time is up it is up there is nothing you can do. The chick that was killed is the first fatality I can remember in the bay, way back yonder in the ultimate case of **ty luck a guy dropped something from his boat jumped over the side and apparently pretty much straight onto a big shark. My dad told me this story so it could be anywhere up to 80 years ago, it did happen out from wynnum.

My family has been netting down at Lota on the banks for years and would regularly get up to 6-7ft sharks tangled in the nets, you take care getting them out but they've never attacked us. They have had a few close calls over the years whilst fishing waist+ deep in water but that is just asking for it. drjukka the tiger is a little bigger than that, there are plenty of 8-12ft sharks in the bay.

Sharks really arent too interested in people, watch surfers from a headland for a while and you'll see them swimming around underneath. There are/were also some old guys floating around that would swim out into the bay at both manly and wello and have done so for 20+ years. I asked the guy at wello if he worried about sharks, didnt worry him and he swims right out past the leads at wello down to ormiston and back up (boats are a greater concern). My dad is at me all the time about sharks, I tend to point out the high number of dugong, turtle, dolphin and crap pots in the bay which they can readily eat all of which have a little less fight than an angry human and are a little more nutritional as well.

Mike I think your gps is broken, or maybe mine you dont exactly overtake me too often . I wish i was sailing at wello, tom dosent like loading gear into car even though everyone else has to. I guess I cant push him too much it took a year to get him on the water again.
cozza
cozza
QLD
4 posts
QLD, 4 posts
11 Jan 2006 8:29am
i swim at redcliffe but never seen a shark but i fish too and i have caught 3 sharks and to sting rays at woody point and redcliffe jetty. one was a moster
Yousurf
Yousurf
WA
165 posts
WA, 165 posts
11 Jan 2006 8:15am
The only reason sharks try to eat people is to get back at them for being caught on a huge hook stuck in there mouth and getting dragged back to a boat. If we started catching dolphins they would turn on us too!
Boris
Boris
261 posts
261 posts
11 Jan 2006 8:34am
But if we don't catch dolphins, where do we get our cat food from?
I suppose there's still horses.
nitai
nitai
QLD
62 posts
QLD, 62 posts
11 Jan 2006 11:37am
I can hear my board calling me so I don't think i'll be giving it up.

Do many people sail at Wello regularly? It's always comforting when there are others around, plus it reduces the odds!

where abouts at Wello do you guys surf?

@ Yousurf: I tend to agree with you. Personally i'm vegetarian (that includes no fish) so maybe if I paint "vegetarian" on the bottom of my board the sharkies will leave me alone.

Whats Redcliffe like?
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
11 Jan 2006 4:41pm
Wello it depends on wind direction. n/e we generally sail western side of sand bank, here you get some flat water and can sail to Manly and back if you are keen. s/e sail the eastern side launch south of the jetty, you have to watch where you sail at a low tide but it has the least trudge to the water as you can go down the boat ramp by the jetty, 1 tack and you are clear.

Wello is also great in the winter westerlies, chop forms into some nicely shaped ramps for jumping. Seeing Manly last saturday i'd say Wello has a few more sailors, what you do get in droves is kiters which are a bit of a pain in n/e as we use the same sailing area.
nitai
nitai
QLD
62 posts
QLD, 62 posts
11 Jan 2006 7:54pm
cool. I should come over and check it out some time.
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
11 Jan 2006 8:32pm
quote:
Originally posted by mkseven
Mike I think your gps is broken, or maybe mine you dont exactly overtake me too often .


[1]That's because im always in front, cause you carnt jibe.
[2]Your rarely out in over 18 knots or at all.
[3]When have you ever passed me, takes 1-2 knots more to pass someone
[4]GPS doesn't lie LOL

Its about time you posted some times or are you to ashamed too.
drjukka
drjukka
QLD
258 posts
QLD, 258 posts
12 Jan 2006 9:05am
MK7

Vando's GPS is right on the money! (unfortunately) I wish it was broken too!!

On Saturday a few of the crew sailed out of the beach just south of RQ - which is where nitai sails (I think). We were trying this spot out at high tide. (maybe why Manly seemed quiet)

Happy to report it worked pretty well and suffered less from the channel chop you can get at Manly. There was some nice chop/ramps and If I worked upwind hard enough I could have sailed to Wello. The swell here seemed to have a longer pitch makeing it easier to sail - this does not make logical sense to me but it was my observation. Next high tide NE at 15-20 knots I will sail from this location.

FYI my speeds on Saturday (South of RQ) and Sunday (sailed with Vando) were within 0.5 knots.

DrJ
nitai
nitai
QLD
62 posts
QLD, 62 posts
12 Jan 2006 12:17pm
drjukka,
You're close, I actually haven't sailed out of that beach. I sail just to the south, right from the wall at the Lota park. I live just across the road so I walk my board down and hop in off the steps.

I'll keep an eye out for you guys.
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
12 Jan 2006 3:41pm
Geez Mike, talk about throwing down the gauntlet. You should be faster than everyone since you sail more than anyone I know.

I have sailed that spot at RQ, gets a little gusty in southerly. Is awesome in northerly, sailing from there to wello.
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
12 Jan 2006 8:17pm
LOL
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
13 Jan 2006 9:21am
drjukka who are you? I believe that many would have been quite a bit faster, it was the first time I had the hyper out overpowered and it is damn scary (until I get used to it) a board that wide and short flying out of the water- I dont know how the hell formula guys manage. If I had it with me I would have taken out the 263 slalom, then I would have been a little closer to you guys no doubt- wont sail that again until I finish the nose modification though.

Wanted... a sponsor for vando who would humble even Bjorn Dunkerbeck for time spent on the water , I understand you've been missing fast cars for a while now and are trying to make up for it with windsurfing

Are you racing sunday btw?
drjukka
drjukka
QLD
258 posts
QLD, 258 posts
13 Jan 2006 6:11pm
mkseven,

I don't know if we have met - I sail mostly from Manly. (Naish Enduro boards) - various sails - Vando knows who I am. I was one of the few souls who posted times in the WQ GPS event about a month ago!

Faster Than Vando - Thats a challenge!!.

My point about Manly and the beach just south of RQ was that both offer some reasonable speeds. Vando & I tried running up the N side of Rose Bay on mid-high tide (just on the Manly side of shark alley) heading to St Helena for some speed runs - not too bad and can be reasonably flat. We are going to go looking for a good spot in a SE.

I tried running in deep behind the rock wall at the beach just south of RQ but was not getting my top speeds there, rather on the reach out?!?! Think I may have been collecting weed on the run in and this was slowing me down. Wind on Saturday was gusting up to 32 knots, on Sunday about 22-24 knots Max just about the same top speed.

Look forward to catching up on the water soon.

- J


vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
13 Jan 2006 7:40pm
Moreton Bay Waters:
Friday until midnight: NE winds 10/15 knots, seas to 0.7 metres.
Saturday: E/NE winds 10/15 knots, lighter in the morning. Seas to 0.7 metre.
Sunday: SE/E winds 10/15 knots.
Monday: SE/E winds 10/15 knots.
mmm dont think im going racing on Sunday long way for nothing.
Where's all the wind gone.

drjukka haven't had any wind to try that board of yours.
had a look at the bottom shape on it,No Vee but seems to have constant rocker line is this right, Prob why it get out of control
over 20+ knots.

ta Vando
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
13 Jan 2006 8:12pm
I will make a decision tomorrow whether I'm going to the lake or not, might just take the RX for a run- if there is wind all the better.

Feel free to drop that board around if you still want me to redeck it, sorry i havent been down been a little swamped with work at the moment. So have you been getting any unwanted offers whilst using the pink board

drjukka I think you are right about the wall at Manly, you tend to bare away a little too much, that combined with the slight drop/gust of wind = slow.

For me now it is cracking my gybes (as much as I love being picked on by Mike and Dave M ), worrying about speed later.
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
13 Jan 2006 8:47pm
Mark have you got your computer sorted yet.
When you do I give you a hand setting up gps software if you like.
You want to buy that board prob too fast for you $200 and its yours.
ta vando
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
13 Jan 2006 9:36pm
What the hell would I do with another board, I got 2 more than I need right now. I like the hyper but it needs tuning time, I reckon it has more potential than I do. Tom took it for a ride the other day and i've never received a board back from him so quick, come to think of it Mike you gave it back pretty quick too [}:)]

GPS software all good and sorted, hardly worth posting anything under 35.

Been making/adjusting some new fins in my non sailing time so it hasnt been totally wasted , 32cm was getting a little big so I made a 27 .

vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
13 Jan 2006 10:49pm
Hey Mark have you done any good speeds this year.
If you have averaged over 30 it would be worth posting it on Al's site.
I didnt really get a very good go on the the Hyper you only had a 5.5 on in 15 knots.I have a new toy myself now Exocet Scross.
Ive also been playing around with fins in my spare time.
drjukka
drjukka
QLD
258 posts
QLD, 258 posts
14 Jan 2006 12:17am
mk7.

garrY tells me he is thinking of separating out the Sandy Point times on Al's site , this will make posting times that are 30+ (even 28+) reasonable on Al's site.

vando - the board you have was supposed to have 1mm of V with a constant rocker line. What has happened over time is that the epoxy has shrunk at a different rate over the carbon stringer in the board. When you look under the board there is a slightly raised flat surface about 150 mm wide - this is a piece of carbon fibre cloth that acts as a stringer to provide strength. (polystyrene blank with a 6 oz carbon stringer and 4 oz cloth over the base, 4 oz cloth over the back top of the board and the rest is 2oz - from memory.

Suggest we may want to try having the bottom sanded back and recoated to get the mirror smooth surface it was when I had it commissioned.

The board really requires flat water - I will bring to Sandy Pt with me to try it out. In the right conditions (18-23 knots on Moreton Bay)it is like a rocket ship to sail - keeps accelerating - the biggest problem I have always had with this board is the speed at which it hits the chop - the rails are very hard around the mast track area.

mk7 - best thing I have found about the GPS is that I am now consistently sailing 10% faster than when I first strapped the thing on. I am sailing better up and down wind than a year ago. Vando has clearly improved another 10% after his trip to Sandy Pt Last year. He was topping out at mid 32's and now it seems to be be mid 35's - (on average times)


- J

mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
14 Jan 2006 8:58am
Now I know Mike's secret, it's all from Sandy Point ... Mike not really best i've done this year is about 32.9 on the 263, 32.3 on the hyper (on the day you tried it Mike) and 30.8 on my freestyle board.

Having used Mike's setup I do know why he goes faster than most on a broad reach. Mike also sails probably 4 times as much as I do, I think he stepped it up over the year as I dont think he was sailing this much last year. Of that 4 times as much 1/2 is spent on freestyle, 1/2 on slalom so he is more committed to going fast than I am, and gets to make the most of conditions if they are right.

I dont have a problem of times set at sandy point, provided location is stated. People generally know that insane speeds are reached down there.

Why the SCross and which size... 120 or smaller?
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
14 Jan 2006 10:19am
Hi Mark Als site is ranked on 100M that should allows for any errors.
i believe there going to change the site to keep sandy point separate
I tried the scross 120 litre up at Caloundra and ended up driving home with one.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply