valve screws

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Combs
Combs
WA
152 posts
WA, 152 posts
12 May 2006 3:36pm
It is very interesting how long a thread can go on about what you would think was a fairly simple thing - the humble valve screw. However, it is nice to see that the windsurfing forum is good and active.

I have recently taken up surfing (or trying to at least). No wind and wanted to stay on the water - in case you were wondering. I have found it very interesting. Naturally I have been over to the surfing forum and have sadly found very little activity.

Back to the point; I just brought myself an old surfboard and have been informed by some knowledgable people that because the core is of closed cell construction, there is no need to worry about the occassional laceration to the fibreglass. They don't have valve screws, are extremly light and take a lot of punishment.

So I got to thinking. Why is there such a significant difference between my windsurfing board and my surfboard? Why can't they build a windsurfer like a surfboard so that we don't have to worry about valve screws, nor go into immediate panic if we smack our nose and crack it (then spend the next couple of weeks trying to suck the brains out of it with a series of fish pond pumps and the like.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
12 May 2006 3:55pm
quote:
Originally posted by wendell

Therefore I assume the percentage difference is relative to -273C, so when decrepit says 0 to 25 is a bigger change than 25 to 50, it's only about a 10% difference (between those two ranges,


That sounds right to me, so the difference beetween the 2 ranges would be a fraction of 1%, as I said, no practical difference. But just thought it would be interesting to point out that the lower temp range is theoretically more harmfull.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
12 May 2006 4:21pm
quote:
Originally posted by Combs

I just brought myself an old surfboard --- They don't have valve screws, are extremly light and take a lot of punishment.

Why is there such a significant difference between my windsurfing board and my surfboard? Why can't they build a windsurfer like a surfboard so that we don't have to worry about valve screws,



read my post earlier in this thread about closed cell foam, posted - 21/04/2006 : 16:57:19

Unfortunately although your surfboard feels light, it probably has a lot less volume, and doesn't have the extra reinforcment a sail board needs, or the mast track, heavy duty finbox, footstrap plugs, etc.
About 10 years ago most custom sailboards were made this way and were significantly heavier than today's boards.
If you really like the idea of closed cell foam, see if blue juice has come up with a low density foam to his liking, or check out stone surfboards in Gero - www.stonesurf.com/
Juice
Juice
WA
280 posts
WA, 280 posts
11 Mar 2007 11:00am
Keep the vent plug open at all times the board is not in the water.
Only close the vent plug for sailing.
If you don't use the vent plug sell your board after a couple of years.
Don't but a used board that has had the vent plug always closed.
WINDY MILLER
WINDY MILLER
WA
3183 posts
WA, 3183 posts
11 Mar 2007 11:21am
can't find the valve screw in my new board

joy!
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
11 Mar 2007 11:35am
So how does your Stoner react in a hot car Miller?
Whats the construction materials?
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
11 Mar 2007 12:00pm
Miller you trying to outdo me with ugly pics? Or are you 45 and still wear blk jeans and DB's everywhere
WINDY MILLER
WINDY MILLER
WA
3183 posts
WA, 3183 posts
11 Mar 2007 12:48pm
hmmmm dunno, i suppose there's no issues with closed cell tech, but i always open my windows a bit anyway ..just in case


mark if eddy was going to have a dog it would be yours, no questions.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
11 Mar 2007 2:38pm
True!

I wanna see the dog and the fish have a fight..........
CJW
CJW
NSW
1731 posts
CJW CJW
NSW, 1731 posts
11 Mar 2007 7:19pm
quote:
Originally posted by Juice

Keep the vent plug open at all times the board is not in the water.
Only close the vent plug for sailing.
If you don't use the vent plug sell your board after a couple of years.
Don't but a used board that has had the vent plug always closed.



Why?

I open my vent plugs on one occasion only and that's when my board goes in an aeroplane.

In my opinion more damage is done by forgetting to put that plug back in (i've seen it many times) and getting water in than leaving it in for super extended periods.

The biggest 'pressure shock' to a board is when it goes from ambient air into the water and at that time your bung is always in, you hope. Taking the bung out once you leave the water seems pointless to me as the thermal/pressure changes are far more gradual.

I can see your point if you leave your board in the car all day parked in the sun.
ma
ma
NSW
375 posts
ma ma
NSW, 375 posts
11 Mar 2007 7:34pm
yep CJW is spot on, never had a problem with leaving it done up.
JESUS
JESUS
WA
150 posts
WA, 150 posts
11 Mar 2007 8:51pm
"Why?" are you kidding? check out the board lady she'll explain it in real simple terms.
Forgetting to put the vent plug in damage is related to the operaters brain power or lack of.
mineral1
mineral1
WA
4564 posts
WA, 4564 posts
11 Mar 2007 9:45pm
What is amazing is that here we are 2007, and the whole idea of a screw plug, hasn't evolved by the manufactures to a system like Carbon Art use, or some other system that doesn't need constant removal or replace each time a board is used.
besides the issue of the average run of the mill person forgetting to remove plug, tighten/refit plug, the end user is faced with the chance of a seal fracturing or the seat its sealing against having a grain of sand damage the sealing area or the seal with the torsional force. Seal breakage without the end user being aware its broken until he removes plug at end of session and so on.
Added to this, check your board, most will find that the recess that the plug fits into, has the screw threaded section not drilled on the same plane. I.E. the recess drilled at 90degree to board, the vent hole is drilled at anything from 86 degrees to 90 degrees, depending on each board.
The disappointing issue is, most people have outlaid a considerable amount of funds for a board that is protected by a cheap cheap agricultural vent plug that is prone to failure either by self inflicted none correct use, or seal failure.
Mineral
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
11 Mar 2007 10:08pm
Dudes who ever doesn't use the vent plug is a dick. As I said in this thread months ago, it is easier to get a bit of water out of a board than fix a 3ft long delam. If you can afford to even remotely chance something happen to your $2500 investment then you are too rich

Mineral, yes they could do a better system, but I just replace the O-ring at the start of the season so I knwo it is good...... same as my tendon, ropes, harness lines. $50 all up to have less prob's.............
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
11 Mar 2007 11:47pm
I went to Bunnings and got a box of O-rings for five bucks. This allows me to replace the O-ring every session. I also make sure that the vent is clean and free of sand. This only takes a few seconds every time I rig. I am also like Mark and replace tendon and ropes every so often. Mostly twice a season
garynoel
garynoel
WA
260 posts
WA, 260 posts
12 Mar 2007 11:17am

In my opinion the vent plug is something that needs serious redesign!

It's far too easy to forget to undo (when travelling) or do up (when sailing).

If its so important here should be a big fat orange lever on it or something so that it is obvious which position it is in.

swoosh
swoosh
QLD
1929 posts
QLD, 1929 posts
12 Mar 2007 12:22pm
i take mine out every now and again, i figure the manufacturers must tell you to do it for a reason. they build the boards so you think they might have a clue. and i've never managed to sail off without mine, thou i have lost it before. spend an hour combing through long grass for it (luckily after a session). came back the next day with my neighbours metal detector and found it in seconds. Metal detectors are awesome
garynoel
garynoel
WA
260 posts
WA, 260 posts
12 Mar 2007 11:37am

Yeah,
I'm not questioning its importance, just lazy design.
I've lost a couple. Why don't they tether them to the boards?

Or better still incorporate the bung into the finbox and just put a rubber grommet on the fin endplate?
So each time you remove the fin you open the breather hole?

Mackay
Mackay
NSW
78 posts
NSW, 78 posts
12 Mar 2007 3:38pm
The new Carbon Art boards have a goretex membrane rather than a plug. Lets air in and out but no water. This sounds pretty good if you can't poke something through it. If this membrane was built into a plastic plug you could replace the metal one with, I'd buy one!
woody46
woody46
WA
78 posts
WA, 78 posts
12 Mar 2007 7:08pm
Maybe the designers could come up with a pressure relief, one-way valve, so that if the board expands ,the XS air can escape, but we wouldn't have to worry about removing and Especially: replacing the valve.After I asked the original question, I started to remove the valve each usage.......guess what I forgot to do ,just the once, got about 10 metres out and saw something was missing!!!!!!! duh
Juice
Juice
WA
280 posts
WA, 280 posts
12 Mar 2007 10:34pm
When I make a board I put the vent plug in the nose area, so if it forgotten to be done up then that area of the board has the highest chance of staying out of the water, you can also see it when sailing which helps remind you to think if it was done up.
CJW leaving it done up all the time means that the board shrinks and expands EVERYDAY with the min and max temps, so after this happening say 730 times(2years)the weakest link in the board which is the bond between the little polystyrene balls pulls apart and the board delams. Ive ripped open many delam boards for repairs and theres a thin layer of beads still stuck the skin of the board.
snides8
snides8
WA
1731 posts
WA, 1731 posts
12 Mar 2007 11:15pm
yep ditto that mr juice, i believe that delam is possibly not the correct term more likely the styrene is 'fractured' as the bond between beads is weaker than the initial bond between the the styrene and the first laminate....
not certain about the other states but make no mistake leaving your vent plug screwed in here (when not sailing) in wa will eventually lead to tears...
as for the issue on vent plug design, i have a carbon art with a gortex vent and have had no problems with it so far (touch wood)you can apply soap suds to it in the heat and it bubbles away like mad.

the general design with vent plugs and o rings is fundamentally flawed...
o rings are not designed to be used in this situation. the over tightening of the screw can lead to pinching of the ring and posibly splitting and if you lubricate the oring too much this can lead to the oring spreading and creating small gaps as well.
the plastic insert into the board doesnt help either as it can quickly wear from sand and grit as well, creating imperfections in the 'seat' where the oring is squashed against.
there is definetly room for companies, especially those reknown for quality and innovation, to come up with a better,fool proof way of maintaining a water tight hull.
WINDY MILLER
WINDY MILLER
WA
3183 posts
WA, 3183 posts
12 Mar 2007 11:23pm
heres a thing too...

check that the mfctr has remembered to drill a whole from the vent plug hole down into the board.

I've had a couple of boards that haven't been drilled, so the valve screw was pointless.

check by pouring some soapy water around the scew on a hot day, then open slightly and see if it bubbles..... if it doesn't then get the drill out....don't drill too far though
garynoel
garynoel
WA
260 posts
WA, 260 posts
13 Mar 2007 11:27am

Yep.
I can see me now windy spending 2 grand on a board and then getting my black and decker out to drill a hole through the middle of it!
Boris
Boris
261 posts
261 posts
14 Mar 2007 8:34am
Why bother? Just super glue the thing in so it never comes out.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply