CH3MTR4IL5 said..
So, fwiw I have adapted the stinkbug to a technique I'm calling the zen stinkbug, but the 'zen sniper' is maybe a better title!
I had a lot of difficulty with the pitching you've described JY77, I'm on a 4'7" board and in swell I found I was either going over the front or sliding off the back as the board went vertical in either direction. It was super tiring and lots of attempts to get to a starting position.
My approach is (can start from sitting or lying)
- both hands on front of board with leading hand holding the wing
- knees are either side of the board so my thighs are on the edges of the board and my knees are over the side (think of lying down straight from a seated surfer position without moving your legs)
- my feet come up to the back of the board so the soles of my feet are touching on the back of the board with my inside ankles on the board, my big toes are just hanging off the end of the board
The secret sauce is your feet in this position automatically centres you perfectly on the board weight-wise, and it doesn't rely on 'getting a feel for the right position'.
From here, you now have two hands on the front of the board to help stabilise you fore and aft, your body is just as low as lying down, and your legs are acting as wings to stabilise you left and right. This position you can maintain literally all day, its more stable than lying on the board.
Then follow the techniques above - leading hand comes up with elbow or press off the wing tip, let it rotate you around and then push off board with back hand to grab the wing. you can time this last bit with the swell. you can also balance the wing on your head or shoulder if you find that more comfortable depending on the wing size and where it sits for you - i find this works in light wind to let the wing fill before I try and get to my knees to pump the wing. I also find it better to keep my head down and push my ass back (another yoga move as I transfer my hand, keeps the weight down low until i get the power in the sail.
I have had two sessions on a semi-floater board (-5L) dropping down from +20L. I am a very recent winger and can nail this every time even in sloppy medium-sized swell after 2 hrs when i'm exhausted.
Downsides - it does require a bit of hip flexibility and if you have a wider board it may not work as well, but it was a gamechanger for me. Just being able to lie in a relaxed stable position in swell without burning your core and stabiliser muscles means that whatever way you get up from there you're not burning all your energy before you commit to getting to your feet.
Ok I haven't tried your zen technique or the mikedubs sniper sequence but have used the traditional stinkbug with Great Success on inland lakes with light to moderate wind. Btw, I'm 6'6", 98kg using a 95L board.
However, the last couple of days I was wing foiling around Hood River in the Columbia Gorge with an average wind speed of 35 mph, gusts to 50+ and swell 6-10' on the river. I can tell you my stinkbug technique completely FAILED and I had a miserable downwinder.
Problems: 1. could not adequately stabilize the board being perpendicular to the wind and up to 10' swell; 2. while attempting to get to my knees, my 3m wing would constantly flip over on its back in the high winds. My upper back would lift 1/2 of the wing up and that was enough unbalance to flip the wing (smaller wing lacked the ability to use the over side of the wing to pivot) and makes the whole sequence completely worthless.
The only technique that gave me very marginal success was pointing the nose of the board downwind, wing downwind in front of me, go quickly from sitting or lying on board to kneeing while using the wing's leading edge as balance, saying a little pray or swearing whichever and then quickly lift the wing up, hoping you don't get a 50+ wind gust and go.
I haven't tried the sniper technique, but it would seem to me that in those conditions, the complex dynamic movement of lifting the wing up into the wind with both hands and simultaneously bringing the front leg on to the board in a kneeing or foot position is just not going to be successful with unpredictable gusts of wind.
Would like to hear any advice, techniques that would be useful in high winds, big swell, small wing conditions. Is there a way to modify the sequence that would give a higher success rate? I know, more time on the water, but I really don't think it's possible for me to start the sequence with the board being perpendicular to the swell and wind.