Boatbuilder didn't know but takes the fall - three years jail

10:26 PM Mon 13 Jul 2009 GMT

'Excalibur after fatal capsize' .

The boatbuilder found guilty of manslaughter in April because of faulty construction in a yacht's keel, has been handed the full blame with a three year jail sentence, even though he had been kept in ignorance of his workmen's error during the construction of the yacht.

The faulty workmanship, which consisted of the cutting and re-welding of a keel, had caused the deaths of four sailors.

Prosecutors had failed to prove that Adrian Presland, who was in charge of overseeing the welding, was responsible beyond reasonable doubt for the faulty work and he was therefore acquitted.

The boatbuilder, Alex Cittadini, director and engineer at Applied Alloy Yachts, could serve the full sentence, but will not be eligible for parole for at least 18 months.

Four crew members of the racing yacht Excalibur died after the boat's keel broke and it capsized in 2002. An inquest in 2005 found that the keel had been cut and re-welded during construction.

NSW District Court Judge Stephen Norrish granted bail for Cittadini while an appeal is heard. 'The degree of negligence was serious,' said the judge. 'As the manager of the business he was under a duty (to provide) proper quality control.'

But Norrish was not convinced that Cittadini knew about the shoddy workmanship and said he would probably have rectified it had he known. 'There's no suggestion he did the welding,' said Norrish. 'The person who did it may have hid it from the accused.'

The court heard that Cittadini was a man of excellent character, a family man, honest and professional. He was a sailing enthusiast and a member of the Royal Melbourne Yacht Club for 25 years.

by BW Media

Newsfeed supplied by

#News #Cruising #Sailing

Nearby
Samuel Hill, QLD	4 kn SW	25°
Yeppoon, QLD	6 kn ENE	23°
Central Coast (Coastal), QLD	6 kn ENE	23°
Rosslyn Bay Ntc, QLD	Calm	22°
Windiest in Australia
Mount Wellington, TAS	35 kn SW	2°
Most Windless in Australia
Bridgetown, WA	Calm	14°
Hottest in Australia
Oenpelli Airport, NT	14 kn ENE	33°
Coldest in Australia
Mount Baw Baw, VIC	10 kn SW	1°
Wettest in Australia
Cape Bruny (Cape Bruny), TAS	5.4 mm

Foiling
	2026 Starboard windfoil or the 2026 ZFins Slalom/Race Foil?
	Decoding Reflexed Airfoils
	Front foil size vs wind speed - building my quiver
	Starboard Ucs durability
Gps and Speed talk
	September Virtual Slalom at ka72.com
	GPS Replays
	Make it Personal - track segment colours
	Delta fin
Wave sailing
	Mana Island - Fiji
Gear Reviews
	Severne 2027

Boatbuilder didn't know but takes the fall - three years jail

Live Weather

Nearby

Windiest in Australia

Most Windless in Australia

Hottest in Australia

Coldest in Australia

Wettest in Australia

Windsurfing Forum Topics

Buy & Sell

2024 Core Xr8 + Sensor Pro 3 Bar

2025 Duotone Dlab Glide 2.0 750 Duotone

2022 Switch Kites Nano

2021 Infinity Blurr V2

Starboard Phantom 299

2019 SIC Rs

2026 F-One T1 85Mm 14Mm Foil Kit

Weather

Activities

About

Other

Support