Gees , I said red screwdriver
What does it all mean?
Skeptacles
For every expert there's an equal and opposite reexpert.
Wikipedia Affiliate Button
Steve Sturgill
My Photo Steve Just one of way too many humans. ------------View my complete profile
Blog Archive
??? 2013 (1)
??? 2012 (9)
??? 2011 (18)
??? 2010 (23)
??? 2009 (18)
??? 2008 (118)
??? 2007 (100)
??? 2006 (164)
??? 2005 (159) ??? December (10)
??? November (10)
??? October (18)
??? September (9)
??? August (11) Daniel C. Dennett: Agent of SATAN!
Phoenix OzzFest 2005
The 98% Red Hammer
Intelligent Design
The New Republic Online: Creations
BBC NEWS | Technology | Berners-Lee on the read/wr...
The Politics of Ignorance - Sam Harris - Huffingto...
Taliban Go Home!!
Art prankster sprays Israeli wall
"Brain-dead woman dies after birth" - No, she died...
USNews.com: Culture: Atheists claim discrimination...
??? July (10)
??? June (13)
??? May (14)
??? April (36)
??? March (28)
Links
My Music Videos
Langa Blog
Google News
RealClimate
AlterNet
EffectMeasure
TheOilDrum
Reason
Schneier
Astronomy Picture of the Day
Drug WarRant
Energy Bulletin
Prensa Libre
Volokh Conspiracy
The Ergosphere
Alternative Energy Blog
A Constrained Vision
A Means of Control
Complexity, Problem Solving and Sustainable Societies
Die Off
Nuclear Reaction
Tragedy of the Commons
General Statement of the Tragedy of the Commons
Misanthrope Manor
Edge
Brights
Sorry But Your Soul Just Died
Self Makeover
7 Pillars Partners Publications
Dr Susan Blackmore
Wilson's Almanac - Founding Fathers
My Delicious - Social Bookmarking
Friday, August 19, 2005
The 98% Red Hammer
There's this Internet email meme, I think of it as the "2%-98% red hammer meme". Click directly to the comments to read it. You might want to read it first, then return to the spoiler below. That is what I would have opted if presented with a spoiler before reading the thing.
Anyway, the email arrives (thanks Rick), boldly proclaiming "This is really weird." Then it gives instructions to scroll down the page doing some simple additions along the way. Toward the end it primes you further with "Just a little bit more". When I reached the punch line, it did have a weird effect on me for a moment. I hope it is "for a moment" with others on whom this trick works, but I suppose some people may go on misunderstanding the reality.
Here, I already wrote this in an email (OK, now I've edited it a little bit):
No, it's just a trick.
When I read this thing and did the additions and scrolled down and then it asked for the color and the tool and I thought "red hammer" and then scrolled further down to be told I was part of a certain important group of people, I felt . . . . impressed. When I came to the part where it says "You were thinking "red hammer" weren't you?", I got a really strange sensation for a minute. Complete incredulity. How the hell...?
It's just a trick that works sometimes.
First, I think the 2% / 98% claim is bogus. It's a lie for effect. It's to increase the stickiness of the meme. Which will work better?
Telling them they're in a highly significant and, by extension, prestigious group, or
Telling them they part of a large but probably non-majoritarian group, but that the grouping itself is irrelevant?
If they'd said the more-true number 2, the trick wouldn't work as well on those for whom it works. Even if it doesn't work on most other people, the ones likely to think something other than "red hammer", the trick would still play on a lot of people, whose who will say "red hammer".
So the number is bull****.
Then, apparently they have researched the likelihood of a person answering a question a certain way out of the blue ( "they" being the scientists). The majority of people (a large number of them anyway), when asked for a color out of the blue, will say "red". It's the same when people are asked to name a tool out of the blue. Most, or a large percentage, will say "hammer." They're just two thing that are likely to come to mind first, except these are more likely. Put the two together and you get some percentage (not necessarily a majority) of people who'll think "red hammer". For that group of people this thing can work (at least the first time they see it). For some people the most likely answers are not "red" and "hammer", but who cares. Then they give you the false 2% / 98% statistic and prime the ones who answer "red hammer", they are primed with the apparent (though explainable) weirdness that the email "knows" you were going to say "red hammer". Some of the supposed 2% wind up wondering what's wrong with them.
If you are falsely primed for an answer to an unanswerable question about an unknowable truth, you'll stand for something so won't fall for anything. Besides, those other people may be stupid. HA! Let's make that meme more sticky. Bull**** can be sticky.
The purpose of having you do the additions as you scroll down the page is to put you into concentration on something else, so that your answers to the questions actually do come from out of the blue.
Maybe some day scientists will discover subtle neurological differences among different types of different sorts of people's brains. I wonder what they'll find different about some people, who read the red hammer meme in the email and pick the color "****" and the tool "you" and wonder why they read this far. Why they did the additions. Why they forwarded the email.
Anyway, it was an interesting diversion. I thought the momentary initial reaction when the trick worked on me was pretty cool, and I think the explanation (though there's more to it, I'm sure) is pretty cool, too.
Posted by Steve at 5:59 AM
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to Facebook
95 comments:
Steve said...
Here's the email. It doesn't have the html effects but you get the drift.
- start quote -
This is really weird.
At the end of this message, you are asked a question. Answer it immediately. Don't stop and think about it. Just say the first thing that pops into your mind.
This is a fun "test"... AND kind of spooky at the same time! Give it a try, then e-mail it around (including back to me) and you'll see how many people you know fall into the same percentage as you.
Be sure to put in the subject line if you are among the 98% or the 2%. You'll understand what that means after you finish taking the "test."
Now ... just follow the instructions as quickly as possible.
Do not go to the next calculation before you have finished the previous one..
You do not ever need to write or remember the answers, just do it using your mind.
You'll be surprised.
Start:
How much is:
15 + 6
