Pressure when vac bagging

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
crashtestdummy
crashtestdummy
VIC
63 posts
VIC, 63 posts
24 Nov 2004 2:14pm
How much vac pressure can you apply when bagging without getting 'pin holing' in the surface of the laminate?. Answer in Hg (inches of mercury' please for those of you with imperial gauges. Does it vary depending on the weight of cloth used?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
24 Nov 2004 8:51pm
G'Day crash test.
My theory is that pinholing isn't caused by excess pressure, instead wick or capillary action by the bleader or soaker layer, is the culprit.
Trouble is I haven't done enough to be really certain of this!!!
However stuff that I've done with dacron batting as bleader has come out much better than using fiberglass cloth as bleader.
If you drape a piece of each over the edges of containers of water, and leave for a while, there will be a puddle under the fiberglass but the dacron will be dry, apart from where it's submerged. (well mine was any way, be a good idea to do this test before using a material as bleeder)
So if I'm right you should be able to use as much pressure as your job can handle. And squeeze the layup as thin as it will go.

I'm using low density styrene so don't go lower than a third of an atmosphere. (don't know how many inches of mercury in an atmosphere sorry)
Be interested to know if anybody else can confirm this, pinholes are a pain in the butt!!!!!

The coarseness of weave is probably a factor as well, if the weave is coarse enough for the peel ply to pull into the gaps between fibers, the resin there will be sucked out. So yes I think cloth is a factor, best result should be from more thin layers, rather than less thick layers.

Mike.

PS. A mate came round yesterday with a new blue foam kite board, he was modifing the straps and wanted to know what resin to use. The deck wasn't sandwich construction, just seemed to be cloth, didn't look like carbon, but may have been glass/kevlar/glass layup.

decrepit
crashtestdummy
crashtestdummy
VIC
63 posts
VIC, 63 posts
26 Nov 2004 11:24pm
Thanks Mike. I was using thick breather but I dont know what type it was I think it was dacron. As far as pressure goes, I understand that one atmosphere is equal to 30 Hg (inches of mercury) so your pulling about 10 Hg if your operating at 1/3 ATM. Apparently blue foam is Ok up to about 18 Hg but I dont know for which density (I do some tests) As far as resin goes, I'm told Epoxy resin is safe to use on blue foam when using carbon or Kevlar.

Jamie.



decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
27 Nov 2004 8:14pm
I knew 1 atmosphere was 30 something, but I thought it was feet of water.
May be it's that as well, by some sort of cosmic coincidence!!!

Yes blue foam is fine with epoxy, but don't try polyester!

I'm planing on some tests as well. I'm sure "G10" the epoxy/fiberglass lay up that windsurfing fins are often made of, is made in a physical press, with pressure much higher than 1 atmosphere. So I'm going to compare physical lay ups done under weights and vacuum bag at the same pressure per area. Should be able to get very similar results, I'll see.

If I discover anything I'll start a new thread.


decrepit
lauriew
lauriew
WA
53 posts
WA, 53 posts
7 Dec 2004 9:05am
Hi Guys,
2 things, I look forward to being corrected however in my experience the likelihood of generating a pinhole free bagged laminate is as good as zero. I know a few amateur and ex-professional makers in WA and we all wet layup our final coat with a low weight, very tight weave glass, no bag.
b) experience with avon descent powerboats (yes they are high tech constructions) suggests that while you may save 50g in weight by pulling the last bugger alls of resin out via bagging you will suffer a significant loss in impact resistance, resin sucks up damage very nicely.
You can generate a pinhole free laminate but generally not via bagging it has to be either labour intensive wetout or via the generation of non vacuum derived external hydrostatic pressure (you can pick your own method but they are all a hassle)

L
leski
leski
NSW
661 posts
NSW, 661 posts
7 Dec 2004 8:16pm
Pinholes?..in anycase,
cover with lots of Qcell+resine (really thick) then sand it all ...
pole boy
pole boy
WA
292 posts
WA, 292 posts
13 Jan 2005 2:45pm
so what pressure is that in PSI. because those naish pumps can go upto 7 psi and cutoff (or what ever pressure you set it at). so anyway this could be an easy vac, with no construction needed as well as a practical use outside of construction.

why walk when u can sail?
gremlin
gremlin
WA
55 posts
WA, 55 posts
13 Jan 2005 8:46pm
depends on what foam you are using as to how a pressure u can go .the surfboard foams i wouldnt go too much higher than 15Hg,
divinycell/15-21Hg, corecell you can go as high as 27Hg without deforming the foam-tough stuff!increasing the pressure will (witin reason) force more resin into your laminate, but can also draw resin out if the breather layer is too thick. you should use something about the thickness of a light weight t-shirt or what i have done in the past is use multiple layers of peel-ply and really stretch that vac bag down as tight as you can get it(its pretty strong stuff)when you put the pressure on and use a cloth to try and work out any air pockets that may have formed!if you have already done the laminate and it is pinholed the only way to fix it is to do a mix with q-cells and cabosil(thixotropic agent-makes the mix a little bit stiffer)to quite a stiff mix and run a thick layer over the whole board and sand it back to the desired shape.you may have to doit a couple of times to get it perfect.as long as your pinholes arent excessive ther isnt much loss in strength.whew!!
rodger
rodger
QLD
1 posts
QLD, 1 posts
3 Mar 2006 11:24pm
where abouts can i buy some Divinycell 5/8 inch foam ive been looking everywhere
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
3 Mar 2006 9:55pm
America or England, they're about the only places still using imperial.
Any reason you can't use metric????
Where abouts are you?
If W.A. here's a 1999 contact.
Synthetic Resins who sell Divinycell.

Ph. 08 9458 7188 speak to Mal Cowan.

If not you could try emailing the aussie distributor, again a 99 contact. STEVEN TAYLOR <[email protected]>
Fatboy
Fatboy
NSW
42 posts
NSW, 42 posts
6 Mar 2006 10:50pm
I suggest to anyone who is unsure of the pressure unit conversions, visit joshmadison.com/ and download CONVERT.
sinker
sinker
WA
255 posts
WA, 255 posts
10 Mar 2006 11:25am
I think you problem may lie partly in your layup. We used to vacuum bag entire small yacht hulls in one hit and I never saw any evidence of pinholing, the worst problem was print-through of the foam core.

The trick is to make the outer laminate a layer of CSM which will hold the resin better than woven cloth. Use peel ply on top of that and we used to use hessian as a cheap bleed material although I have used tontine (like the stuff they insulate sleeping bags with) and it's probably the best.

Make sure you've got a perfect seal around the bag.

If you pull too much pressure onto to the job you will end up with a lean resin/glass ratio which will weaken the finished laminate and may contribute to the pinholing.If you want to get technical you should really work out your glass/resin ratio first and then mix up that ammount of resin (allowing some extra for wastage)you can also weigh the finished product to check you got it right.

You should be able to get advice on exact vacuum pressure and resin ratios from a friendly composite supplier.(I can't actually remember what vacuum pressure we used but can find out if you're really stuck)


Good luck
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
10 Mar 2006 7:51pm
If CSM fixes pin holes I want some!!!
So what the f is it????
What do those letters stand for?

ps hesion sounds like a bad idea, I'm sure it has a "wick" action this will suck the resin out of the layup. A non wick action soaker layer. won't suck. The excess resin is just squeezed out by vacuum pressure, the soaker layer just gives it somewhere to go.
sinker
sinker
WA
255 posts
WA, 255 posts
13 Mar 2006 10:42am
Hi Decrepit,

No magic bullet mate, CSM is chopped strand mat don't know another name for it...just 'chop'...just random chopped glass fibres on a roll.

I don't know what's going on with your bagging, what type of peel ply are you using?
How long do you leave the bag on for? What resin do you use.. gel time?
There shouldn't be that much resin getting through the peel ply into the breather layer, the reason for the breather layer is to allow air to be sucked out of the job evenly, the peel ply should work as a barrier as well as leaving a nice finish...

I get the feeling that far too much bag-pressure is being applied.

We are talking about resin infusion here aren't we?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
13 Mar 2006 7:48pm
quote:
Originally posted by sinker

CSM is chopped strand mat


Oh that stuff!

quote:

what type of peel ply are you using?


Don't know actually, just bought it from the shop, it's a greyish very fine material coated with release agent.

quote:

How long do you leave the bag on for?


overnight usually or until resin is well set.
quote:

What resin do you use.. gel time?


varies, at the moment I'm using botecoat, sets in about 6 hours.
quote:

There shouldn't be that much resin getting through the peel ply into the breather layer,


There's heaps mate, depending on how thick the lay up is, the worst is when carbon is involved, I'm never sure when there's enough resin with that unlike glass, when it's obvious when it's wet out.

quote:

I get the feeling that far too much bag-pressure is being applied.


I use about 1/2 atmosphere
quote:


We are talking about resin infusion here aren't we?


No idea, what's that???
sinker
sinker
WA
255 posts
WA, 255 posts
14 Mar 2006 10:14am

Hi Decrepit,

I think we may be talking about different processes here.

Resin infusion is where you put all the glass into the mould dry, place your peel ply and bleeder material on top and then put the bag on.

When you have a perfectly sealed bag under vacuum you catalise the resin in a bucket and the resin is sucked through a tube with a tap in it into the bag. The resin impregnates the entire layup from one end of the job to the other. There is normally a chamber between the vac pump and the job which catches any waste resin before it enters the pump.

when the job is fully impregnated you shut off the taps and the pump and leave it under vacuum until the resin is off (used to take less than an hour)You de-bag when the resin has gelled to a rubbery consistancy
(you can test by making a small cut in the bag and removing a piece of resin from an area where it is pooled)
the piece of resin should crumble when you rub it between your fingers.

the bag, ply and bleed material should come off reasonably easily.

What's botecoat? (epoxy?)

How do you bag normally?

hoop
hoop
1979 posts
1979 posts
14 Mar 2006 12:53pm
I think most people making boards at home lay up all the glass, wet it out, lay peel ply and breather cloth then stick it in the bag till it has all gone off. (Thats how Ive allways done it anyway) Resin infusion would be pretty tricky for most backyarders.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
14 Mar 2006 3:34pm
Hoop's got it, botecoat's epoxy.
sinker
sinker
WA
255 posts
WA, 255 posts
14 Mar 2006 4:25pm

Well why bag then?

If you're wetting out and laying up/rolling by hand you should be able to calculate the exact ammount of resin to use (glass/resin ratio) so shouldn't have to reduce the resin content.

I imagine if you leave a bag on for 6 hours there will be a bit of pinholing because the glass/resin ratio would be too lean.

Or is there another theory at work here?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
14 Mar 2006 4:52pm
laying up by hand makes the resin ratio higher than it needs to be, Vaccuming squashes the cloth flat, so not as much resin's needed to wet it out, and not as much "filler" is needed afterwards to fill the weave.
And as you say, it leaves a much better finish. I haven't done an exact check, but I think 2 layers of 4 oz cloth vacuumed is less weight than 1 layer of 6. As I can run each 4 oz layer at slightly different angles, this makes for a stronger lighter construction. The 4 oz cloth being finer doesn't pinhole as much as the 6 either..
eightfootplus
eightfootplus
NSW
298 posts
NSW, 298 posts
2 Jun 2006 9:40am
Guys,

I am interested in making my first foam core kite board. But I have my suspicions about the benefits of the vacuum bagging. Specifically I see the logic in what sinker is saying.

I have read previously that the glass has a certain strength with a certain ratio of resin and that more resign simply adds more weight.

But I can not immagine that there would be that much weight saving by vaccuum bagging such a small kite board, as opposed to a large boat which would use a sh@t load of resin, so I am wondering the following.

1)Has anyone any estimates of how much resign to use for say a 140cm TT kite board, I would imagine it to be a 1kg to 1.5 kilos max.

2)Has anyone actually measured the before and after weights of the blank glass and resign to determine how much is being pressed into the breather cloth, by the vaccuum. i.e. is it a half kilo or less??. I would imagine that you would be using at least a kilo of resin on the board.

3)As the strength of glass is along the cloth, does anyone think that if the rails were overlapped in a traditional hand layup like a polyester board, that it would be stronger and require less glass matting, my theory here being the main strenght is in the rails, not the flats.

4) what is with the long gel times for epoxy, can you not get 1hr gel time, why is the gel time so long for such a small job. I suspect the gel times are so long because guyes like Sinker need a heap of time to difuse the resign into the job?

5) I have a fridge compressor, Im looking for the parts to make a circuit, especially check valves, a solonoid preasure release valve and pressure controller. I dont particularly want to spend all weekend mucking around with an old vacuum advance from a car. can anyone advise me if I can use normal pressure phnumatic fittings or are there special vacuum equipment suppliers. Anywhere good to get these near Caringbah Sydney?

I am not opposed to the vacuum bagging as I see it will save time sanding.

Thanks

Please advise Andrew

decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
2 Jun 2006 4:34pm
I've never made a kiteboard, so can't help you there.
Epoxy gel times are what they are, it's not like poyester where adding more catalyst/accelerator will set it off faster. There are several different systems varying from a 2:1 to 5:1 ratio resin to hardener for optimum properties. If you change the ratio the resin doesn't go off any faster just isn't as good. Faster hardeners are available for some varieties (like west systems but they're more expensive).

I bought a pressure sensor from Radio Spares, wired it up through a relay to switch the pump, but that was last century.

I did some measurements when we built Hardy's board, but haven't got the figures at hand. I know I was convinced that for a windsurfer, surfboard it's definately worth the effort.

So what sort of foam are you using??? just going with medium density divinycell all the way through or are you having a lighter core and a hard skin?

And I agree about strength in the rails, I'd certainly overlap them.
hoop
hoop
1979 posts
1979 posts
2 Jun 2006 5:26pm
Just a guess but I dont think bagging a board that small will make too much difference,especially if you've never done it before. If you're worried about too much sanding then use a layer of peel ply over your glass job. It's easy to do and gives a much smoother finish.
Have fun.
eightfootplus
eightfootplus
NSW
298 posts
NSW, 298 posts
5 Jun 2006 8:55pm
Hey Thats a good idea,


I have some good old white styrafoam. I intend to shape it with a hot wire cutter, I have worked out the tools to cut the rocker plane and shape, the rails are hard all over. Foam doesnt have much tensile strength and compreson strength of foam even white styraphome is quite high.

I'll see how I go.

KAOS69
KAOS69
WA
1012 posts
WA, 1012 posts
6 Jun 2006 5:56am
eightfootplus , there are a few epoxys out there so shop around the the price changes alot . i use FGI R 180 with fast hardener now that it winter the gel time is about 2 hour which is very fast . any faster than that and it will heat up to much and melt your foam core if you use styreine . as for vacum baging if it is for kite boards i always use a bag beacuse it is the only way to hould the klegie cell in place ( to get rocker and concave perfect every time) you are best to make a rocker jig. but if you are making one of back yarder it will take longer to make all the tools you need than to make the board . but no matter how good you hope it will turn out you will have to make at least half a dozen boards before you get the idea how evey thing works .
the vacum bag is the greatest invention for boardmaking since since foam . and should be used always . it reduces the glass , epoxy ratio . compress the lay up , prestreches the cloth and form moulds the klegie cell and the list goes on ,
after saying all that for one board you can get away with (only kite boards) make a jig and weigh the board down with sand bags .not to heavie may be 2kg each,
i have made quite a few kite boards and my best advice is to put concave in it has it will help alot with the stiffness and use a smaller than you think amount of carbon .
good luck and go for it
eightfootplus
eightfootplus
NSW
298 posts
NSW, 298 posts
6 Jun 2006 7:14pm
thanks for the advice.
Regards

Andy
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply