Bow kites flawed?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
GazMan
GazMan
WA
848 posts
WA, 848 posts
14 Aug 2006 10:05pm
I recently read an interview with Ken Winner, the chief kite designer for North, in the June/July 06 edition of Kiteboarding Magazine (US) where he commented:

"But we (at North) do want something that we enjoy riding, which is one of the reasons we've been slow to go in the bow direction, because we really don't like riding those kites. It's hard to get enthusiastic about something that seems so flawed".

Anyone know what he's talking about?

I've heard nothing but good reviews about some of the more popular bow kites such as Crossbows and Switchblades, so what and where are the flaws?

Or could this be some kind of marketing ploy on the part of North to try and sell more of their "flawless" kites?

GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
15 Aug 2006 12:36am
troll on!
bigmark100
bigmark100
NSW
584 posts
NSW, 584 posts
15 Aug 2006 1:46am
the flaw is that north didnt hop on the band wagon quick enough.
they have now with the rebel.
t o b y
t o b y
WA
530 posts
WA, 530 posts
15 Aug 2006 1:06am
wow and thats really good coming from north when there newest kite doesnt even relaunch....
angie pangi
angie pangi
QLD
1782 posts
QLD, 1782 posts
15 Aug 2006 6:54am
It is one of the easyest kites to relaunch, just remember new kite new way of doing things.

i'v crashed it plenty of times and can relaunch it faster than just about any kite, its always about techinque.

cheers paul
oxy
oxy
WA
50 posts
oxy oxy
WA, 50 posts
15 Aug 2006 5:58am
Well you have to give them credit its a nice kite to fly without all the extra baggage a bow kite has like.
Inversions
Bridles that get caught on your wingtips
Pulleys
The messy bar setups with those stupid depower straps
And of coures the wonderful Cabrinha workmanship where some of the stitching is starting to wear after just one season and the bridles are wearing as well.I have flown the rebel and its a step in the right direction.
Munter
Munter
NSW
210 posts
NSW, 210 posts
15 Aug 2006 12:25pm
In my books, KW has lost a bit of credibility with his stance on bow kites. He seems to exagerate their disadvantages somewhat. Bow kites aren't perfect but they are a massive step in the right direction as far as I'm concerned.
Gorgo
Gorgo
VIC
5127 posts
VIC, 5127 posts
15 Aug 2006 1:13pm
It's either a trick or self-delusion. KW says that bows suck and he would never stoop to bringing out something so crappy as a bow.

All the C-kite diehards sit around saying yeah bows suck.

North then bring out the Rebel which has all the attributes of a bow kite. Curved tips, concave trailing edge, leading edge bridle. All the C-kite diehards dash off and buy it because it's North and it's "not a bow".

The only difference between the Rebel and other bows is that other bows use some sort of pulley arrangement to attach the leading edge bridle to the front lines and North uses a 5th line (the same as the Ozone Instinct).

That just means that there are 4 types of bow kite now. The Legaignoux style with pulleys between the front and rear lines. The Sonic style with the front lines attached directly to pulleys, the 5th line format and the WindWing with no pulleys at all.
NJPornstar
NJPornstar
WA
790 posts
WA, 790 posts
15 Aug 2006 1:32pm
Im with Ken

Bow sux if you know how to kite. Too limited in real safety potential.
The kite has the potential to fall everywhere, The wind has the potential to do everything.

No offence to my bow buddies.
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
15 Aug 2006 1:40pm
Bows rock....dunno why they create such a stir.
bondo
bondo
QLD
699 posts
QLD, 699 posts
15 Aug 2006 4:10pm
of course, in a year of bow use including northern and southern hemisphere winters there have been no deaths, OTOH, several deaths on C's over the same period. Im not saying you cant be killed on a bow (Im certain you could if you tried hard enough), but the proof is in the pudding, so to speak. There seems to be a lot of kiters quick to point out the safety issues around bows, maybe because these are used as their biggest selling point, but they conveniently forget the persistent safety issues around C kites that keep leading people to die on them.
Kitingpaul
Kitingpaul
WA
36 posts
WA, 36 posts
15 Aug 2006 2:26pm
Bows have many issues that are negative and most have been listed here. Personally I agree that they are not as enjoyable to ride as a 'c' and the de-power is an annoyance when you let the bar go to unspin it ! The inversion thing is downright dangerous and scary as **** if it happens high up in the air !

Saying that 'c' kites lack of de-power makes them far more dangerous I agree.

The exception to this is the BEST Waroo ! It rides like a 'c' and de-powers like a bow - Even on a standard bar.

I imagine that all the next generation of bows will be as good as the Waroo and then the old 'c' kiters will have no chance but to change over !

If you have not ridden the Waroo don't wate your time arguing ! - I have ridden both Cabrinahs alot and also the Airush bow - I can only hope the "BIG" comanies swallow their pride and take notice of this marvelous kite !
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
15 Aug 2006 2:32pm
YAWN......
Waroo's don't invert i guess??
Prepare
Prepare
WA
132 posts
WA, 132 posts
15 Aug 2006 2:56pm
quote:
Originally posted by poor relative

YAWN......
Waroo's don't invert i guess??



dont know about everyone else but my waroo doesnt. and hasnt throughout this winters gusty SW'ers and my poor attempts at jumping. not saying there arent better kites but I think its pretty good.
kiterpilot
kiterpilot
WA
249 posts
WA, 249 posts
15 Aug 2006 3:02pm
Yeah I'd have to add Poorreli that if you pump them up properly they dont invert !. Most issues have come from underinflated leading edge bladders.

PS, Cant wait to try my 2007 waroo pro out when it arrives... ARH only five minutes drive from my new house to the beach... bring on summer

And going on the specs i've seen for both the waroo and waroo pro (pretty much the diff is in the fabric) I'd have to say while the waroo pro will be the top level performer in this range the waroo standard model would have to be the BEST value for money product in our line of 2007 models.

regards browneee
puppetonaring
puppetonaring
WA
26 posts
WA, 26 posts
15 Aug 2006 8:42pm
bows suck!!! i should know 5 cent told me, he has a pink waroo, noone knows who he is.
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
15 Aug 2006 10:48pm
a kites a kite,false puppet.
kiterpilot, can i still get three kites, a bar and lines and pump for two grillas?
summers cummin!
JB
JB
NSW
2232 posts
JB JB
NSW, 2232 posts
16 Aug 2006 6:49am
The North rebel is far being from a bow. It's plan shape actually doesn't have a concaved trailing edge (as with the Naish Shockwave). Both these kites were designed from scratch, not copies of an existing design.

KW has tried endless numbers of proto types of bow/bridal kites, and doens't like the side effects of the bridale and off axis flying plain. To achieve the same goal as the bow (DEPOWER) but keep the kite flying nicely was an extremely impressive achievement! It took more proto types to get this to work than any other kite. The rebel has all the good attributes of the bow family, but also has all the attributes that the bows can't achieve(i.e. that C-kites have)! BTW, there is no bridal on the Rebel, since when have we been calling a 5th line a bridal? The duel contact points just add some extra stability, you'll see that Naish have done this aswell, makes tuning your 5th line length a little less of an art form, no more advertising for McDonalds by numpties!

Anyway, like every kite out there, you gotta try it before making your mind up on weather YOU like the kite or not. Just remember some people still ride rollerblades and like them! thats up to them!

regards,

JB
user
user
WA
1140 posts
WA, 1140 posts
16 Aug 2006 4:59am
Same old story from the late comers !

Its a bow but it isn't.

Its not a copy,but designed from the ground up.(just happened to end up looking like the other bows!)

Its better than all the others.(Even though all the others are better than all the others!)

JB, I could be wrong,but I am sure the pics of the Rebel on the North site show a concave trailing edge??
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
16 Aug 2006 7:54am
quote:
Originally posted by kiterpilot

Yeah I'd have to add Poorreli that if you pump them up properly they dont invert !. Most issues have come from underinflated leading edge bladders.

PS, Cant wait to try my 2007 waroo pro out when it arrives... ARH only five minutes drive from my new house to the beach... bring on summer

And going on the specs i've seen for both the waroo and waroo pro (pretty much the diff is in the fabric) I'd have to say while the waroo pro will be the top level performer in this range the waroo standard model would have to be the BEST value for money product in our line of 2007 models.

regards browneee



Yeah yeah yeah yeah..........Cool on the new house Brownee, hopefully see you in the water a bit more often this season eh??
Hows the knee doing??
JB
JB
NSW
2232 posts
JB JB
NSW, 2232 posts
16 Aug 2006 10:35am
quote:
Originally posted by user



JB, I could be wrong,but I am sure the pics of the Rebel on the North site show a concave trailing edge??



There may be a bee's dick worth between the s1 & s2 struts, but not what I'd call a concaved trailing edge, and it doens't go from the tips, leech hollow is different to concave!

Anyway, I think people should go out and fly this kite before trying to understand it! It is a different animal to what everyone is used to!

regards,

JB
Gorgo
Gorgo
VIC
5127 posts
VIC, 5127 posts
16 Aug 2006 12:06pm
www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=2168

Looks pretty concave to me. Looks just like any other bow kite.
kiterpilot
kiterpilot
WA
249 posts
WA, 249 posts
16 Aug 2006 12:04pm
quote:
Originally posted by poor relative

quote:
Originally posted by kiterpilot

Yeah I'd have to add Poorreli that if you pump them up properly they dont invert !. Most issues have come from underinflated leading edge bladders.

PS, Cant wait to try my 2007 waroo pro out when it arrives... ARH only five minutes drive from my new house to the beach... bring on summer

And going on the specs i've seen for both the waroo and waroo pro (pretty much the diff is in the fabric) I'd have to say while the waroo pro will be the top level performer in this range the waroo standard model would have to be the BEST value for money product in our line of 2007 models.

regards browneee



Yeah yeah yeah yeah..........Cool on the new house Brownee, hopefully see you in the water a bit more often this season eh??
Hows the knee doing??




Mate I havent had a session in somthing like three months , the knees ****,sooo weak... But the house is great, jeeze I love space and being sooo close to my fav kite spot...

regards browneee
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
16 Aug 2006 12:17pm
quote:
Originally posted by bondo

of course, in a year of bow use including northern and southern hemisphere winters there have been no deaths, OTOH, several deaths on C's over the same period. Im not saying you cant be killed on a bow (Im certain you could if you tried hard enough), but the proof is in the pudding, so to speak. There seems to be a lot of kiters quick to point out the safety issues around bows, maybe because these are used as their biggest selling point, but they conveniently forget the persistent safety issues around C kites that keep leading people to die on them.



No deaths on Bows in the last year doesn't prove that Bows are safer than C-kites.
The chances of someone getting killed on a C-kite are greater,
because there are more C-kites than Bows in the air.

How many injuries were sustained while using Bow kites ?
I'd guess many.

Deaths can't be blamed strictly on the type of kite,
factors like wind direction and speed, risky sites, poor kiting skills and judgements,
and simply bad luck will always tempt the hand of fate.
stamp
stamp
QLD
2800 posts
QLD, 2800 posts
16 Aug 2006 2:19pm
quote:
Too limited in real safety potential.
The kite has the potential to fall everywhere, The wind has the potential to do everything

what do you mean by that exactly NJpornstar?
bondo
bondo
QLD
699 posts
QLD, 699 posts
16 Aug 2006 2:30pm
quote:

No deaths on Bows in the last year doesn't prove that Bows are safer than C-kites.
The chances of someone getting killed on a C-kite are greater,
because there are more C-kites than Bows in the air.

How many injuries were sustained while using Bow kites ?
I'd guess many.

Deaths can't be blamed strictly on the type of kite,
factors like wind direction and speed, risky sites, poor kiting skills and judgements,
and simply bad luck will always tempt the hand of fate.



I agree there are confounding factors, however the simple fact is C kites have one major flaw and that is that they largely rely on reaction time for kite release in the event of emergency, something that is not as problematic on bow kites. both bows and C's still suffer from unreliable QR's. from my own experience and anecdotal evidence on the web the people getting seriously hurt or dragged into the bushes are the guys on the standard C's (of course the guys on bows are pulling their safety without a leash and watching their kites fly off over the highway or beach goers). regardless, with the new 5 line high depower hybrids which are arguably even safer than bows I will predict that most of the serious accidents in the future will occur on standard C kites despite their decreasing popularity. i guess time will tell.
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
16 Aug 2006 12:38pm
sooooooo......are bows gay anymore???
or should that be a new thread.
Perhaps we could do a poll.?
stamp
stamp
QLD
2800 posts
QLD, 2800 posts
16 Aug 2006 3:08pm
no need for a poll; simply count those with their heads in the sand next time you are at the beach
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
16 Aug 2006 3:54pm
quote:
Originally posted by poor relative

sooooooo......are bows gay anymore???
or should that be a new thread.
Perhaps we could do a poll.?




Nah, bows and pretend bows aren't gay now,
but your seat harness still is, PR.
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
16 Aug 2006 6:32pm
Will this subject ever end.....

Im teaching my 60kg wife how to kite and wouldnt touch a C kite....

Must admit I got bored with the massive depower bows have to offer. they make things sooo easy. Went and bought a powerlock for different tricks......issue solved....

any surfers remember kelly slaters radical change in design with surfboards..... Yeah some things need refining but if they are a step progressing something... get over it...

Mals Vs short boarders,,,,surfboards Vs boogy boards,,,,,and yes poleys Vs teabaggers
Soonee
Soonee
VIC
147 posts
VIC, 147 posts
16 Aug 2006 8:52pm
Bow kites Flawed..Sounds like sour grapes to me.
I agree .. too late getting on the wagon, too proud to admit being sluggish.Probably worried about paying copyright fees to the Leginoux bros.

If I don't call it a bow.....is it no longer a bow?
If it waddles and quacks and I call it a dog will that stop it being a duck!!

BTW, the new EH kites ship with pulley bridle and an optional fixed bridle (bow with no pulleys).

Yeah, bows got their issues, but are C's perfect? If so then why have half the brands dropped them like a hot potato.
Step in the right direction to less fatalities...hell I hope so.


Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply