Does Safety Gear make us safer?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
meerkat
meerkat
WA
644 posts
WA, 644 posts
2 May 2007 11:11am
Situation: Out in the surf on sunday down at the harbour, big surf, gusty 25-35+ knot conditions and squalls every 15-20mins. So i am kiting with care and coming in to land my kite everytime there is a squall.

Three other guys out, they kite through the squalls. Ballsy i think sitting on the beach, until two of the kiters drop/release/eject out at the back and kites and kiters get blown/drift back to shore.

Had a conversation with one the guys and mention that maybe he should be a touch more careful in unpredictable conditions? his reply, i have loads of safety features, quick release this, depower that. I NEVER have to come in becuase my safety gear is state of the art.

So has the improvement in safety turned everybody into the terminator? and how come i still sit on the beach when the squalls come through?
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
2 May 2007 11:47am
Must be a preferance thingy.

When it is on shore and one is way out, then I can see the funk of "doing a squall." However, you never ever know the severity of a squall...so this is highly risky and in my mind stupid behaviour...but to each their own. I choose to come in when the cloud is real dark and nasty....I do not like riding out squalls, or worse, having to pull the safety.
wilski
wilski
WA
21 posts
WA, 21 posts
2 May 2007 11:53am
All the safety features in the world only help when you can actually use them.

When I had a nasty incident water relaunching (got a steering line wrapped around the end of the bar in 20knts) I didn't have time / couldn't quick realease the chicken loop before it was all over. I was dragged toward the beach, concrete outflow pipe, trees, road etc...

I had enough space downwind and luckily no harm done to me or the kite, but certainly reminded me to be cautious. If the kite had looped a second time it might have been a different story, but then I might have got to that release in time....?

In my limited experience when it hits the fan it hits hard and fast
Mr float
Mr float
NSW
3452 posts
NSW, 3452 posts
2 May 2007 2:47pm
I think your approach and respect for the elements is far more safer than any so called state of the art "safety" system
In fact I would say that most of those maimed and killed through kiting had state of the art "safety " systems

'
quote:
Originally posted by meerkat

Situation: Out in the surf on sunday down at the harbour, big surf, gusty 25-35+ knot conditions and squalls every 15-20mins. So i am kiting with care and coming in to land my kite everytime there is a squall.

Three other guys out, they kite through the squalls. Ballsy i think sitting on the beach, until two of the kiters drop/release/eject out at the back and kites and kiters get blown/drift back to shore.

Had a conversation with one the guys and mention that maybe he should be a touch more careful in unpredictable conditions? his reply, i have loads of safety features, quick release this, depower that. I NEVER have to come in becuase my safety gear is state of the art.

So has the improvement in safety turned everybody into the terminator? and how come i still sit on the beach when the squalls come through?

BoDiddly
BoDiddly
VIC
622 posts
VIC, 622 posts
2 May 2007 3:01pm
I guess that as state-of-the-art your gear is, there are additional elements that have to come into play. You may have awesome gear, but if you are going to decide to ride out some nutty squalls then the understanding of those risks need to be accepted also.

It's the same situation with onshore or even extreemely gusty conditions, you safety may work, but you're relying on a reaction time of a ninja or some sht like that.

I've eaten it a couple of times, as I'm sure we all have, but things happen that can be totally out of your control wich can affect your 'safety'.

I'd prolly sit out the crazy squalls, think there's also some learning from the accidents we hear of in this forum. Looking at a Bern helmet, just need to find a stockist.

Later.
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
2 May 2007 1:57pm
Hey Guys,

Assessing the conditions, having experience, having quality safety systems and being prepared will allow you to kite in squalls, but it is really only safer if you take ALL the above into consideration.

On Sunday at Scarborough I was riding a 9m DNA on my 6' Converse in 1.5 - 2.0 m swell in on/cross on wind blowing from 15 to 20 knots. every now and again the wind would go more or less onshore and increase in the squalls.

I chose to ride out the squalls by riding further out the back to give myself more reaction time in the event of crazy tea bagging strong winds, and switched my leash from suicide to disable the kite in the event that I pulled the QR trigger.

The kite was set with no stopper and 99% depower when you let go of the bar in suicide mode and once I changed the leash to the front line, then it goes to complete disable of the kite. I knew I could handle the conditions even in the event of gusts to 35-40 knots, but prefer to take precautions should I have needed to disable the kite.

What you did Meerkat, was sensible and showed great intelligence. Knowing your ability to handle the unexpected, knowing the conditions and being prepared for the worst is a smart kiter. As you gain more and more experience, you may choose to take more calculated risks.

If your gut says no, and your head says go, don't listen to your head. Intuition is your friend and may save your life, thats why you have it.

Good winds,

meerkat
meerkat
WA
644 posts
WA, 644 posts
2 May 2007 2:15pm
Experience can be just as dangerous as it is helpful. Makes people a little bit to indestructable.

Have been kiting for 5years now in, Edinburgh, Tarifa, Faro, Invercargill, Broome, Byron Bay, Perth etc etc in varied conditions and was a lifesaver for a couple of years on the gold coast as well, so consider my abilities to read wind and wave conditions to be ok.

I think maybe i have been unfortunate to "experience" individuals who have relied too much on their safety gear, never mind equipment failing snapping lines, bars etc. and seen first hand the consequences. Nothing like watching somebodies achilles tendon get sliced in half to double check your safety leash.

Or maybe i am getting old and the lawn bowls club needs me!
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
2 May 2007 3:02pm
I reckon if your kiting on frontal stuff, wind is oooo 25-35kn, your on small gear and you see a big black mass of nasty coming your way had in quick.

Squalls can be up to and above 50kn, most of the time you dont know how strong the win is in the nastiness.... it just ain't worth it.

Ten fifteen minutes the squall passes, and back out you go. Its often a good time for some liquid replenishment, and to boast about your last move.

Leech
Leech
WA
1933 posts
WA, 1933 posts
2 May 2007 4:00pm
quote:
Originally posted by poor relative


Ten fifteen minutes the squall passes, and back out you go. Its often a good time for some liquid replenishment, and to boast about your last move.




and to envy the windsurfers
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
3 May 2007 11:11am
I read on a thread ages ago a comparison to the correlation of accidents with air pilots.

Basically a fair few bingles as a beginner due to lack of skills etc. Then the numbers go right down in the intermediate stage as the skill and awareness rises.. Then a big jump in bingles and splats at the expert end!! Reason being simple compacency and a "I know what's goin on, so I don't have to do my double checks anymore" attitude. [}:)]

Wev'e all seen newbies doing some suss stuff (mostly through ignorance) but by far the most stoopid stuff I have seen is from the hero brigade. This falls neatly into line with the pilot stat sheet. Their funeral and hopefully no-one elses!
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
3 May 2007 9:50pm
quote:
Originally posted by wilski

All the safety features in the world only help when you can actually use them.




Ho right, Wilski!

I have "state of the art" QR on my gear, I know exactly where it is and how to use it, however, it takes 3 - 5 seconds to react, and that was enough to have my shoulder dislocated
Lost all the season this year, stil recouperating

Enough said
kite boy
kite boy
WA
354 posts
WA, 354 posts
3 May 2007 11:39pm
safety is over rated
manicskier
manicskier
VIC
772 posts
VIC, 772 posts
4 May 2007 5:27am
but kites can kick ur arse.... real quick
Spacemonkey!
Spacemonkey!
SA
2288 posts
SA, 2288 posts
4 May 2007 10:48am
quote:
Originally posted by kite boy

SAFETY is over rated



Wow thanks BrAd for the enlightenment..., some places you need a good safetY some places it doesnt matter so much...
kite boy
kite boy
WA
354 posts
WA, 354 posts
4 May 2007 9:37am
i say lets all complicate our gear as much as possible so there are as many things as possible to break or go wrong then we will be sweet
tommyb
tommyb
QLD
103 posts
QLD, 103 posts
4 May 2007 1:55pm
NEVA EvA USE A BOARD LEASH
meerkat
meerkat
WA
644 posts
WA, 644 posts
4 May 2007 2:34pm
quote:
A board leash is not safety gear, it's the opposite, what ever that is.



non-safety gear.

BTW. the board leash was what i saw cut through the achilles tendon.
meerkat
meerkat
WA
644 posts
WA, 644 posts
4 May 2007 3:44pm
a long home made one. he must have used glass though or perhaps it was the fact he was strapped to a 12m kite in gusty conditions without having had any lessons.

some may think safety gear = "not having fun", but they usually do it from the carpark on crutches.
Charl dv
Charl dv
WA
2485 posts
WA, 2485 posts
4 May 2007 10:59pm
squalls never really bothered me with the mass waroo depower, if its really giving me **** i jz depower n keep kite low at edge of window. i only really come in if overall im struggeling or my legs turn into jelly. you do get a false sence of security though as it gives u this idea that u can go crazy n not worry.. safety means nothing 25foot in the air
axis
axis
VIC
399 posts
VIC, 399 posts
5 May 2007 2:40pm
quote:
Originally posted by BoDiddly
Looking at a Bern helmet, just need to find a stockist.



Hey BoDiddly,

Ive been looking at the Bern as well. Have emailed the Oz distributer to find out where to get one.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply