KNEES help please!

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
BOOMAN
BOOMAN
VIC
333 posts
VIC, 333 posts
13 Jul 2009 10:43am
I just arrived back from cwc(cable in philippenes) after 8 days sitting on my ass most likely because of an screwed mc in my knee.
Can anyone offer advice and very good doctor ?
Neill
Neill
VIC
484 posts
VIC, 484 posts
13 Jul 2009 11:32am
I see you are in VIC, don't go to a GP, go see a sports medicine doctor or a physiotherapist. There's a good bloke in north melbourne;

Errol St Spinal and Sports Physiotherapy
106A Errol St
North Melbourne

Ask for Neill
caveman
caveman
QLD
116 posts
QLD, 116 posts
13 Jul 2009 3:30pm
best thing to do is get an MRI and that should pretty much tell your doctor what's going on inside your knee... good luck and hope it gets better!
NSW, 4382 posts
13 Jul 2009 3:52pm
BOOMAN said...

I just arrived back from cwc(cable in philippenes) after 8 days sitting on my ass most likely because of an screwed mc in my knee.
Can anyone offer advice and very good doctor ?


Dr Hayden Morris is the guy that a lot of foootballers use, he is super experienced with knee reconstructions and replacements.
Not sure where his consulting rooms are, I saw him a few years ago at the Freemasons Hospital in East Melbourne.

Don't wait and wonder, see someone sooner and at least you will know your options and best path to recovery.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

whatthe
whatthe
WA
186 posts
WA, 186 posts
13 Jul 2009 3:11pm
Go see a sports physio, (you may need a referral from a GP for this). Things like MRIs and surgery are expensive and there are lots of options before going down that path. A good physio will only recommend this after assessing and trying some different things.
Spacemonkey!
Spacemonkey!
SA
2288 posts
SA, 2288 posts
13 Jul 2009 6:08pm
So treat whats on the image hey? MRI's are expensive and you can't just go get an MRI, you need the appropriate referral, a good doc should be able to diagnose and treat without the need for such expensive equipment and if required refer for additional imaging.

caveman said...

best thing to do is get an MRI and that should pretty much tell your doctor what's going on inside your knee... good luck and hope it gets better!


pluzi9mm
pluzi9mm
NSW
20 posts
NSW, 20 posts
13 Jul 2009 6:51pm
Definately see a physio. Doc will most likely give you a generic "you've sprained it take some anti inflamitries and get some rest" diagnosis.

I got a beautiful Grade 3 tear through my MCL 9 weeks ago and I'm still out of action. Knees aren't worth cheaping out on. Invest in getting some good care.
BOOMAN
BOOMAN
VIC
333 posts
VIC, 333 posts
13 Jul 2009 7:13pm
pluzi9mm said...

Doc will most likely give you a generic "you've sprained it take some anti inflamitries and get some rest" diagnosis.


just got back from the gp.... he pre-scribed anti infamitorys and told me I had most likely sprained it....>????? weird
rez
rez
WA
354 posts
rez rez
WA, 354 posts
14 Jul 2009 8:03am
I tore my mcl at the beginning of last December. Its only just starting to come good now but still hurts. Be prepared to rest it for a while. I had a MRI to see how severe the tear was so I knew wether I needed surgery or not. That was good as I had a clear idea of my injury and the timeframe it would take to heal.

The doctor I went to told me I had only sprained the ligament also but I had actually torn it.

Speedy recovery.
superlizard
superlizard
VIC
702 posts
VIC, 702 posts
14 Jul 2009 11:29am
GP's are a complete waste of time in my experience... i still haven't found a good GP in this country that really impressed me... (no offence to any good GPs out there)... the senior GP i used to see (with good reputation) would prescribe antibiotics or anti-inflamatory drugs EACH time i would see him... it's absolutely ridiculous... I had some wrist injury few months ago, and he totally miss diagnosed it... went to see osteopath, afterwards and he fixed the issue in 2 sessions. Same for the knee... i injured my knee kite landboarding, and he said everything is ok the pain will go away in 6 months... i'm surprised he didn't say, pain will go away once you're dead. After i saw another GP, I ended up getting referral to knee specialist who finally found the issue and provided solutions (well couldn't avoid MIR in my case)... my advice, DO NOT EVEN TALK TO GPs, just demand that you are in ridiculous pain and you must get a referral to specialist. What i've learned is that no one around here cares for you or your health... if you don't take it in your own hands it ain't gonna happen... good luck
lostinlondon
lostinlondon
VIC
1159 posts
VIC, 1159 posts
14 Jul 2009 2:45pm
This is the way it works:

If you injure yourself and its not a broken bone (generally you will in hospital anyway if this happens), go to a physio. If after diagnosis and treatment its not improving the physio should refer you on. You may need to go to a GP for the specialist referral, but the notes from the physio will ensure you get a referral that suits your condition.

If you are sick, have some weird rash, etc etc, go to a GP they will prescribe you the appropriate treatment, refer you for further tests etc etc.

Go and see Neill, he has earned your treatment I reckon. At least you can be pretty certain he won't stooge you.
pluzi9mm
pluzi9mm
NSW
20 posts
NSW, 20 posts
14 Jul 2009 5:21pm
rez said...

I tore my mcl at the beginning of last December. Its only just starting to come good now but still hurts.


Really! It's taken that long?!
Have you kited at all in that time? I thought I'd be back on the board after 12 -14 weeks. Mind you, its week 9 and its still not stable
7 months out... depressing.
GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
14 Jul 2009 9:53pm
superlizard said...

TALK TO GPs, just demand that you are in ridiculous pain and you must get a referral to specialist.


fixed that for ya - always worked for me...

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply