Kite Incident off Swanbourne

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Sime.
Sime.
WA
8 posts
WA, 8 posts
22 Nov 2007 1:37pm
I would also like to thank Fred. Im the yellow kite guy who attempted the first rescue and just ended up with a nice swim.
Bascially the guy on the red kite crashed in a kite loop off swannie. His chicken loop came off the bar and he was attached only by the saftey. As unlucky as it sounds the saftey got caught around the bar and was balanced enough to stop the saftey for pulling the kite only on one line - thus the kite continued to fly, looping out to sea. He was too far from the bar to reach it as the kite was smashing and dragging him so rapidly. Also he could not cut the lines as the only line he could reach was the safety (too thick). I tried to crash my kite into his to tangle them up and stop his looping so badly. This kinda worked but it was not until his line snapped when fred rocked up that he could wreasle his way out of his harness. THANKS again fred. By this stage he could not swim and had a few broken ribs. The only thing that would have saved this situation would be if the red kiter had a harness with a second release on the bar (common in one brand). There was nothing else this guy could do.
We were the two at Charlies, red kiter is sore but will kite again after ribs repair.
As far as chipping in for a kite - very nice offer but unnecessary. I would also like to thank all the crew who saw this happen and called the appropriate people etc.. you guys have just made me feel far better about this incident. The fact that clubbies and police were all notified is a great relief. I have been thinking about what could have happebed without fred as red kite could not swim. But know I know that he would have been good with the arrivial of boats etc..
Thanks again to all of you.
Sime


getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
22 Nov 2007 1:45pm
Top effort Sime. Sounds like if you didn't reach him the outcome may have been far more tragic than busted ribs...Glad to hear you got your kite back too.

I will be taking a fresh look at every release on both my bars this afternoon...


Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
22 Nov 2007 3:48pm
Its sounds surprising that he couldn't release his leash. I thought all kites had quick releases on the leash as well or have I misunderstood the situation?
manicskier
manicskier
VIC
772 posts
VIC, 772 posts
22 Nov 2007 4:12pm
Not one on my 07 waroo safety...
PattyB
PattyB
WA
2 posts
WA, 2 posts
22 Nov 2007 2:18pm
I am the guy on the red best waroo kite, a bit bruised and battered but happpy to be sitting here writing. Firstly thankyou to Fred for dragging me into Floreat after a pretty Torid downwinder from Swanbourne and Thankyou to the guy who gave us a lift to Swanny, and finally thankyou to my mate Sime (yellow Kite) for sacrificing kite and almost dog to try and rescue me. Thankyou to anyone else who called for help....

Just to clarify the incident and hopefully take some learning from it. It started with my chicken loop coming out of my harness, instead of depowering on my emergency my kite instantly went into strong loops (5) followed by a crash in the water and then lopping, this continued all of the way down the beach, slightly to the left of the window pulling me further offshore (the least of my worries). I had a small harness knife but was not in a position to reach it or cut my lines as I was at this stage connected by my emergency only and could not pull up the line to either grab my tangled bar an/or lines. I was in serious trouble effectively in survival mode trying to relax and keep my head above water. I tried to undo my harness but was too powered to attempt much and worried I would start submerging. My mate Sime (yellow kite) came along and tried to lend a hand, the only solution in my head was to pop my kite (looping viviously) or get a big knife or boat to help. Sime tried to stop my kite with his which failed and he disconnected when they became tangled, his kite did slow me down for while as I grabbed the inflated edge to keep above water and then when I could not hold it acted as a sea anchor with me in the middle of two tangled kites. just offshore Floreat Fred came along on his kite and handed me a knife, again this was of no use as it was very small and would have struggled to cut the emergency line, however as fate would have it one of my lines then broke (from the 30 minutes of pounding) and I was depowered. I then got out of my harness and grabbed an exhausted Fred who body dragged me in to shore from where another good samaritan gave me a lift to Swanny and then a long night in emergency treating broken ribs and saltwater in my lungs.

My learnings

- Have disconnect between your emergency and harness mine was looped around a ring with no vecro or release.
- Have an emergency disconnect on the front of your harness as it is impossible to undoo when fully powered and being whipped out of the water.
- Always kite with a mate.
- Should kiters have better access to surfclub and emergency numbers? these things happen quickly and a rubber ducky would have been handy from Flozza?

Thanks and happy kiting.

PS If anyone finds a yellow and red waroo bars and a harness give me a hoy.

Pat
ianyoung
ianyoung
WA
649 posts
WA, 649 posts
23 Nov 2007 1:59pm
Well done Fred & Jeremy!

I'd be more than happy to chip in to help the guy who tried to rescue the first guy to get into trouble - WAKSA how can we do this?
Skwinty
Skwinty
WA
164 posts
WA, 164 posts
23 Nov 2007 3:03pm


Scary Stuff! Good to hear nobody got to badly hurt.

Not sure if many people use these or not? A guy told me to get one for safety as a backup release, when I first started kiting.
You can get these at most boating/marine supply shops.
Mine cost about $15.

You pull the little ring to release the shackle, and it opens up. (Ive got a small peice of line with a toggle attached to mine so its easy to grap)

Ive got mine between my safety leash - connecting to my harness so you can ditch the lot in these sorts of situations. (thats the theory anyway.... it may be a little harder to grab when your getting flung around like a rag doll!)
puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
23 Nov 2007 3:51pm
Dont suppose we can ever get 100% guaranteed cover. BUT....
I've been advocating the use of the Slingshot Surefire Quick release harness bar for several years now.
This is IMO the BEST safety innovation in kiting ever.
It gives you one single QR point which is an auxillary to any QR provided by the kite you are flying at any time.
Brilliant - its always there, always in exactly the same place, always the same action required, simplest reload system of any QR etc etc etc. AND you can use your QR to unhook everytime you land - makes for great consistent practice - just like the doctor orders but also just like hardly anyone ever does.
And the downside is ......... some may tell you they accidently trigger ???? In 3 years mine has done this once - big deal Ive only ever used it a few times & cant say what the consequences would have been otherwise but at least twice it could have been as serious as this incident

SERIOUSLY - Do yourself a favour & check them out.

I did a gear review a long time back which has disappeared . I'll post another one sometime but you could try a search of the slingshot sites.
In WA - Choicey had a few on the shelf a while back; probably also at Windforce and even non slingy kiteshops carry them (just cos they are just so good )
MartyJ
MartyJ
QLD
95 posts
QLD, 95 posts
23 Nov 2007 5:38pm
Squinty ..... there are many different types of these quick releases available. Many of which are hard to impossible to release under HEAVY LOAD. I bought some for the same reason but when I tested them under load .....
Bo
Bo
WA
192 posts
Bo Bo
WA, 192 posts
23 Nov 2007 4:40pm
First of all BIG kudos to all the helpers involved who pulled off this rescue. It's heartening to see that we're basically a fairly decent group of people

However I feel it's important that we accurately learn all we can out of this scary incident. I fly Waroos myself and I'm a bit confused:

Firstly here are some pictures of the Waroo bar to ensure we're talking about the same thing: http://www.bestkiteboarding.com/07Bar

1. So your c-loop came out and the kite started looping? This tells me you had the safety attached to the metal handlepass ring located on the chicken loop? This ring should only be used by experienced riders while doing unhooked tricks, who have trimmed their kites appropriately and always when out on the water. Attaching your safety leash there will only depower the kite 90% when released and put your bar OUT OF REACH. With a bit of bad luck - spiraling can occur, twisting your lines multiple times with no hope of unspinning and relaunching the kite. In that case all you can really do is let the kite go completely...

2. So why could you not let the kite go? Why could you not pull the leash's saftey release on the bar side? (See picture of leash, the red tube) This would have released the entire rig? Could it be you were not using the leash that comes with the bar?

I think it would be helpful to others if you could clarify this so we can take preventative action

Thanks and regards,
Bo

RayQ
RayQ
WA
638 posts
WA, 638 posts
23 Nov 2007 4:56pm
Regarding the pix that SKWINTY posted, that is not a good snap shakkel / Quick release, about 4-5 years ago these were discussed heavily on all forums, there is a brand called WICHARD, they are one of the few that dont load up and then not open. They were used by quite a lot of kiters before kite companys finaly decided they would spend a few dollars more to save our lives, and I still see those ****t " pull the pin " releases on some kites.

Ray
Skwinty
Skwinty
WA
164 posts
WA, 164 posts
23 Nov 2007 4:59pm
Bo said...



2. So why could you not let the kite go? Why could you not pull the leash's saftey release on the bar side? (See picture of leash, the red tube) This would have released the entire rig? Could it be you were not using the leash that comes with the bar?




Not sure... But I think these guys might have been on the 2006 Waroo's which didnt come with the leash saftey release.
PattyB
PattyB
WA
2 posts
WA, 2 posts
23 Nov 2007 6:05pm
Yep. the old waroos had no quick release on the safety line, I will be ordering one though!
Bo
Bo
WA
192 posts
Bo Bo
WA, 192 posts
24 Nov 2007 5:04pm
PattyB said...

Yep. the old waroos had no quick release on the safety line, I will be ordering one though!

Onya, thanks for sharing this info guys, so that others can learn! Your painful experience and lucky escape from this near-fatal incident was perhaps not quite in vain. Waroo riders can extrapolate:

1. Invest in the the 07/8 Best Bar (with HP leash)
2. The Waroo manual-endorsed safety setup is: the leash attached to OSH (back line)
3. PLEASE only hook the leash onto the handlepass ring on the chickenloop in open water away from any crowds.
4. Importantly, understand the danger of riding with this setup in crowded conditions and when powered up. You may be faced with releasing both kite and bar!

I leave you to imagine what might happen when your leash is hooked into the handlepass ring while launching on a crowded beach. (I see this happening every day at my local) - Say something goes pear-shaped and you have to pull the quick release. You will have a looping kite on the leash and 2 choices:

A) Get dragged inland by a fully-depowered, looping kite - but with a bar that's out of reach
B) Release the whole rig at the harness end and have it fly, lines-and-all, possibly into others downwind of you...difficult choice, it's either you or them

Further tips:

Tip 1
Make sure the leash's red release-all tube is on the harness side, not the bar side. It's a mistake easily made and you will then not be able to reach the release.

Tip 2
Attach a ball stopper (eg Slingshot makes one) and attach it 1.5 kite lenghts above the OSH. This will prevent the bar running all the way up the line when activating the safety or self landing.


Sorry to make this sound somehwat like a lecture. Please ride safe and have fun
Bo


tomtomtom
tomtomtom
1 posts
1 posts
25 Nov 2007 1:18pm
Here are 2 new posts on kiteforum which pertain to a lot of the questions asked in this thread, about what to do in the case of kite wraps, and about the subject concerning the value of kite knives.

These are new threads, and I hope that some experienced kiters will contribute useful suggestions. Warning: Some posters can be quite rude on Kiteforum, but don't let them put you off.

http://www.kiteforum.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=2343812&start=0&postdays=0&postorder=asc&highlight=

www.kiteforum.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=2343820&highlight=

It seems like both subjects have come up a lot recently, on the kite forums.
bolgo
bolgo
WA
912 posts
WA, 912 posts
26 Nov 2007 3:18pm
there is also lots on those shackles

they are bad news

i'm with puppet with the surefire spreader bar - saved my bacon on a few occasions and adds in an extra level of dedundancy to safety systems

never accidently activated it, but use in all the time to self land

dont leave home without it!
kitecrazzzy
kitecrazzzy
WA
2184 posts
WA, 2184 posts
26 Nov 2007 3:33pm
the harnesses with the leash release built in is one of the best methods and should be promoted to beginners a lot more than they are.
NSW, 4382 posts
27 Nov 2007 2:14pm
Skwinty said...



Scary Stuff! Good to hear nobody got to badly hurt.

Not sure if many people use these or not? A guy told me to get one for safety as a backup release, when I first started kiting.
You can get these at most boating/marine supply shops.
Mine cost about $15.

You pull the little ring to release the shackle, and it opens up. (Ive got a small peice of line with a toggle attached to mine so its easy to grap)

Ive got mine between my safety leash - connecting to my harness so you can ditch the lot in these sorts of situations. (thats the theory anyway.... it may be a little harder to grab when your getting flung around like a rag doll!)


G'day Skwinty

Please don't recommend that shackle for kiting, they do not release reliably, especially under load.
If you do not pull the release in the same direction as the pin sits in the shackle, they will not release, especially under LOAD.
Get a wichard shackle like this, they work much better but are not foolproof either.

All good leashes have a quick release. Best kites leashes are good.

Use a leash that has a quick release, do not add bits that are not designed to release under load or designed for kiting.


Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

NSW, 4382 posts
27 Nov 2007 2:20pm
PattyB said...

I am the guy on the red best waroo kite, a bit bruised and battered but happpy to be sitting here writing. Firstly thankyou to Fred for dragging me into Floreat after a pretty Torid downwinder from Swanbourne and Thankyou to the guy who gave us a lift to Swanny, and finally thankyou to my mate Sime (yellow Kite) for sacrificing kite and almost dog to try and rescue me. Thankyou to anyone else who called for help....

Just to clarify the incident and hopefully take some learning from it. It started with my chicken loop coming out of my harness, instead of depowering on my emergency my kite instantly went into strong loops (5) followed by a crash in the water and then lopping, this continued all of the way down the beach, slightly to the left of the window pulling me further offshore (the least of my worries). I had a small harness knife but was not in a position to reach it or cut my lines as I was at this stage connected by my emergency only and could not pull up the line to either grab my tangled bar an/or lines. I was in serious trouble effectively in survival mode trying to relax and keep my head above water. I tried to undo my harness but was too powered to attempt much and worried I would start submerging. My mate Sime (yellow kite) came along and tried to lend a hand, the only solution in my head was to pop my kite (looping viviously) or get a big knife or boat to help. Sime tried to stop my kite with his which failed and he disconnected when they became tangled, his kite did slow me down for while as I grabbed the inflated edge to keep above water and then when I could not hold it acted as a sea anchor with me in the middle of two tangled kites. just offshore Floreat Fred came along on his kite and handed me a knife, again this was of no use as it was very small and would have struggled to cut the emergency line, however as fate would have it one of my lines then broke (from the 30 minutes of pounding) and I was depowered. I then got out of my harness and grabbed an exhausted Fred who body dragged me in to shore from where another good samaritan gave me a lift to Swanny and then a long night in emergency treating broken ribs and saltwater in my lungs.

My learnings

- Have disconnect between your emergency and harness mine was looped around a ring with no vecro or release.
- Have an emergency disconnect on the front of your harness as it is impossible to undoo when fully powered and being whipped out of the water.
- Always kite with a mate.
- Should kiters have better access to surfclub and emergency numbers? these things happen quickly and a rubber ducky would have been handy from Flozza?

Thanks and happy kiting.

PS If anyone finds a yellow and red waroo bars and a harness give me a hoy.

Pat



G'day Pat

Crikey!! That is one of the worst Kitemares I've heard of where the person survived, it sounds like you were close to passing out??
Good on Fver for coming to your aid and your mate with the yellow kite.

I'm fairly certain from reading your account that there were some basic errors in the way your gear was rigged, and I want to help you and other understand what happened, so if you don't mind can I ask you a few questions.

Where did you have the leash connected before the looping began?
Was it a standard 07 Waroo leash?
Had you altered the length of the grey amsteel c-loop line (shortened it)?


Really glad you are OK and can now contribute to a better understanding of how to deal with emergencies.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

Gstar
Gstar
WA
391 posts
WA, 391 posts
27 Nov 2007 12:23pm

'Get a wichard shackle like this, they work much better but are not foolproof either'


That is a Wichard shackle, can't you see the little W on it?
Be definite when recommending a product.
Not every vacuum cleaner is a Hoover.
Blaster
Blaster
WA
501 posts
WA, 501 posts
27 Nov 2007 1:02pm
Kitepower Australia said...

Had you altered the length of the grey amsteel c-loop line (shortened it)?


So please explain Steve what you think this will do before I cut mine. I've shortened it so I can just reach the front line safety for self landing but haven't cut it yet. It's rediculously long in the standard setup, to self land you put yourself in danger as I currently need to pull in the rope a few feet to grab the front line. In the process the kite falls back in the window then powers up if your not quick enough. I feel I've still got enough depower when it's shortened if required. I also run a 2 safety system setup with a short leash attached to my bar(not hook).

I did see someone's hook snap off last week and he had his safety attached to it. He was lucky, very light winds and he was able to swim after and grab the chicken loop and get back to the beach.
NSW, 4382 posts
27 Nov 2007 8:10pm
Gstar said...


'Get a wichard shackle like this, they work much better but are not foolproof either'


That is a Wichard shackle, can't you see the little W on it?
Be definite when recommending a product.
Not every vacuum cleaner is a Hoover.


Exactly Gtar!
Not all snap shackles are wichard and not all look like this.
Only use a shackle that looks like this



Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

pds
pds
WA
28 posts
pds pds
WA, 28 posts
27 Nov 2007 7:28pm
Hey guys...

If you see an incident the best course of action - if you consider it an emergency (as per current incident being discussed) then ring Police on '000'. If not quite sure as to the urgency then ring 131 444. This will put you thru to Police who can then access Water Police / Helicopter / Sea Rescue much quicker than dialing individual groups etc.

Water Police Marine Co-ordination Centre is well set up for this sort of stuff and they will respond in the quickest way possible.

Best thing you can do is try and keep eyes on the parties involved as you can then direct resources into the right area via your mobile.

Pete the kiting copper.....

NSW, 4382 posts
27 Nov 2007 10:00pm
Blaster said...

Kitepower Australia said...

Had you altered the length of the grey amsteel c-loop line (shortened it)?


So please explain Steve what you think this will do before I cut mine. I've shortened it so I can just reach the front line safety for self landing but haven't cut it yet. It's rediculously long in the standard setup, to self land you put yourself in danger as I currently need to pull in the rope a few feet to grab the front line. In the process the kite falls back in the window then powers up if your not quick enough. I feel I've still got enough depower when it's shortened if required. I also run a 2 safety system setup with a short leash attached to my bar(not hook).

I did see someone's hook snap off last week and he had his safety attached to it. He was lucky, very light winds and he was able to swim after and grab the chicken loop and get back to the beach.


The Best 07 bar, allows the advanced rider to shorten the throw on the chicken lop line, but there can be dir consequences for doing that.
The main one is that the 07 Waroo kite will not be able to depower fully!! The length of grey steel line supplied will depower all the waroo kite sizes, so there can be a bit taken off the bar on the smaller ones.
I'm only guessing, so don't take my word on this trim the kite with the depower?trim strap and then let go of the bar in light and medium winds to test if the kite will fully depower, if it does you could trim off the amount that equates to the trim stap adjustment length (its only a few to several inches).
It would be far better to err on the side of safety and not trim any!

To reach the centre lines, for self landing, just pull on the centre line with one hand and then grab the appropriate centre line to spin the kite as it lands. This technique requires practice in light winds.

Otherwise clip the leash to the OSH, or flagging handle on either rear line making very sure that you only clip onto the OSH ring, not the ring on the end of the float.

If you are not sure what I am talking about please contact a more experienced kiter and get them to show you how the system works.

AFAIK the 06 Best leash still had a safety release, other wise its not a leash its a death line!!!

Get a leash with a push away release, never use pull towards you safety releases!!!
If the kite is down and the lines are slack, but tghe kite is going to hot relaunch you may not be able to release with apull towards you system.

Become VERY well aquainted with your safety system!!

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

cat
cat
WA
48 posts
cat cat
WA, 48 posts
27 Nov 2007 11:03pm
As a regular kiter with yellow and red kite I was shocked to hear this tale. It's testament to their fitness and determination that it ended up as it did. I had a very similar kitemare in the Safety Bay race several years ago ending up with a 2km swim in in a big swell. The rescue boat repeatedly missed me due to the swell and my flare failed. The thing that saved my bacon was my bouyancy vest. Since then I've always been cautious of kiting on my own or even with a couple of other kiters around. Haven't worn my vest for ages but will dust it off for my next outing.
Blaster
Blaster
WA
501 posts
WA, 501 posts
28 Nov 2007 11:45am
Cheers Steve.

I don't ride best, but I have had a few sessions on a mates with the 07 bar (personally hate that bar). I do understand what your saying in regards to that specific setup, it could be dangerous if modified I guess. I think my mods will be fine, my mate is IKO instructor and we did the changes together. I will check it for depowering ability this arvo by throwing the safety in the light winds before I cut the rope.

To the guys that lost their kites, glad to read about that guy finding out at sea. Sound like he had a job on his hands with a 5 hour recovery, Few beers in order. Anyhow good ending to a possible tragedy.
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
28 Nov 2007 2:51pm
Great story. Life threatening stuff does happen in this sport. How nice is that no one got killed or maimed; quick intervention by local kiting kiters shows what excellent people we have in this sport and how our local community is involved and caring.

I believe that it would be good for kiters to enter sea rescue numbers in to their mobiles.

This incident is a perfect example of how well some things do function here. Ok, so there is some criminals who steal and loot from us, but as I said there are risks associated with kiting. I do wish the petty crime and garbage throwing would come to an end though because I do know as a group kiters do not steal from each other and leave a mess.

Looks like it is windy every day now and there will be plenty of people out on the water. Say hi and look out for each other.
kitecrazzzy
kitecrazzzy
WA
2184 posts
WA, 2184 posts
28 Nov 2007 4:08pm
Just a list of the metro volunteer sea rescue groups, they run off donations and the fuel they use would rack up a significant cost even for a small call out.

http://www.freosearescue.org.au/about.php 9335 1332

www.whitfordssearescue.org.au/about.php 9401 3757

www.cockburnsearescue.org.au/index_about.htm 9410 1544

add them to your phone as you wish.
in a life threatening situation you might be better to phone the water police HQ as they over see all emergencies on the water.
water police coordination centre 9442 8606

if you loose a kite it is a good idea to phone the water police or closest VSRG so they dont start a search for you when they find just a kite.
NSW, 4382 posts
29 Nov 2007 10:39am
@ PattyB

I'm fairly certain from reading your account that there were some basic errors in the way your gear was rigged, and I want to help you and others understand what happened, so if you don't mind can I ask you a few questions.?

Where did you have the leash connected before the looping began?
Was it a standard 07 Waroo leash?
Had you altered the length of the grey amsteel c-loop line (shortened it)?

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

Perthvert
Perthvert
WA
7 posts
WA, 7 posts
13 Dec 2007 3:09pm
If the rescuer is still with out a kite, i reckon the community should all chip in a get a replacement kite, if enough people chipped in, it would cost bugger all, its a community thing i reckon, and communities support each other, don't they???
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply