Mullaloo - ABC 720 WA

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
whatthe
whatthe
WA
186 posts
WA, 186 posts
20 Mar 2009 12:22pm
Apparently there is some discussion re Mullaloo bans occurring on ABC 720 (WA) at the moment.
airhead
airhead
WA
814 posts
WA, 814 posts
20 Mar 2009 12:26pm
yeap heard that too! snippet I heard they were talking about some young kid being dragged down the beach through swimmers/sun bathers

bad news all round
whatthe
whatthe
WA
186 posts
WA, 186 posts
20 Mar 2009 12:34pm
Didn't hear the start myself, but I think some of the complainers rang in and expressed their views as per council meeting.

Heard a nice call from a mum in Waikiki who commended the local kitesurfers (& poleys) for congregating in the one area. She made the point that she was happy cos she knew where they operated and consequently didn't take her small children swimming in that particular area. A fair & sensible approach by all parties - I think that is all we ask for!!!
puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
20 Mar 2009 1:53pm
Thanks to a phone call I caught the end of it as well - two very good replies.
1) the mum from Safety Bay - thank you for that.
2) Pat from Hillarys ? excellent call Pat. Very informed, accurate and reasoned response - esp re self regulation & needing 'no go zones' rather than 'go zones'.
WAKSA will be interviewed as well some time soon.
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
20 Mar 2009 3:20pm
Fek!! They are right below where i am sittin now!

Any grief from (Bernie I think?) and I will start stamping on the floor!

Didn't hear it myself but hope it was balanced. If the kid getting dragged through was factual - well whaddaya gonna do?

the walks
the walks
WA
448 posts
WA, 448 posts
20 Mar 2009 3:20pm
can you let us know times & dates so we can all listen in please phil ?
pds
pds
WA
28 posts
pds pds
WA, 28 posts
20 Mar 2009 4:50pm
Listen to the discussion for yourself.

www.abc.net.au/local/audio/2009/03/20/2521988.htm?site=perth&rotator=true

lemming
lemming
WA
75 posts
WA, 75 posts
20 Mar 2009 6:54pm
"10ft long cables"!!! wtf!!!

An irresponsible broadcast by not asking WAKSA to be part of the discussion!


Durks
Durks
WA
118 posts
WA, 118 posts
20 Mar 2009 8:27pm
Hate to say it but I think the mothers brigade will eventually win without some serious internal regulations coming from the kitesurfing community. ie WAKSA

Hearing the article as a freshy kiter and then trying to imagine how the general public will hear this argument I reckon we've got an uphill battle without some concessions being made.

The best concepts following this Mullaloo issue so far I think have been designated launching areas and no-go spots on very busy beaches. In my area there is no way people should be setting up around Trigg, Scarborough or Mullaloo SLSC and yet they do. It increases the risks for beach users and those in the water around those areas, plus people with less experience aren't as likely to stray far from their launching spots.

Newby areas should be identified and advertised prolifically when selling gear etc where out of control kites arent gonna be downwind of congested areas of the uninitiated. There's heaps of dudes out there who buy gear and then just try to wing it; yeah stooopid but at least if they're gonna do it its our responsibility as sellers or kiters in the area who come across it to put them onto to seabreeze, rules and WAKSA.

If the public sees this as an 'extreme sport' in a public domain we're gonna face HUGE regulation. Look at sport skydiving; compulsary annual APF membership (alot more than WAKSA), 6 monthly gear checks and graduated licenses with qualified instructor. Yes, the risks are different but the public perception isn't particularly when it's the public at risk rather than the kitesurfer.

I for one am gonna get a WAKSA membership. A more aggressive approach to self-regulation is the only way I reckon this things gonna float as the numbers of kiters in Perth climb.
jeremy
jeremy
WA
202 posts
WA, 202 posts
20 Mar 2009 10:27pm
I listened to the 720 segment. Some very emotional statements by the anti kite surfing lobby.. "blood on their hands if nothing is done "sort of stuff.
There were two calls pro kite surfing ....one mother and a kite surfer Pat. They were reasonable and good.

IMO we have a problem . Some kiters are endangering the public and those members of the public that are injured or who observe close calls ( or what they perceive to be) are livered. As a kiting community what we are doing now i don,t think is working. Unless the kiting community comes up with a solution that works , the authorities will solve it for us.

Perhaps all kiters should have a readable registration number sown on their kites so they can be identified.
sir ROWDY
sir ROWDY
WA
5378 posts
WA, 5378 posts
20 Mar 2009 11:15pm
Someone needs to build a case with clear statistics and proof that kitesurfing is not really very dangerous at all. Pretty much every incident involved with a kitesurfers the kiter is injured and not the public.
Also need to point out the positives involved, tourism, lifesaving potentials etc...

When the mal riders were trying to shut us down with all this "danger" hype and "how many people are injured and are going to end up dead if its not banned etc..", we replied with the amount of innocent parties admitted to the hospital every year from being hit/run over by surfboards and the real statistics on how many people are injured by kites. This act in itself pretty much ended the saga.

People are easily persuaded to things by other people just claiming false statistics and hyping up how dangerous something is, they dont really anylise the situation themselves and instead just get on side.
You need to point out just how safe and positive kting is and just how much these people are whinging and trying to stop you doing something you love.
People hate it when a minority trys to stop someone from having fun. Use this and run with it, get kid kiters, women, older dudes, everyone you can to write letters to the paper and the like saying how much they love the sport and how dissapointed they will be to loose this wonderful spot.
Highlighting the big cross section of people that do the sport is also a good idea.

just some ideas, you probably already thought of these, just trying to help.
Cal
Cal
QLD
1003 posts
Cal Cal
QLD, 1003 posts
21 Mar 2009 9:01am
The way I see it, the issue is very straight forward. If a beach is busy, dont kite there, or at least dont come close to shore. Dont rig or pack down there and dont move through crowds. If we all obey these simple concepts, there will be no issues. If you are learning, go to the well established 'newbie zones'. If you are a poser, pretend the trees, white caps etc are your public, or just get over yourself!

As has been said many times, the actions of a few... So to everyone, listen to the sensible side of the argument to remove us from the busy beaches, and before it becomes legislation, move on your own free will. Then when the beaches are not crowded, they are still open to us.
sandgroper
sandgroper
WA
368 posts
WA, 368 posts
21 Mar 2009 8:22am
We've been through all this.

The solution is SIGNS!!! SIGNS!!! SIGNS!!!

And I'll keep saying it till it gets through.

SIGNS!!!

Stop bitching about who'se right or wrong and ask the councils to put up signs, and have on the spot fines for breaches.

Write to his majesty TryHard Prick and get some signage up there so people are informed what to do and what not to do. FFS, thats his F**ing job. Get him to do something for once in his Macavellian life.


Solved.
onepump
onepump
WA
66 posts
WA, 66 posts
22 Mar 2009 12:50pm
sandgroper said...


The solution is SIGNS!!! SIGNS!!! SIGNS!!!
Solved.


Yeah, right. Lets put a sign up every 50/100m along the Australian coastline near metro areas. I reckon they would have to be fairly large signs with maps showing highlighted exclusion areas and a list of dos and do nots in English and maybe German/French. That would be a great addition to the natural beauty of the beach.

As a 1980's philosopher once said: "Stop, collaborate, listen."
Every issue raised by the 'killer kite' lobbyists could have been solved or prevented by verbal communication. Talk to each other, talk to other beach users. The solution is TALK!!! TALK!!! TALK!!! I saw a dude trying to self land a kite at leighton beach last week when there were maybe 4 or 5 kiters standing watching, not cool. The dude should have talked to the others and asked for a hand. The others should have talked to the dude and offered a hand. Kiting is a team sport now because we must support each other to make it a safer sport with a more family friendly image

Let's also have kite only zones, we would be well separated from the rest of the public and we would never have to mix with other beach users and infect them with our love of kites, fitness and fun.

Peace
puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
22 Mar 2009 5:49pm
Cal said...
So to everyone, listen to the sensible side of the argument to remove us from the busy beaches, and before it becomes legislation, move on your own free will. Then when the beaches are not crowded, they are still open to us..


Absolutely spot on Cal. If only everyone could see it - AND do it.
It really is this easy.

Way better to give up little bits here & there sometimes than be stuck with nothing but a few little bits all the time.
puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
22 Mar 2009 5:59pm
onepump said...

Let's also have kite only zones, we would be well separated from the rest of the public and we would never have to mix with other beach users and infect them with our love of kites, fitness and fun.



I agree with all the rest 'onepump' but if it comes 'kite only zones' we have totally lost.
Think about it. No more choice, no more downwinders, massive over-crowding etc etc.
This is the worst possible outcome.
This is what we must self-regulate (& talk talk talk) to avoid - at all cost.
shooterMcgavin
shooterMcgavin
WA
90 posts
WA, 90 posts
22 Mar 2009 6:15pm
the beach isnt very family freindly at all what about sharks rips jelly fish or the electric eel I wouldent take my kids to the beach.
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
22 Mar 2009 7:15pm
All about the teething issues coming with a new sport.....I hear you all. What I was pondering today was; why is it that the anti kite lobby at Mullaloo is so vigilant and getting some support vs. the people at Meliville who are not as able to rally others? I theorize that the answer lies with the differing demographics.

The Mullas crowd are young active families who worship the beach and the activities well established before kites came around. Now imagine how all the young kids who see the kites get turned on by this and want to do it. Kiting looks like so much more fun than running, paddling or swimming....even surfing. The mummies and dadies of these kiddies are confronted with something their kids want to do...imagine what goes through their heads....danger, money, the unkown...the list goes on. Why can't the kiddies just be happy surfing and swimming they ask............go figure. So, these mums and dads wish the sport was never invented and would love to have it banned, especially at "their" beach. It is kind of like parents who want to ban kids from being on the net....they more they speak badly of it and the more they try an ban it the more the kids want to do it.

Now the demographics of Melville crowd is a bit different. People living along MBP are not beach types at all.....they are likely to hate the beach. Not as many young families live along MBP either. So it is a few elderly ladies who have a constant cry to Council and they can not really neighbor support because kiting at Melville is not an issue.

And where does this possible insight to the vigilant attitudes at Mullas leave us? I think that the only way to win over the Mullas anti kite crowd is to understand the deep reasons why they want to ban kiting....and not random events that they use to support their cause.

Perhaps the local Mullas kiters need to have an open round table discussion with the leaders of the ani-kite movement and ask some more questions. They of course also have the opportunity to ask you all things about kiting. So what can the Mullas kite crew do for all those young kids who want to get in to kiting? An explanation to mummies and daddies about all the benefits of kiting to their dear little ones might be a start.

Perth and kiting go hand in hand...it is the best sport for this town. The sooner we embrace this the better. I am for registering every single kiter in WA period....you want to kite here, you register and are given the local rules...no if and or buts.....otherwise fark off to another country or state.
onepump
onepump
WA
66 posts
WA, 66 posts
22 Mar 2009 10:00pm
puppetonastring said...

onepump said...

Let's also have kite only zones, we would be well separated from the rest of the public and we would never have to mix with other beach users and infect them with our love of kites, fitness and fun.



I agree with all the rest 'onepump' but if it comes 'kite only zones' we have totally lost.
Think about it. No more choice, no more downwinders, massive over-crowding etc etc.
This is the worst possible outcome.
This is what we must self-regulate (& talk talk talk) to avoid - at all cost.




Yeah bro. I was kinda being sarcastic

puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
22 Mar 2009 11:44pm
onepump said...

Yeah bro. I was kinda being sarcastic



DOH sorry onepump .... my bad - missed that.
Still. Worth spelling it out though. Everyone needs to understand the fight is for isolated 'no go zones' NOT isolated 'go zones'.
buckwheat
buckwheat
WA
85 posts
WA, 85 posts
23 Mar 2009 9:41am
I agree with Sandgroper on this one. If you're going to approach someone on the beach about their poor form / behaviour, its nice if you have a sign to back you up. They don't need to be every 50m as someone suggested, but a few in obvious spots would certainly be helpful. You can't hold someone to account if you haven't made an effort to communicate the rules to them.

As a snow skier, I will often do everythign it takes to get fresh pow pow (within the bounds of my own safety and others of course). When I'm on skis, my attitude is "if it isn't signposted, then it isn't officially a rule, and you can't bust me for breaking it". I wouldn;t be surprised if many kiters also had the same attitude.

Everyones verison of "common sense" and "safety" can vary, but you can't argue with something in writing.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply