Statements that aren’t true

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
gerard
gerard
QLD
175 posts
QLD, 175 posts
26 Jun 2008 6:49pm
“I'm 85kgs and can hold the 13 down in 28knts on a 132flx.

Why do people make statements that aren’t true? I got this from another thread, it really annoys me that people say stuff that is possibly or even more likely actually going to get other less experienced people in trouble. They read things like this on Seabreeze and think it’s possible.

Holding a 13mtr Rev in 28 knots, what a load of crap!

Keep it real please!

(same with surf here in Perth, you almost always 1/2 the size people say the surf was, so you can get the right size)
the pm
the pm
QLD
31 posts
QLD, 31 posts
26 Jun 2008 7:00pm
I agree Gerard.
Lets save all our good lies for talking to the Ladies.
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
26 Jun 2008 7:01pm
Normally, this happens when a person see's a wind chart after and see's the gusts were hitting 30 knots. Woohoo, I can hold a kite in 30 knots! Not! Real wind is actually 25 knots with gusts of 30, so you're actually able to ride in 25, not 30. holding a kite in 30 would mean sustaining gusts of 35 and we all know most people couldn't hold a 13m in 35knot gusts.
Macca Wollongong
Macca Wollongong
NSW
295 posts
NSW, 295 posts
26 Jun 2008 7:12pm
So if i said i can handle my 06 11m instinct in 25-30 knots and im 60kg on a 125 best drive, would this be untrue?
gerard
gerard
QLD
175 posts
QLD, 175 posts
26 Jun 2008 7:18pm
Is it true that your only 60kg?
the pm
the pm
QLD
31 posts
QLD, 31 posts
26 Jun 2008 7:28pm
I agree Gerard.
Lets save all our good lies for talking to the Ladies.
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
26 Jun 2008 7:30pm
This is a bit of a grey area (the catchphrase of forum admin it seems). While it is quite possible for experienced riders to hold down stupidly large kites in strong wind, it's possibly not a good idea to go around claiming it in front of impressionable newbies in case they try the same thing.

Anyway, how much fun is it riding with so much power that you have to dig right in and go at a snails pace while the kite is almost touching the water so as to not risk losing an edge?
teabagg
teabagg
NSW
141 posts
NSW, 141 posts
26 Jun 2008 8:01pm
^^^exactly, know a guy who rides a 17mtr fuel in well over twenty knots, claims his killin it, but watchin him, he's strugglin to hold it, and we all have ride with one eye on him to make sure we give him a wide- super wide berth cause he's one gust from totally losing it and crashing down through the lot of us... does big out of control jumps downwind and totally thinks he's hadlow... except i'm sure hadlow doesn't ride the twenty years older than him town bike, if you know what i mean...
Macca Wollongong
Macca Wollongong
NSW
295 posts
NSW, 295 posts
26 Jun 2008 9:16pm
well in summer i was 60kg but i packed on 5kg from then

Riding a big kite in strong winds isnt fun, as much depower the ozone has, it is just too big above 28knts, and not that fun.

But riding an older 17m in that sort of wind is crazy go nuts, i only rode a larger kite cause thats all i had.
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
26 Jun 2008 7:39pm
I don't ride (86 kg) in 30 plus even on a 7 Fuel........not much fun really....maybe on a 5.

There are so many sad testosterone males on in this sport who are the big mouths on the forum...agreed Gerard, keep it real for the sake of the impressionable.
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
26 Jun 2008 8:41pm
Hi guys,

Once you have been in the sport for a while you'll realise it's not how big a kite you can hold down that is imressive, but how small a kite you can comfortably ride with that shows the skills.

I see guys out on Crossbows trying to hold down 30 knots and they just look like out of control tools, they make me angry because these are the same tools who get into trouble and cause incidences.

Nothing, but nothing screams NOOB louder than somone with massive POO stance hanging on to a canopy which is backwinding inside out in the gusts. No style, no grace, no control and like a school on Easter Sunday .... No Class!

Keep it real. Small kites show kite mastery as you fly them quickly around the window and sllow you to ride the board with ease and control.

here's a secret for NOOBS, a small comfortably powered kite will always boost you way higher than a big overpowered kite. Every single time. Big canopies will give longer hangtime, but not height. I don't know about you, but I like to see 30 foot jumps of 3-4 seconds rather than a 5 second hangtime 6 foot off the water.

Unless you can control it fully sheeted in, in the average wind speed, it's too big!

Good winds,

kitecrazzzy
kitecrazzzy
WA
2184 posts
WA, 2184 posts
26 Jun 2008 9:22pm
that's not an excessive statement... it may not be something worth bragging about but it's possible
fattso
fattso
VIC
170 posts
VIC, 170 posts
27 Jun 2008 12:12am
untrue statements in kiting, I'm shocked!
Bomb proof?
light wind kite?
100% depower?
extreme sport?
where will it end?
walshd
walshd
SA
601 posts
SA, 601 posts
27 Jun 2008 10:37am
Gerard said:
“I'm 85kgs and can hold the 13 down in 28knts on a 132flx.

Why do people make statements that aren’t true? I got this from another thread, it really annoys me that people say stuff that is possibly or even more likely actually going to get other less experienced people in trouble. They read things like this on Seabreeze and think it’s possible.

Holding a 13mtr Rev in 28 knots, what a load of crap!

Keep it real please!


Ease up turbo! I wrote that statement. And the only reason I were out on the 13 that day was because my 9m was off getting a warranty job fixed.

Yeh, sure the weather station graphs arent perfect but I thought that 28knts was fairly reserved seeing that gusts up the 35knts were recorded that session.

You can definatley hold the big girl down in 25knts, so why dont you think the absolute top end isnt 28knts?

Next time I'll have someone out with a wind meter just to prove you wrong.

I accept the fact that learners read these forums and prob should apoligise for encouraging noobs to ride big kites in unsuitable winds.

Just because I dont unhook and do stupid spinny wake style moves doesnt make me a noob. I've been around kiteboarding for 4 years now and just enjoy boosting as high as possible and doing basic hooked in stuff.



So next time I quote a certain kites wind range, what the hell do you guys want??? the average, min lulls and maximum gusts?? How about the standard deviation?
walshd
walshd
SA
601 posts
SA, 601 posts
27 Jun 2008 11:06am
Cabron said:
12m Switchblade IDS:

Details - see above

First thoughts: When overhead, not sure if just the colours, but this kite seems to have a very low AR. Looked like a parachute above me...laughs

On the water: Well it was never going to be as quick or twitchy as the 9m, however the kite was fun to fly, thoughts are Stable, Predictable, Smooth.
Comparing to last years SB 12m, the turning radius seems smaller, though not much quicker. Ate the gusts easily, with heaps of depower, and still steerable at arms length depower. Had to bring on trim depower at the bar at one stage, timing would have been when it kicked back up to 25-28kn, which seems a much higher wind range than last years 12m. Not sure about bottom end.


This is from your old mate in the gear review section. Note the 25-28knts on a 12m SB IDS and he aparently only slightly adjusted the trip strap.
DaveSpruce
DaveSpruce
WA
568 posts
WA, 568 posts
27 Jun 2008 9:52am
Riding a big kite in loads of wind doesn't make you cool, impress anyone or make you a good kiter. On the contrary. I could probably "hold" a 16m kite in 30knts for a while if I wanted to but why would I? I'm not gonna be able to ride it or have fun with it so what's the point!?!?!

Also people ALWAYS say it's this and that wind. 25knts this and 30knts that when in reality it's usually far less then you estimate.



Why drive around in a station wagon (12m) or truck (16m) when you can be driving a sportscar (9m)?
walshd
walshd
SA
601 posts
SA, 601 posts
27 Jun 2008 11:45am
DaveSpruce said:
Why drive around in a station wagon (12m) or truck (16m) when you can be driving a sportscar (9m)?


I totally agree with all of you on the big kite Vs small kite arguement. Perhaps you didnt read the bit where I said that my 9m was away getting repaired.

I would have loved to have been on the 9m that day but it wasnt available
DaveSpruce
DaveSpruce
WA
568 posts
WA, 568 posts
27 Jun 2008 10:30am
walshd said...

DaveSpruce said:
Why drive around in a station wagon (12m) or truck (16m) when you can be driving a sportscar (9m)?


I totally agree with all of you on the big kite Vs small kite arguement. Perhaps you didnt read the bit where I said that my 9m was away getting repaired.

I would have loved to have been on the 9m that day but it wasnt available



I did read, I'm just talking in general.. And I would have done the same thing.. if it's on you use whatever you have. I've gone out kiting with a climbing harness and some carabiners when my kiting harness broke a day before. Not ideal but it worked. Having said that, wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
meerkat
meerkat
WA
644 posts
WA, 644 posts
27 Jun 2008 11:05am
gerard said...

“Why do people make statements that aren’t true?


Do you mean the ENTIRE review section? please be more specific?

and i am still looking for a 7m that fits my budget, that does everything including pump itself up and pack itself away when i am finished. there has to be at least 5 kites out there that can do that? surely?

elizabethb
elizabethb
QLD
2081 posts
QLD, 2081 posts
27 Jun 2008 1:13pm
meerkat said...

gerard said...

“Why do people make statements that aren’t true?


and i am still looking for a 7m that fits my budget, that does everything including pump itself up and pack itself away when i am finished. there has to be at least 5 kites out there that can do that? surely?


Well first you have to make sure that there is no fake blonde, Paris Hilton looking female attached to you or the kite, or this definately won't happen.

Rule out those who like to sit and watch, refuse to learn to launch or land, or run your bar and lines out.

Those who like to sit in the car and watch, and stand on the corner waving at you to come in because she is bored.

Those who sit on the nearby bench with her other somewhat similar friends gossiping about the days fashion and celebrity news....

Just find an Aussie girl, and you'll get the pumpitself up and pack it away stage for maybe about 2weeks.... Then you get to choose... Kite or girl or kiting girl... [}:)]




This does not apply to females who kite, windsurf or any such sport, and is not exchangeable for any other offer.
h20fly
h20fly
WA
384 posts
WA, 384 posts
27 Jun 2008 11:19am
Kitehard said...

Hi guys,

Once you have been in the sport for a while you'll realise it's not how big a kite you can hold down that is imressive, but how small a kite you can comfortably ride with that shows the skills.

I see guys out on Crossbows trying to hold down 30 knots and they just look like out of control tools, they make me angry because these are the same tools who get into trouble and cause incidences.

Nothing, but nothing screams NOOB louder than somone with massive POO stance hanging on to a canopy which is backwinding inside out in the gusts. No style, no grace, no control and like a school on Easter Sunday .... No Class!

Keep it real. Small kites show kite mastery as you fly them quickly around the window and sllow you to ride the board with ease and control.

here's a secret for NOOBS, a small comfortably powered kite will always boost you way higher than a big overpowered kite. Every single time. Big canopies will give longer hangtime, but not height. I don't know about you, but I like to see 30 foot jumps of 3-4 seconds rather than a 5 second hangtime 6 foot off the water.

Unless you can control it fully sheeted in, in the average wind speed, it's too big!

Good winds,




was that aimed at me daz i have learned from those days i dont even own a 12 anymore my biggest kite is a 9. im with you its not fun poo stancing kite on water snail speed then jumping by just pulling the bar in 6 feet for 100metres this was reminded to me monday i think it was trying to hold down a 12 atom. my house mates only kite and he is a begginer so i gave him my 9. really didnt have as much fun.. got a good work out though :) trying to out edge that kite
walshd
walshd
SA
601 posts
SA, 601 posts
27 Jun 2008 12:49pm
So whats the deal then?

“I'm 85kgs and can hold the 13 down in 28knts on a 132flx" This statement is not false and anyone that owns a 13 rev would know that the top end on these kites is very good and that 28knts is probably a truthful absolute top end range.

Now I dont want to encourage any learners to attempt this on the 13 rev unless they weigh over 100kgs, but that statement isnt False.

At this wind speed, the kite will be fully depowered and controlled by edging it to the edge of the window.

I'm not trying to encourage anyone to ride a big kite in these winds.

FYI: Best advertisde their nemisis hp 12m windrange as 10-28knts on their website. Dont you think that a noob buying this kite will expect it to be good in 28knts?

waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
27 Jun 2008 11:39am
elizabethb said...

Then you get to choose... Kite or girl or [u]kiting girl



Hi Elizabeth,
Here's a thought.

Lets be honest,
Seabreeze.com is really kitesurfing-central here in Oz.
Right ?
The voice of Aussie kiting.
Kiteboreder mag comes a close second.
And you are the most (vocal) kitechic on Seabreeze....
the main female player.
So that makes you kind of famous.
Now, there must be a way of capitalizing on this ?
Or have you already ?
regards slave.



GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
27 Jun 2008 1:51pm
Should I mention here where Liz sabotaged my lines one day when she ran them out? She claims it wasn't intentional, but really I think she wanted me to death loop into the rocks...
elizabethb
elizabethb
QLD
2081 posts
QLD, 2081 posts
27 Jun 2008 4:30pm
Paaatt! Shhhuusshhh.
I must tell the whole story.
I was so overwhelmed by Pat's gorgeous personality, charm and handsome looks, that I wasn't even paying attention to the lines... I DID however, suggest he check them first!

GreenPat said...

Should I mention here where Liz sabotaged my lines one day when she ran them out? She claims it wasn't intentional, but really I think she wanted me to death loop into the rocks...


HAHA 'Slave!

I may be 'vocal' on here, but most will inform you that once you meet me, I will have an opinion on some things., but nothing like the forum. So shouldn't the main female player (me as you said), go with the main male player!? Pat!?

waveslave said...


And you are the most (vocal) kitechic on Seabreeze....
the main female player.
So that makes you kind of famous.
Now, there must be a way of capitalizing on this ?
Or have you already ?
regards slave.


sunseeker
sunseeker
QLD
1203 posts
QLD, 1203 posts
27 Jun 2008 4:50pm
Laurie, I think you should start a dating service on Seabreeze - would be a bit one sided though with the male dominance on the forum. Although woman who are budding kite bitches could log on and date a kite boarder...[}:)]
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
27 Jun 2008 4:52pm
elizabethb said...


I was so overwhelmed by Pat's gorgeous personality, charm and handsome looks,


Which Pat are you talking about? Not this one, surely.

elizabethb said...

go with


Go with where?
elizabethb
elizabethb
QLD
2081 posts
QLD, 2081 posts
27 Jun 2008 4:54pm
GreenPat said...

elizabethb said...


I was so overwhelmed by Pat's gorgeous personality, charm and handsome looks,


Which Pat are you talking about? Not this one, surely.


Oh most definately....

You are THE one and only Pat I know... ...

Go with.... Depends... [}:)]
sunseeker
sunseeker
QLD
1203 posts
QLD, 1203 posts
27 Jun 2008 4:58pm
Does anyone know if there has been a Seabreeze wedding before - this is all quite overwhelming really....
gerard
gerard
QLD
175 posts
QLD, 175 posts
28 Jun 2008 12:15am
walshd said...

Gerard said:
“I'm 85kgs and can hold the 13 down in 28knts on a 132flx.

Why do people make statements that aren’t true? I got this from another thread, it really annoys me that people say stuff that is possibly or even more likely actually going to get other less experienced people in trouble. They read things like this on Seabreeze and think it’s possible.

Holding a 13mtr Rev in 28 knots, what a load of crap!

Keep it real please!


Ease up turbo! I wrote that statement. And the only reason I were out on the 13 that day was because my 9m was off getting a warranty job fixed.

Yeh, sure the weather station graphs arent perfect but I thought that 28knts was fairly reserved seeing that gusts up the 35knts were recorded that session.

You can definatley hold the big girl down in 25knts, so why dont you think the absolute top end isnt 28knts?

Next time I'll have someone out with a wind meter just to prove you wrong.

I accept the fact that learners read these forums and prob should apoligise for encouraging noobs to ride big kites in unsuitable winds.

Just because I dont unhook and do stupid spinny wake style moves doesnt make me a noob. I've been around kiteboarding for 4 years now and just enjoy boosting as high as possible and doing basic hooked in stuff.


So next time I quote a certain kites wind range, what the hell do you guys want??? the average, min lulls and maximum gusts?? How about the standard deviation?


I’m not saying you’re a noob, I’ve seen you kite a few times. I just think that statement of ridding an 13 in 28 knots is not true. I believe anything over 25 and you’d need a concrete block tied to your leg so ya didn’t take off and Top Hat it.


gerard
gerard
QLD
175 posts
QLD, 175 posts
28 Jun 2008 12:20am
walshd said...

So whats the deal then?

“I'm 85kgs and can hold the 13 down in 28knts on a 132flx" This statement is not false and anyone that owns a 13 rev would know that the top end on these kites is very good and that 28knts is probably a truthful absolute top end range.

Now I dont want to encourage any learners to attempt this on the 13 rev unless they weigh over 100kgs, but that statement isnt False.

At this wind speed, the kite will be fully depowered and controlled by edging it to the edge of the window.

I'm not trying to encourage anyone to ride a big kite in these winds.

FYI: Best advertisde their nemisis hp 12m windrange as 10-28knts on their website. Dont you think that a noob buying this kite will expect it to be good in 28knts?




I own 4 Rev’s 7,9,11 & 13 and at a true 28 knots my 9 is starting to get a hand full let alone a 13? I’ve ridden the 9 up to 30 – 35 but it was crap you’re so depowered the thing fly’s poorly and is slow to turn.

I don't really care what Best say?

So I guess we will have to agree to disagree on the wind range of the 13?
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply