The proliferation of Lies

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
20 Dec 2008 12:56am
Hi Peeps,

Every day I receive at least one call from someone who has been fed the following two misinformations.

Lie 1. 5th Line kites should be avoided because they will tear in half when luffed or rolled in surf. Just how many people have had kites "Torn in half" by their 5th line? 5th line kites have the best safety system of all kites.

Lie 2. Trainer foils are a waste of time and money. You are better to put your money into full sized gear. How many people actually believe this? Better yet, how many people who have owned trainer foils actually believe they were a waste of money and that they were not of great fun and value?

How many people believe this stuff and who told you? A shop? An instructor? A friend? Or did you just read it somewhere?

Curious.....

Good winds,


Morg
Morg
QLD
129 posts
QLD, 129 posts
20 Dec 2008 9:46am
Usually said by people that have experienced neither and are to pig headed to think outside their own opinion.

My trainer foil / buggy kite still gets pulled out a bit, especially if its going 30+ knots its great fun.
stabber
stabber
NSW
1114 posts
NSW, 1114 posts
20 Dec 2008 11:43am
self peddling bullsp!t artists do this all the time....can we actually name and shame?
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
20 Dec 2008 10:55am
Kitehard said...

Better yet, how many people who have owned trainer foils actually believe they were a waste of money and that they were not of great fun and value?


I got my trainer kite two years after starting kiting. I love it. Great fun for low wind hanging out on the beach. Can also be a good icebreaker with the ladies. "Sure, I've got a trainer kite, how about I show you how to fly it?"

Everyone should get trainer kites.
theDoctor
theDoctor
NSW
5786 posts
NSW, 5786 posts
20 Dec 2008 11:57am
sounds to me like maybe someone is a little overstocked with 5-line and trainer foil kites...

waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
20 Dec 2008 10:26am
Having an extra flying line (5th line) just to support the mid-section of the leading edge.....
is superflous when a 4 line bridle will do the same job much better.
coreyb
coreyb
WA
463 posts
WA, 463 posts
20 Dec 2008 11:21am
Id say 5th line does a better job than bridles. More bridles, more lines to tangle, pulleys to wear.5th line simple, easy. Mine has never wrapped around the kite and mine get flipped in the surf more than your ave joe who spends his time cruising.
NJPornstar
NJPornstar
WA
790 posts
WA, 790 posts
20 Dec 2008 2:18pm
5 line kites are very good. Actually they are better kites for a number of reasons I could not be bothered rattling off.
I dont bother making bridle kites cause they arent as versatile as a 5 line control system

Hey kitehard you are a changed man, I remember 2 or 3 years ago you were anti 5 lines like the rest of the gumbies around.
Unchained
Unchained
WA
193 posts
WA, 193 posts
20 Dec 2008 2:39pm
somehow i still manage to tie my kite up every now and then riding with saftey on 5th..
seems to be fine on suicide tho...
Interesting
WA Surf
WA Surf
WA
336 posts
WA, 336 posts
20 Dec 2008 2:41pm
I used to be anti 5-line kites, until I actually started trying them. I am now pro-5 line, I definately prefer it.

The word on the street is "From an engineering point of view, having a line straight to the centre of the kite creates a much better and consistent curve in the leading edge that cannot be achieved quite as well with a bridle system. This allows the designers to therefore focus more design on the actualy shape and dynamics of the kite, without worrying about the leading edge"

or something like that
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
20 Dec 2008 4:57pm
NJPornstar said...

5 line kites are very good. Actually they are better kites for a number of reasons I could not be bothered rattling off.
I dont bother making bridle kites cause they arent as versatile as a 5 line control system

Hey kitehard you are a changed man, I remember 2 or 3 years ago you were anti 5 lines like the rest of the gumbies around.


Hey Nate,

Yup! Seen too many SLE bridles catch around wingtips resulting in never ending death loops. I think that all the kites have their place, SLE, Flat 5, Hybrid etc, just depends on the characteristics you are looking for I guess. They all have pro's and cons. 5 Line ain't perfect either, but definately a better safety system in terms of self landing to begin with.

I just get tired of hearing, "Oh the guy I spoke to on the phone told me that 5 line kites cut themselves in half and therefor should be avoided." [}:)]

Good winds,

iandvnt
iandvnt
QLD
581 posts
QLD, 581 posts
20 Dec 2008 7:44pm
yeah 5th line really is good - like having someone up in the sky able to grab the leading edge when needed. easy relaunch. even if it fails/breaks (which i have never head of- maybe once due to wear...) - it does not matter- you can still ride!

essentially it is a very simple solution to a problem so many other kites try to overcome with a multitude of pullies and bridles but this unfortunately introduces new problems into the game if these components fail of tangle somehow.
TurtleHunter
TurtleHunter
WA
1675 posts
WA, 1675 posts
20 Dec 2008 6:56pm
I've got a 2 line wipika classic that would be perfect for learner. No problems with tangles there.
Simple and fast setup allows for steeper learning curve.
mattyjee
mattyjee
WA
575 posts
WA, 575 posts
20 Dec 2008 11:11pm
I've never said that trainer foils are a "waste of time and money" but i do tell people that you dont need one.

In fact I agree with Pat that I want to buy one now for playing around with and letting my friends have a play with it.
Glennno
Glennno
QLD
124 posts
QLD, 124 posts
21 Dec 2008 7:54am
I own both - a sle boxer and ozone instinct sport. They are both great kites but I can't say I've ever had any problems with bridles tangling up and death loops - I've had more problems with the 5 line especially when self launching sometimes the anti invert line gets tangled up with the 5th line attachment point which gives you a very powered up kite.

I'm sold on 4 lines and thankfully ozone is going to 4 line set-ups in 09. The 20 meter/4line boxer set-up is simpler and quicker to set up than the ozone. Sure I've broken a few bridles - more operator error not keeping a good eye on things but you live and learn. As for depower the sle boxer sh@ts on the ozone.
chadster
chadster
QLD
136 posts
QLD, 136 posts
21 Dec 2008 8:40am
Oh well here you go they can read it again

5 th line kites may be ok in flat water but if you ride waves the 4 line set up is so much better

I have several sessions where my kite ( 4 line sle bridle ) has been rolled through itself and even tho the lines are crossed the kite relaunches and flys fine so you can finish your session

If I had been on a 5th line your session is over and you are swimming in -

In big surf this is the difference of getting you and your gear smashed


So in Summary - In waves 4 lines are so superior -

Sorry Kitehard but this no lie. This be fact bro

chad
NSW, 4382 posts
21 Dec 2008 10:21am
What about all the lies about bridles tangling on bow/sle kites?

Read Chadsters post, and;

Unhooked the 5th line system is as good as a high depower bow/sle, and relaunch is usually just as easy.
Hooked in (80+% riders ride hooked in), the high depower bow/sle kites are much safer, because they have a simple ONE stage primary safety system - let go of the bar!

5th line, hooked in, you have to pop the chicken loop, and let go of the bar, letting go of the bar on a c kite to pop the chicken loop is where the trouble starts, people hesitate, and its a TWO stage primary safety system.

Relaunch after popping the chicken loop on a 5th line kite is not simple, but can be done with training and practice.

4 line bow/sle kites are simple and superior for the majority of kiters - full stop!

I have seen kites cut and badly dmaged by a 5th line wrap up, it can happen but its rare.

I have seen bridle kites get a tangle and loop, can happen but on a well maintained modern kite it is extremely rare.

Trainer kites, teach people kite flying skills, anyone who denies that is just plain crazy or has some weird agenda, often involving selling full set ups or their used kites to begginers!!

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
21 Dec 2008 8:47am
Trainer kites on public beaches are annoying insects....
and the flyers are inconsiderate pests.
Families who are trying to enjoy the beach are made to feel uneasy.....
when they are constantly getting buzzed by the stupid things.
Go fly your toy-kites in a cow paddock, you don't need to be flying them on a beach.
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
21 Dec 2008 10:59am
The first point is probably a lie although I have seen one fifth line kite ripped in two in Cairns by a 5th line. That said, one in the last couple of years does not prove its a problem.

As for the trainer, I do consider them a waste of time. The money for a trainer would be better spent on two extra lessons. The only purpose of a trainer is to help some people (who are slow or nervous learners) or for people to put their mates on a kite for the first time. Thats my opinion but I doubt I'm responsible for the phone call you get every day unless its me calling every day and I have a sleep phoning problem that hasn't been diagnosed.
TurtleHunter
TurtleHunter
WA
1675 posts
WA, 1675 posts
21 Dec 2008 9:06am
Drop any kite in front of a decent wave and it will be the end of your session. But flat kites can relaunch faster so they give a better chance of getting the kite out of the water before the next wave....Who cares any way summer is here and the swell has gone
hoskoau
hoskoau
NSW
100 posts
NSW, 100 posts
21 Dec 2008 11:08am
Saffer said...

As for the trainer, I do consider them a waste of time. The money for a trainer would be better spent on two extra lessons. The only purpose of a trainer is to help some people (who are slow or nervous learners) or for people to put their mates on a kite for the first time. Thats my opinion but I doubt I'm responsible for the phone call you get every day unless its me calling every day and I have a sleep phoning problem that hasn't been diagnosed.


I'd like to re-buff that with my own experience. I had a group lesson with two other guys. I had used a trainer kite for a fair amount of time, 1 of the guys had powerkited before and the third had never touched a kite before. Needless to say the person who had never touched a kite before struggled to even maintain the kite at 12 when he was asked to and wasted a large amounts of time simply because he had no kitemanship.

You can pick up a trainer kite for less then it costs to have a lesson and you can also hire them from places. To me it means you get the most out of your lessons because lets face it if you are struggling to just control the kite you can't focus on all the other aspects your being taught. That would mean you would need more lessons and that means your going to spend more money then if you had of just used a trainer kite.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
21 Dec 2008 9:19am


Here's a 5-liner that's fully fingered. ^^^
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
21 Dec 2008 11:21am
hoskoau said...

Saffer said...

As for the trainer, I do consider them a waste of time. The money for a trainer would be better spent on two extra lessons. The only purpose of a trainer is to help some people (who are slow or nervous learners) or for people to put their mates on a kite for the first time. Thats my opinion but I doubt I'm responsible for the phone call you get every day unless its me calling every day and I have a sleep phoning problem that hasn't been diagnosed.


I'd like to re-buff that with my own experience. I had a group lesson with two other guys. I had used a trainer kite for a fair amount of time, 1 of the guys had powerkited before and the third had never touched a kite before. Needless to say the person who had never touched a kite before struggled to even maintain the kite at 12 when he was asked to and wasted a large amounts of time simply because he had no kitemanship.

You can pick up a trainer kite for less then it costs to have a lesson and you can also hire them from places. To me it means you get the most out of your lessons because lets face it if you are struggling to just control the kite you can't focus on all the other aspects your being taught. That would mean you would need more lessons and that means your going to spend more money then if you had of just used a trainer kite.


Then its a matter of opinion, not a lie.
pinkee
pinkee
WA
27 posts
WA, 27 posts
21 Dec 2008 10:04am
my 2c, ive only been kiting for 9-10 months. so i would class myself in the full safety come sle taught generation.

1 - I never bought or used a trainer, had my standard one lesson and was up on a board after bout 3 hours of practicing on a beach. Needless to say, i did use a 2 line kite way back when iwas 4 ft tall tho and habits are never lost.

i have seen 2 5-liners been halved in my time, one from a wave and one from an invert. However from time to time I still pull out my trusty 5 liner fuel.

NSW, 4382 posts
21 Dec 2008 12:56pm
WA Surf said...

I used to be anti 5-line kites, until I actually started trying them. I am now pro-5 line, I definately prefer it.

The word on the street is "From an engineering point of view, having a line straight to the centre of the kite creates a much better and consistent curve in the leading edge that cannot be achieved quite as well with a bridle system. This allows the designers to therefore focus more design on the actualy shape and dynamics of the kite, without worrying about the leading edge"

or something like that


Sorry, but thats just not true, and would fall into one of the category of "lies and myths" of kiteboarding kites.
How many suspension bridges have you seen, with just one central support column, supporting a long arch?
How many suspension bridges have you seen with a bridle like network of columns and/or bridle like network of wires etc?

The main structural problem with C kites is that as the load on the tips increases the shape of the kite distorts and becomes more U shaped, giving less projected area and power, and other issues like poor steering response.

5th lines that are load bearing and that split and attach to several points on the leading edge are a pseudo bridle and are definitely being used to support the leading edge and are preventing shape distortion under load. The other benefit this type of 5th line usage gives is a greater ability to change AOA of the whole kite canopy, leading to much better power control and performance.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
21 Dec 2008 1:52pm
WA Surf said...


The word on the street is "From an engineering point of view, having a line straight to the centre of the kite creates a much better and consistent curve in the leading edge that cannot be achieved quite as well with a bridle system."


From another engineering point of view, being the point of view of an engineer, I'd have to agree with Steve. Sorry bud.

I like 5 line kites though. I have put mine in plenty of waves and never cut any of them in half.
cwamit
cwamit
WA
1194 posts
WA, 1194 posts
21 Dec 2008 1:25pm
i love my 5th line kites, come in when its windy, drop kite onto its side, start pulling in the 5th as i walk to same side of the kite and the kite casually settles directly downwind on its back.... no reliance on elegant 4 line depower systems that require all 4 lines to be functional, and sea weed free. no worries about pulleys jams either. or flagging a kite on one line and watching it as it does somersaults as its heading to its least resistance.

have had 4 times in 3 years of using a 5th line kite the 5th line wrap, 3 times i released and the line unwrapped and off i went again, the other time i rode my kite into shore with it wrapped... call me lucky i guess.

...

trainer kites are great fun to learn with , but yeah they don't really have any *relevance to actual kitesurfing kites* but they do help in basic steering control but its the power / steering ratio thats more important which can only be learnt on a modern depower kite.

*unless trainer kite is a 3 to 4 meter inflatable*

i can understand back in the c kite days only several years ago when lessons required to be unhooked until the student was in the water, so back then using a trainer kite was invaluable.. these days with the high depower kites and personal experience from several people i have taught most seem to have more trouble with the finesse of power/depower and steering combined as opposed to basic steering inputs learnt on trainer kites.

they are fun and probably do help a little, just not as justifiable as they used to be in my humble opinion.





Lovely
Lovely
QLD
248 posts
QLD, 248 posts
21 Dec 2008 2:55pm
From observation better riders use 5 line kites.
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
21 Dec 2008 4:16pm
Lovely said...

From observation better riders use 5 line kites.


Probably because c kites are the choice for professionals. It doesn't mean that riding a 5th line kite will make you a better rider though

WA Surf
WA Surf
WA
336 posts
WA, 336 posts
21 Dec 2008 3:20pm

"WA Surf said...


The word on the street is "From an engineering point of view, having a line straight to the centre of the kite creates a much better and consistent curve in the leading edge that cannot be achieved quite as well with a bridle system."


From another engineering point of view, being the point of view of an engineer, I'd have to agree with Steve. Sorry bud.

I like 5 line kites though. I have put mine in plenty of waves and never cut any of them in half. "


I shall stop spreading the myth that I was told then Didn't make that much sense to me, being a Mechanical Engineer in training, not a civil engineer. Kitepower your bridge analogy is wasted on me
Cezar
Cezar
VIC
270 posts
VIC, 270 posts
21 Dec 2008 6:35pm
cwamit said...

...

trainer kites are great fun to learn with , but yeah they don't really have any *relevance to actual kitesurfing kites* but they do help in basic steering control but its the power / steering ratio thats more important which can only be learnt on a modern depower kite.

*unless trainer kite is a 3 to 4 meter inflatable*

I dont know what sort of a trainer you have in mind, if 2 line crap with handles 1- 1.5 meters in size you are dead right as some others responding to this topic.
They dont have any relevance to actual kites and do very little to get you ready to start on a board and limit professional lessons ,as lets face it most people are reluctant to spend hundreds of $ just to learn the basics or they simply dont have the cash.
I belive some schools put you on that sort of trainer during first lesson,I was put on such kite for half of my 1st lessons and didnt like it at all.
It seemed to me just idiotic to have an instuctor (for $ 130 1.5 hrs.)standing by me and telling me how to fly the stupid insect
2nd half was spend on unpacking and setting up 9m kite, at the end I said to myself there must be a better way or it will take forever and I run out of money or the patience( no previous board or sail experience)
I did ask a few guys on the beach who would be the best to get something done, most said Alex was.
On his advice I got 2 m 4 line Ozone Samurai and 25 m lines on the 50 cm bar and such akite IMO IS NOT MUCH DIFFRENT than proper kite why would you need 3-4 meters and on top of that inflatable, the power from that little kite in 20 knts is awsome speed on the landboard is simply scary and I DO ASURRE you learn power /steering control very quickly unless you like your knees busted( had one- 8 weeks no sport ).Its perfect for body dragging and learning to go upwind why on earth you have to pay someone to do this with you its much more fun to do this on yourown on bit smaller kite without time constraints( read $$$). The schools have very important role to play but IMO its diffrent from teaching kite control,body dragging, going upwind etc.But I guess perhaps its only alex sanc way to teach you kiteboarding.
Or atleast it was about 2 years ago when I met him unfotunately it was brief encounter and only 2 month ago I was able to start proper kiteboarding due to something that starts with the letter R.
.


Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply