Video Editing Software

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
wassaby
wassaby
QLD
92 posts
QLD, 92 posts
18 Mar 2009 11:12am
Hey guys just wondering what software you guys use to edit your videos on.
superlizard
superlizard
VIC
702 posts
VIC, 702 posts
18 Mar 2009 12:16pm
Used Final Cut Pro (Mac only) - powerful but harder to use or learn how to use.

Used Sony's Vegas (Windows) - very intuitive and easy to learn and use. (Very happy with it)

there are many others...
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
18 Mar 2009 10:58am
Hi Wassaby,

For professional results; Adobe Premier Pro or Premier Pro 1.5

This software is not super user friendly unless you know what you are doing. Once you know the way it works, it's really sweet.

There are many easier and simpler programs to use depending on the desired outcome.

Good winds,

uvblue
uvblue
QLD
23 posts
QLD, 23 posts
18 Mar 2009 12:40pm
I'm using Adobe Creative Suite 4 which is a huge leap from its predecesors.
CS4 has Premiere Pro, AfterEffects, SoundBooth and other tools which do a great job for those slomo kiting moves.
Highly recommended!
Fooosh
Fooosh
WA
563 posts
WA, 563 posts
18 Mar 2009 11:51am
Where do you lie in terms of PRO output vs EASE of use?

Another issue is stability as Vid editors are complicated power hungry beasts and like to kill your computer.

I haven't found a decent, easy vid editor which allows output to DVD / AVI files (my needs) which doesn't cost several hundered dollars, until Power Director 7.

I've got a deluxe version for sale if you want it. Brand new in box! I needed the ultra version for blu ray (if you're not going blu ray then the deluxe has all the other features.) Doh!
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
18 Mar 2009 1:53pm
If you're on Mac, you have a choice of Final Cut Pro or Adobe Premier (and After Effects if you buy one of the suites) along with Final Cut Express if you're looking for a more budget orientated option. Mac seems to be the suite of choice for professionals but comes at a premium.

If you're on Windows, you are pretty much stuck Adobe Premier on the high end or something like Sony Vegas on the low end.

If you don't know what you are doing, I suggest you avoid Premier or Final Cut Pro and stick to the basics like Final Cut Express and Sony Vegas. Most of the premier packages are brilliant for professionals but about as easy to use as a 2 line c kite in 15 knot gusts if you don't know what you are doing and therefore not advisable for beginners.
lancekenny
lancekenny
SA
402 posts
SA, 402 posts
18 Mar 2009 2:53pm
agree with super lizard and saffer - final cut pro or express on a mac and sony vegas on windows...

another handy tool is quicktime pro - especially if you want to do some quick conversion of formats - very useful and a cheap option for trimming also!
au_rick
au_rick
WA
752 posts
WA, 752 posts
18 Mar 2009 3:23pm
Fooosh said...

Where do you lie in terms of PRO output vs EASE of use?

Another issue is stability as Vid editors are complicated power hungry beasts and like to kill your computer.

I haven't found a decent, easy vid editor which allows output to DVD / AVI files (my needs) which doesn't cost several hundered dollars, until Power Director 7.

I've got a deluxe version for sale if you want it. Brand new in box! I needed the ultra version for blu ray (if you're not going blu ray then the deluxe has all the other features.) Doh!



Pinnacle works well and costs around $100
Simple to use and stable, outputs in a variety of formats (including HD, BlueRay, etc..)
CS4 and all the others are more powerfull, but you need to weigh up the price vs. what you want out of it and how long it will take you to become proficient.
bolgo
bolgo
WA
912 posts
WA, 912 posts
18 Mar 2009 3:45pm
i've used pinnacle studio for a number of years- simple, intuitive and very good results
had adobe premier (some cut down version) bundled on my new lap top so given that a go - similar to studio fiel management probably better but also now use sd cards

biggest plus i have found recently is sd cards which allow pre editing and heaps easier management of footage as in files and can move them around, play individual file or ditch it if it isnt any good
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
18 Mar 2009 6:05pm
bolgo said...

i've used pinnacle studio for a number of years- simple, intuitive and very good results
had adobe premier (some cut down version) bundled on my new lap top so given that a go - similar to studio fiel management probably better but also now use sd cards

biggest plus i have found recently is sd cards which allow pre editing and heaps easier management of footage as in files and can move them around, play individual file or ditch it if it isnt any good


The cut down version of Premier is Adobe Premier Elements. I forgot Adobe recently released the lighter "Elements" version of Premier so it may be worth checking on. I haven't tried it so I can't comment on it, but judging by photoshop elements, it would probably give 90% of users everything they need.
ewan kite
ewan kite
VIC
928 posts
VIC, 928 posts
18 Mar 2009 6:17pm
i am using the pro trial of sony vegas which is super easy and great but it wont finalise the movies but this could be because it is a trial version. does anyone know if this is the case?

thanks
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
18 Mar 2009 6:17pm
It should do, you probably need to use the correct render settings. Did you check out the link I sent you on youtube?
hydra
hydra
SA
254 posts
SA, 254 posts
18 Mar 2009 6:47pm

id like to know what these guys use to edit their vids.





ewan kite
ewan kite
VIC
928 posts
VIC, 928 posts
18 Mar 2009 9:06pm
Saffer said...

It should do, you probably need to use the correct render settings. Did you check out the link I sent you on youtube?


yer idid that all the same as the vid said. i dunno wats wrong?
Fooosh
Fooosh
WA
563 posts
WA, 563 posts
18 Mar 2009 8:40pm
Another may also be what sort of support you get when things go pear shaped - Cyberlink (Power director) were pretty basic.

I tried Pinnacle years ago but there were some glitches and it killed my PC plus the support was bad so I never went back!

cnet.com has some good reviews of the suites around - not all favourable.
mjaygray
mjaygray
WA
125 posts
WA, 125 posts
18 Mar 2009 9:10pm


Windows Movie Maker ++++++++++

bolgo
bolgo
WA
912 posts
WA, 912 posts
18 Mar 2009 10:01pm
yes it is premier elements 4.0
can render to DVD, utube etc
all sorts of settings for hd PALetc
limited transitions and graphics but dont use them much as it is
seems the higher cost just gives more transitions, fancy efx but the basic edit, sound and outputs tape,dvd, mpeg,avi etc are there

runs ok on 4g ram p9500 processor and vista

cant see i need much more for amateur home vids, once i locate a couple of girls to star in my home porno flick might need to up grade thou

pinnacle studio wasnt perfect, but was running it on a older computer, would occasionally crash, but realistic for the money and results , rendering could be slow but it got there

would say my productions are only 5-20min and pretty simple a few chapters and minimal titles but import and edt music surround sound etc all available on both above
mathew
mathew
QLD
2174 posts
QLD, 2174 posts
19 Mar 2009 9:26am
I'm specifically looking for image stabilization features, say something like these guys produce: http://www.2d3.com/product/?v=5

I've look at Premier (CS3) but did find anything in it native - although there are some plugins available, but with some feedback, I'm not going to buy them...

Do any other packages offer stabilization capabilities?
uvblue
uvblue
QLD
23 posts
QLD, 23 posts
19 Mar 2009 2:33pm
Mathew, I use Adobe AfterEffect (both CS2, CS3 or CS4) for image stabilizing. It's one of the most powerful engines for it out there.

Hydra, that flic is another masterpiece by Andy Gordon (do a search in this forum). He's also using (or at least, used) Adobe products for his flics.
mathew
mathew
QLD
2174 posts
QLD, 2174 posts
19 Mar 2009 3:42pm
I should really re-read my own posts... that was terrible engrish...

uvblue said...

Mathew, I use Adobe AfterEffect (both CS2, CS3 or CS4) for image stabilizing. It's one of the most powerful engines for it out there.

Hydra, that flic is another masterpiece by Andy Gordon (do a search in this forum). He's also using (or at least, used) Adobe products for his flics.


I'll look into it - thanks.
AngryKoala
AngryKoala
NSW
42 posts
NSW, 42 posts
19 Mar 2009 7:11pm
Try Muvee.
www.muvee.com/products/muvee-reveal-encore-automatic-video-editor

Hands down best movie editor for non professionals (though lots of semi-pro's use it for weddings)

* pick the music
* pick the bits you don't want
* pick the bites you do want
* pick the style of editing
* HIT GO

Just don't tell your friends how you made it.

Produces amazingly professional video's without the huge amount of time it normally takes to edit a video.

Grant
KitingCasey
KitingCasey
QLD
242 posts
QLD, 242 posts
19 Mar 2009 6:54pm
Whats the most user friendly???
And most resonably priced???
YoMoFo
YoMoFo
NSW
240 posts
NSW, 240 posts
19 Mar 2009 8:11pm
I did the imovie seminar thing at the apple store in syd the other week.
Must admit I was very impressed. A big step down from premiere pro 2
(What I normally use) but imovie had some cool features (like the stability bit) for your average punter.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply