Windsurfer or kitsurfer rights of way.

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
westhammer
westhammer
WA
507 posts
WA, 507 posts
28 Oct 2008 11:47pm
Can some one tell me what the give way written rules are between the windsurfer and the kitesurfer inany brake where the two meet..seems to be no fkn rules at this learn as we go stage of the sport,that is kite ,and should be restricted to R and only soled under licence.So who decides the rules,or is it some sort of union?That rules.
Flux
Flux
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
28 Oct 2008 11:53pm
There are rules mate, it's just that the sport is growing rapidly and people just don't know them, which is just getting better educated I suppose.
There is no real difference between kite and sail as far as right of way goes they both occupy the same water best you do a search this topic has come up heaps on here, not that it is'nt a good one but a wealth of info in your internet connection mate just search around a bit.
Start here www.seabreeze.com.au/Articles/Kitesurfing/Right-of-Way-Rules_903070.aspx
Hope this helps
westhammer
westhammer
WA
507 posts
WA, 507 posts
29 Oct 2008 12:35am
Looks like i am stirring it up ; but i tell ya eventually there will be a do or die rule put in place...there has to be for everyones sake and thats it.peace to the eye
lostinlondon
lostinlondon
VIC
1159 posts
VIC, 1159 posts
29 Oct 2008 3:07am
The existing right of way rules for sailing that have been modified for kite work well but it's just not a big topic in the lessons you receive for kiteboarding.

I remember doing my NZYF lessons and there was a whole lots of time devoted to rules of the road, with a test at the end. But that's just not going to happen out there with kiters.

phrase
phrase
WA
228 posts
WA, 228 posts
29 Oct 2008 3:56am
Do what I do, jump over them. But yes there are rules. Marine rules like if you meeting head on you should pass to the right side,,,,, traffic going out to sea has rightr of way etc. But I don`t take it for granted that the next person (kiter or windsurfer) know the rules so I make sure I just get out of their way, it`s no big deal to me. I`m out there to have fun and if it starts to get a crowded I move a bit to find my own space. Besides, all the poleys do is go in a straight line up and down up and down (yawn), let them get on with it.
user
user
WA
1140 posts
WA, 1140 posts
29 Oct 2008 5:50am
westhammer said...

Can some one tell me what the give way written rules are between the windsurfer and the kitesurfer inany brake where the two meet..seems to be no fkn rules at this learn as we go stage of the sport,that is kite ,and should be restricted to R and only soled under licence.So who decides the rules,or is it some sort of union?That rules.


Juz sthay awaa frm enny winsurfers !
Mr float
Mr float
NSW
3452 posts
NSW, 3452 posts
29 Oct 2008 10:10am
move to Newcastle .Never enough wind for poles and on the odd occasion when there is there are plenty of other places to ride where there aren't any .

swoosh
swoosh
QLD
1929 posts
QLD, 1929 posts
29 Oct 2008 9:30am
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racing_Rules_of_Sailing

Basically if you aren't in the surf you have right of way if you are kiting on a starboard tack. But as always use a liberal dose of common sense.


ianmac
ianmac
WA
267 posts
WA, 267 posts
29 Oct 2008 8:47am
i dont come across any real issues with the local crew ( at the moment) they do a lot longer runs than kites do so its not too much of a deal to keep the space between us. i also give the ocassional wave "G'day" it goes a long way in keeping a happy environment. common sense does prevail in right of way as there is not generally enough known about right of way
the gaz
the gaz
WA
173 posts
WA, 173 posts
29 Oct 2008 8:57am
Have to agree with User, just stay out of their way.

My experience is you have to get out of their way or they'll run into you. I'm not sure if they have trouble seing kites or choose not to.

Probably a jealousy thing, they spend years just learning to turn aorund without falling off.
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
29 Oct 2008 9:21am
From a poleys perspective:

Kiters take up lots more room than we do. If I'm on a collision course with a kiter, I'll try to go upwind because that means less 'swerve' for both of us. If the kiter is hell bent on going upwind of me then I'll go slightly downwind and we both pass with loads of room to spare.

Port and starboard rules only really apply on flat water, and even then they don't really apply to poleys and kiters... it's usually pretty clear who's going to go upwind of the other, and if it's not then one of us will make a sudden change of direction to indicate which way they want to go. This system seems to work quite well.

Right of way is something that beginners are often hung up on (I know I was!) but the more you go out in the surf, the more you understand how others behave and so can give everyone else lots of racing room. I honestly don't think much about it anymore, perhaps I've learned how to read other peoples body language on where they want to go.
The only time I have trouble is when people give way unnecessarily (like a newbie on a foil last weekend at scabs) or others who don't look before they gybe.
Dawn Patrol
Dawn Patrol
WA
1991 posts
WA, 1991 posts
29 Oct 2008 10:09am
Yeh just steer clear of them. And as Nebbian said it is easier for the windsurfer to go a little bit upwind, than have to go a long way down wind.

In the surf, I try to give way to anyone trying to get out. The breaking zone is a hard and annoying spot to be, especially when people are zipping all around. And a windsurfer who needs a bit more time to get some speed up, needs the room.
I hate nothing more than trying to get back out, and someone comes racing in and forces me to aim for the shore.
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
29 Oct 2008 10:29am
Hi Guys,

It's all very nice having rules of the road so long as everyone uses them .... or even knows them. This is a guide as to right of way for kiters.

kiteboardingschool.com.au/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=66&Itemid=53

It is only a guide. Best bet is to just show consideration when on the water to ALL water users. Surf rules are pretty much universal. Keep an eye out for learners or beginners, they are usually pretty obvious and are the only ones who really need special consideration. Don't go too close to them, expect them to do something totally erratic and unexpected. They are generally consumed with flying the kite and will have less idea as to what to do when you approach and will often panic doing something illogical out of fear and confusion.

With regard to kiters and windsurfers, as Kiters we are generally the more manoeuvreable craft and should find it easier to give way to sailboards if on collision course. Keep in mind sailboarders are terrified of lines and will generally prefer to go upwind of you, so let them have the upwind side of the passing. It generally creates a more harmonious environment for all of us to enjoy the wind and water.

It's pretty easy to make eye contact with the other rider and signal or gesture what your intentions are. Smile as you go past and treat others how you would like to be treated.

Rules of the road are easy if you apply common sense and courtesy.

Good winds,

effovski
effovski
WA
65 posts
WA, 65 posts
29 Oct 2008 10:45am
try gnaraloo early sept
was free for all
definitely poler v kiter rage going on for some

personally wasnt an issue, but a few from both camps getting very hot under the collar

drop in's, snaking, cursing and fist waving - nothing like relaxing in the wind and the waves!

a bit of commonsense and less greed and (almost) all would be happy,
but
it seems there are a few that are just hell bent on giving the opposite camp grief no matter what, like bald headed d#%khead at dutchies - rules aint going to change that

personally i'm not going to go somewhere else just coz there are polies around, especially g'loo, we are going to have to learn to co-exist, along with the growing numbers of kiters to contend with too

GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4108 posts
QLD, 4108 posts
29 Oct 2008 12:48pm
phrase said...

Do what I do, jump over them.


It wasn't quite jumping over them, but there I was one day at Pelican Point and had unconsciously tacked upwind into the path of the more downwind windsurfers. Just cruising along, keeping an eye out, and one of them had the hammer down right on my tail, catching up pretty effectively. By itself, he would have had to negotiate me as the overtaking craft, but there was another poley approaching on the opposite tack and somewhat downwind of my tack. Had old mate not been about to overtake me to my upwind I could have easily stayed upwind of oncoming poley, but I decided to avoid the situation entirely and absolutely reefed it skywards. One minute there was a multidimensional problem to consider, the next I was looking down from well above their masts and out of the equation altogether. I have to admit, as I spotted my landing and started my descent back to the water, I felt a bit of kite vs. poley pride for the fact that in that wind on that water no poley could ever jump that high.


kitecrazzzy
kitecrazzzy
WA
2184 posts
WA, 2184 posts
29 Oct 2008 12:00pm
rule 1. Avoid collisions
2. give way to some people and some people will give way to you
3. rule 2 is void if other vessel is riding a wave or stricken in its movement, given this circumstance give way and/or refer to rule 4
4. render assistance to any stricken vessel unless it shall place one's own self in danger.
5. use the search function before asking questions that will obviously have lengthy discussion

sailing rules don't help as although half of the kiters out there come from a background where they would be accustomed to them, the other half isn't.

Rule 6, don't trust noobs ie don't go down wind of them.
richswing
richswing
WA
724 posts
WA, 724 posts
29 Oct 2008 12:14pm
Hey Guys,

Who has right of way (kiter and or Poley) when for example you are on a wave and a kiter/poley has has turned to go back out to sea in a fairly flat water area and has time to judge the situation. I would say the person on the wave:

1. In less controlled position to change course
2. The stoke

Another question is if you are heading into shore from way out backline and a kiter comes up behind you slightly downwind and nearly cuts your lines in half, who has right of way.

The reason for both these questions is I think there is a guy at a local beach that has done both of these issues and I was wondering if I was wrong or he was.

Cheers
Rich
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4108 posts
QLD, 4108 posts
29 Oct 2008 1:27pm
Tailgating is definitely not cool.
wormy
wormy
QLD
679 posts
QLD, 679 posts
29 Oct 2008 1:32pm
As a poley I think the major source of confrontation is when a poley is trying to gybe up wind of a kiter, a lot of kiters don't realise how much of an arc is required to pull off a full planing gybe whereas the kiter will gybe on a dime, or the kiter is upwind of the poley and boosts and lands going the other way however whilst in the air he has floated downwind and lands in the poleys path,
Most of the time it all works out as all our guys give each other a bit of consideration, But everynow and then a fly by nighter will be hell bent on holding me upwind until I have to gybe then they wonder why I am heading straight for them.
RayQ
RayQ
WA
638 posts
WA, 638 posts
29 Oct 2008 1:06pm
Poleys and kiters can co-exist with no problems you can windsurf / kite real close to each other.
The thing is though, both have to be reasonably good at their sport.
Beginners dont mix with either and they always want to kite where the crowds are, like some one can help them if they stuff up.
stamp
stamp
QLD
2800 posts
QLD, 2800 posts
29 Oct 2008 2:23pm
richswing said...

Hey Guys,

Who has right of way (kiter and or Poley) when for example you are on a wave and a kiter/poley has has turned to go back out to sea in a fairly flat water area and has time to judge the situation. I would say the person on the wave:

1. In less controlled position to change course
2. The stoke

Another question is if you are heading into shore from way out backline and a kiter comes up behind you slightly downwind and nearly cuts your lines in half, who has right of way.

The reason for both these questions is I think there is a guy at a local beach that has done both of these issues and I was wondering if I was wrong or he was.

Cheers
Rich



whoever is riding down the line of a breaking wave has right of way.

i'm not sure what you mean by the other question; it sounds like you have picked a wave and are following it in waiting for it to break and the kiter has snaked you?

surfingboyo
surfingboyo
QLD
318 posts
QLD, 318 posts
29 Oct 2008 5:29pm
im sick of this... there should be a password on the kiting forums so no poleys can comment on our topic. Go on leave...
wormy
wormy
QLD
679 posts
QLD, 679 posts
29 Oct 2008 5:36pm
well thats a great attitude,
most people would agree that a bit of education on how each other operates would go a long way to prevent a collision.
user
user
WA
1140 posts
WA, 1140 posts
29 Oct 2008 5:40pm
wormy said...

well thats a great attitude,
most people would agree that a bit of education on how each other operates would go a long way to prevent a collision.



I think sufingboyo forgot to put a ""
Flux
Flux
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
29 Oct 2008 7:44pm
Why all the thumbs down on my post? anyway obviously others know better, common sense tells me if someone is coming toward me irrespective if it's a windsurfer or a kite you don't want a collision, so I either bear off downwind, edge harder up wind, turn or hold your kite high in the sky if it's a sail and the other rules, that we all should know some of you thumbs down characters should pull your heads in! We're all a like community trying to help each other or one would hope.
Best idea put that red thumb you like clicking on where you THINK the sun shines from.
dirtyharry
dirtyharry
WA
444 posts
WA, 444 posts
29 Oct 2008 8:07pm
I can't believe it, Greenpat heavily red-thumbed and Kitecrazzzy heavily green-thumbed AND talking sense. Must be the global financial crisis.
dism
dism
NSW
660 posts
NSW, 660 posts
29 Oct 2008 10:40pm
It doesn't matter who is coming at you

When your on a collision course, does it really matter if it is a kiter or a windsurfer?

It's still gunna freaking hurt if you don't know the rules and stuff up and hit eachother

Everyone can enjoy there own sport when they know everyone on the water (regardless of kite or sail) knows what they are doing (both with their skills and rules)

Pass on the rules to the new kiters and windsurfers, make it safe for all

On thing: An out of control windsurfer can be stopped within a few board lengths, whilst I gather that a kiter out of control and getting ragdolled will take up more space, so this needs to be taken into account.

Every craft has different handling, have a bit of an idea of how other craft handle, that way everyone has enough space to manouvre
Ioz
Ioz
WA
495 posts
Ioz Ioz
WA, 495 posts
29 Oct 2008 8:47pm
When I am on the same tack as a windsurfer, I like to make a nice, quick and obvious down wind turn 1 or 200m out - so they know early you are happy to pass down wind if them.

This has got to be the way as we can't expect them to enjoy having our lines pass so close to the top of the mast,

but hey if it is clear that I can go upwind of them easily I will do so.
dism
dism
NSW
660 posts
NSW, 660 posts
29 Oct 2008 10:52pm
Sounds like a good call to me Ioz

I'd be happy with that

I never like being downwind of something/someone I don't fully know (craft or individuals skill with craft), as dunno what will happen if they get into trouble

Nothing worse then someone capsizing onto you or equivalent
surfingboyo
surfingboyo
QLD
318 posts
QLD, 318 posts
29 Oct 2008 9:59pm
^^^ its board, not "craft"...^^^

Or are you talking about . i sure do not.
dism
dism
NSW
660 posts
NSW, 660 posts
29 Oct 2008 11:05pm
surfingboyo said...

^^^ its board, not "craft"...^^^



Craft = any water user on anything that isn't swimming

Craft = proper term for anything boat related

Windsurf board and Kiteboard both = Craft

Are you feeling happy?
Does it make you happy?
Are you f'ing happy?
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply