kite stuck in tree at melville accident

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Geeza
Geeza
WA
90 posts
WA, 90 posts
30 Nov 2004 9:30am
Yesterday I had my first bad kiteing experience, fortunately it left me with no injuries, but my shiny new kite has 3 or 4 tears in the canopy of varying sizes.

I am pretty new to the sport, but have become relatively confident with controlling the kite. I had launched and was just preparing myself to get going when the wind dropped and my kite luffed and fell into the water. At this stage haveeing just launched i was very close to the beach. I began going through the water relauch procedure.I was trying to move my kite to the river side of the window, but the current kept pushing my kite towards the beach, to the point where the kite was sitting just on the edge of the sand.

In hind site this is where my lack of experiece and eagerness to get out on the water,prevailed over comman sense and cuased the accident. With the wind being a SW I ran over to the the river side of the kite and tryed to lauch with my kite on the Road side. This began to work but at that point a gust hit and i got pulled further towards the road, end result my kite getting stuck in a tree. I pulled the QR and didnt injure myself in anyway, but my kite had wrapped itself around a branch, with the back line caught in another.

I would like to thank the guy, i didnt get his name, that ran down the beach and helped with some difficulty to get the kite out of the tree. I didnt get to thank him as i had to retreive my board. But he was a great help and it was much appreciated.

Now whats to learn from this accident, espeically for newbies to teh sport. Firstly it was my fault and it could have been avoided.At the point where the current had pushed my kite onto the beach i should have pulled the QR, just sorted out my lines and just relauned again. I know its a hassle but it would have saved my kite and my wallet. You should always lauch your kite from the water side so if you lose control you will be dragged into the water rather than onto land. Up to now i havent been doing this, as i dont like asking people to walk into the river but it is the safest way. Dont be too eager to get out there,make sure you edge on the side of caution in every situation, and take your time. And finally do not go out in wind your not comfortable in, especiallly in gusty conditions, before i launched yesterday, i thought twice about going out as the wind was quite gusty, but you live and learn.

Anyway thanks again to the guy thank helped me prize my kite out of the tree. And can my kite be repaired and how much will it cost? its got one large rip in the canopy about 30 cm long and few smaller ones. its an airush 10m.



ianyoung
ianyoung
WA
649 posts
WA, 649 posts
30 Nov 2004 10:20am
Thanks for sharing your lessons learned DRW - it's really important.

AKSA and WAKSA have long-term plans to introduce a system of incident reporting so that statistics can be analysed and strategies implemented to improve safety.

Dino the Kite Doctor 0417 915 868 or Neil Taylor @ Hold the Line Kites 9387 5676 can help you out getting your kite repaired.

The most important lesson you have learned is to assess your conditions with care and don't take unecessary risks.

The issue of launching on the water vs land side is not as straight forward as it might first appear. There have also been many accidents where kites have been launched on the water side and swung right across to the other side of power zone with even more dire consequences - Even though the situation was directly onshore, Mick Eastland launched with the kite to his right and died as his kite catapaulted him as it accelerated across the wind window to the left.

If you can't find anybody who is willing to get their feet wet to assist you launch further off the beach andother option to consider is to walk out 100m+ and let your kite drift downwind then water relaunch. If you've ever been to Point Danger, Torquay VIC then you'd see that's how they all launch every time there at high tide because they are in a wind shaddow inside the point.


Cheers,
Ian Young
www.flysurf.com.au
0414 716 812
Dean Gilkison
Dean Gilkison
WA
107 posts
WA, 107 posts
30 Nov 2004 10:28am
Yep it's good to see that you're on the right track with what you've got out of this incident.

if there is any doubt, it's always better imo to release to safety and live to kite another day... what's a few tangled lines compared to a broken neck.

keep on kiting tho mate... that sort of experience will pay off in the long run and will probably save you a more severe injury

Cheers
Deano
Captain Goodvibes
Captain Goodvibes
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
30 Nov 2004 12:48pm
Newbies and Melville - lucky Bay -

what a very bad place for learning

The Pig of Steel
flake
flake
WA
116 posts
WA, 116 posts
30 Nov 2004 12:57pm
don't worry about it I've crashed my kite into trees hundereds of times with no rips at all
PaulG
PaulG
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
30 Nov 2004 1:16pm
Dan

Sorry I couldn't get to you sooner. I watched it happen in slow motion. I dont think it will cost much to repair. The tears are easily patched.

Paul
CODY
CODY
WA
56 posts
WA, 56 posts
30 Nov 2004 3:50pm
Read this post with eyes wide open as i am green as kelp and want to lessen my chances of learning the hard way .
So if lucky bay is a bad place for newbies capt where is a good place..

STUART
Captain Goodvibes
Captain Goodvibes
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
30 Nov 2004 4:12pm
Our multitude of wonderfull wide open beaches is a great start

sand & dunes and normally not to many potential objects to hit

leighton, scarborough, trigg, pinaroo, woodies are all good IMO.

IMO the river is far more gusty and has no buffer zones when things go wrong ( a road or a stone retaining wall generaly surrounds the river)

anyone calling lucky Bay a good learning spot is kidding themselves and the newbies

The Pig of Steel
CODY
CODY
WA
56 posts
WA, 56 posts
30 Nov 2004 4:18pm
thanks capt

STUART
Geeza
Geeza
WA
90 posts
WA, 90 posts
30 Nov 2004 4:26pm
Ive taken my Kite up to Neil Taylor @ Hold the Line Kites and he thinks the damage want cost much.Thanks for the number Ian. Hopefully ill be back on the water by thursday, albeit a little safer and wiser.
PaulG I think i owe you a beer.
Rod
Rod
WA
102 posts
Rod Rod
WA, 102 posts
30 Nov 2004 5:01pm
My experience learning was that I didn't go in the ocean until I could confidently water relaunch in deep water. I think a newbie, well me at least, would find it a pretty daunting situation being a few hundred metres offshore and not being able to relaunch.

I learnt in the river where, despite the other dangers, I could hold my ground by standing up while learning water launches and just walk in when it all went to &^$%#.

But I was well aware of the river hazards and mitigated these by launching and landing with assistance from more experienced kiters, practiced using my quick release, wore a helmet and had a good level of fear to keep me from being reckless.

It was good to hear that DRW used his quick release before it was too late, a trashed kite is meaningless compared to you own safety.

CODY
CODY
WA
56 posts
WA, 56 posts
30 Nov 2004 5:10pm
while you were posting that comment rod i have been reading past threads on misshaps and locations. AND i got to say its confusing .
Sure it makes sence to get away fron the river side obstacles and away from pedestrian paths and the beach is a great spot for that .
But on the other hand knowing the conditions best to practise in and having the time when the winds arent that strong .
All i want to do is be proficient handling a kite , body drag and then get another lesson.


STUART
30 Nov 2004 5:35pm
yeah, let's send the new guys down the kn beach where they can drop there kn kites on other beach kn users

kn beauty!!!

tron
tron
WA
84 posts
WA, 84 posts
30 Nov 2004 7:53pm
when i learnt i went down to port kennedy (5klm south of saftey bay)and done a 5klm down winder no getting out and walking back,done that once and ready to go upwind,if you can get someone to drop you off and pick you up this will speed up you learning curve,it will be a bit choppy but its very safe for one and all
Rod
Rod
WA
102 posts
Rod Rod
WA, 102 posts
30 Nov 2004 11:07pm
Yeah sorry to create confusion Cody, every place has its good and bad points and it depends a lot on where your up to in your kiting progress. Also I haven't kited all spots around Perth myself so can't comment on all of them. But I learned at both Peli Point and the estuary at mandurah, after having several professional lessons. Peli was gusty and crowded but I felt comfortable knowing I could quick release and walk back in and water re launches were easy to learn being able to run round to the side of the kite.

Now I ride at Lucky bay, Leighton, Scarborough and Pinaroo. Of all spots I'd give Scarbs a miss for a while though the waves can really clean you up and in summer there's loads of people around who always seem to set up camp a metre from your kite just as your about to launch.

Despite the obvious dangers I still reckon Lucky Bay is as good a place as any to learn if you are cautious, it has a long body drag run and is stand up depth all the way along and a few hundred metres out. Just be careful with the launch and the shallow water, stay at least 30m from shore and dont' go out if its howling or overly gusty. I really like Ians idea of walking out with your kite on the water and water launching 100m out.

One really big help I had at the beginning was I spent a few weekends kiting with my brother, having a buddy to help out and share the learning is a huge help. I still kite with my mates most times and we keep on eye out for each other.

Safety is your primary concern, if in doubt don't go out and IMHO all newbies should wear a helmet. Of the last 4 fatalities I've heard about in the last year 3 were from head injuries and they were all very experienced kiters hit by gusts off the ocean. Don't let this put you off kiting its wicked fun, just be careful and take it slowly.
Captain Goodvibes
Captain Goodvibes
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
1 Dec 2004 8:58am
Keithy you Kn agressive man

the kn idea is to kn avoid people (even on the Beach)

if you kn look south toward kn city beach from scarborough theres kn

approx 3-4 ks of very uncrowded kn beach and generally on the

kn windier days there are not to many kn beach users

I kn agree if you cant kn relaunch your kite its a bit of a kn
problem

but hey even the kn top riders drop there kites and cant kn sometimes get em back up SO SWIM IN and start again

Tron has the kn Idea big long downwinders IMO is the KN way to go

if you are kn learning

kn oath



The Pig of Steel
1 Dec 2004 9:14am
Hey kn pig,

I am a not a kn aggressive man, I am a kn aggressive bear

Captain Goodvibes
Captain Goodvibes
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
1 Dec 2004 9:33am
A hairy Bear

or a

grizzly Bear

The Pig of Steel
Captain Goodvibes
Captain Goodvibes
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
1 Dec 2004 9:36am
Oh yea

I prefer Swine

a pig could be a fat human something swines find offensive



The Pig of Steel
Geeza
Geeza
WA
90 posts
WA, 90 posts
1 Dec 2004 9:42am
Hey cody

When your up on your board, ill be in for doing some downwinders, maybe city beach to trigg.

Give us a shout when you think your ready.
Poida
Poida
WA
1922 posts
WA, 1922 posts
1 Dec 2004 3:35pm
if you are getting sucked over the beach in a gust shouldnt you try to ride it out before releasing the kite on the unsuspecting public? ie for instance at brighton where the kite would possibly go through scarborough beach?
just something for discussion!>!>?!?!?
MikeN
MikeN
WA
368 posts
WA, 368 posts
1 Dec 2004 5:10pm
Captain Ding Dong you are a nob .

You are willing to send a beginer to the open beaches just so they won't get in your way at Lucky Bay ????

Stuart do not listen to anything that this nameless hero is suggesting .

IMO Lucky Bay is one of the best spots in Perth to learn . All you have to do is pick the right weather conditions and get a safe distance from the shore .
As DRW said in his post the weather was a bit iffy and he was in doubt as to go out or not .

The open beaches present a lot more problems to the newbie.
My view is do not go out at the exposed beaches until you are comfortable with your gear , can bodydrag back up wind and can relaunch your kite in deep water .

I am not an instructor and for some safe and unbaised advice contact any of the schools in Perth and I am sure they would be happy to suggest the safest spots to learn in .

Good luck
Captain Goodvibes
Captain Goodvibes
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
1 Dec 2004 10:26pm
WOA Miken strong words and big assumptions lets have a look at the

situation

Open beaches (as you call them) have no obsticles nothing to hit =

no injury

but remember kids (and those with no common sense) open beaches with lots of people on them are a big no no,

IMO the river has no buffer zone - just rocks roads trees and houses

surrounding it

Do you know of one person or ever herd of someone at lucky bay that walks more than the length of their kite lines so the person launching can do so from the beach without getting their feet wet?? -heres were the problem is and also with persons coming in to close to shore, not when they have body dragged 50 or so meters further out to where they can stand safely

I bet at least %50 of kiters started/learnt on the ocean



The Pig of Steel
HIZAKITE2005
HIZAKITE2005
QLD
41 posts
QLD, 41 posts
2 Dec 2004 10:51am
Over here on the Eestcoast we live with shifty unpredictable conditions that can cath you with your pants down. One golden rule we should all play by is "IF THERE IS ANY DOUBT (GUT FEELINGS) DONT GO OUT"

Those of us who aim high should do so fully overpowered!!!!!!!!!
dalestanton
dalestanton
WA
272 posts
WA, 272 posts
2 Dec 2004 10:37am
I agree with you Mike, the river is one of the safest places to learn once you are away from the shore, you can stand if you crash your kite, its a good spot to learn how to water launch your kite, there are always people around who will help you out if you get in strife and your bloody car wont get broken into!

The dangers that the open ocean poses to a beginner are enourmous, crowds, tides, waves, currents and undertow...There is not always anyone else close by to help. What happens to them if they can only tack one way and they end up stranded 500m out with their kite in the water...BIG PROBLEMS, at least in the river they can walk back to sure!

Kiters need to be able to handle their kite in flat water conditions before they should try the ocean.

Kiters and newcomers should not be put off by comments that the river is unsafe, I learned on the river and is my first port of call when I want to learn new moves.

Together with the assistance of WAKSA and local river users we can find a solution to manage the area to reduce unsafe practices.

See you down there.





FlyingWhiteBoy
FlyingWhiteBoy
WA
111 posts
WA, 111 posts
2 Dec 2004 11:16am
Sorry guys but I'm with the captain. The beach is perfect for a beginner IF the swell is not large and if it is not crowded. The river is a very dangerous place to learn compared to the ocean, way too many obstacles including passing cars, trees, houses, fences etc. If you spend enough time in light winds learning the basic kite skills you will be fine on the ocean. There is no way I would take a total beginner on the river, you need the open space to have a reasonable margin of error. When I first started out, I found the river to be an absolute nightmare, the kite ended up on the road, in two different trees, in a couple of different bushes and over a fence. This was all due to lack of experience and when I had learnt all the basic kite handling skills including relaunching in deep water (safely on an empty beach) I then came back to lucky bay and had no problems.

One spot on the river that looks much safer is point walter which has a very large sand bar almost like a mini beach!! I went down and had a look at it yesterday to find shallow water but gusty winds. What wind direction do people use at point walter?

White men can jump! (With the help of my 15.5m Titan.)
2 Dec 2004 12:53pm
Long time no kn posting White Boy -kn welcome back!
PaulG
PaulG
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
2 Dec 2004 2:16pm
Lucky Bay is a great spot and the majority of beginners have no problems.

Its a big shallow bay so simply walk out and stay away from the trees and road.

I haven't seen anyone have a problem with an assited launch off the beach. Accidents occur when people kite to close into shore so just be aware of the dangers in close and have a good time.

If you're new and not familiar with the spot just ask for some advise from the guys who are always there.

I aggree with Rod. Make sure you can deepwater relaunch before you head to the beach.

rez
rez
WA
354 posts
rez rez
WA, 354 posts
2 Dec 2004 3:50pm
I think it all comes down to where you are most comfortable.

Personally the river as a kiting location terrifies me because of all the obstacles along the waters edge and in the water (boat markers). I have kited there less than 8 times in the last 4 years.

I am an ocean person and feel safer kiting with heaps of space and water I can see through! When I was learning at the beach I did the swim in on a few occasions. My theory is if im drifting too far out and cant get my kite back up (wind dropping off at sunset was the usual mistake of jugement) then wrap up your gear and half float half swim in.

Before you kite alone you should have learn't how to relaunch in your kite lessons and have learn't how to wrap up your gear in the water so you can swim in if something goes wrong. If you havent, go get another lesson no matter where you are going to kite!

However, I really disagree that Scarbs (popular parts) is the place to learn if you are body dragging and trying to get on your board. The waves can be tricky and there is a current. Also there are lots of people on the beach and in the water. Once you are well and truely cruising and can deep water relaunch that would be the time to give the waves a go. There are other flatter beaches to go to.

I learnt at the beach Pinnaroo Pt. It has about 5kms of beach that is always empty downwind. Also it is a bay so you tend to wash in if you can't relaunch. The waves are rarely bigger than chest high and they break right on the shore.

The best thing to do if you are learning at the beach is to kite with someone else so there is someone there to help if its needed.
FlyingWhiteBoy
FlyingWhiteBoy
WA
111 posts
WA, 111 posts
2 Dec 2004 6:31pm
Yarr, to be sure Mr Bear, I havent been frequenting the kitesurfing scene until the last few days, been cuttin up dead dudes as a mad doctor in training since march. Been missing my time on the water, although I had a awesome session today down at leighton.

White men can jump! (With the help of my 15.5m Titan.)
CODY
CODY
WA
56 posts
WA, 56 posts
3 Dec 2004 9:34am
Its interesting to hear about different experiences from those who have learnt at the different spots .
All i can do is take my time , be safe .
Its just a matter of me assessing the winds and different spots to make sure i dont bite off more than i can chew ..a fault i have !
I can see how both river beginners and ocean beginners have valid points.

STUART
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply