Different bar with different kite

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Brohan
Brohan
VIC
528 posts
VIC, 528 posts
30 Jun 2014 5:34pm
Can I mix and match bars? Or do they have to be the specific brand to go with the kite?

I like my new Ozone bar and wanted to try using it on my Core xr3 as they are both 4 line kites I didn't think there'd be a problem... But maybe the safety would be less effective or something else?

Anyone else use a different bar on their kite?
jms
jms
NSW
131 posts
jms jms
NSW, 131 posts
30 Jun 2014 6:29pm
It depends!

If they are both 4 line kites, both use equal line lengths, both flag to safety in the same way (single front line for Ozone bars, no idea about Core), then go for it!

Also some bars/lines split the front lines higher or lower (high y or low y). If the kites are expecting one and get the other they may not fly so well...
Loftywinds
Loftywinds
QLD
2060 posts
QLD, 2060 posts
30 Jun 2014 7:01pm
I checked out the R3 control bar. It's a 4line bar with equal connecting lines to the core kite. Ozone is the same. You should be ok. Best to check with your local shop though. Having equal lines is not the issue. It's the type of safety systems each bar has. If the Y point is too close to the kite, and the other bar has a lower point, you could drastically alter the kite's performance, especially having the tips of the kite 'pulled in' too much. This could cause the kite to spin out of control. But if both bars have Y points closer to the bar, then it could work. Measure the distances between each bridle point and compare with distances on the core kite. If they are similar then it could work. If there is large differences, then it's not worth the risk.
Brohan
Brohan
VIC
528 posts
VIC, 528 posts
1 Jul 2014 9:34am
Thanks for the info, lucky I asked I didn't think the y would make a difference but I think the ozone bars y is closer to me then the cores. The safety systems both look the same. I'll measure them properly tonight.
Daniel1973
Daniel1973
VIC
226 posts
VIC, 226 posts
2 Jul 2014 9:03am
Cabrihna this year introduced the overdrive bar and said it is backwards compatible with all IDS equipt kites which means right back to 2009.

The point I make here is that the older cab kites have the V quite high and the new bar has it low. The old safety flags on 2 front lines and the new safety flags on 1 front line. So all in all you'd say "not compatible in theory". Cabrihna say "totally compatible".

I tried the new bar on the old kites and it works perfectly. The lower V changed the shape of the kite slightly but the feel was identical. I hit the eject to test the safety and the new bar drops out all residual power and flags quicker and is safer in my opinion.

Long storey short, try the bar on the kite while on the beach at the lower wind range of the kite, tell a mate or fellow kiter what your doing and get him to hold the back of your harness while you try it just in case. Try the eject, see how it flags and drops power and I rekon you won't look back!

Far too much bulls**t that kite companies give us regarding bar compatibility etc.... When if we all just used our physics brains we'd figure out that most equal 4 line bars will work with most kites set up for it! As long as we aren't stupid and we test safeties etc on the beach and are confident with that, we are fine!!!

PS- as mentioned earlier never test alone, even if it works perfectly first time a second set if eyes watching the kite flag out might pick up something that you don't!
Loftywinds
Loftywinds
QLD
2060 posts
QLD, 2060 posts
2 Jul 2014 1:01pm
Daniel1973 said...
Far too much bulls**t that kite companies give us regarding bar compatibility etc.... When if we all just used our physics brains we'd figure out that most equal 4 line bars will work with most kites set up for it! As long as we aren't stupid and we test safeties etc on the beach and are confident with that, we are fine!!!


Well said. I agree. I recently modified a Naish 5 line bar to work on my Cabrinha Switchblade (the old duck!) and it worked fine. I had to shorten the steering lines two knots, but overall it was fine. The reason I wanted to do this is to use the better safety aspects of the Naish bar, as I was not happy having one steering line as the depower line.

Common sense always prevails.

Brohan
Brohan
VIC
528 posts
VIC, 528 posts
2 Jul 2014 2:37pm
Daniel1973 said...
Cabrihna this year introduced the overdrive bar and said it is backwards compatible with all IDS equipt kites which means right back to 2009.

The point I make here is that the older cab kites have the V quite high and the new bar has it low. The old safety flags on 2 front lines and the new safety flags on 1 front line. So all in all you'd say "not compatible in theory". Cabrihna say "totally compatible".

I tried the new bar on the old kites and it works perfectly. The lower V changed the shape of the kite slightly but the feel was identical. I hit the eject to test the safety and the new bar drops out all residual power and flags quicker and is safer in my opinion.

Long storey short, try the bar on the kite while on the beach at the lower wind range of the kite, tell a mate or fellow kiter what your doing and get him to hold the back of your harness while you try it just in case. Try the eject, see how it flags and drops power and I rekon you won't look back!

Far too much bulls**t that kite companies give us regarding bar compatibility etc.... When if we all just used our physics brains we'd figure out that most equal 4 line bars will work with most kites set up for it! As long as we aren't stupid and we test safeties etc on the beach and are confident with that, we are fine!!!

PS- as mentioned earlier never test alone, even if it works perfectly first time a second set if eyes watching the kite flag out might pick up something that you don't!


Gonna try it in 10ish knots just gotta wait for the wind, the two bard look the same it's just the v is different on my ozone bar.
Daniel1973
Daniel1973
VIC
226 posts
VIC, 226 posts
5 Jul 2014 11:04am
Thanks for your input lofty, just goes to show how compatible bars are with kites! I've tried a few different bars on different brand kites just to prove to myself that equal 4 lines = well....equal 4 lines!

I had to prove it to myself because everyone I spoke to or every forum I saw said don't mix and match etc....

I agree with your old switchy flagging out on 1 steering line not being very good, I've got an old 12m switchy that now retired and not only agree but actually think the safety on them is actually dangerous and can when released (if in a bad situation) actually encourage the kite to start looping! It's almost like cabrihna didn't even test that old system prior to selling it!!! Thank f**k they got away from that old and horrible "safety".
Loftywinds
Loftywinds
QLD
2060 posts
QLD, 2060 posts
5 Jul 2014 2:52pm
Yeah but some centre line depower systems can be just as bad, if not worse, with the kite still pulling hard in a somewhat twisted or crumbled way. The worst situation I've seen is when the lines wrap around the tips and the kite is hovering upside down, like when you hold it walking the kite to the beach. Once it's like that, it's very difficult to recover and sometimes a self rescue has to be performed.

Here is an example of what can go wrong with 4 line depower systems, the most common...

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/Newbies-Tips-Tricks/4-line-kite-safety/

The best safety systems are on kites with 5th lines, attached to the centre of the kite, which acts like parking the kite when activated. Even the old Cabrinha left hand depower line along the left hand steerer, allows the kite to park, but it's more by chance than by deliberate design. It's a very hit and miss affair. It doesn't always do that.
Daniel1973
Daniel1973
VIC
226 posts
VIC, 226 posts
6 Jul 2014 9:20am
I read that link you sent loft,

There are some worrying stories when it comes to safety systems! I guess the long and the short of it it you just have to keep your wits about you and if it starts to get ugly just sacrifice the kite rather than trying to hang on to save the kite! Even if you eject and it's still holding power and still getting ugly so you eject from your leash the chances are the kite will find something to land against and might get a rip or whatever but a rip repair and a long walk or swim is heaps better option than plaster on a limb or worse!

You actually reminded me to check my harness to see if I had a line knife in it. And bugger me I haven't got one. It's one of those things that you never actually think of and if your going for the knife things have gone really pear shaped, but still should have one in the harness!
snalberski
snalberski
WA
858 posts
WA, 858 posts
6 Jul 2014 4:52pm
In relation to different Y height.... For my North Fuses and Evo I use a Switch Contoller 2 (with a low Y) instead of the North bar (with a high Y). I never notice any difference in the flying characteristics of the kites at all. The Switch bar is better in my opinion. The low Y is heaps better for self landing and it can be used universaly... single line flaggging, dual front line flagging, or dedicated 5th line. The build is also better.
Dl33ta
Dl33ta
TAS
463 posts
TAS, 463 posts
6 Jul 2014 7:21pm
snalberski said...
In relation to different Y height.... For my North Fuses and Evo I use a Switch Contoller 2 (with a low Y) instead of the North bar (with a high Y). I never notice any difference in the flying characteristics of the kites at all. The Switch bar is better in my opinion. The low Y is heaps better for self landing and it can be used universaly... single line flaggging, dual front line flagging, or dedicated 5th line. The build is also better.


Does controller 2 allow you to flag out without reaching up to the Y swivel now? Controller 1 was a bit of a death trap in that respect. They must have come a long, long, long, long way in their build techniques to warrant the build statement.
snalberski
snalberski
WA
858 posts
WA, 858 posts
6 Jul 2014 11:00pm
Dl33ta said...

snalberski said...
In relation to different Y height.... For my North Fuses and Evo I use a Switch Contoller 2 (with a low Y) instead of the North bar (with a high Y). I never notice any difference in the flying characteristics of the kites at all. The Switch bar is better in my opinion. The low Y is heaps better for self landing and it can be used universaly... single line flaggging, dual front line flagging, or dedicated 5th line. The build is also better.



Does controller 2 allow you to flag out without reaching up to the Y swivel now? Controller 1 was a bit of a death trap in that respect. They must have come a long, long, long, long way in their build techniques to warrant the build statement.


I haven't owned controller 1 but controller 2 doesn't have the 'flag it' at the swivel. It can also be set up with high Y if desired. Build wise I did read controller 1 had some issues but my comparisons are between the controller 2 and the 2013 North quad bar. The quad bar to me seemed over engineered - clip on reversible floats that never clip on or off (easily), self destructing plastic bar centre insert and lifting bar grip. The Switch bar has the same lines, smooth action polished metal bar centre, no lifting grip and a simpler more solid system for the bar ends/bar widthing. The only issue I did have with controller 2 was the original swivel was sticking which they replaced and alls good
general_dude
general_dude
WA
150 posts
WA, 150 posts
7 Jul 2014 9:12pm
Daniel1973 said...
Far too much bulls**t that kite companies give us regarding bar compatibility etc....

I totally agree. I have been mixing and matching for a long time now.
eg. I like the cabrinha bar and ozone kite. I don't like the ozone bar.

Flagging and safety need to be checked, but it is really only the 2 line flagging bars that should be a problem. How wrong can a single line flagging kite go? - It's gonna be messy anyway! (But if you're new or in doubt - check it out with a shop and do a light wind flat beach test). My experience is that the y-point position makes stuff all difference.

As an aside - I can't believe there isn't a manufacturer out there targeting just the control bar market. I would happily buy an excellent bar from a non-kite manufacturer.
All I want is:
Clean, above the bar trim, trim always reachable - cabrinha
Heaps of depower
Comfy, light, stainless insert, good swivel - like many
Easy single piece release - like ozone and many others.


And don't even get me started on the separate bar for each kite thing - what a monumental marketing have.



PenKite
PenKite
VIC
29 posts
VIC, 29 posts
11 Jul 2014 9:37am
Sorry guys, I just want to clarify a couple of things.
Firstly when we talk tech with kite designers and manufactures we call it a "hi or low V" in the front lines.

The hi or low V is not the issue when mixing bars & kites. The important thing to check is how the flag out system works, as some of you mentioned.
A two front line flag out system has a different bridle set up compared to a single front line flag out.

Please remember that, generally speaking, you can run a single front line flag out bar on either bridle set up but you can not run a two front line flag out bar on single front line flag out bridle.

Hope that helps clear up a few things....safe kiting
ActionSportsWA
ActionSportsWA
WA
1007 posts
WA, 1007 posts
11 Jul 2014 11:35am

Hi Brohan,

To answer your question succinctly, Yes, you can use your Ozone bar on your Core kites, but you cannot use a Core Bar on the Ozone kites.

Reason being that the Ozone kites us e a single front line flagging system which they need because they don't use pulleys to facilitate full flag out safety. Kites that have pulleys have a "virtual 5th" front line system which means a single front line from the bar up to the "Y". The Y is where thew safety flag out line attaches so when you engage the safety, the kite is given heaps of back line slack as the front lines are tensioned. In most situations, this will result in a complete dump of power.

The single front line flag system in my opinion is the safest of the 4 line setups. I still think 5th line is the ultimate in safety as the kite won't spiral on flag out. So by all means, use your Ozone bar on a Core, North, Cabrinha, F-One whatever .... But don't use your Core bar on any Ozone kite or any other brand that doesn't run bridled pulleys.

DM
CodeRed
CodeRed
NSW
58 posts
NSW, 58 posts
6 Aug 2014 12:53am
yep, you can.
Also, Ozone bars r way better than core bars IMO

Any 4line kite that uses equal line length bars will take any other bar of any other equal line length kite.

You only may have to swap over the pig tail ends as Ozone are dicks and use the opposite larks head\knot system to everyone else.

Just change or add them on your ozone kite and bar and then you're good to go with your whole kit.
ThomasU
ThomasU
WA
31 posts
WA, 31 posts
4 Jan 2015 9:22am
Just bringing this tread to life.
i have nobile kites 2012 9m + 12m that I fly with nobile bar 2013. I also have nobile T5 2014 with 2104 bar..
Yestarday I used 2013 bar with T5 and kite was super unstabl, nervous and overall uncomfortable to fly when changed back to 2014 it was all normal and good again. any idea why that might be I will try to test both bars back to back with bigger kites today.

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply