Brohan said...
...
Experience: Currently using an old strapless surfboard that's 6ft, can gybe that 50% - 60% of the time and can ride toe side okay ish (lose a lot of power when I do?).
...
You need to get much better at riding toe side, and you should really get better at gybing. Riding a surfboard is almost completely pointless if you're not rock solid on toe side. The whole point of a surfboard is to carve blisteringly fast turns onto waves and you can't do any of that if you can't ride really well on your toe side.
Gybing is arguably less important, especially if you're really good at toe side. For me gybing (and the foot swap) adds hugely to the fun and versatility of a surfboard.
As far as boards go, I am the same size and weight as you and I ride a 5'4" F-One Bamboo Fish. It rocks in light winds and small-medium surf. It is quite wide and flat so it can be a bit bouncy during transitions, especially with a little chop and poor technique.