Question??

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
jfletch
jfletch
SA
147 posts
SA, 147 posts
4 May 2007 7:29pm
why is it when your out riding in sweet clean waves with your mate and another random, that you still manage to get cut off, snaked and dropped in on.

learn the right of way rules if ya dont no em.
check it.
http://kitesurfingschool.org/rules.htm

cheers
airush geoff
airush geoff
974 posts
974 posts
7 May 2007 7:42am
Hey Josh - this seems to be a common problem, I don't think it's people ignoring the rules more ignorance of the rules. We are currently updating the rules on the saksa website and will start to promote them more and hopefully people will start to learn. Have to be honest, until last week I didn't know the right of way protocol. There is also a new rules discussion thread for any questions on the SAKSA website. Cheers
RussC
RussC
WA
69 posts
WA, 69 posts
7 May 2007 2:11pm
Josh,

Checked out the site and they are using the old windsurfing guidelines for waveriding.

There appears to be 2 schools of thought: windsurfing rules - Incoming kitesurfer to give way to outgoing kitesurfer and the surfing rules - the kitesurfer riding closest to the breaking part of the wave has right of way over all others

I reckon kitesurfing should be the same as surfing. Here's my take on it

1)(Incoming)Closest to the breaking part of the wave - who is upwind of the other rider has right of way over all others

2)(Outgoing) If you have just ridden a wave you should blast back out the back and not muck around in the surf zone - leave it clear for down the line riding

Needless to say, there is no absolute right of way - All parties should take any action necessary to avoid a collision.

Check out the WAKSA right of way rulesfor waveriding.
http://waksa.org.au.86.aspwebhosting.com.au/info.aspx

What do people think of the windsurfing versus surfing right of way rules?

Russ

RussC
RussC
WA
69 posts
WA, 69 posts
7 May 2007 2:14pm
Oops, just updated my profile to living is SA. Dont want people thinkin i'm one of them WA ****ers
dazza5172
dazza5172
SA
311 posts
SA, 311 posts
8 May 2007 2:19pm
quote:
Opposite tack rule: A wave sailor coming in (surfing the wave in) shall keep clear of a wave sailor heading out (jumping the wave).
Same tack rule (on the wave): All wave sailors shall keep clear of a wave sailor in front of or nearest to the peak of the wave (the breaking part of the wave).
All kitesurfers shall keep clear of all surfers (surfers are less manoeuvrable than kitesurfers).


I looked at these rules and I don't really agree with them. I admit having had a background in sailing I understand the sailing rules, however wavesailing / wave kiting I fully believe that surfing rules apply. Surfing rules are as RussC says, when you are on the wave nearest the critical section you have right of way, when you are finished surfing the wave you get clear of the surf zone and head out for another turn in.

With surfing on a kite naturally we have a greater area that can be covered, therefore there may be many critical sections on a wave, especially on shore, therefore 2 kitesurfers riding on one wave need to provide enough room for safety and abide by give way rules.

I disagree that if you are comming in surfing a wave you should have to give way to someone coming out, it breaches all the surfing rules.

He on the wave has right of way.

we have some general rules for our local crew just for fun which sets up different rules for wakestyle and wave comp.

www.southcentralkiteboarders.com/comp.html
airush geoff
airush geoff
974 posts
974 posts
9 May 2007 7:31am
Russ is looking into this at the moment- we are trying to get a feel for what is most appropriate here in S.A. and still keep with the general consensus. There is a rules discussion forum at www.saksa.com.au - check it out, and give us some feed back.
RussC
RussC
WA
69 posts
WA, 69 posts
9 May 2007 8:51am
Checked out the southcentral wave guidelines. I think you guys have got it right.

Here's some more on wave riding judging criteria. These criteria look to push the standard and boundaries of waveriding.

The objective is to reward progressive kite surfing and introduce a reward system based on demonstrating variety of repertoire and linking maneuvers together, still in the critical sections of the wave, in a seamless flow of power and speed.

1. A surfer must perform radical controlled maneuvers in the critical section of a wave with Speed, Power and Flow to maximize scoring potential.

2. Innovative / Progressive surfing as well as Variety of Repertoire ( maneuvers ),will be taken into consideration when rewarding points for waves ridden.

3. The surfer who executes this criteria with the maximum Degree of Difficulty and Commitment on the waves shall be rewarded with the higher scores.

4. All kite riding styles are to be scored equally no matter the wave riding style/ board style or kite style or line length used.

5. Unstrapped riding will be rewarded as requiring higher skill. Where 2 riders ( 1x strapped- 1x unstrapped) achieve the same score in a heat. The unstrapped rider will win. In the event of a strapped rider getting a higher score in heat than unstrapped rider the highest score will win.
sinbad
sinbad
SA
213 posts
SA, 213 posts
9 May 2007 3:11pm
Russ i will add them to the rules on the SAKSA site, if you want then they can carry on the discussion and get them formalized.
dazza5172
dazza5172
SA
311 posts
SA, 311 posts
9 May 2007 5:00pm
Thanks for the comments Russ

I suppose one of the aspects of this is the question

'what constitutes a wave'

does a 1 ft bit of slop mean you have right of way, if you were at Kent coming in on a 1 ft line which is feathering off shore and carving it up you would expect that the other kiters give you room to ride it, but would this apply to a messed up 1 ft onshore wave that hardly looks like a wave? or is a wave a wave? and thatis it

I think the latter

A wave is a wave and you are on it

the only exception is always giving way to other water users


JMO
RussC
RussC
WA
69 posts
WA, 69 posts
9 May 2007 5:56pm
I agree, if guys are wave riding, no matter how bad it is, a wave is a wave.

It could get hard in bad surf. This is where common sense and understanding of the basic guidelines are important.
airush geoff
airush geoff
974 posts
974 posts
10 May 2007 7:13am
Do we need to look at different areas being treated differently- down south is definitely waves, but henley or semaphore I don't think are. You need to have somewhere for everything.
dazza5172
dazza5172
SA
311 posts
SA, 311 posts
10 May 2007 2:00pm
I think you are correct Geoff, it would be a bit much to expect a give way when someone is riding a 1 ft wavelet at Semi, I think a surf definition of a wave should prevail, The wave rules should prevail when in 'surf' as apposed to wind slop, it has to be a good line wave, but not necessarilly big, something you could ride a mal on surely regardless of how gutless the ride would be.

Like Seacliff, when the stormie puts up that swell line would require wave rules, but a normal sea breeze and just wavelets no way.

JMO

jfletch
jfletch
SA
147 posts
SA, 147 posts
13 May 2007 8:19pm
true the area of riding changes things, but no matter where u r there are some basics to follow.

such as:

not jibing in front of someone.

not dropping in down wind, and then pinching way upwind.

and not being a ****en spastic.

if your out riding in waves, i dare say you no what your doing so try and ride with a brain, in stead of a strapped on wide brim hat.
cheers
kangaroo
kangaroo
34 posts
34 posts
14 May 2007 4:36am
hello folks
have read for a while this forum from uk
sorry but im joing the ranks of adelaide in a few months time - hope your all friendly on and off the water...:)
if anyone uses hotmail messenger service i would love the opportunity to make contact with any fellow wind junkies on -

[email protected]

will my airrush 6ft 2 converse be a good board for use in the surf conditions you expereince down south ?
never used it in surf - rare here but im dandy ho on a nobile skim board in small onshore slop we frequently get
i will be living in seaview downs for first 7 months - i think this is central to aldingsand semaphore beaches ?

good to hear club formation and socials - i look forward to sharing your beaches and warm waters

martin

p.s. we always say the more rules you have the more grey areas you create
more **** more buckets syndrome
keep it simple - end of day no excuse for a collision exists other than broken equipment etc ?
airush geoff
airush geoff
974 posts
974 posts
14 May 2007 8:02am
I agree that rules create grey areas but they are not rules as such more some sort of guide for people to be educated by. Knowledge of how it all works will help people to know what to do in the different situations they find themselves in.
RussC
RussC
WA
69 posts
WA, 69 posts
14 May 2007 10:15pm
Kangaroo, airush 6 2 converse is a great board for the surf here and west oz. i have used one from 1 foot pus through to solid double head high + and love it
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply