Well that seems to have killed this discussion! Ok I'll throw a few comments out there. I am probably the newest member of ALSA as I have been told $5 from my membership to ALYC goes to ALSA.
However that said these comments are strictly as an outsider to the sport.
I have had some experience with other sporting organisations that have governing bodies like Confederation of Australian Motorsport and Yachting Australia Inc.
Just for comparison these are the objectives of Yachting Australia Inc:
1. To promote and administer the sport of yachting in all its branches
2. To serve as a national body for the advancement of yachting throughout the Commonwealth of Australia
3. To take such steps to affiliate with other international and national associations as may be required
4. To recognise as national classes such class of yachts which may from time to time comply with the requirements of the federation.Unfortunately for us, Yachting Australia has tens of thousands of members from clubs, many of which are multi-million dollar businesses.
But that said when I was sailing I didn't even know of their existence. All of my interaction with Sailing was done through the 2 clubs I was a member of. Now I'm not saying for a minute that they don't do a great and essential job, its just it wasn't in my face.
CAMS was, but then again that's a professional organisation administering a multi-million dollar industry.
I guess the bottom line of this is we should be able to expect out of ALSA what we put into it, and I'm afraid at $5.00 p/a that’s probably not going to be a whole lot.
So what should we recommend? Change the model to take over some of the roles of the clubs and increase the price of membership appropriately or leave this role with the clubs and just use ALSA as a register of sail numbers as repository of international land yachting rules.
Personally I'm not fussed either way, I just want to sail

BTW if I was administering ALSA, at my hourly rate this post has just burnt your membership fees for several years (I didn't realise it was so long until I read it back!!)

Well that's my $5.00 worth

, what are your thoughts, bearing in mind people from other sports are reading this and we don't want to scare them off.