Advice on similar yacht types

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
knight
knight
NSW
60 posts
NSW, 60 posts
28 Nov 2010 10:45am
Hi all,

I'm looking for some advice from the knowledge base that makes up this forum.

I'm looking at getting my first yacht and I've got my mind set on an Eastcoast 31. I want to ask the forum for some yachts similar to an Eastcoast so that i'm not overlooking other very good yachts.

Basically i'm looking for something that can do coastal sailing along with the normal club racing each week. I'm not looking to win each week, more just going for the fun of it. I eventually want to get into offshore passages, up and down the east coast and so on, and in a few years time maybe some of the offshore races.

She needs to be a good seakeeper in all weathers and ideally would have berths for 6 or 7, 30 feet long +. Probably $50000 to $60000 is the sort of figure i'm looking at.

I know thats alot to ask of one boat, and that anything that can fulfil all those requirements won't be very good at any of them, but thats life and i expect that.

And i know some people will probably think that aiming for those things on my list is a silly idea for a first yacht, or that i don't have enough experience. Don't worry I'm not about to go in the Sydney to Hobart a couple of days after getting my first yacht, I fully intend to start simple and work up those list of things, training myself and my crew as we go. (And myself and two others of my crew are currently serving Naval officers, trained in navigation, shiphanding, seamanship and survival at sea)

Thanks everyone for your help in advance.
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
28 Nov 2010 12:03pm
An Adams 31, centre or aft cockpit may be relevant for you. Also an S&S 34 could be had for around the price you are talking.

This one is very much worth your consideration. I see it has come down $10,000 in price. You will probably notice it is running out of space to attach racing plaques.

http://www.boatpoint.com.au/boats-for-sale/boatdetails.aspx?R=7481651

This particular boat was built in the UK around 1970 using I believe epoxy resins rather than polyester and was imported to Aus in the mould for the S&S 34s when Swarbrick bought the moulds from the then UK builders. It is quite a piece of Aus yachting history.

The Army had a few S&S 34s for a while too and their offshore capabilities are legendary as recently exampled by Jessica Watson.

A veritable gold mine of information on the Marque of yacht is available on the two sites below.

www.ss34.org/ www.topshare.com.au/cgi-bin/SnSForum/YaBB.pl

Happy Hunting.
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7758 posts
NSW, 7758 posts
28 Nov 2010 6:18pm

And i know some people will probably think that aiming for those things on my list is a silly idea for a first yacht, or that i don't have enough experience. Don't worry I'm not about to go in the Sydney to Hobart a couple of days after getting my first yacht, I fully intend to start simple and work up those list of things, training myself and my crew as we go. (And myself and two others of my crew are currently serving Naval officers, trained in navigation, shiphanding, seamanship and survival at sea)

Thanks everyone for your help in advance.


David,
If you go to page 3 of these forums you will see a thread for ex pussers. Buying a yacht is not something to rush into, especially these days when they are so cheap and tempting. I have always been a fan of the East Coast 31 and any Cole yachts as a matter of fact. Trouble is they are always over priced for some reason, several in the Sydney area have been for sale for years. 6 people is a bit of a crowd on a 30 footer, my yacht has 8 bunks in theory but more like 3 in practice. I agree with Cisco that an SS34 is more your size and would suggest you check out their forum. John McCormack is a regular there and is an ex Commander, naval officers seem to be regular owners of SS34's. He will talk your ear off on the subject and point you in the right direction. Like a lot of yachts the SS34's vary a lot in quality and equipment and models. UFO 34's are also top boats along with Carter 33's.
Best bet is to partake in some club racing as a crew and keep your ear to the ground, really good buys pop up.
Just be aware the costs increase markedly once you go above 30 foot.
SandS
SandS
VIC
5904 posts
VIC, 5904 posts
28 Nov 2010 9:07pm

have a look at the carter 30 , s&s defiance 30 and currawong 30 . all built to the 1/2 ton regs same as the eastcoast 31 was . there may be others as well.

regards and have fun
planesailing
planesailing
WA
380 posts
WA, 380 posts
28 Nov 2010 7:58pm
There is a reason Cole yachts are expensive, because they are GREAT and
desireable..."Peter Cole never designed a bad boat".
My opinion (for wat its worth) is get yourself a Carter 33 centre or aft cockpit.
I had one for 5 years raced and cruised really well. Good offshore and quick
around the track.
Poodle
Poodle
WA
868 posts
WA, 868 posts
29 Nov 2010 4:05pm
I'm selling a UFO34. Great racing & cruising record, very good reputation. Sleeps 7-8. Very good nick, very cheap - We have bought a larger vessel (Sydney 36), and we are keen to move the old one on as we don't want to be fleet owners. Don't start me on the old "sell your first boat before buying the second..." She is on a mooring in Perth, but given you are getting a 3/4 ton boat for 1/2 ton price, you can pay for an aweful lot of shipping!!

Check her out at: olfrygt-racing.blogspot.com/

best rgds,

Bryan
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7758 posts
NSW, 7758 posts
30 Nov 2010 8:22am
Poodle said...

I'm selling a UFO34. Great racing & cruising record, very good reputation. Sleeps 7-8. Very good nick, very cheap - We have bought a larger vessel (Sydney 36), and we are keen to move the old one on as we don't want to be fleet owners. Don't start me on the old "sell your first boat before buying the second..." She is on a mooring in Perth, but given you are getting a 3/4 ton boat for 1/2 ton price, you can pay for an aweful lot of shipping!!

Check her out at: olfrygt-racing.blogspot.com/

best rgds,

Bryan


Lovely yacht Bryan. I used the picture off your web page on my desktop for sometime last year when I was tempted by all the UFO's on the market in Perth. I was heading back there at the time anyway for a navy reunion but had a nasty case of shingles. Then a Currawong 30 appeared at a price I could not refuse in Sydney and the rest is history. Sydney yachts used to be in Nowra, they were the largest yacht building company in the southern hemisphere, most were exported. Bit depressing seeing this enormous complex idle. Probably in China now!
Poodle
Poodle
WA
868 posts
WA, 868 posts
30 Nov 2010 9:53am
Seeing as you like the piccies, there's also a bunch of photos of her at this other website:

groups.google.com/forum/?hl=en#!forum/olfrygt

All the best!

Bryan
knight
knight
NSW
60 posts
NSW, 60 posts
2 Dec 2010 6:45pm
Thankyou to all for your advice.

@Cisco: Thanks for the suggestions, although the S&S you had the link to only has 3 berths, beautiful boat however. I will however keep those two in mind when i eventually make a choice.

@Ramona: I'm well aware buying a yacht isn't something to rush into, this is just the initial investigation. I'm expecting to buy the yacht in about 8 months. And i would have popped into the navy thread, but the software told me "This thread is too old for replies"

@Plainsailing: On the Carter 33, whats the difference between a Carter 33 and a Carter Passage 33? Is one the centre cockpit and the other the aft cockpit?

@Bryan: She is a lovely yacht, but unfortunatly as i said, i'm still 6-8 months away from buying my yacht. If she's available when the time comes I'll seriously consider it. (However for your sake I hope its well and truly sold)
planesailing
planesailing
WA
380 posts
WA, 380 posts
2 Dec 2010 4:51pm
passage is the centre cockpit yes. both have same hull, rather fat in the middle and plenty of tumblehome.
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
2 Dec 2010 11:35pm
knight said...
@Cisco: Thanks for the suggestions, although the S&S you had the link to only has 3 berths, beautiful boat however. I will however keep those two in mind when i eventually make a choice.


It actually has 7 or 8 berths!!

knight
knight
NSW
60 posts
NSW, 60 posts
3 Dec 2010 9:15am
cisco said...

knight said...
@Cisco: Thanks for the suggestions, although the S&S you had the link to only has 3 berths, beautiful boat however. I will however keep those two in mind when i eventually make a choice.


It actually has 7 or 8 berths!!


Thats what I thought, but on the S&S association site, they have a PDF file of the yacht for sale ("Western Morning"). Included in the file is:


Set up with three permanent sea berths – 3 extra pipe berths for use in harbour


From the look of the photos, the V berth has been removed and the area is used for storage only.
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
3 Dec 2010 1:04pm
Yes. I have read the pdf brochure but it was a while ago. I have a sister ship to Western Morning and I suppose I am referring to my set up.

If one of these boats is set up for serious regular racing, the fore peak probably needs to be sacrificed to sail stowage but at a pinch it could also have a pipe berth or two.

My port side quarter berth is currently a single because of some fairly useless lockers fitted onto the tumblehome. They will be coming out to create a reasonably generous double berth.

Also the Vee in my Vee-Berth will be filled in to create similar in the fore peak.

My intention is for a fast cruising yacht for two couples accomodated in double berths at opposite ends of the yacht and the saloon settees not often used as berths.

However with retractable pipe berths in the saloon it is possible berth eight people in one of these boats. Whether it would be liveable with farting and other odours is a different question.

This marque of yacht has a generous stbd side cockpit locker which can store several sails. If an inflateable dinghy is to be carried there is adequate room for it under the port quarter berth.

For such a small yacht they have a remarkable amount of space below.
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7758 posts
NSW, 7758 posts
3 Dec 2010 8:06pm
cisco said...

However with retractable pipe berths in the saloon it is possible berth eight people in one of these boats. Whether it would be liveable with farting and other odours is a different question.


For such a small yacht they have a remarkable amount of space below.


The only trouble with SS34's is the lack of a door on the heads in a lot of them. Rampage for sale in WA recently is one of the best laid out SS34's I have seen and it has a door.

If you racing most of the crew would be sleeping in the saloon on the bunks and cabin sole, maybe the navigator on the quarter berth/nav station.
MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2712 posts
NSW, 2712 posts
15 Jan 2011 6:06pm
A bit late maybe but I just saw my name mentioned here. I am absolutely delighted with my S&S34 and would recommend one to anyone who wants to go sailing. However, they are not "cocktail" boats and there are much roomier boats for those who prefer social sailing in Broken Bay etc.
Cheers
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7758 posts
NSW, 7758 posts
15 Jan 2011 6:29pm
MorningBird said...

A bit late maybe but I just saw my name mentioned here. I am absolutely delighted with my S&S34 and would recommend one to anyone who wants to go sailing. However, they are not "cocktail" boats and there are much roomier boats for those who prefer social sailing in Broken Bay etc.
Cheers


G'day John, welcome to the forum.
GetaLife
GetaLife
79 posts
79 posts
16 Jan 2011 6:27pm
We have a Carter 33 Passage and could not ask for a better yacht.

Have owned South Coast 36 Ketch, Seaway 25, Challenger 39 motor sailer and Compass 29.

Sailed on S&S 30 Defiant, Northshore 33, Nauticat 38.

Value for money, the Carter leaves them dead in the water.

Good luck with your quest.

Dusty
azudo
azudo
QLD
34 posts
QLD, 34 posts
17 Jan 2011 3:05pm
I would strongly suggest you opt for the extra 3 or 4 foot
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply