Drogue lines

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Seamonkey_H2024
Seamonkey_H2024
VIC
344 posts
VIC, 344 posts
28 May 2014 4:09pm
What size line should I buy for my seabrake drogue on my clansman?

I'm thinking... ropegalore.com.au/silver-p-e-ropes/

16mm = 2120 Kilo average break load. Suffice?!

LooseChange
LooseChange
NSW
2140 posts
NSW, 2140 posts
28 May 2014 5:16pm
16mm should be more than enough, as the rope is never going to be bar taut it should never get within a bulls roar of its breaking load.
Seamonkey_H2024
Seamonkey_H2024
VIC
344 posts
VIC, 344 posts
28 May 2014 5:44pm
If I wanted to add length to my existing line or deploy two anchors, would 16mm (2120kg) be strong enough for an anchor line?

4.5T displacement btw
Seamonkey_H2024
Seamonkey_H2024
VIC
344 posts
VIC, 344 posts
28 May 2014 5:57pm
After some googling and procrastination at work...

http://anchormarine.com.au/index.php/page/allaboutanchors

Therefore I will purchase either...
-100m of 16mm Nylon for $300 or
-125m of 20mm silver p/e for $255

Silver p/e sounds good to my inner tightarse. Who prefers which?
MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2711 posts
NSW, 2711 posts
28 May 2014 6:39pm
I had silver rope on MB as an anchor rode when I bought it. It floats, wraps around your keel and gets in the way of other boats. It is strong enough but not suitable for an anchor rode so if you intend using it for your secondary anchor get nylon.
I also suggest 16mm is too big for a Clansman. I have 70 metres of 16mm rode for my drogue but that is because I got it for nix. I use 12mm nylon as an anchor rode on MB and could go up to 14mm but I'm not anchoring in cyclonic conditions so am happy with 12mm. I have anchored in gusting to 45kts and I could still pull the boat on the anchor rode by hand (just). I reckon 12mm is more than adequate for a Clansman. And it suits a tightarse like both of us.
keensailor
keensailor
NSW
702 posts
NSW, 702 posts
28 May 2014 8:12pm
SirJman said..

What size line should I buy for my seabrake drogue on my clansman?

I'm thinking... ropegalore.com.au/silver-p-e-ropes/

16mm = 2120 Kilo average break load. Suffice?!



So just for my own interest, when would you be using your seabrake?

I read they are good in huge seas and gales to slow your boat down and stop it from plummeting into the troughs of waves.

Are you planning some long passages. Wondering whether we should have one ;)
MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2711 posts
NSW, 2711 posts
28 May 2014 8:24pm
Keensailor, I have a drogue to slow the boat in extreme conditions when I would need to run before the wind. I would also use it crossing a bar if I thought there was a chance of catching a wave. I may never need it, it is insurance for a boat that goes too far offshore to run for cover when bad weather arrives.
BORNFREEE
BORNFREEE
72 posts
72 posts
28 May 2014 6:28pm
I have always carried 100m of 14mm nylon on my smaller yachts and since it is near new will use it on my 35ft Martzcraft .
I would not go out to sea with out it as Morning Clould said nylon is the way to go mainly for its stretch ability.
While on the subject i also carry a forged galvinised tested swivel so that if need be i can make up a sea anchor out of a sail . Now all i need to do is find somewhere strong enough on the boat to tie it to
Fiesta
Fiesta
QLD
122 posts
QLD, 122 posts
28 May 2014 9:00pm
BORNFREEE said..

I have always carried 100m of 14mm nylon on my smaller yachts and since it is near new will use it on my 35ft Martzcraft .
I would not go out to sea with out it as Morning Clould said nylon is the way to go mainly for its stretch ability.
While on the subject i also carry a forged galvinised tested swivel so that if need be i can make up a sea anchor out of a sail . Now all i need to do is find somewhere strong enough on the boat to tie it to


- Ian Kiernan mentions in his book that he made up a Bridle to go over the stern to attach the drogue to. Loops on each end of the bridle which drop over the primary winches in the cockpit. Apparently this allowed Maris to sort of hinge around the winch attachment point and allow the stern to lift to the waves. Makes sense to me.


Seamonkey_H2024
Seamonkey_H2024
VIC
344 posts
VIC, 344 posts
28 May 2014 9:24pm
keensailor said..

So just for my own interest, when would you be using your seabrake?

I read they are good in huge seas and gales to slow your boat down and stop it from plummeting into the troughs of waves.

Are you planning some long passages. Wondering whether we should have one ;)


The seabrake drogue can be used to...
-Slow way in rough seas (big waves)
-Aid for running downwind/prevents broaching.
-Emergency steering
-Reducing rock while at anchor if deployed vertically abeam
-Aid for vessel under tow
-Bosuns chair

I'm planning a Tasmania trip after Winter, so I'm trying to be prepared as possible.


MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2711 posts
NSW, 2711 posts
28 May 2014 9:43pm
You have it there SirJman.
nswsailor
nswsailor
NSW
1458 posts
NSW, 1458 posts
28 May 2014 10:50pm
Ok Gentlemen,

What I would like to know....

Is there anybody on this forum who has deployed a sea-brake/drogue in earnest and did it work?

Why did you use it?

What type did you use?
Seamonkey_H2024
Seamonkey_H2024
VIC
344 posts
VIC, 344 posts
28 May 2014 11:09pm
nswsailor said..

Ok Gentlemen,

What I would like to know....

Is there anybody on this forum who has deployed a sea-brake/drogue in earnest and did it work?

Why did you use it?

What type did you use?


In coast guard we use them for towing vessels with disabled steering. We also use them to practice emergency steering.

I have a small drogue in my fishing boat when drifting for flathead on a windy day.
claverton
claverton
NSW
165 posts
NSW, 165 posts
29 May 2014 4:55am
In my humble opinion, the Jordan Series type drogue is far superior to other types. Bit of info here:

www.jordanseriesdrogue.com/D_8.htm
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7756 posts
NSW, 7756 posts
29 May 2014 9:26am
claverton said..

In my humble opinion, the Jordan Series type drogue is far superior to other types. Bit of info here:

www.jordanseriesdrogue.com/D_8.htm




I agree. I thought about making my own. Quite a few hours on the sewing machine, but I realized I would probably never be in the situation where one is needed. Coastal sailing these days with excellent forecasting items like these are not required.
Seamonkey_H2024
Seamonkey_H2024
VIC
344 posts
VIC, 344 posts
29 May 2014 10:21am
claverton said..
In my humble opinion, the Jordan Series type drogue is far superior to other types. Bit of info here:www.jordanseriesdrogue.com/D_8.htm


Perhaps... They do look to be a lot bulkier though. Have you got one? Easy to deploy? I was looking on youtube of someone deploying a jordan series drogue, looked like a messy and almost dangerous activity. So I decided for the seabrake to reduce storage space, hazards and its potential other uses.

My thoughts would be that with an appropriately chain weighted para style drogue and the correct length of line you will prevent the drogue breaching and thus providing sufficient breaking capability. That being said I won't make too many more comments on the subject as I havn't deployed one in big seas.

Maybe I'll get to test the seabrake going to Tasmania and record my results for you guys. Although I'm hoping that I will never have to see conditions so rough that a drogue needs to be deployed.
BORNFREEE
BORNFREEE
72 posts
72 posts
29 May 2014 8:58am
Roger Tayler of simple sailor.com uses a Jordon Drogue and has used one in anger on his 20ft Corribie at 72 degrees north he says he would not even think of going to sea without one .I still favour the Corbins parachute from New zealand best ocean chute ever made i know there is risk of rudder damage even with some sort of harness but they stop your drift and on a lee shore that is extremly important not only that you can deploy it in shallow water where your chance of meeting dangerious waves is high the Jordon you cant it needs deep water.

BORNFREEE
BORNFREEE
72 posts
72 posts
29 May 2014 9:04am
By the way winches are a extremly weak point you are better off making chain plates that fit horizontally on the stern sides as Jorden recomends
dmatz
dmatz
SA
9 posts
SA, 9 posts
29 May 2014 12:29pm
nswsailor said..

Ok Gentlemen,

What I would like to know....

Is there anybody on this forum who has deployed a sea-brake/drogue in earnest and did it work?

Why did you use it?

What type did you use?


A mate used a Para-Anchor of WA in a storm.

books.google.com.au/books?id=OTFLAAAAQBAJ&pg=PT411&lpg=PT411&dq=Deborah+Schutz+storm&source=bl&ots=Yb0KbBfiGN&sig=OV7uIP2uZvM1KPRKYa1jxl3XXH0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=146GU_6dO4PGkAXQyIG4Cw
MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2711 posts
NSW, 2711 posts
29 May 2014 7:04pm
I can't agree that the winches are a weak point. My sheet winches are probably the solidest attachment bolted to the boat, 6 or 8 solid bolts through the thickest glassed area. They take enormous loads in heavy weather when driving the boat to windward. The sheet winches are the recommended attachment point for all the steering drogues I have seen.

Mine is a Para drogue (not Para anchor) which are highly recommended but I have only used it to see how it can be rigged so haven't used it in anger. The test videos of it show a quality drogue that rides well, doesn't broach nor tie itself in knots.

I rigged mine as per the instructions. A 12mm rope runs from the sheet winches forward to large blocks mounted just aft of the mast. The rope then run aft to the larger 16mm 70m of rode attached astern. By winching in on one winch or the other I can steer the boat in gentle turns.

http://www.paraanchor.com.au/para-drogues.html
BORNFREEE
BORNFREEE
72 posts
72 posts
29 May 2014 6:01pm
John i can only say yours are not the norm many a boat has had its winches pulled off while trying to be pulled into deep water
MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2711 posts
NSW, 2711 posts
29 May 2014 8:12pm
G'day William. Pulling a boat off the beach into deep water (I assume that is what you mean) is not really what they were designed for. Especially as the pull is probably beam on. The highest load a para drogue is likely to put on a boat is about a tonne, there is a table in the link I posted. Over two winches about 500kg each.

A para anchor on the other hand which tries to stop the boat dead when deployed from the bow would put much higher loads on the fittings. Reports I read years ago are that the anchor is often lost because of a gear failure.
keensailor
keensailor
NSW
702 posts
NSW, 702 posts
29 May 2014 8:33pm
SirJman said..

keensailor said..

So just for my own interest, when would you be using your seabrake?

I read they are good in huge seas and gales to slow your boat down and stop it from plummeting into the troughs of waves.

Are you planning some long passages. Wondering whether we should have one ;)


The seabrake drogue can be used to...
-Slow way in rough seas (big waves)
-Aid for running downwind/prevents broaching.
-Emergency steering
-Reducing rock while at anchor if deployed vertically abeam
-Aid for vessel under tow
-Bosuns chair

I'm planning a Tasmania trip after Winter, so I'm trying to be prepared as possible.





arh, ok cool.
That will be a good passage, you will have to let us know how you find it.
Fiesta
Fiesta
QLD
122 posts
QLD, 122 posts
29 May 2014 8:49pm
MorningBird said..

G'day William. Pulling a boat off the beach into deep water (I assume that is what you mean) is not really what they were designed for. Especially as the pull is probably beam on. The highest load a para drogue is likely to put on a boat is about a tonne, there is a table in the link I posted. Over two winches about 500kg each.

A para anchor on the other hand which tries to stop the boat dead when deployed from the bow would put much higher loads on the fittings. Reports I read years ago are that the anchor is often lost because of a gear failure.


Pulling boats off the bottom could introduce huge loads if the keel starts pushing mud, sand or something nasty and hard on the bottom - think how much load your anchor can take . I think these loads could be massive and have a lifting component in the force vector, compared to a drogue on a high stretch line hanging off the stern.

I would be checking out the reinforcement of the deck area under primaries and if there is some decent reinforcement that distributes the load then should be OK for the drogue. Winches mounted on a combing have the advantage of the combing spreading the load out on a beam structure.



claverton
claverton
NSW
165 posts
NSW, 165 posts
31 May 2014 12:39am
SirJam, I've finished making the cones but haven't put them on the line yet, so no, haven't yet tried to deploy.

Re being dangerous to deploy, I haven't heard that one before. As long as bridles are clear of the windvane rudder and the drogue isn't a tangled mess I can't see this being an issue. The more common complaint is length of time taken to get the thing back in the boat.

Re space taken up I had looked at putting it onto dyneema to make the thing lighter and smaller but have decided to go for double braid nylon for the elasticity. You'd want an appropriate bag to simplify deployment and reduce room the thing takes up. You can see a drogue bag here:

www.oceanbrake.com/

& you can see the thing folded up is respectable re. amount of room they take up.

Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7756 posts
NSW, 7756 posts
31 May 2014 8:57am
That's a very clever idea with that storage bag, have not seen that photo before. You could stitch up one so that it is long enough when rolled up to double as a bunk cushion. Good sized Velcro patch to stop it flying off in bumpy conditions. I have a No 5 headsail I use the same. [pillow]
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply