I'll take your "trolling" on board JacobMatan and try to make it simpler.
My apologies for confusing you! Very good summary of what I was saying however! My answer to your question is yes. then yes , then yes again and finally yes. Good luck with that one

.
As to our weekend SUP surf, it was obviously our fault for going out at a place where there was no one out, in tiny wind affected waves and then catching a few dribbles that made it look a whole lot better than it was. Obviously at our age we should stay out of the water and reminisce about what it was like to surf on long boards in the sixties and different types of short boards during the seventies, eighties and nineties and naughties.
Do you really think that a board makes such a huge difference? Watch Dave Rastovich surf incredibly on anything from a fence paling to an old twin fin. Watch the 'Dogman' Roger Saunders rip on anything SUP'. If you really believe what you're saying, buy a Firewire Sci Phi and surf as well as Stu Kennedy is at the moment at Snapper.
Simpler version of my post: 1./If you haven't surfed on a non paddle propelled board and you are relatively young and injury free, have a go at long or short boarding as you might enjoy it

.
2./ Learn surf etiquette prior to going in the surf no matter what craft you choose

.
3./ Any sized SUP can be fun depending on what you want from it, ask any of the guys on this forum
4./ Water time will improve your performance more than any board will although it will obviously contribute. I thought Supping was about fun but what do I know?
I hope that's a bit simpler JM. Hopefully this clarification will prevent me from having to deal with all the confused people.
Apologies again from a terribly confused old man

.
PS. Dugdeep listen to STC and the others advocating the 9'2" Sunova they know what they're talking about.