Ace vs Ace Pro vs Coast Runner

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
2 Jun 2012 7:11pm
With the temperature gauge bottoming out at 4 degrees in Melbourne this morning, Jean, Dean and I met up at Half Moon Bay and decided to put three Starboards to the test - the 14' x 25" Ace, the 14' x 25" Ace Pro, and the 14' x 28" Coast Runner. The conditions we encountered were near enough to perfect flat water. The wind strength was about 4 knots and blowing from the NW which is onshore at this beach. There was barely a ripple on the water surface. We devised a triangular course of just over 800 metres, and took off one at a time to ensure there was no wake riding. We also randomised the order that we took the boards out to ensure that fatigue effects did not apply to a single board. These are the results:


Paul - Ace: 5:05
Paul - Ace Pro: 5:14
Paul Coast Runner: 5:20


Dean - Ace: 5:14
Dean - Ace Pro: 5:22
Dean - Coast Runner: 5:28

Jean - Ace: 5:34
Jean - Ace Pro: 5:32
Jean - Coast Runner: 5:38








Swanie
Swanie
QLD
1372 posts
QLD, 1372 posts
2 Jun 2012 7:36pm
Thanks Paul. That is interesting stats to show similarities with each person. But 4 degrees. Ever thought of migrating north. I thought it was cold today with a range of 17 to 22.
HumanCartoon
HumanCartoon
VIC
2098 posts
VIC, 2098 posts
2 Jun 2012 7:51pm
Interesting...Jean's spread of times is a good bit narrower than you and Dean (not sure what we can infer from that, if anything)
How much to you reckon your own familiarity with the Ace would have contributed?

I'd also be interested in your subjective impressions - which board you each liked best.

You, Jean and Dean are pretty accomplished paddlers with good balance and board handling - it'd be interesting to send the three of you out to do it again on one of our more typical days, with a 15-20knot SW blow chopping up HMB. I wonder if the relative standings between the three boards would come out much different?
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
2 Jun 2012 8:11pm
Hey Stu, I think Jean has spent more time on the Ace Pro than either Dean or myself. She has also spent much less time on the Ace, which is difficult to jump straight into.

I think my familiarity with the Ace absolutely gave me an advantage with that board vs the other boards and the other paddlers. I also had a little bit of boat wake to contend with on my Ace Pro run but it would have only cost a couple of seconds at most.

There's no doubt the Coast Runner is a whole different board with a bit of wave and chop. That would have tightened up times if we'd seen a typical 15-20 knot SW wind shaking things up.

I love the Ace for speed but the Coast Runner is the most fun and stable board out of the 3.
Deano72
Deano72
NSW
540 posts
NSW, 540 posts
2 Jun 2012 9:11pm
PTWoody said...
I love the Ace for speed but the Coast Runner is the most fun and stable board out of the 3.


Totally agree with PT.....coast runner felt super stable compared to the others.
It was my first paddle on (in) an ace and first time on the 25" wide ace pro.
I've racked up a frew km's on the 28" ace pro in varied conditions and found it comfortable for my 80 kegs.
I reckon I would have done better times on the wider ace & ace pro.....I felt like I had to put a bit of energy into keeping the 25" wide boards flat.....but that's probably due to not being familiar with them.
The ace deffinately felt the fastest of the 3 and I missed a couple of strokes on my run in it due to getting the wobbles.....so my time should have been better.

PT's familiarity with the ace shows in his time!!
Jradedmondo
Jradedmondo
NSW
637 posts
NSW, 637 posts
2 Jun 2012 9:21pm
people seem to like the aces, might have to give one a go one day not the 25incher though, nice comparison of the boards

Jarryd
JonathanC
JonathanC
VIC
1024 posts
VIC, 1024 posts
2 Jun 2012 11:02pm
Good test PT, really just highlights to me what a great all round shape the Coast Runner is to be that close to pretty full on 3+ inch narrower race boards. But at the same time be a very cruisy but still fast downwind/surfing 14 footer. Now a 26.5 version of the Coast Runner, that would be nice....
The familiarity with the Ace came through pretty clearly in your times, that initial instability followed by huge secondary stability takes a little bit to get used to. It's the Ace's light downwind ability that is the real WOW factor as far as I'm concerned, trickier to test accurately but what we see in every group downwinder.
jt737
jt737
QLD
418 posts
QLD, 418 posts
3 Jun 2012 1:05pm
What is impressive is the Ace's times given they are hard to turn, being unable to step turn these boards.
PT, what's your secret to turning the Ace fast?
Agree with Jonathan, if only for a skinnier Coast Runner.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
4 Jun 2012 11:22am
jt737 said...

What is impressive is the Ace's times given they are hard to turn, being unable to step turn these boards.
PT, what's your secret to turning the Ace fast?
Agree with Jonathan, if only for a skinnier Coast Runner.


Knowing my limitations is my secret. If the conditions allow a back foot turn, I know I can get one foot beyond the deck pad and still feel stable, but no more than that. If there are fair sized waves or swell coming from an awkward direction, then I don't attempt it and just go with the sweeping bow turn. Likewise, if the wind is going to catch the big bow when I try to kick around, then that's going be more work for little gain, so I opt for the sweeping bow turn once again. For the tests above, the flat water and lack of wind allowed me the confidence to step back. I think the other two did not have the familiarity with the board to do the same.

I think the important thing is you have to attack the turn, no hesitation. So that means knowing what you are going to do and just going for it 100%. If you are hesitant or if you push too hard and destabilise yourself, then the turn is ruined.
Ali Cat
Ali Cat
QLD
1205 posts
QLD, 1205 posts
4 Jun 2012 11:38am
PTWoody said...


I think the important thing is you have to attack the turn, no hesitation. So that means knowing what you are going to do and just going for it 100%. If you are hesitant or if you push too hard and destabilise yourself, then the turn is ruined.


Totally agree, that and a bit of practice turning the board so you can be confident about it and your limitations.

I hadn't spent a huge amount of time on the Ace (especially not turning it) before the dash for cash at the NSW titles. When at the briefing they told us there was going to be 8 buoy turns (instead of the 2 turns shown on the online course map) I was really worried (and thinking I had turned up with the wrong board for the race). But the board surprised me and though a little wobbly on the first few turns, once I got used to the feel of it, it actually turns ok, maybe not as easily as the BOP or Race (but 12'6 boards are built for turns whereas the Ace is built for straight line speed).

With any board, your turns will improve with practice and knowing how the board will respond, be prepare to fall in lots so you can discover where the limit of the board is! The Ace is a very different board to get used to paddling and turning likewise and though it's never going to be the quickest board to turn, you should be able to find the point where it's not too difficult either.

Goochi
Goochi
WA
846 posts
WA, 846 posts
4 Jun 2012 10:54am
Great review PT, you might have to change your avatar now to a starboard sandwich instead of those red boards!
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
4 Jun 2012 1:15pm
Goochi said...

Great review PT, you might have to change your avatar now to a starboard sandwich instead of those red boards!


The avatar picture features a Starboard K15, Pin and Blend in the old sport tech finish. Ah, the good old days when I only had 3 boards to choose from.
Goochi
Goochi
WA
846 posts
WA, 846 posts
4 Jun 2012 11:44am
whooah, the old red and timber construction!
.....they'll be collectors items soon. Sorry strike my last comment, old school boards on an old school car ...perfect - just a pity you can't see the timber on the boards.
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
4 Jun 2012 5:20pm
the coast runner doesn't need it be skinnier- use it for what it is- a proper downwind board.

lagoongarage
lagoongarage
58 posts
58 posts
5 Jun 2012 4:43am
The Ace Pro has an additional tail pad and i want to do the same for my board.
Is it the best position and how far is it from the tail ?

PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
5 Jun 2012 8:05am
That Ace Pro tail pad was not a Starboard item, someone has added that after market. It looks to be in the wrong position but without knowing the board really well, maybe it's too hard to step back any further than that. The Coast Runner tail pad is more or less on top of the fin, although Starboard's pad goes back a lot further on the Coast Runner so it's debatable whether this one is needed. I like it, especially on a big downwinder. Feeling the need to get right back on the tail pad tells me it's a good downwinder.
TrevT
TrevT
QLD
136 posts
QLD, 136 posts
5 Jun 2012 11:33am
do you reckon it would be worth getting a grip pad like the one on the ace pro but for an ace?

PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
5 Jun 2012 11:58am
I don't think so personally. The grip is okay in the back of the Ace and I don't think slipping feet is the problem back there, it's balance. I like the pad on the Coast Runner just to know where I am on the board.
HumanCartoon
HumanCartoon
VIC
2098 posts
VIC, 2098 posts
5 Jun 2012 1:48pm
lagoongarage said...

The Ace Pro has an additional tail pad and i want to do the same for my board.
Is it the best position and how far is it from the tail ?




tail pad position on that board would depend somewhat on how much you weigh...one of our young guns has the 12'6 version & spent some time on the water experimenting to figure out where the pad would work for him. Based on my experience of to 30" touring version of (roughly) that shape, when you step back that pointy tail gets mighty tippy.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply