Thanks everyone for your input,
Reflex and Elbeau, really good to hear your thoughts on the 10'5. You pretty much confirm that no way is it going to be a bad board, which is what I thought. Elbeau its interesting I thought the same thing about the 9'8 being a really bulky board, I've never ridden it but it looks real thick from the pics I've seen.
Phil (Ogsup) I thought I tried the PSH 10' at OG at the demo day but it must have been the 10'6, thanks for clarifying that. I may well be in touch about your 2nd 10'6. In terms of width I'm on a 32' wide board at the moment so ready to go to at least 30' or under.
Jacko, you mentioned the JL 9'9... my dream board man

But really not sure its the right next one for me. Hmmm, watch this space.
Yeah i have probably talked down the conditions where I am as well. Where I surf we get waves in the windy season only, its usually blowing 20+ knots by 10am and pretty choppy too. Tried the Naish 9'6 in calm conditions at OG and was not that easy to balance. So now I'm wary of going that size (on any brand) in our local conditions.
Oliver LoL, I'm glad you're here to ground me man. You speak it true