Hey denaz,
I've had the Element 9'8 but got bored of it really quickly - it just didn't seem to have enough shape/oomph/speed. I started on a whopper so loved starboards but then went to Oxbow 10'6 which is great in bigger surf but slower in small. I'd nearly looked at the 9'6 Oxbow but have lusted after the G Lopez boards and now have (tonight!) the 8'11.
I was just surprised at how quickly I moved on from the element so do try as many boards as poss and dont worry if it takes time.
The Oxbow's not the strongest and I tend to ding things too but I love the shape of it

but can't wait till I try my 8'11!