Need advice from fellow lock rack enthusiasts - whistling

3 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
theSeb
theSeb
365 posts
365 posts
18 Aug 2022 4:30pm
I finally got fed up with straps and having read here how much people love their lock racks I bought one for my board transport needs. I love the simplicity and quickness of getting the board on and off, but they sure do whistle a lot, especially when I don't have a board on them. With a board the whistling is reduced, but it's still there.

Any advice on what I need to do to try and stop this? They are on Thule wing bar. I had to remove the middle rubber bit to get the lock rack installed. I then cut the rubber to fill the gaps on either side of the lock rack base, but I didn't bother trying to fill in "accessory slot" , or whatever it is called, directly under the lock rack base, because that seemed like a lot of effort.

I am wondering if that open slot in the bar is what is causing the whilsting, or is it simply the gap between the bar and the lock rack base and I should just get used to the whilstling and listen to my music at a louder volume?
colas
colas
5392 posts
5392 posts
18 Aug 2022 5:56pm
You can try the various solutions to reduce the "Von Karman effect"
colas.nahaboo.net/Surf/TheDonaldsonTrailingEdge

Look at the spiral ridges on chimneys or antenna or rockets for instance:




These are called "turbulators", and can be made with rope or even just tape:
www.hyperflight.co.uk/products.asp?code=F-RMXTT1&name=turbulator-tape

Less whistling means less drag, and less fuel consumption
theSeb
theSeb
365 posts
365 posts
18 Aug 2022 8:23pm
Thanks Colas. It looks like I need to do some science!
lam
lam
VIC
263 posts
lam lam
VIC, 263 posts
18 Aug 2022 10:30pm
It's the gap between the bar and racks, fill it with original rubbers. Problem fixed.
micksmith
micksmith
VIC
1701 posts
VIC, 1701 posts
19 Aug 2022 6:52am
I have whispbar racks and on those there is the mushroom rubber insert running the length of the racks, to install lockrack you simply remove side cover of roof rack and slide adapter in (push rubber strip down) on top of rubber strip ( do not remove or cut down rubber strip ) If there is wind noise you can insert rubber between lockrack and roof rack as I did on one of my cars.
You can get a universal adapter that clamps around roof rack instead of being in the slot if you're unable to push the rubber strip down.
good luck
wazza66
wazza66
QLD
622 posts
QLD, 622 posts
19 Aug 2022 2:36pm
Grab some shock cord and wrap it around the bars on the angle as shown in some of the pics above.

The science of it basically break the wind and will stop the whistle and costs next to nothing in time and money.
theSeb
theSeb
365 posts
365 posts
21 Aug 2022 6:16pm
I am going to try all of these suggestions starting from the easiest and report back.
theSeb
theSeb
365 posts
365 posts
30 Aug 2022 9:56pm
lam said..
It's the gap between the bar and racks, fill it with original rubbers. Problem fixed.


yup, it was exactly that. I filled the gaps left between the lock rack mounting points on the original rack and the whistling is gone. The original rubber does have the turbulator shapes that Colas referred to.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply