SUP trouble brewing.

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
5 Oct 2008 11:11am
Let's hope the Aussie Coast Gaurd don't get influanced by the US Coast Guards.

They may call a SUP board a vessel?.. .. www.surfersvillage.com/surfing/36762/news.html

DJ
champcrow
champcrow
SA
804 posts
SA, 804 posts
5 Oct 2008 10:57am
Uh oh i can see we will probably be wearing life jackets all the time soon.

I'm also happy to to tell you that i'm a new proud father of a baby girl born yesterday 6:30amRuby Lee, mum and baby doing well and sister Ella want's put her in her toy pram and take her outside to play already

Over Proud Dad

Champ
aussiewahine
aussiewahine
QLD
798 posts
QLD, 798 posts
5 Oct 2008 10:45am
Congratulations Champ...great to hear !!

Regarding the lifejackets...The Australian Outrigger Association has been going through this over the last few years also. Now all six man outriggers have to have lifejackets fitted inside (not on the person) when going out for all training sessions, races etc. And more recently the one man outriggers also now require a lifejacket to be attached somewhere on the craft every time that are on the water.

It has been controversy for a few years and still is. Recently one of the girls I paddle with lost her canoe in a 20 knot wind (it blew away with lifejacket attached). She was left about 2km out to sea with paddle only, at dusk with the rest of the squad looking for her in the dark for over 2 hours along with lifeguards, I.R.B's and a helicopter on standby. She swam back to Point Cartwright at night(over 2 hours) and saved herself. So in that instance the lifejacket was usless as it was on her canoe blown 4km North !! They have now made it mandatory to wear a leg leash/rope as well which makes more sense.

But where will it stop...next they will target Lifesaving Surf Ski's.
wiltor
wiltor
VIC
13 posts
VIC, 13 posts
5 Oct 2008 1:05pm
How many people would wear a PFD surfing --0--
I dont think we have any worries.
Surfers will not follow the rules and the authorities wont be able to police it.
stuey c
stuey c
QLD
265 posts
QLD, 265 posts
5 Oct 2008 12:57pm
I kind of thought something like this may happen, on downwinders the wearing of legropes is a really good commonsense idea anyway. Early this year Woogie took a guy out for a demo on one of our 16's, the customer had a Laird (I think) and they paddled out the back of Granite bay and swapped boards. It was fairly strong SE with a bit of bump running and they were a long way out when the guy lost the 16' which just continued running towards the North Shore. Woogie left the bloke out there treading water with just his paddle and gave chase on the Laird but he had a real hard time catching it with the wind and swell behind. Sometimes he'd get agonisingly close when the 16' would get a bit of wind and a lump and take off by itself! Woogie eventually mowed it down and began the nightmare task of getting both the 16' and the Laird back to the hapless pilot but it was a mission that would never have happened had the rider been connected to his craft. I really think that having a lifejacket on board a downwind Sup is ridiculous overkill but wearing a leggie and carrying a small EPIRB (particularly on the longer runs) will take care of any safety issues coz, after all it's supposed to be fun and being lost at sea most definetly isn't!......Stuey
billboard
billboard
QLD
2819 posts
QLD, 2819 posts
5 Oct 2008 1:11pm
Interesting topic and I don't think we should say "that surfers won't follow the rules" because in the current climate where we are wanting local councils and the general public to listen to us regarding dredging and sand pumping and other issues we kinda need to appear to be towing the line a little (a little). Rather than say we won't comply we probably should be offering up reasons why we shouldn't have to and perhaps suggesting alternatives.

It would be farsical if the authorities policed the surfing community though when they do nothing about the morons in boats who cross dangerous bars (currumbin for example) without wearing the lifejackets that they are required by law to wear. And then these same boaties have the gall to demand that the bars be dredged and kept safe for them !!!!

Hey, I am all for increasing safety in, on and around the waterways and ocean but we gotta work together and I honestly believe that the days of saying "we're surfers mate and ya's can all just piss off" have long gone. Even if we "aint towing the line" we gotta at least give the perception that we are.
stuartp
stuartp
QLD
41 posts
QLD, 41 posts
5 Oct 2008 1:28pm
A good compromise is the Marlin self-inflatable which some of the OC clubs recommend,
see http://outriggercanoesq.squarespace.com/safety-requirements/

This is an 18cm x 14cm x 4cm pouch that sits neatly on the back of your lower waist.
It weighs next to nothing and costs around AUS $100.

I've worn it on a lot of down wind runs offshore with a hydration pack on my back and it doesn't get in the way.

A good investment with a leggie, as a following swell and lots of wind makes chasing bigger boards down a real task, if not impossible sometimes.
malibupaddle
malibupaddle
16 posts
16 posts
5 Oct 2008 4:01pm
From the USA,

When I'm going around the harbor I was told by the harbor patrol to have a life vest on the craft. They are characterizing the SUP same way as a seakayak. For some reason I haven't seen prone paddleboarders wearing flotation devices.

Obviously I'm wearing it. It hasn't been a hinderance to my paddling. Keeps me from getting too cold after I take a dunk in the Ocean. I don't mind for seems at some point with my open ocean adventures i'll have a miss step and get a knock on my head when in a rogue sea with swells coming from multiple directions.

T
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
5 Oct 2008 7:22pm
Maybe it's going to come down to something like this.. Notice the life jackets on the deck..btw..I think I'd rather it behind me so I can't see it..

DJ

www.standupzone.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=2153.0;attach=741;image

www.standupzone.com/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=2153.0;attach=739;image
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
5 Oct 2008 5:34pm
If it happens - which I doubt - I hope it doesn't affect boards over 11'6. If there is a sign that it's going to apply to all stand up paddle boards then I'll get myself an oversised mal and paddle that while waiting for the authorities to enforce surfers to wear them.
rogerthecat
rogerthecat
188 posts
188 posts
5 Oct 2008 5:38pm
Are windsurfers required to wear life jackets in Oz?
I have sailed a long way offshore with just a seat harness for bouyancy - if knocked out it ensures my flabby arse is visible for miles whilst my head remains under water, and is acceptable for inland lakes over here!!! - unless you have legions of coastguards and lifeguards to police this it will be a nightmare to enforce.

Also, where do they draw the line - my 10yr old rides my Stewart 9' longboard with a paddle - will he need a PFD? And are we talking PFD or full on Life Jacket?

I thought the UK was over regulated to the point of strangulation but this would be impossible to implement and enforce here, think our maritime regulations would be a barrier to getting this one through.

Am going to post the link to this thread on the UK SUP forums if that's ok, think we need a heads up for all SUPer's.

On a personal note - was forced to wear a PFD at a local lake, made no difference other than to provide some useful warmth, pockets and hide the MAS (Middle Aged Spread) that is oh so visible in just a 3mm wetsuit!!!

aus301
aus301
QLD
2039 posts
QLD, 2039 posts
5 Oct 2008 8:17pm
I think this paragraph will preclude surfers from having to wear a PFD:

Based upon the information available, the USCG determined when beyond the narrow limits of swimming, surfing or bathing area, the device known as a "paddleboard" is a vessel under 46 U.S.C.&2101, and therefore subject to applicable regulations administered by the US Coast Guard and its Office of Auxiliary and Boating Safety, unless specifically exempted.


I can only assume that this will apply to SUP surfing as well, as by their own admission a "paddleboard" doesn't become a vessel until it leaves a swimming, surfing or bathing area. I guess this will make the rule only apply to people that are way offshore.

Seeing as there is no rule in Australia that requires Windsurfers or Kitesurfers to wear PFD's I can't see that this will ever be an issue here, actually after a very quick google, it seems PWC operators in QLD are not even required to wear a PFD (http://www.msq.qld.gov.au/resources/file/ebc1130cce3ad8f/Pdf_rec_safety_equipment.pdf). So I really can't see anyone forcing a SUP rider to wear a PFD.

But when all said and done, do what feels safe to you. Not much point in worrying about what are rules or not when you are 5k off shore with no way to get home.
ChrisMcC
ChrisMcC
NSW
667 posts
NSW, 667 posts
5 Oct 2008 10:18pm
Not picking on ya AUS but;

"Safety equipment
Safety equipment is dependent on where you are travelling. All personal watercraft operators must wear the correct personal flotation device (PFD) at all times.

PFD type 2, 3 or a wetsuit with inbuilt flotation approved as PFD type 3 in smooth water limits.
PFD type 2 in partially smooth and offshore water limits.
If you travel more than two nautical miles offshore, when beyond smooth and partially smooth waters, you must carry an Emergency Position Indicating Radio Beacon (EPIRB). Personal watercraft travelling at night, or at times of reduced visibility, must show navigation lights - side lights and either an all-round white light or a stern light."


Thats thing about our friends at Queensland Transport, they really don't know the legislation themselves so its not surprising that the wrong message gets out there.
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
5 Oct 2008 7:26pm
Hey Just Wrong,

You left out an anchor. I remember reading you need to carry an anchor as well in WA if are more than 400m offshore. Here's a post from a previous thread about the same topic.

WINDY MILLER said...

as mentioned in earlier posts,, in WA if your supping 400m from the coastline u need a

pfd type 1
4 flares
and a friggin anchor

what a joke...


or none of the above if you are accompanied by a safety vessell.


aus301
aus301
QLD
2039 posts
QLD, 2039 posts
5 Oct 2008 9:29pm
Ahhh my mistake, On re-reading the link I posted I found the bit about PWC riders needing to wear a PFD...geez you would think they would put it all under the one place in the document that has the PWC heading.

Well hopefully this will get lots of people in trouble and we will see less PWC on our waterways
stuey c
stuey c
QLD
265 posts
QLD, 265 posts
5 Oct 2008 11:43pm
oliver said...

Hey Just Wrong,

You left out an anchor. I remember reading you need to carry an anchor as well in WA if are more than 400m offshore. Here's a post from a previous thread about the same topic.

WINDY MILLER said...

as mentioned in earlier posts,, in WA if your supping 400m from the coastline u need a

pfd type 1
4 flares
and a friggin anchor

what a joke...


or none of the above if you are accompanied by a safety vessell.




Damn it Olly, what with the PFD, Flares, Nav lights and anchor I'm gonna have to thicken up the Penetrator. What if you are operating your vessel in constricted, fog prone, waterways? A pilot and foghorn as well? I'm sorry but from now on anyone wishing to order one of our Downwind Sups will be required to show a current Master Mariners certificate!!!..........
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
5 Oct 2008 11:21pm
Yep Oliver is right. Miller and I got busted by the sea rescue blokes and thats what they told us.
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
6 Oct 2008 10:05am
This was officially recognized by the US Coast Guard on October 3, 2008:

A Paddleboard is considered a Vessel

All applicalbe laws and regulations will apply to the use of a 'stand up paddleboard/paddleboard' that pertain to vessels under the U.S.C.G, such as wearing the appropriate USCG approved 'type' of lifejacket persuant to the waterway being operated under, and not limited to other regulations. The Chief of Boating Safety for the U.S.C.G. has officially recognized a paddleboard as a vessel.

These laws will apply to enforcement of the boating safety regulations for paddleboard specific use. The USCG considers a "paddleboard" to be a vessel upon research and the criteria used and guidance provided in previous legal opinions regarding whether or not it is specified as a vessel under 1 U.S.C.&3. Based upon the information available, the USCG determined when beyond the narrow limits of swimming, surfing or bathing area, the device known as a "paddleboard" is a vessel under 46 U.S.C.&2101, and therefore subject to applicable regulations administered by the US Coast Guard and its Office of Auxiliary and Boating Safety, unless specifically exempted.

PARAMETERS FOR DETERMINING WHETHER A 'PADDLEBOARD" IS A VESSEL

(1) Whether the watercraft is "practically capable" of carrying persons or property beyond the narrow limits of a swimming, surfing or bathing area:

A paddleboard is "practically capable' of and intended to be used as a watersport activity beyond the narrow limits of a swimming, surfing, or bathing area. It combines traits of surfing and canoeing. In Paddleboarding, a person stands on a large board which is stable enough to support a person while they paddle the device using a paddle in a manner similar to operating a canoe.

Paddleboard manufacturers depict this activity as multi-use, ranging from use as a 'paddling' activity on inland waterways to a form of 'surfing' in the ocean. For novice and the less thrill-seeking, using the craft to simply enjoy time on the water is becoming more popular.

(2) Whether the useful operating range of the device is limited by the physical endurance of its operator:

The operator of a paddleboard manually propels the craft through the use of a paddle. To a large extend the operating range is limited to the physical endurance of the operator, although because of its stability, the paddleboard could easily drift with the wind and water current. This potential physical endurance limitation is similar to that impacting sailboarding, canoeing, kayaking and other boating activities requiring high levels of physical capability.

(3) Whether the device presents a substantial hazard to navigation or safety not already present:

Paddleboard maneuvered across a waterway to locations where other larger and faster craft travel present a substantial hazard to navigation or safety not already present. Paddleboards are not as powerful or maneuverable as larger craft and they are not as visible. The paddleboard user faces a similar hazard as other users of sailboards and canoeists/kayakers.

There are paddleboarding competitions in coastal areas and organized paddleboard excursions on inland waterways. Paddleboard 'trails' have also been established, including one on the Deschutes River in Oregon that is 60 miles long.

(4) Whether the normal objectives sought to be accomplished by the regulation of a device as a 'vessel' are present:

As a potential hazard to navigation or safety, regulation of paddleboards as vessels would meet the normal objectives sought to be accomplished by the National Recreational Boating Safety Program.

(5) Whether the operator and/or cargo would no longer be safe in the water if the device became disabled.

Paddleboards would provide a minimal level of safety to operators if they became disabled. Thus, the operator may no longer be safe in the water if the operator of the device became fatigued or disabled, or if the device itself became disabled.

Conclusion.

1 U.S.C.&3 states that "The word 'vessel' includes every description of watercraft or other artificial contrivance used, or capable of being used, as a means of transportation on water." Given the answers to the questions above and the definition of the word "Vessel" in the US Code, when utilized beyond the narrow limits of a swimming, surfing, or bathing area, a paddleboard is a vessel subject to regulations administered by the U.S. Coast Guard.

GregW
GregW
VIC
106 posts
VIC, 106 posts
6 Oct 2008 11:27am
The same storm in the proverbial tea cup arose when kiteboarding first appeared. Lots of chat and dire warnings and quoting of regulations then it all disappeared.

The end result will be that paddlers in close will be ignored completely and paddlers out in the middle of the ocean will risk getting busted if the water police think you are doing something dumb ... which is how it should be.

Water police have two strong aversions: one is retrieving dead bodies, the other is hassling people for no reason. If we avoid the first one then the second one follows automatically.

I think the people at most risk of getting booked would be people doing crossings, or people doing coast runs with long offshore legs.
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
6 Oct 2008 9:36pm
DavidJohn said...

This was officially recognized by the US Coast Guard on October 3, 2008:

Who gives a toss what the Seppos officially recognize
We are in Australia

boardbumps
boardbumps
NSW
698 posts
NSW, 698 posts
7 Oct 2008 1:00am
The US Coast Guard sure have done their research on Paddle boarding DJ.

I think we have to be proactive about all this, and I'm with Stuey c and Gregw, legropes and epirbs when doing downwinders or paddling off shore.

At the least legropes for the close inshore but out of the surf zone regions possibly the leggie zone is out to 500 meters and after this distance, epirbs.

I think one of the main reason the US Coastguard is concerned is about other vessels running down Paddlers because they are hard to see.

We don't want to carry a mast to attach our radar reflector on as well.

The Ocean is getting more crowded each year and SUP is encouraging more people to enjoy the Ocean, People who have no surf skills or boating skills. It's so easy to get your board off the car roof and onto the water.

The leggie makers need to keep up with us on this and make special xtra strong less stretch leggies for the SUP and single canoe market.

Rod
fargo
fargo
2 posts
2 posts
6 Oct 2008 11:09pm
Check out the comments on the bottom of this page, interesting stuff....

supglobal.com/stand-up-paddle-surfing-news/us-coast-guard-considers-sups-a-paddleboards-vessels/

Do you guys have a national org for SUP yet ? We do in the UK, I am pretty sure they don't in the US...
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply