Surf or Flat Water ?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
3 Jul 2009 10:24pm
Over the past couple of months,all the talk is how short do I go?
Well thats up to you and your skill level.Having said that I note that
a lot of the chat is now about surf related SUP'ing and not much chat
about flat water paddling.This raises the question,how many of you
have changed your way's of enjoying standuping?


mac

laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
4 Jul 2009 12:34am
62mac said...

Over the past couple of months,all the talk is how short do I go?
Well thats up to you and your skill level.Having said that I note that
a lot of the chat is now about surf related SUP'ing and not much chat
about flat water paddling.This raises the question,how many of you
have changed your way's of enjoying standuping?


mac




hi mac, you must be off os soon. i started stillwater/small surf, that lasted about 2 weeks. all surf suping, now dw and surfing. still not a big fan of stillwater, but you have to get some k's up with tthe dw-ing. it is good to have the right board for a stillwater when ocean/surf conditions are ####
HAGO
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
3 Jul 2009 10:48pm
I did my first wild downwinder in 40k gusts on Tuesday despite several failed attempts - what a blast that was. On Sunday probably had my best ever still water paddle in the ocean. I try to surf when the conditions are suitable but for me it's just good to clear my head and get out in the water to forget.

40% Surf
40% Glassy Flat Water paddling
20% Other conditions
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
3 Jul 2009 10:48pm
Sunday is the day Lacey,first time the young mac's have not traveled and they are p-ssed,party centro while we are gone.

I started suping just for those crap day's and hit the rivers creeks any and everything,but was soon drawn to the waves.Bugger,which board to pack?

Oh the 11.4 Naish was soon replaced for a more surfable stick 10.6 and that is short enough for me btw the Naish was and is a great stick and if I had the room it would be still living with me and the other hundred sticks


mac
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
3 Jul 2009 10:54pm
oliver said...

I did my first wild downwinder in 40k gusts on Tuesday despite several failed attempts - what a blast that was. On Sunday probably had my best ever still water paddle in the ocean. I try to surf when the conditions are suitable but for me it's just good to clear my head and get out in the water to forget.

40% Surf
40% Glassy Flat Water paddling
20% Other conditions


Hey Oliver, I read your posts and was blown away after watching the news that night (crazy vic's) without p-ssing in ones pants,I note you and DJ having a go in the surf of late.I remember you guy's were focused on flatwater for some time.I have enjoyed the photos of you guy's surfing up and down the coast and ad OG's pic's vic looks ok mac
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
4 Jul 2009 12:55am
For me it's not just about the surf..

or just the flat water..

or the even the down-winders..

It's doing all of them with your mates that's the best..

DJ





62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
3 Jul 2009 10:59pm
Hey DJ to right,I often sit at work and read your posts and pic's of your day's event and think dam that DJ is having too much fun you lucky bugger,keep it going

mac
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
3 Jul 2009 11:19pm
DavidJohn said...

For me it's not just about the surf..

or just the flat water..

or the even the down-winders..

It's doing all of them with your mates that's the best..


Spot on. Love that last shot of Jonothan milking that tinsy bump for all it's worth.
aus301
aus301
QLD
2039 posts
QLD, 2039 posts
4 Jul 2009 8:04am
Interesting Mac, I remember about 6 months ago (could be longer, my memory is shot) so much of the talk on the forum was about flat water and down winders, I would guess at about 75%. Now it seems to have gone the other way with surf talk. Swings and roundabouts I guess...

For me, at the moment I am most interested in the surf, lets face it, I'm not about to try pushing the 9'6" too far on flat water. But in saying that I have lately been considering selling off one of my lesser used lighter wind windsurfers to get some sort of distance SUP along the lines of a DC 12'6, so who knows.
Th0m0
Th0m0
QLD
529 posts
QLD, 529 posts
4 Jul 2009 10:14am
100% surf for me, but I'd like to have a go at ocean paddling and downwinders. I'ts a good excuse to order a new board anyway.
Gorgo
Gorgo
VIC
5126 posts
VIC, 5126 posts
4 Jul 2009 12:25pm
Surf is the ultimate form of play and if it came down to a choice it would always be surf.

The truth of the matter is we don't always have access to surf and the promise of SUP is something that is fun that doesn't need surf.

The other thing is that all the development seems to be happening in surf boards. Everybody that can claim some surf cred is bringing out surf designs.

I'm thinking that flat water SUP design will run into a brick wall. To go fast in flat water you have to have length and a displacement hull. Long boards are either heavy or expensive or both. Not many people are going to want to pay $3000+ for a board or have a board you need a trolley and helpers to manage.

If it's stable enough then you can potter along in flat water on a surf shaped board. You don't need to go far or fast for fitness and leisure paddling. Adding length improves stability but the extra speed is marginal. Why go super long if a moderate surf length board will do what you want?

Downwinders sound like epic fun but also epic organisation efforts. I can't see it becoming more than a fringe activity.
boylos
boylos
NSW
769 posts
NSW, 769 posts
4 Jul 2009 3:35pm
DavidJohn said...

For me it's not just about the surf..

or just the flat water..

or the even the down-winders..

It's doing all of them with your mates that's the best..

DJ


Spot on DJ ..... I took up SUPing for the long distance /downwinders as when the surf's up I'd rather surf my 9ft 6 longboard...... so I get the best of both worlds!

So I'm 99% long distance paddling .... 1 % surfing !

Boylos




Lobes
Lobes
885 posts
885 posts
4 Jul 2009 2:18pm
Very simple. From March to September the wind blows and we have conditions for surf and downwinding.

From November to February its flat. No wind and all paddles are on flatwater.

I enjoy both. But probably enjoy flatwater more as I can be on the water 5 mins after leaving work whereas the surf beach is a good 30 min drive.
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
4 Jul 2009 4:21pm
Th0m0 said...

100% surf for me, but I'd like to have a go at ocean paddling and downwinders. I'ts a good excuse to order a new board anyway.


hey, i was the same. get on dw in the ocean- you only need to get one kind of runner and you'll be hooked. when the surf is really small, i go surfing on em- 16 feet of pleasure and pain
ps it worth the price just to see the look on peoples face when surfing one of these suckers
GizzieNZ
GizzieNZ
4103 posts
4103 posts
4 Jul 2009 3:30pm
Well heck surely lots of flatwater paddling is the foundation that your later surfing skills rest upon
paul.j
paul.j
QLD
3381 posts
QLD, 3381 posts
4 Jul 2009 6:39pm
The flat water and dw side of the sport is awesome and so much fun and now with company's like Naish,Starboard and all the local shapers getting in to it its only going to get bigger. I love my waves and they still rule what i do but if the wind is blowing or no waves around then out come the bigger boards and the fun continues. The dw boards are getting better all the time and faster,my feeling is this year will see some good racing with some sick race's on the cards..

Can't wait to get my new 14 and 17 foot race boards....

Jacko
oliver
oliver
3952 posts
3952 posts
4 Jul 2009 6:22pm
Gorgo said...

Downwinders sound like epic fun but also epic organisation efforts. I can't see it becoming more than a fringe activity.


Yep, you are right, but it's something you will have to try when the planets align next time. I was skeptical, I gave it a go and now I'm a convert.
sunnySUP
sunnySUP
QLD
199 posts
QLD, 199 posts
4 Jul 2009 8:29pm
Both.
I usually paddle 1-2 km to get to the river mouth surf. Its great for a warm up and I always enjoy it.

However I also Mountain Bike. I reckon SUP without surf would be like Mountain Biking without hills. Not that challenging.
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
4 Jul 2009 9:10pm
oliver said...

Gorgo said...

Downwinders sound like epic fun but also epic organisation efforts. I can't see it becoming more than a fringe activity.


Yep, you are right, but it's something you will have to try when the planets align next time. I was skeptical, I gave it a go and now I'm a convert.


Hey Oliver.. Next Saturday is looking like another beauty..

DJ

Forecast for Saturday 11/7/09
Cloudy. Patchy rain. Winds northerly averaging 20 to 30 km/h tending north to northwesterly 30 to 45 km/h during the morning.



pmorgan1974
pmorgan1974
NSW
1080 posts
NSW, 1080 posts
4 Jul 2009 9:55pm
for me it is all about the ocean, water. like you guys. whether it is chasing down the NE gales and wind chops, or sliding onto a offshore 6 footer double sucking out the bomby, or cruising on sunset in the Pwater. It is all about the water....all about looking up and feeling down...
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
4 Jul 2009 10:16pm
i was thinking about this today. i was a shortboarder full stop. if it wasn't any good for surfing them that was it for the day. since i have been suping its opened my eyes to different craft and water activities. now i look back and think of all that wasted time when i could have been doing something else water wise.now i run into guys looking at cr@p surf and you can see that their pi##ed because they have no other options and i just laugh at them to myself
ps i really struggled to cope when goaties would say hello when i first started suping. hard to get rid of anti goatie feelings after so many years- they used to be the outcasts,worse the esky lidders ha ha
pps sorry goatman

OG SUP
OG SUP
VIC
3516 posts
VIC, 3516 posts
4 Jul 2009 11:11pm
Hmmmmmmm,

My major focus will always be surf because thats where my real passion lies and I live on the coast!

Next I want to explore the offshore bombies because the crowds of 2 to 4 are more managable than 100 of my closest friends NOT.

I am setting up a crew to explore the offshore islands around the prom as I have locations there that will blow peoples minds, hence my interest in the 12ft gun.

I have not experienced down winders at this point, but wont rule anything out until I have tried it.

I do think on down winders and offshore explorations via sup that legropes and PFDs as well as detailing proposed routes and return deadlines etc to a responsible party is a an absolute minimum and for longer journies or in marginal or extreme conditions VHF hand helds and GPS should be maditory as it is all to easy for something to go badly wrong especially outside the bay.

Life is an adventure not a rehersal push the envelope, live on the edge.

You only live once.

Phill







laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
4 Jul 2009 11:22pm
OG SUP said...

Hmmmmmmm,

My major focus will always be surf because thats where my real passion lies and I live on the coast!

Next I want to explore the offshore bombies because the crowds of 2 to 4 are more managable than 100 of my closest friends NOT.

I am setting up a crew to explore the offshore islands around the prom as I have locations there that will blow peoples minds, hence my interest in the 12ft gun.

I have not experienced down winders at this point, but wont rule anything out until I have tried it.

I do think on down winders and offshore explorations via sup that legropes and PFDs as well as detailing proposed routes and return deadlines etc to a responsible party is a an absolute minimum and for longer journies or in marginal or extreme conditions VHF hand helds and GPS should be maditory as it is all to easy for something to go badly wrong especially outside the bay.

Life is an adventure not a rehersal push the envelope, live on the edge.

You only live once.

Phill










i'm not one for regs, but what you said makes good sense.maybe more than a k off shore that stuff applies!
OG SUP
OG SUP
VIC
3516 posts
VIC, 3516 posts
4 Jul 2009 11:48pm
Hey Lacey,

I have been a qualified commercial charter skipper for 8 years.

The authorities in Melbourne are very much aware of SUP operating in channels and commercial waterways like the Yarra and the Port of Melbourne and are watching with an extreme amount of interest.

It will only take one wrong step or incident involving SUP especially in the Port and life for all of us will be very different.

I hope it never gets to that point!

Phill
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
4 Jul 2009 11:54pm
OG SUP said...

Hey Lacey,

I have been a qualified commercial charter skipper for 8 years.

The authorities in Melbourne are very much aware of SUP operating in channels and commercial waterways like the Yarra and the Port of Melbourne and are watching with an extreme amount of interest.

It will only take one wrong step or incident involving SUP especially in the Port and life for all of us will be very different.

I hope it never gets to that point!

Phill


interesting, what do you make of the after work supers in waterways when they are probably paddling back in darkness? i know some are wearing head lamps
OG SUP
OG SUP
VIC
3516 posts
VIC, 3516 posts
5 Jul 2009 12:14am
Lacey,

Operating any form of vessel in a designated commercial waterway particularly the Yarra the entry to the port and docks area without lights at night is asking for intervention.

What people dont realise is that large commercial vessels create a significant amount of suction as they travel along constricted channels and a SUP close to that vessel may end up getting a very close view of the props.

Its simple any incident or a near miss and Marine Safety Victoria and or the Water Police will be forced to legislate its a no brainer.

Phill



firstpoint
firstpoint
QLD
613 posts
QLD, 613 posts
5 Jul 2009 7:28am
GizzieNZ said...

Well heck surely lots of flatwater paddling is the foundation that your later surfing skills rest upon


flatwater/dw will strengthen your stroke and balance but surfing is surfing,you need wave knowledge and years of doing it to get good at it.go somewhere quiet and learn,watch the waves look at people surfing,but hey,you gotta learn sometime and sup surfing is so much fun
firstpoint
firstpoint
QLD
613 posts
QLD, 613 posts
5 Jul 2009 7:39am
lacey said...

OG SUP said...

Hmmmmmmm,

My major focus will always be surf because thats where my real passion lies and I live on the coast!

Next I want to explore the offshore bombies because the crowds of 2 to 4 are more managable than 100 of my closest friends NOT.

I am setting up a crew to explore the offshore islands around the prom as I have locations there that will blow peoples minds, hence my interest in the 12ft gun.

I have not experienced down winders at this point, but wont rule anything out until I have tried it.

I do think on down winders and offshore explorations via sup that legropes and PFDs as well as detailing proposed routes and return deadlines etc to a responsible party is a an absolute minimum and for longer journies or in marginal or extreme conditions VHF hand helds and GPS should be maditory as it is all to easy for something to go badly wrong especially outside the bay.

Life is an adventure not a rehersal push the envelope, live on the edge.

You only live once.

Phill










i'm not one for regs, but what you said makes good sense.maybe more than a k off shore that stuff applies!


phil is spot on,some qld downwinders are trying big distances up to 6km out to sea,i would cover my arse if i did that,i was wondering though,dolphins are paying a lot of attention to sup up our way,must be the standing part,but what about the big beasties they have trained to jump in the interest of science/tv.these suckers could take you clean off a sup if they felt the urge and the researchers have trained them to go surfers on boards.
loco4olas
loco4olas
NSW
1525 posts
NSW, 1525 posts
5 Jul 2009 9:46am
I'm 100% surf-only ever paddle in the ocean. Having said that I would REALLY like a big down winder board to do some open ocean paddling-particularly in a big open ocean swell to ride some of them monsters-just $ that are holding me back from going there.
teatrea
teatrea
QLD
4177 posts
QLD, 4177 posts
5 Jul 2009 10:21am
Flat water paddling is good fun and a good workout , also with a DW board you can also have some great fun catching the little 2 ft waves that are on offer at the moment.Just about to go catch some know.
Oi
Oi
QLD
97 posts
Oi Oi
QLD, 97 posts
5 Jul 2009 3:53pm
Th0m0 said...

100% surf for me, but I'd like to have a go at ocean paddling and downwinders.


yep same, whats the chances someone has a spare dw board in need of a friend on the Goldie!!!
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply