WelshDragon said...
Thanks everyone-really appreciated.
Will a 10' be too much hard work for long distance/downwinder etc ?
Do most of you have two boards?
Two boards

hah some people on this forum have enough boards to open their own shops

.
It all comes down to what you want to do more of. If you want more surf with some long distance paddling then 10'5 to 11'5 is your length to go.
If you want more distance paddling with a little bit of surf then 12'6 is your length.
But remember like the old saying goes jack of all trades master of none. A board that does a little bit of both will not be the best in one particular discipline.
From what you have said I would say that you want to do more paddling on the river/flat days with some downwinders as well. Surf once in while when conditions are suited to you

If this is correct try the 12'6 Cruiser from Starboard, 12.1 (?) Laird or 12' glide from Naish (this one has the least surfing capability of them all).
PS Demo the board first before you buy.
I have an 11'2 Blend (Starboard) and a 12'6 Pin Starboard (flatwater board) so yes would say most guys/girls here have at least 2 boards.
I started with the 11' then went to the more fitness flatwater racer and now want a 16 foot downwind board

good luck.