I personally hate roof racks. they make your car look Sh1t. Like a tourist.
Im getting the 11'2 Starboard and we tried to fit it in my wagon and it stuck about 2ft out the back! So now I gotta get some roof racks before I pick my board up too.
I think Im gonna go the soft racks purely for the fact that I can chuck them in the back of the car. These also ruin your seals around the doors when you shut them. I once used them for a trip to the Gloo and it rained and the water came through the seals where the straps went through and the water dripped all over us. They also rubbed pretty hard on the paint job and made a mark which took alot of polish to get off.
IF, and I mean a big IF I go for the fixed roof racks Id go for the Rola racks because they have a model which is quite slim line looking and wont look so intrusive like a tradies van with big ass roof racks.
The soft racks you can get for about 50 bucks? And the Rola racks for about 300?
Im still unsure as to what to get too.
Sorry I couldnt help