SP said..
Over thinking things is what humans do naturally. With surfing you just got to realise you peaked by your thirties and enjoy it for fun.
I reckon I peaked at about forty.
i like to think that if I worked hard and got fit that I could still surf like that, but injuries took their toll so maybe not.
I still have lots lots to learn about long boarding so there is heaps of improvement there possible there hopefully.
I sometimes only take one board down to the beach so as to avoid over thinking board selection and line up strategy.
I don't surf as big a wave as I did in my late twenties (12-15), but I reckon my surfing in 8-10 has improved heaps over the last few years when I got some boards actually designed for that, rather than thinking a 7'2" was an appropriate gun. I can still get analysis paralysis when it's big where I don't go anywhere near the peak which is firing because I don't want a big one to get me despite not seeing a single big one wander through - you know, worried about the 10-12 footer on a six foot day with the odd eight foot one or two wave set. Maybe that's just cowardice.
I sometimes overthink where to surf too. This then impacts on my enjoyment of the surf I am having if it's not pumping because I fantasise that the spot(s) would have been better. Almost always they aren't. I know all this but still do the head miles.
my best surfs occur when I am just in the moment appreciating the opportunity to do something I love. And if I remember the waves at my local beach that I grew up on which were frequently 2 foot with a 25 knot inshore. Whenever I think of that I always appreciate what I am surfing as it has to be better than that.
crowds? I live by Tom Hoye's wisdom for that: "Don't get in the race, find your own place, paddle down the face."
I forget the paddle diwn the face bit simetimes when it's solid.