old or new

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
jasdeking
jasdeking
QLD
1820 posts
QLD, 1820 posts
5 Jul 2014 7:03pm
longboard shaping has come a long way we all know that.

if you were looking for a longboard.. would you prefer an old shape that gave a classic old feel and maybe harder to ride... or a more modern shape that works better for a surfer these days?

im not saying old style of surfing vs new/or hp

but board shapes.

thoughts?




Ted the Kiwi
Ted the Kiwi
NSW
14256 posts
NSW, 14256 posts
5 Jul 2014 7:21pm
Just get one of each - no need to put yourself under so much pressure

Personally I agree with what SDR said in an interview a while back - I can not begin to even quote the great man word for word but effectively he said there was a reason those old boards were super seeded back then - there were issues with the design. So things developed and improvements were made as knowledge was gained. I reckon its best to take a modern day approach to some of the old shapes and designs. Get the best of both worlds.


Macaha
Macaha
QLD
21982 posts
QLD, 21982 posts
5 Jul 2014 7:35pm
Thats why The Pinnacle is such a great board old school looks modern features best of both worlds.
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
5 Jul 2014 5:57pm
Ted the Kiwi said...
Just get one of each - no need to put yourself under so much pressure

Personally I agree with what SDR said in an interview a while back - I can not begin to even quote the great man word for word but effectively he said there was a reason those old boards were super seeded back then - there were issues with the design. So things developed and improvements were made as knowledge was gained. I reckon its best to take a modern day approach to some of the old shapes and designs. Get the best of both worlds.





Was a conversation he had with midget farrelly. Sdr asked midget what he thought about everyone /hipsters buying all these old school boards. M F basically said the boards did not work well then,so why would ya ride them now with all the great innovations we now have.... It was a bit more articulate than my memory version
surfbroker
surfbroker
NSW
1489 posts
NSW, 1489 posts
5 Jul 2014 8:34pm
Drive an FJ and see what they were like..Then drive a new Commodore ..then compare

Nicer to have an FJ....with current running gear....That's what a modern log or HP are.
AndyrooMac
AndyrooMac
TAS
1925 posts
TAS, 1925 posts
5 Jul 2014 9:21pm

Whilst I just love the romance of the old classic I'm really loving this fusion of taking the old school log and using modern shaping ideas to iron out the wrinkles and improve performance when surfing in that classic logging style.

What I do like it's shapers who have given great consideration to what they are doing, why, how to get the right performance abs balance and then creating their unique idea. I reckon Steve at Cw and Grant Miller are really spot on with this.

There's a really cool 4 part docco on YouTube of Tom Wegener going super old school with his shaping, back to the first Hawaiian ideas and designs. Really interesting stuff.

Ctngoodvibes
Ctngoodvibes
WA
1404 posts
WA, 1404 posts
5 Jul 2014 7:45pm
chrispy said...
Ted the Kiwi said...
Just get one of each - no need to put yourself under so much pressure

Personally I agree with what SDR said in an interview a while back - I can not begin to even quote the great man word for word but effectively he said there was a reason those old boards were super seeded back then - there were issues with the design. So things developed and improvements were made as knowledge was gained. I reckon its best to take a modern day approach to some of the old shapes and designs. Get the best of both worlds.





Was a conversation he had with midget farrelly. Sdr asked midget what he thought about everyone /hipsters buying all these old school boards. M F basically said the boards did not work well then,so why would ya ride them now with all the great innovations we now have.... It was a bit more articulate than my memory version

That being said, a modern single fin can just rip. Some things from past era's can be good.
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
5 Jul 2014 8:06pm
Ctngoodvibes said...
chrispy said...
Ted the Kiwi said...
Just get one of each - no need to put yourself under so much pressure

Personally I agree with what SDR said in an interview a while back - I can not begin to even quote the great man word for word but effectively he said there was a reason those old boards were super seeded back then - there were issues with the design. So things developed and improvements were made as knowledge was gained. I reckon its best to take a modern day approach to some of the old shapes and designs. Get the best of both worlds.





Was a conversation he had with midget farrelly. Sdr asked midget what he thought about everyone /hipsters buying all these old school boards. M F basically said the boards did not work well then,so why would ya ride them now with all the great innovations we now have.... It was a bit more articulate than my memory version

That being said, a modern single fin can just rip. Some things from past era's can be good.



That being said......you said MODERN single....not old
Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
6 Jul 2014 1:58pm
The Redline is an example od old mixed with new... Similar from my Occasional Pin. Old & new. My Tracker is also Old & New... (some modern tweaks to the tail, harder modern rails, out through the tail)...
Ctngoodvibes
Ctngoodvibes
WA
1404 posts
WA, 1404 posts
6 Jul 2014 1:11pm
You still riding yr Boston switch Chrispy? Thinking of getting one as a mid ranger
surfbroker
surfbroker
NSW
1489 posts
NSW, 1489 posts
7 Jul 2014 5:09pm
chrispy said...


That being said......you said MODERN single....not old


Yes the Modern Log has a real old school shape.....shame about the quality though

A local guy loves his sooooo much..he's getting.......Denis Anderson to replicate it but +++ quality
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply