Thanks JJ!
I love how you experiment with stuff that’s already built. Way easier and faster to learn the lessons!
I guess... no, I know... that I’m a glutton for punishment!
So, the downwind board was not all that much longer. The big difference was the cross-section shape with the deep beveled rails.
So here are my last three boards, in order of their build. All in the 145–150 liter range.
Red = Funky Dory, the downwind board. It sucked! Hard to uphaul, hard to slog straight, and it refused to release. I chalk it all up to the bevels. Note how far forward the bottom handle is, it balanced the weight nicely but would knock me over when it was windy because the handle was too close to the aero pivot point.
Blue = Folly Boat. After the DW disaster, I went brutally flat-bottomed. This board uphauled well and was easy to slog. It was still a bit squirrely in yaw when on the water, I think that is from the round tail outline. Predictable and nimble in the air though. I loved this board and was not planning to build another until the tracks ripped out!
I glued the tracks to the side of a Tuttle box. The ends of the tracks cantilevered fore and aft of the Tuttle. With my SAB foils, the foil was placed from middle to full forward. I had zero issues using this track design across three boards and six years. Then I switched to Axis and needed to move the foil full aft.
The load from the aft bolts pulling downward is the big design load that has to be handled. When that big load pulled in the middle, in way of the Tuttle, it was fine. When it pulled on the unsupported aft end of the track, it failed slowly over about 10 sessions.
White = Pearl, my current whip. I needed a board, and fast. I did not find anything I could buy or wanted to buy.
The big change here is the foam. I switched from 1# EPS to 2# XPS. I built it from 2" thick sheet foam in slices parallel to where a stringer would go, then hole-sawed a bunch of foam out from each slice.
I went a touch shorter to keep the nose off the ground when carrying it with the foil mast on my shoulder and the board on my back. It’s also a touch narrower.
I’m sneaking some arc back into the bottom shape, lowered the rocker forward, and made the deck mostly flat fore and aft, partly for aero drag.
The other big change is in the laminate. I had always used Innegra, and I skipped it this time and went with less carbon because the foam is waterproof. It made the build a LOT easier, but the board is already full of small punctures and if it were EPS would probably be in the bin by now. I’ll bring the Innegra back when I get the strength to build again, I have the foam staring at me in the garage. This board tracks straighter and takes off early. The arc in the bottom maybe helping the release. The really low rocker forward allows for aggressive pumping and the straighter outline and square tail seem to help slow speed tracking. The low nose is fine until it's not and is easy to pearl but I have adjusted,
This one is going good for now and has taught me a lot, and the learning is part of the fun for me.
I hope I’m not derailing this thread. With the conversation being about uphauling and light wind, I figured this was a good place to share this info.