Creased board?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
steller_3
steller_3
QLD
123 posts
QLD, 123 posts
6 Nov 2009 12:24am
Exactly what is meant by a creased board. Would you ever consider buying one?

how easily can they be fixed like prity much new, it would only get light use.
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
6 Nov 2009 1:21am
a creased board has an area (usually from rail to rail) where the board has failed either undertension or compression.

it used to be very common on wave boards back in the polyester days due to flat landings or high jumps.

it can be fixed if the damage is not too bad but i would not bother myself.
wormy
wormy
QLD
679 posts
QLD, 679 posts
6 Nov 2009 6:43am
steller_3 said...

Exactly what is meant by a creased board. Would you ever consider buying one?




NO!!
spot1
spot1
WA
1588 posts
WA, 1588 posts
6 Nov 2009 6:04am
no
555
555
892 posts
555 555
892 posts
6 Nov 2009 7:16am
Yes.
But only if it was a really good board, was really cheap, and I had the time to fix it myself..

It would also depend on how it was creased - it may be a symptom of poor construction if it creased doing something relatively tame.
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
6 Nov 2009 7:56am
Here's an idea of how to go about fixing it -- note that this is a crease near the nose, a crease near the footpads is more difficult to do.

boardlady.com/seatrendnose.htm
nick0
nick0
NSW
510 posts
NSW, 510 posts
6 Nov 2009 10:59am
remember if the outer skin has a crease due to extreme pressuse (tention or compreshion) that hier a fair chance of damage inside the board as well .. the central stringer may be broken or delaminated .. also the foam inside may have broken to pieces
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
6 Nov 2009 8:29am
It is pretty major to fix.

If you don't have any gear like vac pump, glass, epoxy, divinycell etc, figure on $400 materials and a month to fix it. And even then you may find the rocker line of the board has changed just enough to make it sail funny.

steller_3
steller_3
QLD
123 posts
QLD, 123 posts
6 Nov 2009 10:49am
Thanks for the comments, I know my decision.
Id rather be sailing than sanding
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
6 Nov 2009 10:00am
Maybe whoever gave me a red thumb can enlighten us all about how it is sooo easy and cheap to fix a sandwich board that is creased properly
wormy
wormy
QLD
679 posts
QLD, 679 posts
6 Nov 2009 1:15pm
I have often noticed Mark, that you regulary get red thumbed for what is helpful advice and offered without negative intent. Maybe you have a stalker.
barn
barn
WA
2960 posts
WA, 2960 posts
6 Nov 2009 11:25am
anything can be fixed.. i am sailing with a carbon repair across the deck between the mast track and the front straps. that was a crease, no problem. and my last board had a carbon repair across the bottom after a crack from rail to rail... if fixed well with carbon its fine, and with stuff all weight gain.

here in brasil the italian guy who fixes them does about 1-2 per week.. ( u dont throw out a brand new board just cause its snapped) he doesnt use vacuum pump, just sands it back and sets woven carbon (same stuff that shows thru the limited finish) over the crease or crack, finish the repair with micro bubbles.. jobs done. its stronger than any other part on the board.. he charges 110aud for a complete rail to rail repair, takes 3 days.

what board is it? whats the rest of it like? cheap?
barn
barn
WA
2960 posts
WA, 2960 posts
6 Nov 2009 11:31am
i didnt give the red thumb. but in jeri a snapped board results in 3 days off the water and 180 reals less in your pocket (im down about 500reals for lots of cracks).. dunno about the rocker, but i reckon the shape memory of the board is pretty good.. or theres a 50% chance u could get a better rocker?



the black bits the repair, the other damage was a separate story
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
6 Nov 2009 4:29pm
barn said...

anything can be fixed.. i am sailing with a carbon repair across the deck between the mast track and the front straps. that was a crease, no problem. and my last board had a carbon repair across the bottom after a crack from rail to rail... if fixed well with carbon its fine, and with stuff all weight gain.

here in brasil the italian guy who fixes them does about 1-2 per week.. ( u dont throw out a brand new board just cause its snapped) he doesnt use vacuum pump, just sands it back and sets woven carbon (same stuff that shows thru the limited finish) over the crease or crack, finish the repair with micro bubbles.. jobs done. its stronger than any other part on the board.. he charges 110aud for a complete rail to rail repair, takes 3 days.

what board is it? whats the rest of it like? cheap?



Barn, I think the reasoning that Eva the boardlady uses is that you need to repair like materials with like to get the same performance of the materials.

I wonder if these boards repaired at Jeri are lasting long term. Does the carbon reinforcement make a very stiff area that creates further problems in the future?

I guess there may also be a big difference between something that has a crease and something that is just about to tear in two all the way through. Maybe you can stop/repair a minor crease if you get it at the right point with just carbon?

It would be interesting to see how well these ex-demo boards from the major hire centres in Egypt and elsewhere last. They must get a lot of a working in just one season.

NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
6 Nov 2009 6:54pm




Good Lord! That looks like it might just be a bargain


Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
6 Nov 2009 5:28pm
That is what I call a temporary fix (especially in the middle of the board like that)and only for slalom / race boards. No jumping hi on that one!

The repaired area is stronger than the rest, and the boundary line where the repaired area and original laminates meet there will be a break eventually. If you jumped that board it would break exactly along that boundary.

The only way to truly fix it is to remove the sandwich layer/s completely, repair the styro cracks underneath with expanding polyurethane (the real stuff not the pressure pack gap filla from Bunnings) and re do the sandwich layers.
The area removed and replaced need to be exact same construction, and in a diamond shape or on a big diagonal so there is no boundary line running across the board. Ideally the sandwich layers need to be bevelled so they blend in gradually with the existing layers... in effect the repair is angled in all 3 dimensions. I'll post a pic of a small one I did

All that is usually out of the reach of the average sailor and very time intensive.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
6 Nov 2009 5:54pm
OK as promised, pics as per above post.
LOTS of steps are ommitted here but it is easier to see what I'm talking about.

This is a small repair and I did not want to encroach upon the foam heel bumpers and footstrap inserts.... the area should have been more of a diamond or oval shape but it is acceptable.

(1) Glass removed, you can see the crack in the sandwich layer:




(2) Sandwich layers removed, bevelled out .... a really gentle bevel, you can see the 3 glass layers on the deck. Also the styro has nee filled with epoxy / q'cell filler and sanded smooth



(3) last pic is after filling in the hole with
layer of expoxy and q'cell
layer of glass
more q'cell
1 x divincell bevelled just right
glass
1x divinycell, again bevelled real nice tight fit
3 x glass
vac bagged down



still needs a heap of fairing and filling at this point before paint and footpads go back on

That is a lot different to bogging the crack and bunging a couple of layers of carbon over it... and this was not a full crease.
The only damage visible was a wrinkle in the paint about 10cm long, and look what the actual damage underneath was.

barn
barn
WA
2960 posts
WA, 2960 posts
6 Nov 2009 9:07pm
the tabou repair was a structural failure, there was no strength left in the board. and yes the inside layer of glass under the dyvinicel was not repaired to the original construction.. as i said this guy does this repaid 1-2 times a week. he lives here. and between board repair and his storage center its his only source of income. these repaired boards last, its in his intrest for them to last. there are still old boards being sailed here hard by local kids with this very same repair. and i jumped mine just fine. his personal board (skate 100) has this repair done on the top and the bottom from separate repairs.

before i saw these boards i would not have trusted the repair. i would have routed out the damage. injected micro bubbles into the foam. inserted glass under the original dyvinicell. layed down fresh dyvinicell bla bla bla repair the board exactly how it was made. (this is the process i was taught by a fat russian board repair oracle, who spoke no english and had a 6ft super model for a girlfriend).

the repair on the acid is not from landing jumps. thats a collapsed deck from heavy heels and needs to be fixed from the inside out.. carbon on the outside cant fix that. and i would fix it the russians way. the acid repair pictured is how a center board gets fixed, quick and easy. but without getting the new glass in and under the original bottom layer of glass the repair is not factory spec, just like robbos repairs.. but who cares it works.



HowlingDog
HowlingDog
WA
61 posts
WA, 61 posts
6 Nov 2009 10:16pm
barn said...

the repair on the acid is not from landing jumps. thats a collapsed deck from heavy heels and needs to be fixed from the inside out.. carbon on the outside cant fix that.


I keep telling people - DO NOT LET KITERS try your boards!! When will people listen to me..... Kiters in Heels will wreck your gear!!

An expensive lesson Barn has learned - we should all pay attention.
Rider5
Rider5
WA
567 posts
WA, 567 posts
6 Nov 2009 10:36pm
I so fully agree with Mark Oz. That repair looks so temporary, it's not a matter of if it will break again it's just when A week in Gero would sort that board out.
A strip of carbon on one side of the sandwhich is not going to be as stiff a the original sandwhich it butts up against.
and the black stuff you sometimes see under those half finished looking boards is sometimes just black pigment in the resin not carbon fibre.
barn
barn
WA
2960 posts
WA, 2960 posts
7 Nov 2009 12:59am
the black repairs strong, it lasted 2 months sailing every day 4.2 weather.. landing flat forwards, flat shakas, flat everything.. ther rest of the board broke cause i eventually sent it into the sand and split the nose, and the the bottom peeled of.. the repair held.

but my point is, just cause a board is creased or cracked or snapped... its repairable.. if the rest is solid, its worth it if the price is right..
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23688 posts
WA, 23688 posts
7 Nov 2009 10:10am
Barn,

I dunno how you can say the break in my Acid was heel dents??!!! Your heels go where the black bits are (they are the foam heel bumpers under the pads) The break is right between front and back straps, it just so happens that a couple fo cracks close to each other looks like a depressed circle but it wasn't. It was classic hi jumping crease action.

As to your last post, sorry but I don't think 2 months of use on a board proved it was a proper or good repair.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply