Hi Bubs,
Whats the width of your 158ltr?
I ride a Mistral 161 ltr board mostly and the ideal fin on larger sails is 50cm, and smaller and I just dont get planning early. That said I am currently using a 48cm freeride and it seems perfect.
I think it depends on the sail size, board width and wind strengh.I was for a while using a 38cm, but could never get on the plan unless it was blowing its head off!