Hip replacements and windsurfing.

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
stonesurf
stonesurf
WA
77 posts
WA, 77 posts
28 Sep 2006 7:59pm
l am 45 yrs old and after 25 yrs of twisting on my right leg shaping l have worn my hip out. This means it is a square peg going into a round hole. Pains not unbearable but constant, and the Doc told me to comeback when l can't bear it anymore. How will l know l asked? You will know he said, $105 for 5 minutes. Well can l wind surf after it, what is the best type of hip, Titanium?. l am allergic to epoxy so l figure a glue in one may be suss, can any one please educate me from their experience. l still want to wave ride , happy to jump but no loops, leave that to Jaeger.
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
28 Sep 2006 10:28pm
a couple of windsurfing friends of mine (and my mum) have had hips replaced with titanium.
the pain went and mobility was restored without any problems.
probably the biggest concern for the windsurfers was the lack of flex to be able to lift the knees high enough to waterstart, they both resorted to uphauling on higher volume boards in light winds. (no big issue) however this was a decade or so ago and i'm sure bionic terminator joints have improved greatly. hasta la vista.
and best wishes for a really big decision for you.
regards ian.
stonesurf
stonesurf
WA
77 posts
WA, 77 posts
28 Sep 2006 8:46pm
Thanks but l use a 64 litre most the time, l weigh 75 kilo so up hauling is out, bad for you back any way.
MikeyS
MikeyS
VIC
1509 posts
VIC, 1509 posts
29 Sep 2006 9:10am
Geez, stonesurf. Worn out at 45! Well at least there's plenty of great hardware out there to fix hips. I can't give you any advice from first hand experience, although I do have this relationship with an orthopaedic surgeon who tightens up my shoulders from time to time.
First, make sure you've got private health insurance, otherwise your pelvis is likely to be grinding on your kneecaps before you get a hip replacement through the public system. With a pre-existing condition, you might need to hobble out a 12 month waiting period before being covered for surgery, assuming that's what's required.
Now to the hardware. Some of my firm's clients are manufacturers of hip replacements, so I get to see info about their latest and greatest technology. Pretty cool engineering actually. Anyway, have a look at www.zimmerbiomet.com/anz or www.stryker.com/jointreplacements/medprof/hiphome.php Most of the stuff is made primarily from a titanium alloy, and is glued into place with an inert bone cement. They don't use just any epoxy!
When the pain does become unbearable and you get a referral to an orthopaedic surgeon, it would be his or her decision what would suit you best. But I'd be very surprised if you were advised against sailing after a hip replacement.
stonesurf
stonesurf
WA
77 posts
WA, 77 posts
29 Sep 2006 7:48am
Thanks again, l have private and already seen a specialist. l am just doing my homework to make sure of the best way to go. l have heard of them now relining the ball joint too. Its a bit like buying a new video camera l geuss, next week its outdated but l doubt it will be half the price. Money is not the issue though, ripping up the waves is,l really want to maintain what l have. l could not handle sailing in straight lines.
garynoel
garynoel
WA
260 posts
WA, 260 posts
29 Sep 2006 12:10pm

You poor bugger stonesurf.
That sucks.
I'm sure you'll do all your homework and get the best replacement on the market and you'll be slashing the waves for many years to come!

My dad takes glucosamin and chondriotin for his sore joints, but i'm sure you know of this stuff already.

Gary
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
29 Sep 2006 8:37pm
Mark, you could try posting on rec.windsurfing, if you can get (newsgroups). It's mainly Americans, but it does have a world wide audience, and in the past I've seen medical questions answered convincingly.
holgs
holgs
WA
303 posts
WA, 303 posts
3 Oct 2006 6:00pm
Hip replacements are generally designed for old people who cannot walk anymore because of the pain. The hip replacement enables them to walk again pain free and they might be able to play a round of golf. They are not really designed for young people to engage in "extreme" sports.

One problem is that they wear out if you use them too much. The other problem is that they can be prone to dislocating during sports especially when bending the knee and rotating the hip inwards, which could easily happen while windsurfing.

If you want to keep wave sailing I would wait with surgery as long as I could stand the pain. I'm no orthopaedic surgeon but if they tell you otherwise make sure they understand how demanding wave sailing on a 65 litre board is.
rustle
rustle
QLD
279 posts
QLD, 279 posts
3 Oct 2006 8:36pm
holgs post is spot on .
Don't fix it until it is unbearable with painkillers.My mother has had on e and it is really not designed for sports.
holgs
holgs
WA
303 posts
WA, 303 posts
3 Oct 2006 7:05pm
You could consider coming down to Perth to see an orthopaedic surgeon who is used to dealing with athletes / sporty types for a second opinion.

You could possibly be suitable for some other options such as a hip arthroscopy that might be able to buy you a bit of extra time before needing that hip replacement.

You`re absolutely right in taking time to consider your options carefully as otherwise you could be trading in your wave board for a Starboard Start

Good Luck !!!
holgs
Barto
Barto
WA
8 posts
WA, 8 posts
3 Oct 2006 10:02pm
Hi Stonesurf

I will turn 37 in a couple of weeks and I had a hip replacement back in 2001. Long story as to why, but lets say bullets and hip joints don't mix.

I did the rounds of Ortho docs and got the same answers as you, "you are too young, come back when you can barely crawl"...etc. It wasn't much of an option for me with my wife expecting a baby and a fairly active lifestyle. In the end I came across a "hip" called the birmingham cup which was specifically designed for young active people.

The basic premise is to resurface the ball joint and install a cup into the pelvis. There are two advantages. First is that it most closely resembles what was originally there and is therefore more stable than the typical hip replacement. The second is that by resurfacing the ball joint, they do not have to cut off the neck of the femur, which in the end means that you can have more than the two or three (if needed) hip replacements down the track, which is what the older style offer.

When I had mine done, they hadn't worn any out yet. They had "bench" tested them for 15 years plus, and they had fitted them in a competitive long distance runner and Tae Kwan Do bloke.

Since I have had mine I have been into mountain biking, snow skied and took up windsurfing last year. I am far from being any good but it certainly doesn't slow me down. The only thing keeping me from water starts is practice.

I am not really sure what it is all made of but I can honestly say that the only thing that reminds me of the whole thing is a pretty cool scar. Definitely no pain, and the Docs words, after asking him what I could and couldn't do, when he discharged me were "the gloves are off".

I hope you find the right one for you. I remember what the the pain was like before I had mine. If you want to know anymore, I'll keep an eye out here.

All the best
Bart
stonesurf
stonesurf
WA
77 posts
WA, 77 posts
4 Oct 2006 12:01am
Thanks Bart, sounds the best so far. l have sent an email to the Birmingham crew to see who specializes in Perth. l geuss l still wont be able to walk around shopping centres with my wife though.
Cheers
Stoney
rustle
rustle
QLD
279 posts
QLD, 279 posts
4 Oct 2006 8:41am
I knew there had to be a positive in stuffing my knee.Those shopping centre trips will have to wait until FULL recovery.
Barto
Barto
WA
8 posts
WA, 8 posts
4 Oct 2006 7:47am
Hi again Mark,

I had my op done in Canberra. Let me know if you have any trouble tracking someone down over this way. I can't remeber the doc's name but I am sure it is on one of the x-rays and can dig up if you want.

Stay out of those shops.......you'll wear your hip out faster.

Cheers
Bart
fences
fences
VIC
89 posts
VIC, 89 posts
5 Oct 2006 12:04am
hey stoney,
Its Dan here (myself and matty bourke took those boards back to perth 3 weeks ago). My girlfriend's dad is an orthopeadic 'salesman' and sits in on the surgeries making sure that all goes to plan. From what I understand, wait as long as possible, there is no epoxy, titanium and there are good and bad specialists so pass the name on to me and I'll ask him if you like. I'll press for more info on the action side of things when I see him next.

You may just need to take up kiting mate!!

Cheers
Dan
stonesurf
stonesurf
WA
77 posts
WA, 77 posts
4 Oct 2006 11:53pm
Would rather go shopping with my wife Dan,
Cheers for the info though, will keep in contact
stoney
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply