Kiting at Dutchies

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
spinout
spinout
18 posts
18 posts
22 Nov 2005 10:07pm
Sorry to open with a rant, but I had a rather unpleasant encounter with a kiter at Dutchies on the weekend. I fell in gybing close to shore (not unusual!) and heard a thud behind me as a kite hit the water 6 feet behind. The kite was then dragged over me, all with the kiter repeatedly shouting at me "GET OUT OF THERE" (and go where, and how?). The kite lines dragged over me, caught on my rear footstrap, & the whole thing could have easily ended badly (for me that is). I have to admit to returning a few choice words as well!
I, up to this point, have had no issues with kiters. I even envy their aerobatics and light wind ability, and actually thought of trying it, if my old bones could still bend rather than break! However, there is one big difference between the sports. Windsurfing is of very limited risk to anyone else, kiting is potentially deadly. I know there have been issues regarding kiting in Cottesloe, but are there any rules regarding their proximity to us? They seem to move further upwind everytime I sail at Dutch Inn, and today I was sailing right under someones lines, feeling far too nervous.... I'm tempted to carry a line cutter
eyespy
eyespy
WA
8 posts
WA, 8 posts
22 Nov 2005 10:45pm
I think that you should write a formal letter accurately detailing the incident and how dangerous you believe it to be and send copies to the local ranger, cottesloe council,local member of parliment for that area and any other officials you can think of. The more incidents that are officially reported the sooner kiters will be restricted to certain areas. The more individuals that can actually be bothered and motivated to put pen to paper the sooner the change.
.
To any kiters that are going to throw a tissy fit about this post I REALLY DON'T CARE and I'm not going to click back on this post to read any replies.
spinout
spinout
18 posts
18 posts
22 Nov 2005 11:18pm
Cheers for the support eyespy - I don't want to start a war, I just don't want anyone (esp & selfishly me) to be hurt. Unfortunately it looks like someone is going to be. I welcome input from kiters on this issue - hissey fits or not!
spinout
spinout
18 posts
18 posts
22 Nov 2005 11:45pm
Just checked out the WAKSA site- plenty of information on right of way kiter vs kiter, absolutely none for kiter vs rest of world!
blacklotusninja
blacklotusninja
WA
26 posts
WA, 26 posts
23 Nov 2005 12:54am
In case you hadn't noticed these right of way rules are taken from other wind sports such as sailing, windsurfing and boating so you would think they would apply in most situations not just "Kiter vs Kiter".
airhead
airhead
WA
814 posts
WA, 814 posts
23 Nov 2005 9:18am
Caleb,

Firstly let me apologise for that unfortunate incident.

I realised immediately after that the tone in my voice was probably not the most effective way to communicate what I wanted to. My ONLY concern was for your safety and all I was trying to convey was for you to try your absolute best to get yourself clear from my kite lines as quickly as you can.

I must admit that I was very shocked to see you there as I did check the area immediately down wind of me before attempting that particular trick. It also appeared to me that the kite was about to "hot" launch and I had only just in that small fraction of a second surfaced to see you there.

From memory the breeze was a little light that afternoon and most (not all) of the windsurfers were struggling to stay upwind. Normally you guys are a good 50-100m upwind of the kiters but on this occasion you had drifted down into our narrow little zone.

Unlike the windsurfers, we have been confined to a small area in which we are legally allowed to kite and I would urge you not to take a "knee jerk" reaction as eyespy suggests but understand that it's not a perfect world and we just have to do our best to try and get along and keep out of each others way.
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
23 Nov 2005 9:45am
Hey Airhead...

Nice one for sorting the story Pretty nasty situation for all involved.

I met some kiters once, and they were alright

Peace wind lovers

Pugs
spinout
spinout
18 posts
18 posts
23 Nov 2005 1:22pm
Hi Airhead

Apology accepted! The wind was light that day, but the issue still stands that kiters and windsurfers are increasingly intermingling. I just felt that I ended up in a situation where I had no way out. You didn't see me - I didn't see you either - a factor of the huge area taken up by kiting lines. Awareness obviously needs to increase on both sides.
Blacklotusninja - please read the site yourself before commenting - a lot deals with kiters not entangling lines and how to fly a kite close to other kiters- hardly applies to a windsurfer.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
23 Nov 2005 3:30pm
Wow, a victory for reason and good manners, may everybody take a lesson from this!!!!! There's hope for the world yet!
Not sure how the Zones at dutchies works, but if the kites are confined to a narrow area, seems apropriate for windsurfers to try and stay clear of their zone. From what I remember there's only a small launch spot that's free of reef, does have to be shared???

This incident has started me thinking, if perchance I'm in that situation, hanging on to windsurfer with kite lines trailing over me, what's the safest/best thing to do?????
Can I use the rig to act as a buffer between me and those lines???
Certainly can't waterstart until clear of lines.
Don't want to hold the lines in case kite launches, so eyespy's solution of using a knife could be just as dangerous.
Is it possible to swim the rig across the lines very carefully??
airhead
airhead
WA
814 posts
WA, 814 posts
23 Nov 2005 4:03pm
quote:
Originally posted by decrepit

...
This incident has started me thinking, if perchance I'm in that situation, hanging on to windsurfer with kite lines trailing over me, what's the safest/best thing to do?????
Can I use the rig to act as a buffer between me and those lines???
Certainly can't waterstart until clear of lines.
Don't want to hold the lines in case kite launches, so eyespy's solution of using a knife could be just as dangerous.
Is it possible to swim the rig across the lines very carefully??



I would think that you need to make a very quick assessment of the situation. If it appears the kite is going to relaunch or the "pilot" seems not to be in complete control of the situation you should just get yourself the hell out of there and leave your rig for the moment until it's all clear.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
23 Nov 2005 8:07pm
Decrep,

If kite lines are trailing over you, this is what you do.

1. Abandon windsurf gear.
2. Dive deep and swim underwater to clear lines.
3. Surface and survey scenario.
4. When the dust has settled, reclaim your gear and continue ripping the waves.

Handy Tip by 'slave.
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
23 Nov 2005 8:30pm
If you leave your board, who is responsible when it all gets mashed on a reef or by waves

I'd rather have my head than my board
fish
fish
WA
155 posts
WA, 155 posts
23 Nov 2005 11:17pm
so why are we talking about how to get out of danger when it happens?
it shouldnt happen in the first place
i have absolutely nothing against kiters
i went to dutchies for the first time last week
hated the place!
1 there were no waves
2 kites flying all over the place
these kites can be lethal no matter whos flying them as we have just read from this post
airhead sounds like he knows what he is doing
so.... accidents happen and when they do we hope that know one has to abandon anything
therefore we have to stay away from each other
kites downwind of windsurfer sounds like a good rule to start
good luck kiters and keep doing what you do best....
having fun :)
see you out there
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
23 Nov 2005 11:45pm
Hmm abandoning my rig wouldn't be my natural reaction, but now you guys mention it, I think you're right, it would be the safest option!

As fish says this shouldn't happen, but it certainly could, with no real fault on anybody's part.

Airing these scenarios is important, it could save a nasty incident if we know what to do.
JohnnoKeys
JohnnoKeys
WA
551 posts
WA, 551 posts
24 Nov 2005 2:42pm
To the wind surfer at Cottesloe. I'm the WA kite surfing Association guy at Cottesloe so will let you know what we are up to. Sorry from WAKSA about the crash. MOST about 95% of the kiters at Cottesloe are regular/ Cottesloe locals and all respect and avoid, as much as possible windsurfers. WE all know the rules. Windsurfers are mainly up by the small groyne and kiters 100m north. However we do get the occasional learner and or out of state/ euro commin to town and they can cause a few problems. As kiters we try as soon as possible to talk to these gdanderoue types and get them out of the area.

By the sounds of the crash the light wind caused a few problems. I'm sure airhead just had a momentary " **** what is going on".

I've been kiting at Cottesloe for 4 years and 99.9% of the time all parties get on well.
WAKSA is printing up brochures and posting a kite rating system for Cottesloe that states it is NOT A PLACE FOR LEARNER KITERS. Also to avoid all wind surfers. This will be available from all kiting shops and on a sign at Cottesloe soon.

PS I was never at windsurfer myself, but a surfer for 20 years before giving kiting ago. But I would reckon about 70-90% of kiters are Cottesloe are windsurfers.

Jonathan Keys WAKSA rep Cottesloe 0401 60 3838

Call any time if you guys have a bitch about the kiters, WAKSA is very keen to sort out any issues.
spinout
spinout
18 posts
18 posts
24 Nov 2005 2:45pm
Im have to admit that abandoning my kit didn't occur to me! I was only half joking about carrying a line cutter (a safety cutter, not a knife) -if entangling incidents are getting more common (& I expect they will) carrying a safety cutter could prevent a major injury if a limb is entangled. Whether you would have the time or presence of mind to use it is a different matter.
JohnnoKeys
JohnnoKeys
WA
551 posts
WA, 551 posts
24 Nov 2005 2:57pm
PS about kite lines.

In my experience having kited for hundreds of hours, kite lines are of little to dander to others if the kite is on the water, and in experienced hands. THe new kites are very easy to use, and are not as dangeroues as kites a few years ago. Most kites now have full
100% depower safety systems that fully depower the kite in micro seconds.



WAKSA/ Kiters will keep the learner kiters away from Cottesloe and we all will be safe.
spinout
spinout
18 posts
18 posts
24 Nov 2005 8:25pm
Hi Jonathan
We seemed to post at the same time - so my last post didn't quite fit in.
I was out at Dutchies this evening - pretty busy time. I've no idea how you guys avoid tying yourselves in knots!! I kept well upwind the whole time (more so than most out there), and there were still kiters south of me. On one occasion I couldn't avoid sailing under lines, and, as you imply, my safety was fully dependent on the skill of the kiter. I'm very grateful for your input, and completely agree that a place as busy as dutchies is not for beginners.
May the font of mutual respect & consideration continue to flow....!
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
24 Nov 2005 9:28pm
Has a kiter killed a windsurfer ever anywhere in the world ??

I haven't read of any deaths.
mdjnelson
mdjnelson
WA
33 posts
WA, 33 posts
24 Nov 2005 10:34pm
About 4 years ago when i was learning to windsurf, i think the 00/01 or 01/02 season a kiter lost control of his kite and it came flying down and whacked my mast, im glad none of those ropes strangled me. I was ****house then so i didnt use footstraps or a harness so i was probably moving at snail pace so nothing dramatic happened .. but i still classify it as a near death experience!
airhead
airhead
WA
814 posts
WA, 814 posts
25 Nov 2005 11:23am
i was out there yesterday evening also. 10-12 kiters and the place is a real jungle. can't see it getting any better anytime soon. there were probably a couple of kiters who shouldn't have been there or at least put up smaller kites. the wind on the top of the small cliff and even on the beach can be very deceiving sometimes and it can be a lot stronger than it looks...
leski
leski
NSW
661 posts
NSW, 661 posts
25 Nov 2005 2:31pm
quote:
1. Abandon windsurf gear.


this is the most stupid thing I've ever heard..any person with a bit of common sense or experience of the ocean would know that this is the first basic that you NEVER do..
so

1. NEVER ABANDON YOUR GEAR
jezza77
jezza77
WA
33 posts
WA, 33 posts
25 Nov 2005 12:14pm
I am not sure what it is like around cottesloe, but the vibe around scarborough is good, I am sure we all give each other the ****s some times but we just deal with it. We sail under, around kite lines all the time and I would say "most" of us windsurfers have no problems with that. Dare I say we even say gday to each other. The kiters around scabs are generally pretty good so you feel safe to share the water.

In the odd chance we do get in each others way it is nothing unusual. Between the clubbies (ski's and paddle boards, swimming races etc.) boogie boarders, swimmers, surfers, kiters, windsurfers and all round general tourists etc. I guess we have learnt that you will always get in each others way.
FilthyAmatuer
FilthyAmatuer
WA
877 posts
WA, 877 posts
25 Nov 2005 12:33pm
quote:
Originally posted by waveslave

Has a kiter killed a windsurfer ever anywhere in the world ??

I haven't read of any deaths.



Thats not the point, someone shouldnt be put in the situation where they have to abadon there gear, its a stupid thing to wait for someone to die for something to be done. It can be prevented in the first place.

People shouldnt have to fear for their life or injury. People should have the right to come to the beach and use it without having to worry that someone is gonna crash into you and **** you up. Fair enough accidents happen, and there is nothing that can be done about them. People say sorry and if no ones hurt then all is ok, but ur ignorant opinion just makes the situation worse, and while there is kiters that have that opinion the problem will continue to get worse.

I have no problem with kiters, every where else i have sailed where there have been kiters i have never had a problem, my mate is a kiter and we have sessions where we go out together, and no problems.

At cott for some reason... ??? one thing that does piss me off is when kiters point higher than u and force u to sail under their lines, because a windsurfer is faster but cant go as high... how hard is it to go down wind a bit let the windsurfer pass then head back upwind.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
25 Nov 2005 5:29pm
Hey Leski,

You can't take No.1 Tip out of context from a list of 4 and expect to make sense.
Read No.2 Tip.

"Dive deep and swim underwater to clear lines".

It would be difficult to achieve No.2 Tip while remaining with your windsurf gear.
Correct ?

(Although I did witness once a Margies local duck-dive his whole rig under a bomb to avoid breakage).

He surfaced in the waterstart position and sailed away.
Priceless.


But what was I discussing again.....
Oh yeah, avoiding injury due to kite lines.

Carry on.

Regards
'slave
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
25 Nov 2005 6:38pm
Leski,
Agreed letting go of my gear was the last thing I'd think of, it's been so ingrained over the years to hang on to the rig as much as possible.

But think I agree with slave here, and suggest a modification to your rule!
"Never abandon rig unless kite lines are trailing over you"

After all you aren't going all that far away, it's likely to be close to the beach, that's where most congestion seems to occur. And yeh, conceivably the kite lines could tangle in the rig, power the kite up and the whole lot dissapear over the horizon. But I for one would not want to try and stop it, much prefer to be swimming upwind watching it.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
25 Nov 2005 6:54pm
Contrary to my previous question,
it's only fair that I should ask the following.....

Has a windsurfer killed a kiter ever anywhere in the world ?

Nah, I didn't think so.

Well then, that makes it a scoreless draw.
It's time we had a penality shoot-out ! [}:)]
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
25 Nov 2005 7:32pm
quote:
Has a windsurfer killed a kiter ever anywhere in the world ?

If I could have caught that b*stard kiter at corrumbin who missed me by inches while I was newbying my way out to sea, swerving to spray me and just about hit me with the lines, then the answer would be a definite YES!

Lucky for him I was way too slow...
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
25 Nov 2005 8:28pm
Polesurfers have got it easy....

Just say I crash my kite in the cruel sea and I'm attempting a relaunch.
At the same time that this is happening, a kook kiter crashes his kite nearby,
dropping his lines all over me.
Spaghetti with tossed salad.

Man, what do I do ?
Do I dive deep while abandoning the kite ?
TWANG....bye bye kite.

(Loose kites tumbling along out to sea are an awesome spectacle to watch).

That random rollin' is hypnotic.

Regards
'slave
fish
fish
WA
155 posts
WA, 155 posts
25 Nov 2005 8:59pm
blah blah blah
samio
samio
WA
183 posts
WA, 183 posts
27 Nov 2005 10:14am
I think the smartest thing to do would be to abandon your rig. Im a newb kiter, and proud of it! But iv seen kite lines do horrible things to flesh. Theres a whole lot of power in those stings so if there is an accident, god forbid, id just try to get the hell out of there.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply