Why couldn't I hold down a 8.5m?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
8 Nov 2013 6:41pm
Today, at Kyeemagh, (the airport for those not from around here), it was a windy day. It was around 25 knots, give or take 10 or more knots at a time.

I could only hold down a 6.6m, and that was with heaps of downhaul. The plan was to release some downhaul if it got lighter, but it never did. I ended up changing to a 5.7, at around 5:30 because it was too windy for me.

Now, my question is, what do I need to do to be able to hold down an 8.5m? Is there a particular aspect of my technique that needs tweaking? I don't want to eat more pies as I am already a lardy 95kgs.

Anyone get out there with an 8.5m that can offer me some tips?

P.S. I used the 8.5m yesterday, but it might have been a touch lighter.

seanhogan
seanhogan
QLD
3424 posts
QLD, 3424 posts
8 Nov 2013 9:01pm
why would you want to go out in 25 knts with a 8.5 ?

want to race with macro ?
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
8 Nov 2013 10:21pm
Macroscienc has the answer.
paddymac
paddymac
WA
943 posts
WA, 943 posts
8 Nov 2013 8:25pm
Get a Formula Board with a small fin?
Macroscien
Macroscien
QLD
6809 posts
QLD, 6809 posts
8 Nov 2013 10:39pm
My 8.0 RAM is out of order as for today.
Broken second mast in this sail this year and one boom
So If you Formula think that 8 is too much and you will never use it, but by any chance you still have 490 cm I will be happy to buy from you.

Strangely enough all my previous masts broke below the boom , this time mast broke just above .
I hope to use my 8.0 sail in the Wynnum race this Sunday
pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
9 Nov 2013 12:33am
FormulaNova said..
....Now, my question is, what do I need to do to be able to hold down an 8.5m? Is there a particular aspect of my technique that needs tweaking? I don't want to eat more pies as I am already a lardy 95kgs.


Yes.
Your assessment of appropriate sail size for the occasion needs working on.

Around 25 knots, even for a lardy 95kg, (you said it, not me,.. ) would indicate 5.5m maximum for a nice fast and comfortable ride.
In fact, at 25 knots you could rig a 4.7 to 5 metres and still have fun.
Remember, sail power increases with the cube of the wind speed.
(that's sail power, not sail force. Force increases with the square of the wind speed)
fjdoug
fjdoug
ACT
548 posts
ACT, 548 posts
9 Nov 2013 6:57am
a formula racer will rig an 8.5 or bigger, but that is because he wants to go straight upwind, turn around and go straight back downwind.
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
9 Nov 2013 4:52am
pweedas said..

FormulaNova said..
....Now, my question is, what do I need to do to be able to hold down an 8.5m? Is there a particular aspect of my technique that needs tweaking? I don't want to eat more pies as I am already a lardy 95kgs.


Yes.
Your assessment of appropriate sail size for the occasion needs working on.

Around 25 knots, even for a lardy 95kg, (you said it, not me,.. ) would indicate 5.5m maximum for a nice fast and comfortable ride.
In fact, at 25 knots you could rig a 4.7 to 5 metres and still have fun.
Remember, sail power increases with the cube of the wind speed.
(that's sail power, not sail force. Force increases with the square of the wind speed)



Hey Pweedas, I am in training for my bet against Macroscien! I need to be able to hold down an 8.5m I think he was offering a carton of beer and a brand new commodore, so I need to get into shape!

With the 'lardy' comment, I was being generous, so I don't mind. The lardy guys laugh at me.

I do have to argue with the 4.7 or 5m sail suggestion though. This is/was gusty wind, not the 'oh, it's a 1knot gust', WA style. It really did feel 10 knots lighter at times, and a bit of a wind shadow directly off the beach. So I needed something for the first 100m off the beach. I didn't feel overpowered until the wind picked up a little bit later on, and I dropped down to my 5.7m then.

I have used a 4.7m in around 25knots in WA, but it needs to be steady and turning around means I drop off the plane.







FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
9 Nov 2013 4:55am
fjdoug said..

a formula racer will rig an 8.5 or bigger, but that is because he wants to go straight upwind, turn around and go straight back downwind.



I've heard of guys using these size rigs in 25knots, but I just don't know if it'd be comfortable. Even with such a large sail, I don't think the boards would be that much fun in that wind. I use a formula board for light wind, maybe less than 15 knots, with the 8.5m, and its fun. When it picks up a bit its still good, but 25 knots is something else.
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
9 Nov 2013 5:00am
Macroscien said..

My 8.0 RAM is out of order as for today.
Broken second mast in this sail this year and one boom
So If you Formula think that 8 is too much and you will never use it, but by any chance you still have 490 cm I will be happy to buy from you.

Strangely enough all my previous masts broke below the boom , this time mast broke just above .
I hope to use my 8.0 sail in the Wynnum race this Sunday



I might have the answer to your broken mast problem! When I rigged my 6.6m yesterday I had a huge amount of downhaul on it so I could cope with the wind. Maybe you are downhauling too much, and need to downhaul less, and use a smaller sail?
Milsy
Milsy
NSW
1176 posts
NSW, 1176 posts
9 Nov 2013 8:32am
hey formulanova, yeah, plenty of downhaul and outhaul and you should be able to manage the 8.5 in a patchy 25kts.........as people on 6m go past you, the real challenge is, can you convert the more size to more power/speed, good luck man
Sputnik11
Sputnik11
VIC
972 posts
VIC, 972 posts
9 Nov 2013 9:08am
25kts = 15kts?
powersloshin
powersloshin
NSW
1855 posts
NSW, 1855 posts
9 Nov 2013 9:38am
From my experience the ranges that I am comfortable with - weight 80 kgs.
I keep records in a spreadsheet, first figure is avg, second is max. gusts, taken from seabreeze records:

12-15: Formula with 11.0
13-17: Formula with 10.0
PS: I use formula for reaching up and down

14-18: Falcon121 with 8.5
16-22: Falcon121 with 7.5
20-25: Falcon121 or i101 with 7.0 or 6.6 Koncept
23-28: i101 with 5.8
26-35: i101 with 5.0
over 30: 4.2 only used once

So I think it matches with formulanova experience, yesterday was well over 25 knts gusts. The fact that some use much smaller sails is probably because they don't use slalom boards with outside footstraps, so with the weight more in the centre don't need a big sail to keep the board flat.
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
9 Nov 2013 7:48am
powersloshin said..


So I think it matches with formulanova experience, yesterday was well over 25 knts gusts. The fact that some use much smaller sails is probably because they don't use slalom boards with outside footstraps, so with the weight more in the centre don't need a big sail to keep the board flat.


I was using a freeride board yesterday, but the straps were still outboard. I think without them outboard I would have been well out of control. I was using a relatively big fin though, even though I spun out a few times when riding it too hard upwind and got caught in some chop.

I am taking the piss a bit though about the 8.5m. For me at least, an 8.5m in yesterday's wind would have been just crazy.

I think people using smaller sails yesterday were mainly because they were lighter. I think there are a few options. Do you use a small board with a small fin to cope with more power, or do you use a smaller sail with a bigger board and fin? I think both options work.

As usual it was interesting yesterday talking to people on the beach. There were a few people that were overpowered with smaller sails, but I think weight really makes a big difference to what you need to get going.



Macroscien
Macroscien
QLD
6809 posts
QLD, 6809 posts
9 Nov 2013 10:36am
My experience with bigger sails shown that not so much absolute wind speed matter but relative.
With big sail and +20 ktn is quite difficult to launch and start.
But once you have shadowed from wind position and could start at hardly any wind then entering windy area at speed , to hang on on big sail is no longer a problem.
The profile of the sail is also important as sometimes is much easier for me to hang on 8.0 RAM which is extremely stable, with low drag, that 5.7 no cam that seems to deform in strong gust.
I didn't still measured how fast my 8.0 could go with relatively big 118L slalom board, but I am just novice GPS raider.
29 something recorded on my mobile phone but it wasn't the fastest run yet.
The problem I found with strong wind that this board at speed approaching 30 ktn could launch in the air, so I am very very admire slalom riders going into chop at 33-36 ktn on similar equipment.
eyeMhardcor
eyeMhardcor
255 posts
255 posts
9 Nov 2013 8:44am
Because your weak as piss. I hold an 8.5 in 35kts
Roar
Roar
NSW
471 posts
NSW, 471 posts
9 Nov 2013 12:24pm
im 100 kg and i was on a 90 l board with a 5.5 powered up - everywhere except the wind shadow at the shore line.

First problem was you were on a 115 lt board with a big fin which is a slow combo in strong winds. your board would have been dragging so much your apparent wind in the sail would have been huge.
The trick to sailing over powered is to go faster :)

On the 5.5 at 30 knots on a slalom board the apparent wind makes the sail almost weightless with the harness doing about 95 % of the work.

FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
9 Nov 2013 10:35am
Roar said..

im 100 kg and i was on a 90 l board with a 5.5 powered up - everywhere except the wind shadow at the shore line.

First problem was you were on a 115 lt board with a big fin which is a slow combo in strong winds. your board would have been dragging so much your apparent wind in the sail would have been huge.
The trick to sailing over powered is to go faster :)

On the 5.5 at 30 knots on a slalom board the apparent wind makes the sail almost weightless with the harness doing about 95 % of the work.



Roar, I think your 90L board is about the same width as my 115L. Mine is 65cm wide, and I think once you are planing, the width is all that matters. How do you get through the lulls on that board if you are 100Kgs?

The fin I was using was a 30cm, but its a weed/wave fin, so not optimized for speed. It didn't feel like the board was going slow. I was a bit worried a few times when trying to go fast, so maybe a better combo would have felt more comfortable. I got 28 knots on the GPS, and in that water it was more than I wanted. I also had the 6.6 flattened as far as I dared.

100kgs, 5.5m and a 90L board? You should have been on a 8.5m!


FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
9 Nov 2013 10:36am
eyeMhardcor said..

Because your weak as piss. I hold an 8.5 in 35kts



We were talking metres squared, not centimetres
choco
choco
SA
4186 posts
SA, 4186 posts
9 Nov 2013 1:48pm
do you even lift?
whyner
whyner
NSW
762 posts
NSW, 762 posts
9 Nov 2013 2:51pm
eyeMhardcor said...
Because your weak as piss. I hold an 8.5 in 35kts


Is that with or without a harness. If its with than your soft.
BEACHSTART
BEACHSTART
NSW
93 posts
NSW, 93 posts
9 Nov 2013 3:53pm
monday 4th I was sailing along with one of the oz national team .I was on mistral 123l ab+ and 7.2m struggling to keep up .
He was riding a rsx with 8.5m sail in 20 knots + he looked very comfortable on the water and he wasn't a big bloke.
I guess it's all the training and physical preparation. No nead to eat more pies, training is the key.
evlPanda
evlPanda
NSW
9207 posts
NSW, 9207 posts
10 Nov 2013 11:20am
eyeMhardcor said..

Because your weak as piss. I hold an 8.5 in 35kts


I don't know why the red thumbs. I've seen you do one handed spocks with the above.



macroscien said...
The problem I found with strong wind that this board at speed approaching 30 ktn could launch in the air...


If you start to get blown off the water, literally, then it is time to come in and rig something bigger and heavier. Try switching from an 8.5 to a 9.0 or 9.5. Switch to a bigger fin and a bigger board too. The extra weight will keep you on the water!

If you find that you can't even lift the sail out of the water because it starts oscillating violently in the wind then you know you've rigged like a man.
Waiting4wind
Waiting4wind
NSW
1871 posts
NSW, 1871 posts
10 Nov 2013 11:24am
Having a multiple cam sail with good top end helps.

I will use my 8m in up to 25 knots but that's only cause I'm too lazy to change down when the wind comes up. It would be 25 knots in the gusts, which can be a typical botany nor easter, you get that crazy powered run which is full on for about a minute.

I tend to err on the side of a bigger sail so I can plane through the lulls and I don't have to pump too much ( lazy sailing).

It's not fun sailing an 8m at 25kts, albeit a bit exciting at times.

I used the 8m on Thursday, which was great as the wind was ranging 10-25. On Friday I was on a 6.2m, sail was fine but 100l slalom board was a bit big for comfort, I would have been happy on an 80-90 l board.
tilldark
tilldark
QLD
275 posts
QLD, 275 posts
10 Nov 2013 12:22pm
Hey Marco, from what I'm lead to believe you will actually go slower on a bigger sail (even if you can manage to hold it down) than someone on a smaller one, due to drag (wind exiting the sail). Its not something I've noticed at my level of ability its just something I've heard.

I'm 100Kg and put the 8.6 away once it hits 20+ knots, for a few reasons

1. It hammers the sail/boom/mast (especially when its choppy)
2. Its bloody frustrating to waterstart big sails in high wind
3. You tend to muscle the sail and fatigue faster, I'd rather sail for longer and improve my technique on smaller kit

Definitely agree what speed helps manage a large sail, we tend to run larger sails on the broadwater because we often have inconsistent winds. If you were to sail somewhere like WA in say a solid 20 knots you'd probably be on a 7m or less

Still recon you should grab yourself a 7.8 and the right mast (CRITICAL) and you'll notice the difference straight away.
eyeMhardcor
eyeMhardcor
255 posts
255 posts
10 Nov 2013 6:48pm
I use the 8.5m when I'm wavesailing. It helps with getting extra power out of my bottom turn.
ka43
ka43
NSW
3105 posts
NSW, 3105 posts
10 Nov 2013 10:29pm
Im voting for eyeMhardcor, thats hardcore!!!!!!!!!!!

Reckon most people over estimate wind strength and what they can hang onto. Most guys I sail with in Sydney, Canton and Illawarra know how to rock up, look at the wind and know what to rig. Its experience but also you want to be powered when doing GPS sailing as if you are comfortable going deep off the wind you have rigged too small.
As an example, last Monday at Canton. In my opinion it was blowing approx 20-25 in the gusts. Now if you can hang onto an 8.6 then my hats off to you. The weed is gone so the water state is different. Not flat (pretty bloody bumpy) and pretty hairy if you are going for it which everyone was. Most good sailors were hitting 30-33 knots. with the excpetion of non mortals (we all know who they are) it was bloody hard to get past that. If it was flat as normal then I reckon it was PB central for most of us. My opinion!!
Of course there are guys that are in a different league but thats windsurfing. Thats why we all love it!!
I was on a 6.4 and most guys were on similar or 5.8. You cant sail comfortably and go hard in those conditions as you crap yourself. So if you are on an 8.6 then you are a legend. throw in weed etc then Im taking up darts
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply