GPS Software

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Old Salty
Old Salty
VIC
1271 posts
VIC, 1271 posts
4 Nov 2009 1:06pm
Not sure if this has been discussed before so apologies in advance. The choices of software seems to be Realspeed and GPSAR - are there any others and what are the benefits one over the other?
sailquik
sailquik
VIC
6171 posts
VIC, 6171 posts
4 Nov 2009 1:31pm
Also GPS-Results.

GPS Action Replay (www.gpsactionreplay.com)
GPS Results (www.gps-speed.com)
Real Speed (www.intellimass.com)
Old Salty
Old Salty
VIC
1271 posts
VIC, 1271 posts
4 Nov 2009 9:57pm
Can we have a vote on who uses what and why?
wkcwarrior
wkcwarrior
371 posts
371 posts
5 Nov 2009 6:45am
I use only GPS Results becouse it is easy to use, have option for averaging two gt31 at same time, it is quick for view, edit, import google into it, so that is my opinion
GPSR have them all, quick and easy and cost is only 20€ for lifetime key for all new versions and updates
Don't like Action Reply becouse they works in java, so you need java runtime to start, graphics is very poor and options are more than complicated

so much from me
mathew
mathew
QLD
2172 posts
QLD, 2172 posts
5 Nov 2009 9:05am
For simplicity, I go with RealSpeed, once it is setup correctly -> out of the box, RS needs a bit of tweaking (eg min-sats, max-HDOP, trackpoint vs doppler). Compare this to GPSR, which doesn't need any tweaking.

However once setup, the RS interface it much more intuitive than GPSR, eg: GPSR not being able to scroll the complete dataset or the unusual mouse-zoom behaviour.

GSPAR Basic suffers from the inability to zoom in on a given run, but does a really nice track vs background overlay and multi-sailor replays are very nice.

GPSAR Pro is just impossible to use... whats with the elastic graphs?
drift
drift
VIC
737 posts
VIC, 737 posts
5 Nov 2009 12:30pm
I started with GPSAR Pro but the more I use it, the more frustrating it becomes. I agree with MAtt and wkcwarrior on both counts- the interface is lumpy and java can lead to all sorts of fun and games (i have had to to apply for several registry keys since my system admin set up on the mac wipes any data and the software resets after every 10 uses).
I've taken a look at Realspeed and seeing it used during SpeedFortnight, I think that's probably my preferred option. Last month, I was asking exactly the same question and Kato also mentioned Realspeed was Aussie designed if that plays any part in your buying decisions.

Old salty, you may need to test to see which package has the best deceleration graphs. I saw your 28kts to zero run on Tuesday and it was a joy to watch!
sausage
sausage
QLD
4874 posts
QLD, 4874 posts
5 Nov 2009 11:49am
Realspeed is great - use it for my data.
GPS Results (expired trial version) use for Google earth overlay

Downloaded trial of GPSAR Pro yesterday and have to agree with Mathew re: complexity.

PS - should I remove that Java thingy I downloaded as well from my computer.
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
5 Nov 2009 9:55am
Easy...

Aussie = Mal Wright = RealSpeed
Malloy
Malloy
71 posts
71 posts
5 Nov 2009 8:21pm
Have only used GPSResults, but I am overly satisfied with the layout and functions of the program, also Manfred Fvchs(v is u, language filters are too strict) who made it is very helpful and have answered several of my email questions.

IMO check out them all, see which one is the most intuitive one for you and registrer it. Then wait for wind... :)
evets
evets
WA
685 posts
WA, 685 posts
5 Nov 2009 10:11pm
I have used both and find Realspeed far easier to use.
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
6 Nov 2009 7:19am
Realspeed for me. I chose it as there were setup guides on the GPS Challenge site plus its Aussie software. Mal Wright is good to deal with via email with quick responses.

wkcwarrior
wkcwarrior
371 posts
371 posts
6 Nov 2009 4:38pm
sausage said...

Realspeed is great - use it for my data.
GPS Results (expired trial version) use for Google earth overlay

Downloaded trial of GPSAR Pro yesterday and have to agree with Mathew re: complexity.

PS - should I remove that Java thingy I downloaded as well from my computer.


try from control panel, add/remove programs, and find java runtime, then remove
Herbylyn
Herbylyn
QLD
214 posts
QLD, 214 posts
6 Nov 2009 7:24pm
For all our postings we use RealSpeed.
For occasional checking we use KA72
We have found both of these programs give very similar results.
For Google Earth overlay I use the remnants of the trial version of GPS Results.

Hi to everybody.
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
6 Nov 2009 7:32pm
Realspeed for me nice and simple
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12884 posts
WA, 12884 posts
7 Nov 2009 8:28pm
I'd use real speed all the time if I could get it to run in Linux, (I'm very close, just can't get the machine code to come up so it can be registered)
AS GPSARPro runs in Java, that works OK in Linux, but finding the data you want in the trackpoint table is a big hassle, unlike realspeed it doesn't get highlighted when a result is selected.
It is easier than realspeed to combine files thou.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply